Source
HN beta feedback from jfim during v1.0-beta launch.
Problem
The skill currently one-shots all three spec files after the
interview completes. The user has no review gate between
requirements.md and design.md — a bad requirements pass gets
built on immediately.
Proposed change
After generating requirements.md, pause and ask:
"Here's your requirements.md — does this look right, or should
we adjust anything before I generate the design?"
Only proceed to design.md after explicit user confirmation.
Same gate between design.md and tasks.md.
Impact
- Catches bad first-pass requirements before they propagate
- Gives users natural checkpoints to course-correct
- Slightly more friction but significantly better output quality
Labels
v1.1, beta-friction
Source
HN beta feedback from jfim during v1.0-beta launch.
Problem
The skill currently one-shots all three spec files after the
interview completes. The user has no review gate between
requirements.md and design.md — a bad requirements pass gets
built on immediately.
Proposed change
After generating requirements.md, pause and ask:
"Here's your requirements.md — does this look right, or should
we adjust anything before I generate the design?"
Only proceed to design.md after explicit user confirmation.
Same gate between design.md and tasks.md.
Impact
Labels
v1.1, beta-friction