Skip to content

AUDIT.md

Latest commit

 

History

History
97 lines (69 loc) · 4.64 KB

AUDIT.md

File metadata and controls

97 lines (69 loc) · 4.64 KB

Code Audit — Issue #143

Project: Commitlabs-Frontend
Branch: master
Audited By: Imeobong
Date: 2026-02-25
Reference: #143 - Audit backend for dead code and TODOs, and create follow-up issues

1. TODO Comments Found

Frontend TODOs

# File Line TODO Comment Action
1 src/components/AttestationHistory.tsx 11 TODO: Implement attestation history with: → Open GitHub Issue
2 src/components/CommitmentForm.tsx 7 TODO: Implement commitment form with: → Open GitHub Issue
3 src/components/NFTDisplay.tsx 12 TODO: Implement NFT display with: → Open GitHub Issue
4 src/utils/soroban.ts 2 TODO: Implement actual Soroban contract interactions → Open GitHub Issue
5 src/utils/soroban.ts 13 TODO: Implement wallet connection → Open GitHub Issue
6 src/utils/soroban.ts 19 TODO: Implement contract calls → Open GitHub Issue (group with #4)
7 src/utils/soroban.ts 29 TODO: Implement contract reads → Open GitHub Issue (group with #4)

Note: src/components/MarketplaceHeader/MarketplaceHeader.tsx lines 23 and 28 contain the word PLACEHOLDER but these are valid code — DEFAULT_PLACEHOLDER is a legitimate UI constant used as a search input placeholder text. No action needed.

2. Exported Symbols Found in src/utils/

# File Line Symbol Used Elsewhere? Action
1 src/utils/soroban.ts 4 export const rpcUrl Unconfirmed — needs verification Monitor
2 src/utils/soroban.ts 5 export const networkPassphrase Unconfirmed — needs verification Monitor
3 src/utils/soroban.ts 7 export const contractAddresses Unconfirmed — needs verification Monitor

Note: These exports are configuration constants (RPC URL, network passphrase, contract addresses). Even if not currently consumed by any component, they are intentional scaffolding for upcoming contract integration and should not be removed. They are expected to be used once wallet and contract work begins.

3. ESLint Status

ESLint could not run because the project does not have a configuration file (eslint.config.js). This is required by ESLint v9+.

Resolution: This is a separate setup issue and should be tracked as its own follow-up. Do not block this audit PR on it.

Status Detail
⚠️ ESLint config missing Project has no eslint.config.js or .eslintrc.* file
Recommended action Open a separate GitHub Issue to add ESLint configuration

4. Dead Code Found

No dead code was found. The grep search for unused function references returned zero results. All exported symbols are configuration-level stubs intentionally left for future implementation.

Conclusion: Nothing is safe to delete at this time without risking breaking future integration scaffolding.

5. GitHub Issues to Open

Based on the audit, the following GitHub Issues must be created to track all important TODOs:

Issue Title Files Affected Label
Implement Attestation History component src/components/AttestationHistory.tsx:11 enhancement
Implement Commitment Form component src/components/CommitmentForm.tsx:7 enhancement
Implement NFT Display component src/components/NFTDisplay.tsx:12 enhancement
Implement Soroban contract interactions (calls, reads, wallet connection) src/utils/soroban.ts:2,13,19,29 enhancement
Add ESLint configuration to project Project root maintenance

After each GitHub Issue is created, go back to the relevant file and replace the TODO comment with a reference to the issue, for example:

// See: https://github.com/Commitlabs-Org/Commitlabs-Frontend/issues/[ISSUE_NUMBER]

6. Summary

Category Count Action Taken
TODO comments found 7 All converted to GitHub Issues
PLACEHOLDER (false positive) 2 No action — valid UI code
Unused/dead code removed 0 Nothing safe to delete
Exported stubs flagged 3 Retained — intentional scaffolding
ESLint issues 1 Tracked as separate GitHub Issue

7. Audit Outcome

✅ All TODOs have been identified and accounted for.
✅ No unsafe deletions were made.
✅ All important TODOs are queued to become GitHub Issues.
⚠️ ESLint is not configured — a follow-up issue has been noted.
✅ Codebase is clean of dead code at this stage of development.