Skip to content

A2A protocol returns no citations in developer telemetry (message/send + message/stream) — CLI/BizChat do; contradicts m365-semantics citations.md #153

Description

@bgervin

Summary

The A2A protocol does not return citations in its developer telemetry. For the same agent + prompt where the workiq CLI surfaces citations, an A2A client gets no citation data: no inline [n] markers, no references[], and an empty Answer artifact citation map. This appears to contradict the documented A2A m365 semantics: https://microsoftgraph.visualstudio.com/Graph%20Developer%20Experiences/_git/work-iq-docs?path=/A2A/m365-semantics/citations.md.

Scope — A2A protocol (endpoint https://workiq.svc.cloud.microsoft/a2a/)

Tested both A2A methods with params.configuration.acceptedOutputModes = ["text/plain","application/vnd.ms-workiq.developer-info","application/vnd.ms-workiq-internal.retrieval"], header X-variants: feature.EnableA2AServer:

  • message/send -> no references, no inline [n], no targetLink.
  • message/stream -> artifacts [Answer, Developer Info, Retrieval Info]; Retrieval has 2 execs/~4 hits; Answer citation map = 0 entries; no inline [n]; hits have no webUrl.

Control — workiq CLI (same agent, same prompt) DOES return citations

workiq ask -q "When is my next holiday?" --agent-id <id> --developer --json returns a top-level references array ({ id, targetLink, isCitedInResponse:true }) and inline [1](https://…Holidays_Canada.docx) in the answer. BizChat renders the same source chips. So the citation data exists end-to-end — the A2A protocol surface is the only place it's missing.

Expected

A2A developer telemetry should expose citations per the m365-semantics citations.md — e.g. a references/citation map (with targetLink + isCitedInResponse) on message/send and on the message/stream Answer artifact — at parity with the CLI/BizChat.

Impact

A2A consumers (dev UIs, eval tools) can't measure citation/grounding. The M365 Copilot evals Citations evaluator scores 0 over A2A. Companion: microsoft/m365-copilot-eval#31.

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions