Skip to content

TESTING.md

Latest commit

 

History

History
230 lines (193 loc) · 7.34 KB

TESTING.md

File metadata and controls

230 lines (193 loc) · 7.34 KB
Raw

Production Testing & Refinement

Testing Strategy

This document tracks production testing results and refinements for BitPerfectCore.

Test Plan

Phase 1: Single File Playback ✅

  • WAV file playback (tested in Phase 2)
  • FLAC file playback (tested in Phase 3)
  • FLAC file playback (production testing - Jan 17, 2026)
  • ALAC file playback
  • AIFF file playback
  • Sample rate 44.1kHz (tested)
  • Sample rate reconfiguration (96kHz → 44.1kHz tested)
  • Bit depth 16-bit (tested)
  • Bit depth 24-bit

Phase 2: Playlist Playback ✅

  • Multiple WAV files (tested)
  • Multiple FLAC files
  • Mixed formats (FLAC + WAV) - tested Jan 17, 2026
  • Different sample rates in playlist
  • Long playlists (10+ tracks)

Phase 3: Gapless Transitions

  • Verify zero-gap between tracks
  • Test with same format tracks
  • Test with different format tracks
  • Test with different sample rate tracks
  • Measure actual gap duration

Phase 4: Edge Cases

  • Empty playlist
  • Single track playlist
  • Invalid file paths
  • Corrupted audio files
  • Very short tracks (< 5 seconds)
  • Very long tracks (> 30 minutes)

Phase 5: Performance

  • Memory usage profiling
  • CPU usage monitoring
  • Buffer underrun detection
  • Exclusive mode stability
  • Long-running playback (1+ hour)

Known Issues

Issue 1: GaplessEngine Audio Output

Status: ✅ RESOLVED - Audio confirmed playing
Priority: High
Description: GaplessEngine may not produce actual audio output due to buffer synchronization timing between feedAudioBuffers() and the IOProc callback.

Resolution: Testing confirmed that audio IS playing. The buffer synchronization is working correctly. The feedAudioBuffers() method successfully enqueues buffers and the IOProc callback consumes them properly.

Test Evidence:

  • Single file playback: Audio confirmed playing
  • Playlist playback: Audio confirmed playing
  • Exclusive mode working
  • No buffer underruns detected

Issue 2: Preload Logic

Status: ✅ FIXED
Priority: Medium
Description: preloadNextTrack() was trying to get the current track instead of the next track.

Location: GaplessEngine.swift:183

Fix Applied:

  • Added PlaylistManager.peekNext() method
  • Updated preloadNextTrack() to use peekNext()
  • Method now correctly previews next track without advancing

Commit: b4f1053

Test Results

Test 1: Single FLAC Playback

Date: Phase 3
File: London Philharmonic Orchestra - Time.flac
Format: FLAC, 44.1kHz, 16-bit, Stereo
Result: ✅ PASS
Notes:

  • Format detection working
  • Metadata extraction working
  • Exclusive mode enabled
  • Sample rate matching working
  • Bit depth correctly detected

Test 2: Single WAV Playback

Date: Phase 2
File: Pink Floyd - On The Run.wav
Format: WAV, 44.1kHz, 16-bit, Stereo
Result: ✅ PASS
Notes:

  • Playback successful
  • Exclusive mode working
  • No crashes or memory issues

Test 3: Single FLAC Playback (Production Testing)

Date: January 17, 2026
File: London Philharmonic Orchestra - Time.flac
Format: FLAC, 44.1kHz, 16-bit, Stereo
Result: ✅ PASS
Notes:

  • Format detection: ✅ FLAC identified correctly
  • Metadata: ✅ Displayed properly
  • Sample rate: ✅ Device reconfigured from 96 kHz to 44.1 kHz
  • Exclusive mode: ✅ Enabled (bit-perfect)
  • Audio playback: ✅ Confirmed playing
  • Stability: ✅ No crashes

Test 4: Playlist with Mixed Formats (Production Testing)

Date: January 17, 2026
Files:

  • Track 1: London Philharmonic Orchestra - Time.flac (FLAC, 8:13)
  • Track 2: Pink Floyd - On The Run.wav (WAV, 3:31)
  • Track 3: Pink Floyd - Any Colour You Like.wav (WAV, 3:25) Result: ✅ PASS
    Notes:
  • Track loading: ✅ All 3 tracks loaded successfully
  • Format detection: ✅ FLAC and WAV both detected
  • Mixed formats: ✅ FLAC + WAV combination working
  • Playlist summary: ✅ Total duration calculated (15:10)
  • Exclusive mode: ✅ Enabled (bit-perfect)
  • Playback started: ✅ Track 1 playing
  • Stability: ✅ No crashes during loading or playback
  • CLI output: ✅ Clean and informative

Test 5: Edge Case - Empty Playlist (Production Testing)

Date: January 17, 2026
Command: BitPerfectCLI playlist (no files) Result: ✅ PASS
Notes:

  • Error handling: ✅ Proper error message displayed
  • User guidance: ✅ Usage instructions shown
  • No crash: ✅ Graceful exit

Test 6: Edge Case - Invalid File (Production Testing)

Date: January 17, 2026
File: /nonexistent/file.flac Result: ✅ PASS
Notes:

  • File validation: ✅ Missing file detected
  • Error handling: ✅ Warning message displayed
  • Graceful skip: ✅ Continues checking other files
  • No crash: ✅ Clean handling

Test 7: Edge Case - Single Track Playlist (Production Testing)

Date: January 17, 2026
File: Pink Floyd - On The Run.wav (WAV, 3:31) Result: ✅ PASS
Notes:

  • Single track: ✅ Handled correctly
  • Playlist summary: ✅ "1 tracks" displayed
  • Playback: ✅ Started successfully
  • Exclusive mode: ✅ Enabled
  • Stability: ✅ No issues

Test 8: Two-Track Playlist with Improved Buffer Timing (Production Testing)

Date: January 17, 2026
Files:

  • Track 1: Pink Floyd - On The Run.wav (WAV, 3:31)
  • Track 2: Pink Floyd - Any Colour You Like.wav (WAV, 3:25) Result: ✅ PASS
    Notes:
  • Buffer timing: ✅ Dynamic sleep calculation working
  • Playback: ✅ Smooth audio output
  • Track transition: ✅ Ready for gapless transition
  • Exclusive mode: ✅ Enabled
  • Stability: ✅ No buffer issues

Refinements Completed ✅

1. Buffer Synchronization ✅

  • ✅ IOProc callback verified consuming buffers correctly
  • ✅ Dynamic buffer timing based on sample rate and buffer size
  • ✅ Improved sleep calculation: sleepTime = bufferSize / sampleRate * 0.8
  • ✅ Prevents buffer starvation and overflow

2. Preload Logic ✅

  • ✅ Fixed preloadNextTrack() to use peekNext()
  • ✅ Added PlaylistManager.peekNext() method
  • ✅ Respects all repeat modes (off, one, all)

3. Error Handling ✅

  • ✅ Graceful handling of missing files with warnings
  • ✅ Unsupported format detection and skipping
  • ✅ Empty playlist validation
  • ✅ Invalid file path handling
  • ✅ Decoder error recovery

4. Track Transition Cleanup ✅

  • ✅ Buffer clearing between track transitions
  • ✅ Proper state reset on stop
  • ✅ isPreloadingNext flag reset on stop

5. State Management ✅

  • ✅ Pause/resume functionality implemented
  • ✅ Stop with full cleanup
  • ✅ State publishers working (playing, paused, stopped, finished)
  • ✅ Track change notifications via Combine

Refinements Still Needed

1. Memory Management

  • Profile memory usage during long playback
  • Verify buffers are released properly
  • Check for memory leaks with Instruments

2. Gapless Transition Verification

  • Measure actual gap duration between tracks
  • Test with tracks of different sample rates
  • Optimize transition timing

3. Performance Optimization

  • CPU usage profiling
  • Buffer pool optimization
  • Reduce allocation overhead

Next Steps

  1. Fix preload logic bug
  2. Add PlaylistManager.peekNext() method
  3. Test playlist command with real files
  4. Verify audio output from GaplessEngine
  5. Profile memory and CPU usage
  6. Document all findings