Architecture Board - Meeting Minutes #8
Replies: 32 comments 6 replies
-
2025-07-25Participants
Agenda
Meeting Minutes
|
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
-
2025-08-04Participants
Agenda
Minutes
|
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
-
2025-08-25transferred from #26 WorkstreamsArchitecture Participants
Agenda
Meeting minutesNo response |
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
-
2025-09-01WorkstreamsArchitecture Participants
Agenda including Meeting Minutes
|
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
-
2025-09-08WorkstreamsArchitecture Participants
Agenda
Meeting Minutesto 1. status of UDS2SOVD workstream setup
to 2. status of PR / issue template in
to 3. ISO feedback #30
to 4. status on client side
|
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
-
2025-09-15WorkstreamsArchitecture Participants@thilo-schmitt Agenda
Meeting Minutesto 1. update on UDS2SOVD workstream setup
to 2. info: OpenSOVD talk at Eclipse SDV Community Meetup Detroit
to 3. info: CDA workstream with a demo on odx descriptions
to 4. question on status of FaultLib
to 5. how to handle requirements
|
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
-
2025-09-22WorkstreamsArchitecture Participants• @floroks Agenda including Meeting Minutes
|
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
-
2025-09-29WorkstreamsArchitecture Participants@thilo-schmitt Agenda
Meeting Minutesto 1. info: CDA workstream meeting today is cancelledAs decided in last week's workstream meeting, today's (09/29) instance of CDA meeting is cancelled. to 2. info: UDS2SOVD workstream meeting added to READMEUDS2SOVD meeting series was already setup in Eclipse SDV WG Community Calendar. Now an meeting invite as to 3. OpenSOVD logoOpenSOVD as a project has no logo yet. @thilo-schmitt is trying to get the professionals at his organization to create one. (This also relates to issue #29.) to 4. question on plans for contribution@stmuench: Does anyone plan to contribute to the FaultLib or the SOVD Server. |
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
-
2025-10-06WorkstreamsArchitecture Participants@thilo-schmitt (Mercedes-Benz Tech Innovation) Agenda
Meeting Minutesto 1. how close to the SOVD spec do we want implement?@lh-sag presents his motivation: reduce friction, internal and external to the project, as well as towards standardization Feedback from @stmuench, Roland Jentsch, Simone Kriso on how deviations could be handled and that we should drive clarification in the ISO standard. AR: @lh-sag: Provide concrete proposal text. (-> dev mail list?) ( ✅ #43) to 2. supervision of approvals@stmuench: Currently preparing design proposals, but touching several components (has cross-cutting impact). How do we approach project-wide agreement? |
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
-
2025-10-13WorkstreamsArchitecture Participants@thilo-schmitt (Mercedes-Benz Tech Innovation) Agenda
Meeting Minutesto 1. Contribution pitch: Onboard ClientVenkat Sundar (Systream) presents a proposal for contribution: Onboard Client
Discussion points:
Next steps:
to 2. OpenSOVD as contribution pitch for S-CORESee S-CORE Feature: https://eclipse-score.github.io/score/main/features/diagnostics/index.html @stmuench how will the integration in S-CORE specifically work (APIs, processes, CI, pulling code, etc.)? AR: @timkl7 to prepare contribution pitch (S-CORE view) to 3. ISO standard conformance guidelinesAlso see #43
Call to action for everyone: Please leave feedback as comments on the issue (see reference above) and move the discussion there. Once we accrued a critical mass of feedback, we can bring this back here for decision-making and instantiating a decision record. to 4. Draft PR Middleware API Layer for User ApplicationsSee #46 |
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
-
2025-10-20WorkstreamsArchitecture Participants@timkl7 (Mercedes-Benz Tech Innovation) Agenda
Meeting MinutesMVP Scope and Timeline
Fault Lib
Instances of Gateway + CDA
|
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
-
2025-10-27WorkstreamsArchitecture Participants@timkl7 Agenda
Meeting Minutes-> cancelled due to vacation |
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
-
2025-11-03WorkstreamsArchitecture Participants@thilo-schmitt (Mercedes-Benz Tech Innovation) Agenda
Meeting Minutesto 1. MVP Scope ReviewSee #53 AR: @timkl7: to update the PR with the feedback to 2. Fault Lib APISee eclipse-opensovd/fault-lib#1 AR: @timkl7: to update the PR based on the feedback given. to 3. Services API ReviewDue to time limitations, we offload the discussion to the Core workstream (Tues @ 11am CET) |
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
-
2025-11-10WorkstreamsArchitecture Participants@thilo-schmitt (Mercedes-Benz Tech Innovation) Agenda
Meeting Minutesto 1. Information on recent/upcoming talks on OpenSOVD
to 2. Report results from OpenSOVD pitch at S-CORE Architecture WorkshopFault API design and MVP scope was presented at the S-CORE workshop. Both accepted and confirmed from the S-CORE side. to 3. Question: Split of SOVD Gateway and Server@rama492 voiced a need for agreement on whether gateway and server should be separate or one single component. to 4. Question on design of fault API, mapping DTC statusSimone Kriso voiced concerns on unclear specification how test run outcomes are reported and when test runs happen within the driving cycle. Martin Jehle underlined the importance of this, e.g. clearing fault memory is critical and synchronizing the state across the components in the stack. to 5. MVP scope definition (cont'd)Refining discussion on the proposal. Couple questions around what's in and out. Going through the diagram. |
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
-
2025-11-17WorkstreamsArchitecture ParticipantsThilo Schmitt (Mercedes-Benz Tech Innovation) @thilo-schmitt Agenda
Meeting Minutesto 1. Status of PRsPR on fault lib (eclipse-opensovd/fault-lib#1) closed, merged as a first version, with feedback integrated from Simone. Happy to receive any further feedback and refinements. |
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
-
2025-12-08WorkstreamsArchitecture ParticipantsThilo Schmitt (Mercedes-Benz Tech Innovation) @thilo-schmitt Agenda
Meeting Minutesto 1. CI/CD-Workflows repo exists now - call for review, usage & contributionRepository is at: https://github.com/eclipse-opensovd/cicd-workflows to 2. tracing-dlt crateSee: https://crates.io/crates/tracing-dlt
to 3. Eclipse initial contribution IP checkAs per Eclipse project creation process an IP check is to be done after initial contribution. Since some code is already there, we'll proceed to trigger this IP check. (@thilo-schmitt drives this.) to 4. Meeting cancellation during holiday seasonArchitecture Board will be cancelled over holiday season. We'll resume operations on January 12th 2026. to 5. FaultLib repo structureRafal Brewka presents. See PR: eclipse-opensovd/fault-lib#3 to 6. Adding hardware into CIVadim Selinger (Qualcomm) proposes to add actual hardware into CI runs. Argument is to enable gaining some (more) meaningful performance data. Asks for feedback whether this is interesting to the project / community. |
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
-
2026-01-12WorkstreamsArchitecture ParticipantsThilo Schmitt (Mercedes-Benz Tech Innovation) @thilo-schmitt Agenda
Meeting Minutesto 1. Implementation statusCore workstream: @rama492: Plan is to go with @lh-sag's implementation for Server. Not yet Production code, we'll take it from that base onwards. @stmuench: Client API design in PR discussion, pending approval to 2. Logging issue tracker URL (in all components)Context: Came up in @jleuser's comment on CDA PR eclipse-opensovd/classic-diagnostic-adapter#123 and the evolving discussion. to 3. Aligning linting rules across all componentsContext: see discussion on CDA PR eclipse-opensovd/classic-diagnostic-adapter#121 to 4. Authentication / authorization concept for OpenSOVDKai proposes Spiffe to be used as a common framework. |
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
-
2026-01-19WorkstreamsArchitecture ParticipantsThilo Schmitt (Mercedes-Benz Tech Innovation) @thilo-schmitt Agenda
Meeting Minutesto 0. AI bot participationObserving the attendance of an AI bot ("...'s Notetaker (Otter.ai)") - which raised concerns with other attendees. to 1. OpenSOVD at PlugFest @ HS EsslingenPlugFest with S-CORE and OpenSOVD planned for CW18/2026 at HS Esslingen. For details please contact @chheis to 2. Eclipse SDV Community Days in Bonn @ T-SystemsEclipse SDV Community Days are scheduled for end of February in Bonn. to 3. Info: FaultLib PRAn implementation proposal for FaultLib is available: eclipse-opensovd/fault-lib#4
Therefore: call for engagement leading the FaultLib engineering. @rama492 will look into this, but unclear how far the support / ownership can go. to 4. Design documents - where to merge and howPR pending: #46 to 5. Integration of OpenSOVD in S-CORE - Rust build systemIn OpenSOVD uses Cargo so far, S-CORE uses Bazel. |
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
-
2026-01-26WorkstreamsArchitecture ParticipantsThilo Schmitt (Mercedes-Benz Tech Innovation) @thilo-schmitt Agenda
Meeting Minutesto 1. Documentation and Traceability of RequirementsSee #74 to 2. Onboard Diagnostic Client ProposalSkipped due to Venkat Sundar not being available. to 3. Eclipse SCORE wants to discuss integration with us - they ask for a meeting@thilo-schmitt to organize meeting between S-CORE and OpenSOVD. Participants for OpenSOVD (at least one representative per workstream): Unclear curently who asked for it and will participate from S-CORE. |
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
-
2026-02-02WorkstreamsArchitecture ParticipantsThilo Schmitt (Mercedes-Benz Tech Innovation) @thilo-schmitt Agenda
Meeting Minutesto 1. Onboard Diagnostic Client ProposalVenkat Sundar presents follow-up to the contribution pitch from 2025-10-13. Presented slides: 2026-02-02_OnBoard_Client_Proposal_Update.pdf to 2. Decision: Support of C++ applications@stmuench: OpenSOVD stack will be written in Rust. We need a way to integrate this with existing software, which is mostly written in C++. to 3. How to handle stale PRsIn the CDA we have some stale PRs (e.g. no ECA signed since December). How should we as a project handle these? Individual by each component, or do we want a project-wide policy (e.g. remind them after a month, and again after additional week, and close after with no activity?) |
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
-
2026-02-09WorkstreamsArchitecture Participants@timkl7 Agenda
Meeting Minutesto 1. Architecture Decision Record: Rust formatting and linting [Proposal]See #80 to 2. Architecture Decision Record: Handling stale PRs [Proposal]See #82 to 3. Fault-lib PRSee eclipse-opensovd/fault-lib#4
to 4. ODX converter in Kotlin
|
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
-
2026-02-16WorkstreamsArchitecture ParticipantsRoland Jentsch (ETAS) Meeting MinutesArchitecture Decision Record: Rust formatting and linting [Proposal]no opposition to ADR, we will do it as proposed @alexmohr will implement it Architecture Decision Record: Handling stale PRs [Proposal]discussion about days until stale / closed label automatically for issues -> triage, logic only applies if the issue has that label proposal: use 60/30 for PRs and issues, logic only applies to issues with the label process for looking at stale issues - e.g. filter and look at it in the workstreams proposal: 60/30 for PRs -- 90 / 30 for issues vote: decision 90:30 @floroks will implement it Responsibility and further development for fault lib and fault managerquestions on who is responsible, and how it'll be further developed, no information available -> next meeting @thilo-schmitt if no one is contributing we need to revise MVP scope |
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
-
2026-02-23WorkstreamsArchitecture ParticipantsThilo Schmitt (Mercedes-Benz Tech Innovation) @thilo-schmitt Agenda
Meeting Minutesto 1. Status SOVD Server / FaultLib progress and outlooikContext / data points:
OEM interest voiced to make native SOVD PoC in an actual car - requires Server / FaultLib components to be in some sensible state of availability. @rama492: Currently team looking into implementation proposal; rough expectation is that this could be merged to main the next 2-3 weeks, providing agreement in the workstream. @stmuench: Should have an incubation step before we accept FaultLib code into main. to 2. Bazel build / integration strategy with S-CORE@stmuench and @bburda42dot are both working on some aspects of a Bazel build. Only puzzle pieces, not an integration solution right now. Might make sense to exchange on the work being done there, to avoid doubled efforts. |
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
-
2026-03-02WorkstreamsArchitecture Agenda
Meeting Minutesto 1. Committers in subreposHow do we get the right persons, maintainers in subrepos, to become committers. to 2. S-CORE Feature Team for OpenSOVDS-CORE Feature Team for Diagnostics in formation. Related, in-depth discussion: Where should API designs live? |
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
-
2026-03-09WorkstreamsArchitecture ParticipantsSvetlana Serpik (Softing) Agenda
Meeting Minutesto 1. Forking of Sam Preston's DoIP implementation into OpenSOVDFor initial context see eclipse-opensovd/uds2sovd-proxy#4 (comment) and following. @theswiftfox : Issues: focussed on no-std environment, we require custom socket stuff (e.g. tls), upstreaming makes it harder to iterate, Sam seems to use it differently. Our fork removes some python stuff due to build issues. Consensus: We should do it, further discussion about how regarding licenses etc. will be done by Thilo and @floroks - CDA workstream will be in the lead for integration. docs-as-codeQuestion on when @floroks can present docs as code --> Still in discussion with our ASPICE folks, basic idea is to use process description from score, simplify the meta model a bit (similar to how it's currently in the CDA). Will take a bit more time. |
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
-
2026-03-16Cancelled. |
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
-
2026-03-23WorkstreamsArchitecture ParticipantsThilo Schmitt (Mercedes-Benz Tech Innovation) @thilo-schmitt Agenda
Meeting Minutesto 1. OpenSOVD LogoContext: See #29 to 2. Initial IP scan completedSee https://gitlab.eclipse.org/eclipsefdn/emo-team/emo/-/issues/983#note_6648215
to 3. OpenSOVD F2F WorkshopProposal to hold a face-to-face workshop to have very focused and efficient discussions on the various open topics to drive them towards finalization. @lh-sag offered to potentially host this at the Liebherr site in Ulm - to be confirmed and details to be worked out. In general possible dates and an workshop agenda has still to be worked out.
Please engage in the discussion and give your input which topics you think should be handled at the workshop. Please also follow the discussion to give feedback and track preparation. |
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
-
2026-04-13WorkstreamsArchitecture ParticipantsThilo Schmitt (Mercedes-Benz Tech Innovation) @thilo-schmitt Agenda
Meeting Minutesto 1. Reminder OpenSOVD LogoSee #29 to 2. Reminder OpenSOVD F2F WorkshopPlease engage in the discussion and give your input which topics you think should be handled at the workshop. Please also follow the discussion to give feedback and track preparation.
to 3. Info: OpenSOVD talk @ OCX 2026There will be talk on OpenSOVD next week at the OCX 2026 conference: https://www.ocxconf.org/event/2026/agenda?session=848fe283-330f-4937-88e4-8ed3c9adb9a6&shareLink=true to 4. Info: Hackfest @ HS EssslingenOpenSOVD is part of the Hackfest @ HS Esslingen, happening 28th/29th April 2026: https://luma.com/1m5bqx2o to 5. Status Fault API@rama492 asks for status/progress on the fault API to 6. Client lib design / implementation proposal@stmuench created a proposal of the client lib design and possible implementation. Lives in diagnostics iincubation repo in S-CORE: eclipse-score/inc_diagnostics#1 |
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
-
2026-04-20WorkstreamsArchitecture Participantsbozlak AgendaF2F meetingquestion on dates (https://github.com/eclipse-opensovd/opensovd/wiki/1.-Eclipse-OpenSOVD-Meetup), since first proposed date is approaching @lh-sag - we should do a poll when all dates are available to pick one with most participation. fault manager prquestion on how to continue with the fault manager PR -> old one was closed, new one needs to be reviewed opensovd integration into score
Meeting Minutes |
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
-
2026-04-27WorkstreamsArchitecture ParticipantsThilo Schmitt (Mercedes-Benz Tech Innovation) @thilo-schmitt Agenda
Meeting Minutesto 1. OpenSOVD F2F workshopPlease feedback interest in workshop and possible dates. to 2. S-CORE integration F2F workshopA technical workshop in Ulm (targeted for mid-May, exact dates tbd) was proposed to advance diagnostics in S-CORE through the integration of OpenSOVD. The goal is to identify architectural gaps, define a target technical setup, and clarify concrete next steps, and have focus on requirements from adopters. The workshop aims to address open architecture decisions that currently slow down native diagnostics integration and to foster adoption. Theoretically could be combined with OpenSOVD-F2F (see previous agenda item) into one larger workshop. That might help with logistics and organization. On the other hand, it's really two different topics. Also note: Polly on Slack for regular feature team meeting on OpenSOVD integration in S-CORE: https://sdvworkinggroup.slack.com/archives/C0AHJC1Q9BL/p1776679154995299 -- we would see the workshop as a "kickoff" and then go into regular operations using the agreed time slot from the Polly. Announcement to be made via S-CORE and OpenSOVD mailing lists and/or Slack channels. Your feedback then appreciated. to 3.
|
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
Uh oh!
There was an error while loading. Please reload this page.
Uh oh!
There was an error while loading. Please reload this page.
-
2025-07-21
Participants
Agenda
Meeting Minutes
Work packages
Technical components:
High level definition here: https://github.com/eclipse-opensovd/opensovd/blob/main/docs/design/design.md
Cross functional topics:
Project setup
Misc
To do
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
All reactions