v2 - 5.1 FMT_SMF_EXT.1/BT Function-specific Application Note

[woodbe]

Management of the Discoverable and Advertising mode and management of the Bluetooth device name are mandatory. All other management functions for Bluetooth are currently objective.

This seems to point to BT-1, but because of how the requirements are written, it looks like this could also cover BT-6, which doesn't seem to be the intent.

[woodbe]

Only the second paragraph (BT-3) explicitly lists the mapped requirement. The remaining paragraphs should explicitly call out the management requirement it is tied to so there is no confusion about each of these paragraphs. This doesn't mean that every function needs a paragraph, only that these notes need to be tied in, otherwise they could lead to confusion like above.

[jfisherbah]

Clarification needed on intent since there is some contradictory info here. For example, BT-2 is listed as optional but the note on BT-1 says that being able to change the device name is mandatory. I think BT-2 is optional because it wants to be able to define the BR/EDR and LE names as two separate names, but then there is nothing that actually covers the mandatory "manage the device name" situation so it's not clear what we should actually be requiring here.

Also given that all other functions are listed as 'objective', that probably means that these should be assessed to determine whether any of these objective requirements should now be mandatory/optional/removed since they have been in this objective status for a while now