diff --git a/src/renderer/components/SubscriptionsLive.vue b/src/renderer/components/SubscriptionsLive.vue
index 4bea31baf8386..76ad79ac023fa 100644
--- a/src/renderer/components/SubscriptionsLive.vue
+++ b/src/renderer/components/SubscriptionsLive.vue
@@ -59,6 +59,8 @@ const fetchSubscriptionsAutomatically = computed(() => store.getters.getFetchSub
 
 const activeSubscriptionList = computed(() => store.getters.getActiveProfile.subscriptions)
 
+const activeProfileId = computed(() => store.getters.getActiveProfile._id)
+
 const cacheEntriesForAllActiveProfileChannels = computed(() => {
   const liveCache = store.getters.getLiveCache
   const entries = []
@@ -140,22 +142,25 @@ function loadVideosFromRemoteFirstPerWindowSometimes() {
 
   alreadyLoadedRemotely = true
   loadVideosForSubscriptionsFromRemote()
-  store.commit('setSubscriptionForLiveStreamsFirstAutoFetchRun')
+  store.commit('setSubscriptionForLiveStreamsFirstAutoFetchRun', activeProfileId.value)
 }
 
 function loadVideosFromCacheSometimes() {
   // Can only load reliably when cache ready
   if (!subscriptionCacheReady.value) { return }
 
-  // This method is called on view visible
-  if (videoCacheForAllActiveProfileChannelsPresent.value) {
-    loadVideosFromCacheForAllActiveProfileChannels()
+  // Check if this profile needs to be auto-fetched for the first time
+  if (fetchSubscriptionsAutomatically.value && !store.getters.getSubscriptionForLiveStreamsFirstAutoFetchRun) {
+    // `isLoading.value = false` is called inside `loadVideosForSubscriptionsFromRemote` when needed
+    alreadyLoadedRemotely = true
+    loadVideosForSubscriptionsFromRemote()
+    store.commit('setSubscriptionForLiveStreamsFirstAutoFetchRun', activeProfileId.value)
     return
   }
 
-  if (fetchSubscriptionsAutomatically.value) {
-    // `isLoading.value = false` is called inside `loadVideosForSubscriptionsFromRemote` when needed
-    loadVideosForSubscriptionsFromRemote()
+  // This method is called on view visible
+  if (videoCacheForAllActiveProfileChannelsPresent.value) {
+    loadVideosFromCacheForAllActiveProfileChannels()
     return
   }
 
diff --git a/src/renderer/components/SubscriptionsPosts.vue b/src/renderer/components/SubscriptionsPosts.vue
index 761d5c0a4636d..0490ed78ae502 100644
--- a/src/renderer/components/SubscriptionsPosts.vue
+++ b/src/renderer/components/SubscriptionsPosts.vue
@@ -49,6 +49,8 @@ const fetchSubscriptionsAutomatically = computed(() => store.getters.getFetchSub
 
 const activeSubscriptionList = computed(() => store.getters.getActiveProfile.subscriptions)
 
+const activeProfileId = computed(() => store.getters.getActiveProfile._id)
+
 const cacheEntriesForAllActiveProfileChannels = computed(() => {
   const postsCache = store.getters.getPostsCache
   const entries = []
@@ -130,22 +132,25 @@ function loadPostsFromRemoteFirstPerWindowSometimes() {
 
   alreadyLoadedRemotely = true
   loadPostsForSubscriptionsFromRemote()
-  store.commit('setSubscriptionForPostsFirstAutoFetchRun')
+  store.commit('setSubscriptionForPostsFirstAutoFetchRun', activeProfileId.value)
 }
 
 function loadPostsFromCacheSometimes() {
   // Can only load reliably when cache ready
   if (!subscriptionCacheReady.value) { return }
 
-  // This method is called on view visible
-  if (postCacheForAllActiveProfileChannelsPresent.value) {
-    loadPostsFromCacheForAllActiveProfileChannels()
+  // Check if this profile needs to be auto-fetched for the first time
+  if (fetchSubscriptionsAutomatically.value && !store.getters.getSubscriptionForPostsFirstAutoFetchRun) {
+    // `isLoading.value = false` is called inside `loadPostsForSubscriptionsFromRemote` when needed
+    alreadyLoadedRemotely = true
+    loadPostsForSubscriptionsFromRemote()
+    store.commit('setSubscriptionForPostsFirstAutoFetchRun', activeProfileId.value)
     return
   }
 
-  if (fetchSubscriptionsAutomatically.value) {
-    // `isLoading.value = false` is called inside `loadPostsForSubscriptionsFromRemote` when needed
-    loadPostsForSubscriptionsFromRemote()
+  // This method is called on view visible
+  if (postCacheForAllActiveProfileChannelsPresent.value) {
+    loadPostsFromCacheForAllActiveProfileChannels()
     return
   }
 
diff --git a/src/renderer/components/SubscriptionsShorts.vue b/src/renderer/components/SubscriptionsShorts.vue
index b31403273e7f4..8a4f5c828e84f 100644
--- a/src/renderer/components/SubscriptionsShorts.vue
+++ b/src/renderer/components/SubscriptionsShorts.vue
@@ -55,6 +55,8 @@ const fetchSubscriptionsAutomatically = computed(() => store.getters.getFetchSub
 
 const activeSubscriptionList = computed(() => store.getters.getActiveProfile.subscriptions)
 
+const activeProfileId = computed(() => store.getters.getActiveProfile._id)
+
 const cacheEntriesForAllActiveProfileChannels = computed(() => {
   const shortsCache = store.getters.getShortsCache
   const entries = []
@@ -135,22 +137,25 @@ function loadVideosFromRemoteFirstPerWindowSometimes() {
 
   alreadyLoadedRemotely = true
   loadVideosForSubscriptionsFromRemote()
-  store.commit('setSubscriptionForShortsFirstAutoFetchRun')
+  store.commit('setSubscriptionForShortsFirstAutoFetchRun', activeProfileId.value)
 }
 
 function loadVideosFromCacheSometimes() {
   // Can only load reliably when cache ready
   if (!subscriptionCacheReady.value) { return }
 
-  // This method is called on view visible
-  if (videoCacheForAllActiveProfileChannelsPresent.value) {
-    loadVideosFromCacheForAllActiveProfileChannels()
+  // Check if this profile needs to be auto-fetched for the first time
+  if (fetchSubscriptionsAutomatically.value && !store.getters.getSubscriptionForShortsFirstAutoFetchRun) {
+    // `isLoading.value = false` is called inside `loadVideosForSubscriptionsFromRemote` when needed
+    alreadyLoadedRemotely = true
+    loadVideosForSubscriptionsFromRemote()
+    store.commit('setSubscriptionForShortsFirstAutoFetchRun', activeProfileId.value)
     return
   }
 
-  if (fetchSubscriptionsAutomatically.value) {
-    // `isLoading.value = false` is called inside `loadVideosForSubscriptionsFromRemote` when needed
-    loadVideosForSubscriptionsFromRemote()
+  // This method is called on view visible
+  if (videoCacheForAllActiveProfileChannelsPresent.value) {
+    loadVideosFromCacheForAllActiveProfileChannels()
     return
   }
 
diff --git a/src/renderer/components/SubscriptionsVideos.vue b/src/renderer/components/SubscriptionsVideos.vue
index 049a1741a07fd..184dbf498c6ab 100644
--- a/src/renderer/components/SubscriptionsVideos.vue
+++ b/src/renderer/components/SubscriptionsVideos.vue
@@ -59,6 +59,8 @@ const fetchSubscriptionsAutomatically = computed(() => store.getters.getFetchSub
 
 const activeSubscriptionList = computed(() => store.getters.getActiveProfile.subscriptions)
 
+const activeProfileId = computed(() => store.getters.getActiveProfile._id)
+
 const cacheEntriesForAllActiveProfileChannels = computed(() => {
   const videoCache = store.getters.getVideoCache
   const entries = []
@@ -139,22 +141,25 @@ function loadVideosFromRemoteFirstPerWindowSometimes() {
 
   alreadyLoadedRemotely = true
   loadVideosForSubscriptionsFromRemote()
-  store.commit('setSubscriptionForVideosFirstAutoFetchRun')
+  store.commit('setSubscriptionForVideosFirstAutoFetchRun', activeProfileId.value)
 }
 
 function loadVideosFromCacheSometimes() {
   // Can only load reliably when cache ready
   if (!subscriptionCacheReady.value) { return }
 
-  // This method is called on view visible
-  if (videoCacheForAllActiveProfileChannelsPresent.value) {
-    loadVideosFromCacheForAllActiveProfileChannels()
+  // Check if this profile needs to be auto-fetched for the first time
+  if (fetchSubscriptionsAutomatically.value && !store.getters.getSubscriptionForVideosFirstAutoFetchRun) {
+    // `isLoading.value = false` is called inside `loadVideosForSubscriptionsFromRemote` when needed
+    alreadyLoadedRemotely = true
+    loadVideosForSubscriptionsFromRemote()
+    store.commit('setSubscriptionForVideosFirstAutoFetchRun', activeProfileId.value)
     return
   }
 
-  if (fetchSubscriptionsAutomatically.value) {
-    // `isLoading.value = false` is called inside `loadVideosForSubscriptionsFromRemote` when needed
-    loadVideosForSubscriptionsFromRemote()
+  // This method is called on view visible
+  if (videoCacheForAllActiveProfileChannelsPresent.value) {
+    loadVideosFromCacheForAllActiveProfileChannels()
     return
   }
 
diff --git a/src/renderer/store/modules/utils.js b/src/renderer/store/modules/utils.js
index 23030154c9cfd..c1807f307f6ff 100644
--- a/src/renderer/store/modules/utils.js
+++ b/src/renderer/store/modules/utils.js
@@ -49,10 +49,10 @@ const state = {
     podcasts: ''
   },
   subscriptionFirstAutoFetchRunData: {
-    videos: false,
-    liveStreams: false,
-    shorts: false,
-    posts: false,
+    videos: new Set(),
+    liveStreams: new Set(),
+    shorts: new Set(),
+    posts: new Set(),
   },
   appTitle: '',
   openPrompts: new Set()
@@ -159,17 +159,21 @@ const getters = {
     return state.lastPopularRefreshTimestamp
   },
 
-  getSubscriptionForVideosFirstAutoFetchRun(state) {
-    return state.subscriptionFirstAutoFetchRunData.videos === true
+  getSubscriptionForVideosFirstAutoFetchRun: (state, getters, rootState, rootGetters) => {
+    const activeProfileId = rootGetters.getActiveProfile._id
+    return state.subscriptionFirstAutoFetchRunData.videos.has(activeProfileId)
   },
-  getSubscriptionForLiveStreamsFirstAutoFetchRun (state) {
-    return state.subscriptionFirstAutoFetchRunData.liveStreams === true
+  getSubscriptionForLiveStreamsFirstAutoFetchRun: (state, getters, rootState, rootGetters) => {
+    const activeProfileId = rootGetters.getActiveProfile._id
+    return state.subscriptionFirstAutoFetchRunData.liveStreams.has(activeProfileId)
   },
-  getSubscriptionForShortsFirstAutoFetchRun (state) {
-    return state.subscriptionFirstAutoFetchRunData.shorts === true
+  getSubscriptionForShortsFirstAutoFetchRun: (state, getters, rootState, rootGetters) => {
+    const activeProfileId = rootGetters.getActiveProfile._id
+    return state.subscriptionFirstAutoFetchRunData.shorts.has(activeProfileId)
   },
-  getSubscriptionForPostsFirstAutoFetchRun (state) {
-    return state.subscriptionFirstAutoFetchRunData.posts === true
+  getSubscriptionForPostsFirstAutoFetchRun: (state, getters, rootState, rootGetters) => {
+    const activeProfileId = rootGetters.getActiveProfile._id
+    return state.subscriptionFirstAutoFetchRunData.posts.has(activeProfileId)
   },
   getAppTitle (state) {
     return state.appTitle
@@ -787,17 +791,17 @@ const mutations = {
     state.openPrompts.delete(id)
   },
 
-  setSubscriptionForVideosFirstAutoFetchRun (state) {
-    state.subscriptionFirstAutoFetchRunData.videos = true
+  setSubscriptionForVideosFirstAutoFetchRun (state, profileId) {
+    state.subscriptionFirstAutoFetchRunData.videos.add(profileId)
   },
-  setSubscriptionForLiveStreamsFirstAutoFetchRun (state) {
-    state.subscriptionFirstAutoFetchRunData.liveStreams = true
+  setSubscriptionForLiveStreamsFirstAutoFetchRun (state, profileId) {
+    state.subscriptionFirstAutoFetchRunData.liveStreams.add(profileId)
   },
-  setSubscriptionForShortsFirstAutoFetchRun (state) {
-    state.subscriptionFirstAutoFetchRunData.shorts = true
+  setSubscriptionForShortsFirstAutoFetchRun (state, profileId) {
+    state.subscriptionFirstAutoFetchRunData.shorts.add(profileId)
   },
-  setSubscriptionForPostsFirstAutoFetchRun (state) {
-    state.subscriptionFirstAutoFetchRunData.posts = true
+  setSubscriptionForPostsFirstAutoFetchRun (state, profileId) {
+    state.subscriptionFirstAutoFetchRunData.posts.add(profileId)
   }
 }