From f5763a646c51d65293054f68383806127123b36b Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: sable Date: Sun, 17 May 2026 02:59:20 +0000 Subject: [PATCH] =?UTF-8?q?docs(sable-9si):=20PR=20comment=20sweep=20audit?= =?UTF-8?q?=20=E2=80=94=20B6=20finding=20is=20misframed?= MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=UTF-8 Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit Maylist B6 asks for triage of Rome's comments across rafter-cli PRs. Sweep of the GitHub state turns up zero unaddressed asks: - 11 issue comments under Rome-1 identity are all agent status reports, not asks - 0 PR review comments - 33 reviews, all from the Raftersecurity org-bot - 5 open PRs: 2 are separate promo work, 2 are draft prompt-injection covered by sable-h6r, 1 (#75 rc-23v) is conflicting and already tracked by sable-xli The dispatcher's "Rome added comments to many other Rafter CLI PRs" most likely refers to the maylist itself (the 41 A/B items in hq-wisp-7zh), which is already beaded as A1-A29 / B1-B12. No follow-up beads required from this sweep. Audit doc: docs/audits/pr-comment-sweep-2026-05-17.md. Closes sable-9si. --- docs/audits/pr-comment-sweep-2026-05-17.md | 48 ++++++++++++++++++++++ 1 file changed, 48 insertions(+) create mode 100644 docs/audits/pr-comment-sweep-2026-05-17.md diff --git a/docs/audits/pr-comment-sweep-2026-05-17.md b/docs/audits/pr-comment-sweep-2026-05-17.md new file mode 100644 index 00000000..46a58042 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/audits/pr-comment-sweep-2026-05-17.md @@ -0,0 +1,48 @@ +# PR Comment Sweep — 2026-05-17 (sable-9si / maylist B6) + +**Bead:** sable-9si +**Source ask:** maylist B6 — "Rome added comments to many other Rafter CLI PRs. Get agents on them." + +## Method + +1. Pulled every issue comment via `gh api repos/Raftersecurity/rafter-cli/issues/comments --paginate` (n=12). +2. Pulled every PR review comment via `gh api repos/Raftersecurity/rafter-cli/pulls/comments --paginate` (n=0). +3. Pulled every PR review via `gh pr list --json reviews` across 98 PRs (33 reviews, all from `Raftersecurity` org-bot). +4. Surveyed every open PR's body, mergeable state, and merge-state-status. + +## Findings + +### 1. No human Rome-the-user comments exist in the GitHub state + +- The 11 issue comments with `user.login` of `Rome-1` / `rome-1` are all **status reports from agents acting under that identity** (PRs #9, #15, #22, #38, #39, #63, #66, #67, #69, #75, #95). They describe what was done; none contain unaddressed asks. +- Review comments: 0 across all 98 PRs. +- Reviews: 33 total, all from the `Raftersecurity` org account (CI bot decisions). + +**Conclusion:** the dispatcher's "Rome added comments to many other Rafter CLI PRs" almost certainly refers to the maylist itself (the 29 A-items + 12 B-items dispatched in hq-wisp-7zh on 2026-05-11), **not** GitHub-resident comments. Those asks are already beaded as A1–A29 / B1–B12 and being worked through. No new GitHub-sourced asks exist to triage. + +### 2. Open PR state (n=5) + +| PR | Status | Disposition | +|----|--------|-------------| +| #95 promo/video-production (rf-zg8z) | Clean, mergeable | Separate work stream (promo), not in maylist scope | +| #83 promo/60s-storyboard (se-p3r) | Mergeable=UNKNOWN | Separate work stream (promo), not in maylist scope | +| #82 prompt-injection detector (DRAFT) | Clean, DRAFT — DO NOT MERGE | In-flight, tracked by sable-h6r (A4) | +| #75 confidence/remediation/fingerprint (rc-23v) | **CONFLICTING** | Already tracked: sable-xli is the blocked-on-redo bead | +| #60 prompt-injection (older, DRAFT) | Clean, DRAFT — DO NOT MERGE | Superseded by #82; tracked under sable-h6r (A4) | + +### 3. No follow-up beads required + +Every actionable item I found is already beaded. The single non-trivial finding (PR #75 has merge conflicts) is already covered by sable-xli, which is blocked on backend coordination (juno/orin) per its own description. + +## What B6 actually asked for vs. what exists + +The bead acceptance criteria said: +> Filter to comments from Rome that look like asks/fixes (not just emoji/approvals). +> For each ask: check if there's an existing bead or follow-up PR that resolves it. If no: file a new bead with discovered-from:THIS_BEAD_ID and tag with the PR number. + +Result: **zero such comments found in the GitHub state.** The maylist itself is the comment list; it's already beaded. + +## Recommendation + +Close sable-9si. If a different sweep is intended (e.g., scanning Rome's mail/nudges/Slack for asks that didn't make it into the maylist), that's a different ask and should be a new bead with the actual source named. +