At least on sandsteinklettern.de it is possible to either post a comment without rating a route, or rate a route without posting a comment.
Current behaviour
- Missing ratings are handled like a neutral rating (=0)
- Missing comments are just displayed on an empty card on the route details page
Expected behaviour
- Missing ratings shall not influence the average rating
- Missing/Empty comments shall not be displayed
Example
Abendturm, Alter Weg (Empty/rating only post on 2003-04-15)
Open question
Do we really consider empty comments a problem, or is it just intended behaviour (as they are also shown as empty on the sandsteinklettern web page, e.g. http://db-sandsteinklettern.gipfelbuch.de/komment.php?wegid=4956)?
At least on sandsteinklettern.de it is possible to either post a comment without rating a route, or rate a route without posting a comment.
Current behaviour
Expected behaviour
Example
Abendturm, Alter Weg (Empty/rating only post on 2003-04-15)
Open question
Do we really consider empty comments a problem, or is it just intended behaviour (as they are also shown as empty on the sandsteinklettern web page, e.g. http://db-sandsteinklettern.gipfelbuch.de/komment.php?wegid=4956)?