From a2b48be4e30e05f0ebf3059f8727fb6b98c120c1 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Jorge Castro Date: Mon, 1 Jun 2026 13:03:39 +0200 Subject: [PATCH] Replace implement-plan with evolution version, fix plugin versioning - implement-plan-evolution becomes the new implement-plan (orchestrator model with TDD + bugmagnet + test-desiderata delegation) - Remove old implement-plan skill and its workspace (7 evals, 3 iterations) - Keep evolution evals as the new implement-plan-workspace (5 evals, 2 iterations) - Remove duplicate version fields from marketplace.json (plugin.json is the single source of truth per official docs) - Bump stepwise-core to v1.4.0 --- .claude-plugin/marketplace.json | 7 +- CLAUDE.md | 2 +- core/.claude-plugin/plugin.json | 2 +- .../evals/evals.json | 109 ----- .../iteration-1/benchmark.json | 187 -------- .../outputs/add-inventory-features.md | 34 -- .../outputs/extend-string-helpers.md | 32 -- .../outputs/add-username-validation.md | 15 - .../iteration-2/benchmark.json | 66 --- .../eval_metadata.json | 1 - .../with_skill/grading.json | 10 - .../outputs/add-inventory-features.md | 34 -- .../with_skill/timing.json | 5 - .../without_skill/grading.json | 10 - .../outputs/add-inventory-features.md | 34 -- .../without_skill/outputs/inventory.py | 37 -- .../without_skill/timing.json | 5 - .../outputs/add-stats-functions.md | 25 - .../outputs/add-unit-converters.md | 15 - .../iteration-2/feedback.json | 4 - .../inventory.py | 42 -- .../shared/plans/add-inventory-features.md | 34 -- .../Makefile | 7 - .../inventory.py | 37 -- .../test_inventory.py | 111 ----- .../shared/plans/add-inventory-features.md | 34 -- .../shared/plans/add-stats-functions.md | 25 - .../shared/plans/add-stats-functions.md | 25 - .../shared/plans/add-username-validation.md | 15 - .../shared/plans/add-username-validation.md | 15 - .../shared/plans/extend-string-helpers.md | 36 -- .../Makefile | 7 - .../test_text.py | 64 --- .../text_transforms.py | 24 - .../text_utils.py | 19 - .../shared/plans/extend-string-helpers.md | 24 - .../converter.py | 22 - .../shared/plans/add-unit-converters.md | 15 - .../Makefile | 7 - .../test_converter.py | 42 -- .../shared/plans/add-unit-converters.md | 15 - core/skills/implement-plan-evolution/SKILL.md | 164 ------- .../implement-plan-workspace/.gitignore | 7 - .../implement-plan-workspace/evals/evals.json | 134 +++--- .../eval-1-phase-discipline/inventory.py | 19 + .../test_inventory_bugmagnet.py | 0 .../shared/plans/add-inventory-features.md | 28 +- .../eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/Makefile | 7 - .../eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/order.py | 25 - .../eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/test_order.py | 75 --- .../shared/plans/add-order-lifecycle.md | 26 - .../eval-3-manual-verification/Makefile | 7 - .../eval-3-manual-verification/formatter.py | 18 - .../test_formatter.py | 65 --- .../shared/plans/add-formatting-features.md | 25 - .../projects/eval-3-pause-order/Makefile | 0 .../projects/eval-3-pause-order/stats.py | 0 .../projects/eval-3-pause-order/test_stats.py | 0 .../projects/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/Makefile | 0 .../eval-4-bugmagnet-format/test_validator.py | 0 .../test_validator_bugmagnet.py | 0 .../eval-4-bugmagnet-format/validator.py | 0 .../eval-4-cascade-dependencies/Makefile | 7 - .../test_tracker.py | 160 ------- .../shared/plans/build-task-tracker.md | 45 -- .../eval-4-cascade-dependencies/tracker.py | 1 - .../text_transforms.py | 16 + .../eval-5-evolved-codebase/text_utils.py | 11 + .../shared/plans/extend-string-helpers.md | 32 +- .../eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/Makefile | 7 - .../eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/registration.py | 30 -- .../test_registration.py | 109 ----- .../shared/plans/add-registration-workflow.md | 25 - .../eval-7-completion-messaging/converter.py | 16 + .../shared/plans/add-unit-converters.md | 12 +- .../iteration-1/benchmark.json | 283 +++++------ .../eval_metadata.json | 0 .../with_skill/grading.json | 0 .../with_skill/outputs/transcript.md | 0 .../with_skill/timing.json | 0 .../without_skill/grading.json | 0 .../outputs}/add-inventory-features.md | 0 .../without_skill/outputs}/inventory.py | 0 .../without_skill/outputs/transcript.md | 0 .../without_skill/timing.json | 0 .../eval_metadata.json | 13 - .../eval-1-simple-two-phase/project/Makefile | 2 - .../project/calculator.py | 16 - .../project/test_calculator.py | 31 -- .../shared/plans/add-calculator-operations.md | 29 -- .../with_skill/grading.json | 40 -- .../outputs/add-calculator-operations.md | 29 -- .../with_skill/outputs/calculator.py | 16 - .../with_skill/outputs/transcript.md | 53 --- .../with_skill/timing.json | 5 - .../without_skill/grading.json | 40 -- .../outputs/add-calculator-operations.md | 29 -- .../without_skill/outputs/calculator.py | 16 - .../without_skill/outputs/transcript.md | 36 -- .../without_skill/timing.json | 5 - .../eval_metadata.json | 0 .../with_skill/grading.json | 0 .../outputs}/extend-string-helpers.md | 0 .../with_skill/outputs}/text_transforms.py | 0 .../with_skill/outputs}/text_utils.py | 0 .../with_skill/outputs/transcript.md | 0 .../with_skill/timing.json | 0 .../without_skill/grading.json | 0 .../outputs/extend-string-helpers.md | 0 .../without_skill}/outputs/text_transforms.py | 0 .../without_skill}/outputs/text_utils.py | 0 .../without_skill/outputs/transcript.md | 0 .../without_skill/timing.json | 0 .../eval-2-plan-mismatch/eval_metadata.json | 12 - .../eval-2-plan-mismatch/project/Makefile | 2 - .../eval-2-plan-mismatch/project/auth.py | 28 -- .../eval-2-plan-mismatch/project/test_auth.py | 23 - .../shared/plans/improve-auth-logging.md | 26 - .../with_skill/grading.json | 35 -- .../with_skill/outputs/auth.py | 28 -- .../outputs/improve-auth-logging.md | 26 - .../with_skill/outputs/transcript.md | 68 --- .../with_skill/timing.json | 5 - .../without_skill/grading.json | 35 -- .../without_skill/outputs/auth.py | 28 -- .../outputs/improve-auth-logging.md | 23 - .../without_skill/outputs/transcript.md | 79 ---- .../without_skill/timing.json | 5 - .../eval-3-pause-order/eval_metadata.json | 0 .../with_skill/grading.json | 0 .../with_skill/outputs/transcript.md | 0 .../eval-3-pause-order/with_skill/timing.json | 0 .../without_skill/grading.json | 0 .../outputs}/add-stats-functions.md | 0 .../without_skill/outputs/stats.py | 0 .../without_skill/outputs/transcript.md | 0 .../without_skill/timing.json | 0 .../eval-3-resume-partial/eval_metadata.json | 13 - .../eval-3-resume-partial/project/Makefile | 2 - .../eval-3-resume-partial/project/app.js | 29 -- .../eval-3-resume-partial/project/app.test.js | 42 -- .../project/package.json | 10 - .../plans/add-validation-and-logging.md | 39 -- .../project/validator.js | 25 - .../with_skill/grading.json | 40 -- .../outputs/add-validation-and-logging.md | 39 -- .../with_skill/outputs/app.js | 29 -- .../with_skill/outputs/transcript.md | 46 -- .../with_skill/timing.json | 5 - .../without_skill/grading.json | 40 -- .../outputs/add-validation-and-logging.md | 39 -- .../without_skill/outputs/app.js | 29 -- .../without_skill/outputs/transcript.md | 43 -- .../without_skill/timing.json | 5 - .../eval_metadata.json | 0 .../with_skill/grading.json | 0 .../with_skill/outputs/transcript.md | 0 .../with_skill/timing.json | 0 .../without_skill/grading.json | 0 .../outputs}/add-username-validation.md | 0 .../without_skill/outputs/transcript.md | 0 .../without_skill/outputs/validator.py | 0 .../without_skill/timing.json | 0 .../eval_metadata.json | 0 .../with_skill/grading.json | 0 .../outputs}/add-unit-converters.md | 0 .../with_skill/outputs}/converter.py | 0 .../with_skill/outputs/transcript.md | 0 .../with_skill/timing.json | 0 .../without_skill/grading.json | 0 .../outputs/add-unit-converters.md | 0 .../without_skill}/outputs/converter.py | 0 .../without_skill/outputs/transcript.md | 0 .../without_skill/timing.json | 0 .../iteration-2/benchmark.json | 445 +++--------------- .../iteration-2/benchmark.md | 13 - .../eval_metadata.json | 15 +- .../with_skill/grading.json | 10 +- .../outputs/add-inventory-features.md | 2 +- .../with_skill/outputs/inventory.py | 11 +- .../with_skill/outputs/transcript.md | 0 .../with_skill/timing.json | 6 +- .../without_skill/grading.json | 10 +- .../outputs/add-inventory-features.md | 28 +- .../without_skill/outputs/transcript.md | 0 .../without_skill/timing.json | 6 +- .../eval_metadata.json | 14 - .../with_skill/grading.json | 14 - .../with_skill/outputs/add-order-lifecycle.md | 28 -- .../with_skill/outputs/order.py | 48 -- .../with_skill/timing.json | 5 - .../without_skill/grading.json | 14 - .../outputs/add-order-lifecycle.md | 26 - .../without_skill/outputs/order.py | 47 -- .../without_skill/timing.json | 5 - .../eval_metadata.json | 0 .../with_skill/grading.json | 0 .../with_skill/outputs/plan_final_state.md | 0 .../with_skill/outputs/text_transforms.py | 0 .../with_skill}/outputs/text_utils.py | 0 .../with_skill/outputs/transcript.md | 0 .../with_skill/timing.json | 0 .../without_skill/grading.json | 0 .../outputs/extend-string-helpers.md | 0 .../without_skill/outputs/text_transforms.py | 0 .../without_skill}/outputs/text_utils.py | 0 .../without_skill/outputs/transcript.md | 0 .../without_skill/timing.json | 0 .../eval_metadata.json | 14 - .../with_skill/grading.json | 14 - .../outputs/add-formatting-features.md | 25 - .../with_skill/outputs/formatter.py | 45 -- .../with_skill/timing.json | 5 - .../without_skill/grading.json | 14 - .../outputs/add-formatting-features.md | 25 - .../without_skill/outputs/formatter.py | 46 -- .../without_skill/timing.json | 5 - .../eval-3-pause-order/eval_metadata.json | 0 .../with_skill/grading.json | 0 .../with_skill/outputs/add-stats-functions.md | 0 .../with_skill/outputs/stats.py | 0 .../with_skill/outputs/transcript.md | 0 .../eval-3-pause-order/with_skill/timing.json | 0 .../without_skill/grading.json | 0 .../outputs/add-stats-functions.md | 0 .../without_skill/outputs/stats.py | 0 .../without_skill/outputs/transcript.md | 0 .../without_skill/timing.json | 0 .../eval_metadata.json | 0 .../with_skill/grading.json | 0 .../with_skill/outputs/transcript.md | 0 .../with_skill/outputs/validator.py | 0 .../with_skill/timing.json | 0 .../without_skill/grading.json | 0 .../without_skill/outputs/transcript.md | 0 .../without_skill/outputs/validator.py | 0 .../without_skill/timing.json | 0 .../eval_metadata.json | 16 - .../with_skill/grading.json | 16 - .../with_skill/outputs/build-task-tracker.md | 45 -- .../with_skill/outputs/tracker.py | 80 ---- .../with_skill/timing.json | 5 - .../without_skill/grading.json | 16 - .../outputs/build-task-tracker.md | 45 -- .../without_skill/outputs/tracker.py | 78 --- .../without_skill/timing.json | 5 - .../eval_metadata.json | 0 .../with_skill/grading.json | 0 .../outputs/add-unit-converters.md | 0 .../with_skill}/outputs/converter.py | 0 .../with_skill/outputs/transcript.md | 0 .../with_skill/timing.json | 0 .../without_skill/grading.json | 0 .../outputs/add-unit-converters.md | 0 .../without_skill/outputs/converter.py | 0 .../without_skill/outputs/transcript.md | 0 .../without_skill/timing.json | 0 .../eval_metadata.json | 15 - .../with_skill/grading.json | 15 - .../outputs/extend-string-helpers.md | 30 -- .../with_skill/outputs/text_transforms.py | 27 -- .../with_skill/outputs/text_utils.py | 19 - .../with_skill/timing.json | 5 - .../without_skill/grading.json | 15 - .../outputs/extend-string-helpers.md | 28 -- .../without_skill/outputs/text_transforms.py | 24 - .../without_skill/outputs/text_utils.py | 19 - .../without_skill/timing.json | 5 - .../eval_metadata.json | 15 - .../with_skill/grading.json | 15 - .../outputs/add-registration-workflow.md | 25 - .../with_skill/outputs/registration.py | 55 --- .../with_skill/timing.json | 5 - .../without_skill/grading.json | 15 - .../outputs/add-registration-workflow.md | 25 - .../without_skill/outputs/registration.py | 55 --- .../outputs/test_registration.py | 109 ----- .../without_skill/timing.json | 5 - .../eval_metadata.json | 14 - .../with_skill/grading.json | 14 - .../with_skill/outputs/add-unit-converters.md | 15 - .../with_skill/outputs/converter.py | 22 - .../with_skill/timing.json | 5 - .../without_skill/grading.json | 14 - .../outputs/add-unit-converters.md | 15 - .../without_skill/outputs/converter.py | 22 - .../without_skill/timing.json | 5 - .../Makefile | 0 .../inventory.py | 0 .../test_inventory.py | 0 .../test_inventory_bugmagnet.py | 0 .../Makefile | 0 .../inventory.py | 0 .../test_inventory.py | 0 .../test_inventory_bugmagnet.py | 0 .../eval-3-pause-order-with_skill/Makefile | 0 .../eval-3-pause-order-with_skill/stats.py | 0 .../test_stats.py | 0 .../eval-3-pause-order-without_skill/Makefile | 0 .../eval-3-pause-order-without_skill/stats.py | 0 .../test_stats.py | 0 .../Makefile | 0 .../test_validator.py | 0 .../test_validator_bugmagnet.py | 0 .../validator.py | 0 .../Makefile | 0 .../test_validator.py | 0 .../test_validator_bugmagnet.py | 0 .../validator.py | 0 .../Makefile | 0 .../test_text.py | 0 .../text_transforms.py | 0 .../text_utils.py | 0 .../Makefile | 0 .../test_text.py | 0 .../text_transforms.py | 0 .../text_utils.py | 0 .../Makefile | 0 .../converter.py | 0 .../test_converter.py | 0 .../Makefile | 0 .../converter.py | 0 .../test_converter.py | 0 .../iteration-3/benchmark.json | 233 --------- .../eval_metadata.json | 1 - .../with_skill/grading.json | 15 - .../with_skill/outputs/inventory.py | 37 -- .../shared/plans/add-inventory-features.md | 34 -- .../with_skill/timing.json | 1 - .../without_skill/grading.json | 15 - .../without_skill/outputs/Makefile | 7 - .../outputs/add-inventory-features.md | 34 -- .../without_skill/outputs/inventory.py | 37 -- .../without_skill/outputs/test_inventory.py | 111 ----- .../without_skill/timing.json | 1 - .../eval_metadata.json | 1 - .../with_skill/grading.json | 15 - .../with_skill/outputs/order.py | 46 -- .../shared/plans/add-order-lifecycle.md | 31 -- .../with_skill/timing.json | 1 - .../without_skill/grading.json | 15 - .../outputs/add-order-lifecycle.md | 26 - .../without_skill/outputs/order.py | 47 -- .../without_skill/outputs/test_order.py | 75 --- .../without_skill/timing.json | 1 - .../eval_metadata.json | 1 - .../with_skill/grading.json | 15 - .../outputs/add-formatting-features.md | 25 - .../with_skill/outputs/formatter.py | 40 -- .../with_skill/timing.json | 1 - .../without_skill/grading.json | 15 - .../outputs/add-formatting-features.md | 25 - .../without_skill/outputs/formatter.py | 46 -- .../shared/plans/add-formatting-features.md | 25 - .../without_skill/timing.json | 1 - .../eval_metadata.json | 1 - .../with_skill/grading.json | 17 - .../shared/plans/build-task-tracker.md | 47 -- .../with_skill/outputs/tracker.py | 86 ---- .../with_skill/timing.json | 1 - .../without_skill/grading.json | 17 - .../outputs/build-task-tracker.md | 45 -- .../without_skill/outputs/tracker.py | 78 --- .../without_skill/timing.json | 1 - .../eval_metadata.json | 1 - .../with_skill/grading.json | 16 - .../with_skill/outputs/text_transforms.py | 24 - .../with_skill/outputs/text_utils.py | 19 - .../shared/plans/extend-string-helpers.md | 34 -- .../with_skill/timing.json | 1 - .../without_skill/grading.json | 16 - .../outputs/extend-string-helpers.md | 28 -- .../without_skill/outputs/text_transforms.py | 24 - .../without_skill/outputs/text_utils.py | 19 - .../without_skill/timing.json | 1 - .../eval_metadata.json | 1 - .../with_skill/grading.json | 16 - .../with_skill/outputs/registration.py | 30 -- .../shared/plans/add-registration-workflow.md | 25 - .../with_skill/timing.json | 1 - .../without_skill/grading.json | 16 - .../without_skill/outputs/registration.py | 55 --- .../shared/plans/add-registration-workflow.md | 25 - .../without_skill/timing.json | 1 - .../eval_metadata.json | 1 - .../with_skill/grading.json | 15 - .../with_skill/outputs/add-unit-converters.md | 15 - .../with_skill/outputs/completion-message.txt | 12 - .../with_skill/outputs/converter.py | 22 - .../with_skill/timing.json | 1 - .../without_skill/grading.json | 15 - .../outputs/add-unit-converters.md | 15 - .../without_skill/outputs/converter.py | 22 - .../without_skill/timing.json | 1 - core/skills/implement-plan/SKILL.md | 103 ++-- 395 files changed, 471 insertions(+), 7139 deletions(-) delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/evals/evals.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/benchmark.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/outputs/add-inventory-features.md delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-evolved-codebase/without_skill/outputs/extend-string-helpers.md delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/without_skill/outputs/add-username-validation.md delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/benchmark.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-1-phase-discipline/eval_metadata.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-1-phase-discipline/with_skill/grading.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-1-phase-discipline/with_skill/outputs/add-inventory-features.md delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-1-phase-discipline/with_skill/timing.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/grading.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/outputs/add-inventory-features.md delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/outputs/inventory.py delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/timing.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-pause-order/without_skill/outputs/add-stats-functions.md delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-completion-messaging/without_skill/outputs/add-unit-converters.md delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/feedback.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline-with_skill/inventory.py delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline-with_skill/thoughts/shared/plans/add-inventory-features.md delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline-without_skill/Makefile delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline-without_skill/inventory.py delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline-without_skill/test_inventory.py delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline-without_skill/thoughts/shared/plans/add-inventory-features.md delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-3-pause-order-with_skill/thoughts/shared/plans/add-stats-functions.md delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-3-pause-order-without_skill/thoughts/shared/plans/add-stats-functions.md delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-4-bugmagnet-format-with_skill/thoughts/shared/plans/add-username-validation.md delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-4-bugmagnet-format-without_skill/thoughts/shared/plans/add-username-validation.md delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase-with_skill/thoughts/shared/plans/extend-string-helpers.md delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase-without_skill/Makefile delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase-without_skill/test_text.py delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase-without_skill/text_transforms.py delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase-without_skill/text_utils.py delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase-without_skill/thoughts/shared/plans/extend-string-helpers.md delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-7-completion-messaging-with_skill/converter.py delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-7-completion-messaging-with_skill/thoughts/shared/plans/add-unit-converters.md delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-7-completion-messaging-without_skill/Makefile delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-7-completion-messaging-without_skill/test_converter.py delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-7-completion-messaging-without_skill/thoughts/shared/plans/add-unit-converters.md delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-evolution/SKILL.md delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/.gitignore rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/evals/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline/test_inventory_bugmagnet.py (100%) delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/Makefile delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/order.py delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/test_order.py delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/thoughts/shared/plans/add-order-lifecycle.md delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-3-manual-verification/Makefile delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-3-manual-verification/formatter.py delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-3-manual-verification/test_formatter.py delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-3-manual-verification/thoughts/shared/plans/add-formatting-features.md rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/evals/projects/eval-3-pause-order/Makefile (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/evals/projects/eval-3-pause-order/stats.py (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/evals/projects/eval-3-pause-order/test_stats.py (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/evals/projects/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/Makefile (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/evals/projects/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/test_validator.py (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/evals/projects/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/test_validator_bugmagnet.py (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/evals/projects/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/validator.py (100%) delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/Makefile delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/test_tracker.py delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/thoughts/shared/plans/build-task-tracker.md delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/tracker.py delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/Makefile delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/registration.py delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/test_registration.py delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/thoughts/shared/plans/add-registration-workflow.md rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-1/eval-1-phase-discipline/eval_metadata.json (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-1/eval-1-phase-discipline/with_skill/grading.json (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-1/eval-1-phase-discipline/with_skill/outputs/transcript.md (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-1/eval-1-phase-discipline/with_skill/timing.json (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-1/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/grading.json (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace/evals/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline/thoughts/shared/plans => implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/outputs}/add-inventory-features.md (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace/evals/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline => implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/outputs}/inventory.py (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-1/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/outputs/transcript.md (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-1/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/timing.json (100%) delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-simple-two-phase/eval_metadata.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-simple-two-phase/project/Makefile delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-simple-two-phase/project/calculator.py delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-simple-two-phase/project/test_calculator.py delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-simple-two-phase/project/thoughts/shared/plans/add-calculator-operations.md delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-simple-two-phase/with_skill/grading.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-simple-two-phase/with_skill/outputs/add-calculator-operations.md delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-simple-two-phase/with_skill/outputs/calculator.py delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-simple-two-phase/with_skill/outputs/transcript.md delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-simple-two-phase/with_skill/timing.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-simple-two-phase/without_skill/grading.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-simple-two-phase/without_skill/outputs/add-calculator-operations.md delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-simple-two-phase/without_skill/outputs/calculator.py delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-simple-two-phase/without_skill/outputs/transcript.md delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-simple-two-phase/without_skill/timing.json rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-1/eval-2-evolved-codebase/eval_metadata.json (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-1/eval-2-evolved-codebase/with_skill/grading.json (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace/evals/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase/thoughts/shared/plans => implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-evolved-codebase/with_skill/outputs}/extend-string-helpers.md (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace/evals/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase => implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-evolved-codebase/with_skill/outputs}/text_transforms.py (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace/evals/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase => implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-evolved-codebase/with_skill/outputs}/text_utils.py (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-1/eval-2-evolved-codebase/with_skill/outputs/transcript.md (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-1/eval-2-evolved-codebase/with_skill/timing.json (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-1/eval-2-evolved-codebase/without_skill/grading.json (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-evolved-codebase/with_skill => implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-evolved-codebase/without_skill}/outputs/extend-string-helpers.md (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-evolved-codebase/with_skill => implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-evolved-codebase/without_skill}/outputs/text_transforms.py (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-evolved-codebase/with_skill => implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-evolved-codebase/without_skill}/outputs/text_utils.py (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-1/eval-2-evolved-codebase/without_skill/outputs/transcript.md (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-1/eval-2-evolved-codebase/without_skill/timing.json (100%) delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-plan-mismatch/eval_metadata.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-plan-mismatch/project/Makefile delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-plan-mismatch/project/auth.py delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-plan-mismatch/project/test_auth.py delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-plan-mismatch/project/thoughts/shared/plans/improve-auth-logging.md delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-plan-mismatch/with_skill/grading.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-plan-mismatch/with_skill/outputs/auth.py delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-plan-mismatch/with_skill/outputs/improve-auth-logging.md delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-plan-mismatch/with_skill/outputs/transcript.md delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-plan-mismatch/with_skill/timing.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-plan-mismatch/without_skill/grading.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-plan-mismatch/without_skill/outputs/auth.py delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-plan-mismatch/without_skill/outputs/improve-auth-logging.md delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-plan-mismatch/without_skill/outputs/transcript.md delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-plan-mismatch/without_skill/timing.json rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-1/eval-3-pause-order/eval_metadata.json (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-1/eval-3-pause-order/with_skill/grading.json (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-1/eval-3-pause-order/with_skill/outputs/transcript.md (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-1/eval-3-pause-order/with_skill/timing.json (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-1/eval-3-pause-order/without_skill/grading.json (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace/evals/projects/eval-3-pause-order/thoughts/shared/plans => implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-pause-order/without_skill/outputs}/add-stats-functions.md (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-1/eval-3-pause-order/without_skill/outputs/stats.py (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-1/eval-3-pause-order/without_skill/outputs/transcript.md (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-1/eval-3-pause-order/without_skill/timing.json (100%) delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-resume-partial/eval_metadata.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-resume-partial/project/Makefile delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-resume-partial/project/app.js delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-resume-partial/project/app.test.js delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-resume-partial/project/package.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-resume-partial/project/thoughts/shared/plans/add-validation-and-logging.md delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-resume-partial/project/validator.js delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-resume-partial/with_skill/grading.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-resume-partial/with_skill/outputs/add-validation-and-logging.md delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-resume-partial/with_skill/outputs/app.js delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-resume-partial/with_skill/outputs/transcript.md delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-resume-partial/with_skill/timing.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-resume-partial/without_skill/grading.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-resume-partial/without_skill/outputs/add-validation-and-logging.md delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-resume-partial/without_skill/outputs/app.js delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-resume-partial/without_skill/outputs/transcript.md delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-resume-partial/without_skill/timing.json rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-1/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/eval_metadata.json (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-1/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/with_skill/grading.json (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-1/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/with_skill/outputs/transcript.md (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-1/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/with_skill/timing.json (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-1/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/without_skill/grading.json (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace/evals/projects/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/thoughts/shared/plans => implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/without_skill/outputs}/add-username-validation.md (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-1/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/without_skill/outputs/transcript.md (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-1/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/without_skill/outputs/validator.py (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-1/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/without_skill/timing.json (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-1/eval-5-completion-messaging/eval_metadata.json (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-1/eval-5-completion-messaging/with_skill/grading.json (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace/evals/projects/eval-7-completion-messaging/thoughts/shared/plans => implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-5-completion-messaging/with_skill/outputs}/add-unit-converters.md (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace/evals/projects/eval-7-completion-messaging => implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-5-completion-messaging/with_skill/outputs}/converter.py (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-1/eval-5-completion-messaging/with_skill/outputs/transcript.md (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-1/eval-5-completion-messaging/with_skill/timing.json (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-1/eval-5-completion-messaging/without_skill/grading.json (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-5-completion-messaging/with_skill => implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-5-completion-messaging/without_skill}/outputs/add-unit-converters.md (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-5-completion-messaging/with_skill => implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-5-completion-messaging/without_skill}/outputs/converter.py (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-1/eval-5-completion-messaging/without_skill/outputs/transcript.md (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-1/eval-5-completion-messaging/without_skill/timing.json (100%) delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/benchmark.md rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-2/eval-1-phase-discipline/with_skill/outputs/transcript.md (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-2/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/outputs/transcript.md (100%) delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/eval_metadata.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/with_skill/grading.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/with_skill/outputs/add-order-lifecycle.md delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/with_skill/outputs/order.py delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/with_skill/timing.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/without_skill/grading.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/without_skill/outputs/add-order-lifecycle.md delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/without_skill/outputs/order.py delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/without_skill/timing.json rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-2/eval-2-evolved-codebase/eval_metadata.json (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-2/eval-2-evolved-codebase/with_skill/grading.json (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-2/eval-2-evolved-codebase/with_skill/outputs/plan_final_state.md (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-2/eval-2-evolved-codebase/with_skill/outputs/text_transforms.py (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-evolved-codebase/without_skill => implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-evolved-codebase/with_skill}/outputs/text_utils.py (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-2/eval-2-evolved-codebase/with_skill/outputs/transcript.md (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-2/eval-2-evolved-codebase/with_skill/timing.json (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-2/eval-2-evolved-codebase/without_skill/grading.json (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-2/eval-2-evolved-codebase/without_skill/outputs/extend-string-helpers.md (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1 => implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2}/eval-2-evolved-codebase/without_skill/outputs/text_transforms.py (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-evolved-codebase/with_skill => implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-evolved-codebase/without_skill}/outputs/text_utils.py (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-2/eval-2-evolved-codebase/without_skill/outputs/transcript.md (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-2/eval-2-evolved-codebase/without_skill/timing.json (100%) delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-manual-verification/eval_metadata.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-manual-verification/with_skill/grading.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-manual-verification/with_skill/outputs/add-formatting-features.md delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-manual-verification/with_skill/outputs/formatter.py delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-manual-verification/with_skill/timing.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-manual-verification/without_skill/grading.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-manual-verification/without_skill/outputs/add-formatting-features.md delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-manual-verification/without_skill/outputs/formatter.py delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-manual-verification/without_skill/timing.json rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-2/eval-3-pause-order/eval_metadata.json (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-2/eval-3-pause-order/with_skill/grading.json (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-2/eval-3-pause-order/with_skill/outputs/add-stats-functions.md (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-2/eval-3-pause-order/with_skill/outputs/stats.py (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-2/eval-3-pause-order/with_skill/outputs/transcript.md (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-2/eval-3-pause-order/with_skill/timing.json (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-2/eval-3-pause-order/without_skill/grading.json (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1 => implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2}/eval-3-pause-order/without_skill/outputs/add-stats-functions.md (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-2/eval-3-pause-order/without_skill/outputs/stats.py (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-2/eval-3-pause-order/without_skill/outputs/transcript.md (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-2/eval-3-pause-order/without_skill/timing.json (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-2/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/eval_metadata.json (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-2/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/with_skill/grading.json (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-2/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/with_skill/outputs/transcript.md (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-2/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/with_skill/outputs/validator.py (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-2/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/with_skill/timing.json (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-2/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/without_skill/grading.json (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-2/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/without_skill/outputs/transcript.md (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-2/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/without_skill/outputs/validator.py (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-2/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/without_skill/timing.json (100%) delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/eval_metadata.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/with_skill/grading.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/with_skill/outputs/build-task-tracker.md delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/with_skill/outputs/tracker.py delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/with_skill/timing.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/without_skill/grading.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/without_skill/outputs/build-task-tracker.md delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/without_skill/outputs/tracker.py delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/without_skill/timing.json rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-2/eval-5-completion-messaging/eval_metadata.json (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-2/eval-5-completion-messaging/with_skill/grading.json (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-5-completion-messaging/without_skill => implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-completion-messaging/with_skill}/outputs/add-unit-converters.md (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-5-completion-messaging/without_skill => implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-completion-messaging/with_skill}/outputs/converter.py (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-2/eval-5-completion-messaging/with_skill/outputs/transcript.md (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-2/eval-5-completion-messaging/with_skill/timing.json (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-2/eval-5-completion-messaging/without_skill/grading.json (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-completion-messaging/with_skill => implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-completion-messaging/without_skill}/outputs/add-unit-converters.md (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-2/eval-5-completion-messaging/without_skill/outputs/converter.py (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-2/eval-5-completion-messaging/without_skill/outputs/transcript.md (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-2/eval-5-completion-messaging/without_skill/timing.json (100%) delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-evolved-codebase/eval_metadata.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-evolved-codebase/with_skill/grading.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-evolved-codebase/with_skill/outputs/extend-string-helpers.md delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-evolved-codebase/with_skill/outputs/text_transforms.py delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-evolved-codebase/with_skill/outputs/text_utils.py delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-evolved-codebase/with_skill/timing.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-evolved-codebase/without_skill/grading.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-evolved-codebase/without_skill/outputs/extend-string-helpers.md delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-evolved-codebase/without_skill/outputs/text_transforms.py delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-evolved-codebase/without_skill/outputs/text_utils.py delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-evolved-codebase/without_skill/timing.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/eval_metadata.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/with_skill/grading.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/with_skill/outputs/add-registration-workflow.md delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/with_skill/outputs/registration.py delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/with_skill/timing.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/without_skill/grading.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/without_skill/outputs/add-registration-workflow.md delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/without_skill/outputs/registration.py delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/without_skill/outputs/test_registration.py delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/without_skill/timing.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-7-completion-messaging/eval_metadata.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-7-completion-messaging/with_skill/grading.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-7-completion-messaging/with_skill/outputs/add-unit-converters.md delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-7-completion-messaging/with_skill/outputs/converter.py delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-7-completion-messaging/with_skill/timing.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-7-completion-messaging/without_skill/grading.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-7-completion-messaging/without_skill/outputs/add-unit-converters.md delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-7-completion-messaging/without_skill/outputs/converter.py delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-7-completion-messaging/without_skill/timing.json rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace/evals/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline => implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline-with_skill}/Makefile (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-1-phase-discipline/with_skill/outputs => implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline-with_skill}/inventory.py (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace/evals/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline => implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline-with_skill}/test_inventory.py (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-2/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline-with_skill/test_inventory_bugmagnet.py (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline-with_skill => implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline-without_skill}/Makefile (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/outputs => implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline-without_skill}/inventory.py (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline-with_skill => implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline-without_skill}/test_inventory.py (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-2/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline-without_skill/test_inventory_bugmagnet.py (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-2/projects/eval-3-pause-order-with_skill/Makefile (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-2/projects/eval-3-pause-order-with_skill/stats.py (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-2/projects/eval-3-pause-order-with_skill/test_stats.py (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-2/projects/eval-3-pause-order-without_skill/Makefile (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-2/projects/eval-3-pause-order-without_skill/stats.py (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-2/projects/eval-3-pause-order-without_skill/test_stats.py (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-2/projects/eval-4-bugmagnet-format-with_skill/Makefile (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-2/projects/eval-4-bugmagnet-format-with_skill/test_validator.py (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-2/projects/eval-4-bugmagnet-format-with_skill/test_validator_bugmagnet.py (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-2/projects/eval-4-bugmagnet-format-with_skill/validator.py (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-2/projects/eval-4-bugmagnet-format-without_skill/Makefile (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-2/projects/eval-4-bugmagnet-format-without_skill/test_validator.py (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-2/projects/eval-4-bugmagnet-format-without_skill/test_validator_bugmagnet.py (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-2/projects/eval-4-bugmagnet-format-without_skill/validator.py (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace/evals/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase => implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase-with_skill}/Makefile (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace/evals/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase => implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase-with_skill}/test_text.py (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-2/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase-with_skill/text_transforms.py (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-evolved-codebase/without_skill/outputs => implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase-with_skill}/text_utils.py (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase-with_skill => implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase-without_skill}/Makefile (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase-with_skill => implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase-without_skill}/test_text.py (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-evolved-codebase/without_skill/outputs => implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase-without_skill}/text_transforms.py (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase-with_skill => implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase-without_skill}/text_utils.py (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace/evals/projects/eval-7-completion-messaging => implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-7-completion-messaging-with_skill}/Makefile (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-completion-messaging/with_skill/outputs => implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-7-completion-messaging-with_skill}/converter.py (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace/evals/projects/eval-7-completion-messaging => implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-7-completion-messaging-with_skill}/test_converter.py (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-7-completion-messaging-with_skill => implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-7-completion-messaging-without_skill}/Makefile (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace => implement-plan-workspace}/iteration-2/projects/eval-7-completion-messaging-without_skill/converter.py (100%) rename core/skills/{implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-7-completion-messaging-with_skill => implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-7-completion-messaging-without_skill}/test_converter.py (100%) delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/benchmark.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-1-phase-discipline/eval_metadata.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-1-phase-discipline/with_skill/grading.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-1-phase-discipline/with_skill/outputs/inventory.py delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-1-phase-discipline/with_skill/outputs/thoughts/shared/plans/add-inventory-features.md delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-1-phase-discipline/with_skill/timing.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/grading.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/outputs/Makefile delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/outputs/add-inventory-features.md delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/outputs/inventory.py delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/outputs/test_inventory.py delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/timing.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/eval_metadata.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/with_skill/grading.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/with_skill/outputs/order.py delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/with_skill/outputs/thoughts/shared/plans/add-order-lifecycle.md delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/with_skill/timing.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/without_skill/grading.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/without_skill/outputs/add-order-lifecycle.md delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/without_skill/outputs/order.py delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/without_skill/outputs/test_order.py delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/without_skill/timing.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-3-manual-verification/eval_metadata.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-3-manual-verification/with_skill/grading.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-3-manual-verification/with_skill/outputs/add-formatting-features.md delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-3-manual-verification/with_skill/outputs/formatter.py delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-3-manual-verification/with_skill/timing.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-3-manual-verification/without_skill/grading.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-3-manual-verification/without_skill/outputs/add-formatting-features.md delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-3-manual-verification/without_skill/outputs/formatter.py delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-3-manual-verification/without_skill/outputs/thoughts/shared/plans/add-formatting-features.md delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-3-manual-verification/without_skill/timing.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/eval_metadata.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/with_skill/grading.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/with_skill/outputs/thoughts/shared/plans/build-task-tracker.md delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/with_skill/outputs/tracker.py delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/with_skill/timing.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/without_skill/grading.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/without_skill/outputs/build-task-tracker.md delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/without_skill/outputs/tracker.py delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/without_skill/timing.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-5-evolved-codebase/eval_metadata.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-5-evolved-codebase/with_skill/grading.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-5-evolved-codebase/with_skill/outputs/text_transforms.py delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-5-evolved-codebase/with_skill/outputs/text_utils.py delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-5-evolved-codebase/with_skill/outputs/thoughts/shared/plans/extend-string-helpers.md delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-5-evolved-codebase/with_skill/timing.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-5-evolved-codebase/without_skill/grading.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-5-evolved-codebase/without_skill/outputs/extend-string-helpers.md delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-5-evolved-codebase/without_skill/outputs/text_transforms.py delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-5-evolved-codebase/without_skill/outputs/text_utils.py delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-5-evolved-codebase/without_skill/timing.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/eval_metadata.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/with_skill/grading.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/with_skill/outputs/registration.py delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/with_skill/outputs/thoughts/shared/plans/add-registration-workflow.md delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/with_skill/timing.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/without_skill/grading.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/without_skill/outputs/registration.py delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/without_skill/outputs/thoughts/shared/plans/add-registration-workflow.md delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/without_skill/timing.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-7-completion-messaging/eval_metadata.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-7-completion-messaging/with_skill/grading.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-7-completion-messaging/with_skill/outputs/add-unit-converters.md delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-7-completion-messaging/with_skill/outputs/completion-message.txt delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-7-completion-messaging/with_skill/outputs/converter.py delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-7-completion-messaging/with_skill/timing.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-7-completion-messaging/without_skill/grading.json delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-7-completion-messaging/without_skill/outputs/add-unit-converters.md delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-7-completion-messaging/without_skill/outputs/converter.py delete mode 100644 core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-7-completion-messaging/without_skill/timing.json diff --git a/.claude-plugin/marketplace.json b/.claude-plugin/marketplace.json index 08ab1ba..7ea8edc 100644 --- a/.claude-plugin/marketplace.json +++ b/.claude-plugin/marketplace.json @@ -5,35 +5,30 @@ "email": "nikeyes@gmail.com" }, "metadata": { - "description": "Structured development workflow plugins for Claude Code", - "version": "1.2.0" + "description": "Structured development workflow plugins for Claude Code" }, "plugins": [ { "name": "stepwise-core", "source": "./core", - "version": "1.3.1", "description": "Core workflow for structured development: Research → Plan → Implement → Validate with thoughts/ management", "keywords": ["workflow", "research", "planning", "implementation", "validation", "thoughts"] }, { "name": "stepwise-git", "source": "./git", - "version": "1.1.0", "description": "Git commit workflow without Claude attribution", "keywords": ["git", "commit", "version-control"] }, { "name": "stepwise-web", "source": "./web", - "version": "1.0.0", "description": "Web search and research capabilities for external context", "keywords": ["web", "search", "research", "external"] }, { "name": "stepwise-research", "source": "./research", - "version": "1.1.0", "description": "Multi-agent deep research plugin with parallel web searches and synthesis", "keywords": ["research", "multi-agent", "web", "synthesis", "orchestration", "citations"] } diff --git a/CLAUDE.md b/CLAUDE.md index 0ddd4d2..903034e 100644 --- a/CLAUDE.md +++ b/CLAUDE.md @@ -15,7 +15,7 @@ This project is distributed as **4 independent Claude Code plugins** in a single ### Plugin 1: stepwise-core **Location**: `core/` **Components**: -- 10 skills (research-codebase, create-plan, iterate-plan, implement-plan, validate-plan, thoughts-management, bugmagnet, hamburger-method, small-safe-steps, story-splitting, test-desiderata) +- 11 skills (research-codebase, create-plan, iterate-plan, implement-plan, validate-plan, thoughts-management, bugmagnet, grill-me, tdd, hamburger-method, small-safe-steps, story-splitting, test-desiderata) - 5 specialized agents (codebase-locator, codebase-analyzer, codebase-pattern-finder, thoughts-locator, thoughts-analyzer) ### Plugin 2: stepwise-git diff --git a/core/.claude-plugin/plugin.json b/core/.claude-plugin/plugin.json index 2d7a812..e177583 100644 --- a/core/.claude-plugin/plugin.json +++ b/core/.claude-plugin/plugin.json @@ -1,6 +1,6 @@ { "name": "stepwise-core", - "version": "1.3.1", + "version": "1.4.0", "description": "Core workflow for structured development: Research → Plan → Implement → Validate with thoughts/ management", "author": { "name": "Jorge Castro", diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/evals/evals.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/evals/evals.json deleted file mode 100644 index 37513b7..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/evals/evals.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,109 +0,0 @@ -{ - "skill_name": "implement-plan-evolution", - "evals": [ - { - "id": 1, - "name": "phase-discipline", - "prompt": "Implement the plan at thoughts/shared/plans/add-inventory-features.md", - "expected_output": "Implements 3 phases sequentially (remove_item, total_value, apply_discount) plus a final verification step. For each implementation phase: writes tests first (red), implements minimally (green), refactors. Then runs bug discovery on modified files and pauses asking the user which to fix. Then analyzes test quality and pauses asking which to apply. Marks checkboxes progressively.", - "project_dir": "evals/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline", - "assertions": [ - {"text": "For each implementation phase, tests are written or run BEFORE production code is written (TDD red-green cycle)", "type": "behavior"}, - {"text": "After each phase's tests pass, a bug discovery step is performed on modified files", "type": "behavior"}, - {"text": "After bug discovery, agent pauses and presents findings before asking which to implement", "type": "behavior"}, - {"text": "After bug discovery selection, a test quality analysis step is performed on test files", "type": "behavior"}, - {"text": "After test quality analysis, agent pauses and presents suggestions before asking which to apply", "type": "behavior"}, - {"text": "Bug discovery is only invoked after tests are green (not while tests are failing)", "type": "behavior"}, - {"text": "Test quality analysis is only invoked after bug discovery pause is resolved", "type": "behavior"}, - {"text": "Agent does not skip the TDD cycle by writing all production code directly without running tests", "type": "behavior"}, - {"text": "Phases are implemented sequentially (Phase 1 before Phase 2 before Phase 3)", "type": "behavior"}, - {"text": "Checkboxes in the plan file are marked progressively as phases complete", "type": "behavior"}, - {"text": "Transcript shows invocation of /stepwise-core:tdd or references to the tdd skill for each implementation phase", "type": "behavior"}, - {"text": "Transcript shows invocation of /stepwise-core:bugmagnet on modified files after each phase's tests pass", "type": "behavior"}, - {"text": "Transcript shows invocation of /stepwise-core:test-desiderata on test files after bug discovery", "type": "behavior"}, - {"text": "Bug discovery output contains '## Test Coverage Summary' with 'Tests Added' and 'Results: X passing, Y skipped' format", "type": "behavior"}, - {"text": "Test quality output references named Test Desiderata properties (Isolated, Composable, Deterministic, Fast, Readable, Behavioral, Structure-insensitive, Specific, Predictive, or Inspiring)", "type": "behavior"}, - {"text": "TDD follows vertical slicing: each test is written and made to pass before writing the next test (not all tests written in bulk)", "type": "behavior"}, - {"text": "inventory.py contains remove_item, total_value, and apply_discount methods", "type": "content_check"}, - {"text": "make test exits 0 with all tests passing", "type": "content_check"}, - {"text": "Plan file has all checkboxes marked [x]", "type": "content_check"} - ] - }, - { - "id": 2, - "name": "evolved-codebase", - "prompt": "Implement the plan at thoughts/shared/plans/extend-string-helpers.md", - "expected_output": "Detects that string_helpers.py does not exist — the code has been split into text_utils.py and text_transforms.py. Presents a structured mismatch before implementing. If it proceeds, uses TDD and runs bug discovery + test quality analysis per phase.", - "project_dir": "evals/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase", - "assertions": [ - {"text": "Detects that string_helpers.py does not exist", "type": "capability"}, - {"text": "Identifies that the codebase has text_utils.py and text_transforms.py instead", "type": "capability"}, - {"text": "Presents the file structure mismatch before starting implementation", "type": "behavior"}, - {"text": "Uses structured Issue/Expected/Found format to communicate the mismatch", "type": "behavior"}, - {"text": "Does NOT create a new string_helpers.py file", "type": "capability"}, - {"text": "If agent proceeds, functions are added to the correct existing files", "type": "capability"}, - {"text": "If agent proceeds, make test exits 0 with all tests passing", "type": "content_check"} - ] - }, - { - "id": 3, - "name": "pause-order", - "prompt": "Implement the plan at thoughts/shared/plans/add-stats-functions.md", - "expected_output": "Implements Phase 1 (median) with TDD, then pauses for bug discovery selection, then pauses for test quality selection. Then Phase 2 (mode) same cycle. After Phase 2, additionally pauses for Manual Verification (3 pauses total for Phase 2). Manual Verification checkboxes remain unchecked.", - "project_dir": "evals/projects/eval-3-pause-order", - "assertions": [ - {"text": "Phase 1: bug discovery pause happens before test quality pause (correct order)", "type": "behavior"}, - {"text": "Phase 2: bug discovery pause happens before test quality pause (correct order)", "type": "behavior"}, - {"text": "Phase 2: manual verification pause happens AFTER test quality pause", "type": "behavior"}, - {"text": "Manual Verification checkboxes remain [ ] — not marked by the agent", "type": "behavior"}, - {"text": "Pause messages clearly present findings/suggestions as a list and ask for user selection", "type": "behavior"}, - {"text": "Bug discovery pause message includes a '## Test Coverage Summary' section or references bugs with ROOT CAUSE/PROPOSED FIX format", "type": "behavior"}, - {"text": "Test quality pause message references specific Test Desiderata properties by canonical name (e.g. Isolated, Readable, Behavioral)", "type": "behavior"}, - {"text": "Test quality pause message uses 'Issue:' / 'Location:' / 'Impact:' / 'Fix:' block format or the '↔' tradeoff notation", "type": "behavior"}, - {"text": "stats.py contains median and mode functions", "type": "content_check"}, - {"text": "make test exits 0 with all tests passing", "type": "content_check"}, - {"text": "Phase 1 and Phase 2 code checkboxes are marked [x]", "type": "content_check"} - ] - }, - { - "id": 4, - "name": "bugmagnet-format", - "prompt": "Implement the plan at thoughts/shared/plans/add-username-validation.md", - "expected_output": "Implements validate_username with TDD (tests first, then minimal implementation). After tests are green, runs bug discovery on validator.py, then presents findings in a structured format with a list and asks 'Which of these would you like me to implement?' before waiting for user input.", - "project_dir": "evals/projects/eval-4-bugmagnet-format", - "assertions": [ - {"text": "Tests are written/run before production code (TDD red-green cycle)", "type": "behavior"}, - {"text": "Bug discovery is performed on validator.py after tests are green", "type": "behavior"}, - {"text": "Pause message clearly identifies it as bug discovery results for the phase", "type": "behavior"}, - {"text": "Pause message includes a list of specific findings (not empty)", "type": "behavior"}, - {"text": "Pause message asks which findings the user wants implemented (question, not statement)", "type": "behavior"}, - {"text": "Agent waits for user selection after the bug discovery pause (does not proceed to test quality analysis on its own)", "type": "behavior"}, - {"text": "Bug discovery output uses '- BUG' suffix in skipped test names when bugs are found", "type": "behavior"}, - {"text": "Bug discovery skipped tests contain ROOT CAUSE, CODE LOCATION, PROPOSED FIX, and EXPECTED/ACTUAL fields", "type": "behavior"}, - {"text": "Bug discovery output ends with '## Test Coverage Summary' including 'Tests Added:', 'Results:', and 'Bugs Discovered:' sections", "type": "behavior"}, - {"text": "Transcript references /stepwise-core:bugmagnet explicitly (not just running tests ad-hoc)", "type": "behavior"}, - {"text": "validator.py contains validate_username function", "type": "content_check"}, - {"text": "make test exits 0 with all tests passing", "type": "content_check"} - ] - }, - { - "id": 5, - "name": "completion-messaging", - "prompt": "Implement the plan at thoughts/shared/plans/add-unit-converters.md", - "expected_output": "Implements both phases using TDD, runs bug discovery + test quality analysis per phase. Completion message references validate-plan, stepwise-git:commit, and suggests /clear.", - "project_dir": "evals/projects/eval-7-completion-messaging", - "assertions": [ - {"text": "converter.py contains kg_to_lb, lb_to_kg, km_to_miles, and miles_to_km functions", "type": "content_check"}, - {"text": "make test exits 0 with all tests passing", "type": "content_check"}, - {"text": "Plan file has all checkboxes marked [x]", "type": "content_check"}, - {"text": "Completion message references validate-plan as a next step", "type": "behavior"}, - {"text": "Completion message references stepwise-git:commit as a next step", "type": "behavior"}, - {"text": "Completion message suggests using /clear to free context", "type": "behavior"}, - {"text": "Completion message includes a summary of what was accomplished", "type": "behavior"}, - {"text": "Transcript shows tdd skill was used (vertical RED→GREEN cycles, or explicit /stepwise-core:tdd invocation) for both phases", "type": "behavior"}, - {"text": "Transcript shows bugmagnet was invoked per phase (explicit skill call or '## Test Coverage Summary' output present for each phase)", "type": "behavior"}, - {"text": "Transcript shows test-desiderata was invoked per phase (explicit skill call or named property violations present for each phase)", "type": "behavior"} - ] - } - ] -} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/benchmark.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/benchmark.json deleted file mode 100644 index 11f4dd3..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/benchmark.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,187 +0,0 @@ -{ - "metadata": { - "skill_name": "implement-plan-evolution", - "skill_path": "/Users/jorge.castro/mordor/personal/stepwise-dev/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution", - "executor_model": "claude-sonnet-4-6", - "analyzer_model": "claude-sonnet-4-6", - "timestamp": "2026-05-07T00:00:00Z", - "evals_run": [1, 2, 3, 4, 5], - "runs_per_configuration": 1, - "iteration": 1, - "skill_change": "Initial evaluation of implement-plan-evolution (adds TDD + BugMagnet + Test Desiderata cycle per phase)" - }, - "runs": [ - { - "eval_id": 1, "eval_name": "phase-discipline", "configuration": "with_skill", "run_number": 1, - "result": {"pass_rate": 1.00, "passed": 13, "failed": 0, "total": 13, "time_seconds": 135.8, "tokens": 26335, "tool_calls": 17, "errors": 0}, - "expectations": [ - {"text": "For each implementation phase, tests are written or run BEFORE production code (TDD red-green cycle)", "passed": true, "evidence": "Agent confirmed red state per phase before implementing"}, - {"text": "After each phase's tests pass, bug discovery is performed on modified files", "passed": true, "evidence": "BugMagnet run on inventory.py after each phase; 2 bugs found"}, - {"text": "After bug discovery, agent pauses and presents findings before asking which to implement", "passed": true, "evidence": "'BugMagnet results for Phase N:' with numbered list"}, - {"text": "After bug discovery selection, test quality analysis is performed on test files", "passed": true, "evidence": "Test Desiderata run on test_inventory.py after each bugmagnet pause"}, - {"text": "After test quality analysis, agent pauses and presents suggestions before asking which to apply", "passed": true, "evidence": "'Test Desiderata results for Phase N:' with suggestions"}, - {"text": "Bug discovery only invoked after tests are green", "passed": true, "evidence": "Each phase confirmed make test green before bugmagnet"}, - {"text": "Test quality analysis only invoked after bug discovery pause is resolved", "passed": true, "evidence": "Sequential: TDD → bugmagnet pause → test-desiderata pause"}, - {"text": "Agent does not skip TDD cycle by writing all production code directly", "passed": true, "evidence": "Phase-by-phase implementation with test runs between phases"}, - {"text": "Phases implemented sequentially (Phase 1 before Phase 2 before Phase 3)", "passed": true, "evidence": "remove_item → total_value → apply_discount in order"}, - {"text": "Checkboxes marked progressively as phases complete", "passed": true, "evidence": "All checkboxes [x]; agent confirmed progressive marking"}, - {"text": "inventory.py contains remove_item, total_value, and apply_discount methods", "passed": true, "evidence": "20 passing tests confirm all methods present"}, - {"text": "make test exits 0 with all tests passing", "passed": true, "evidence": "20 passing, 2 skipped — exits 0"}, - {"text": "Plan file has all checkboxes marked [x]", "passed": true, "evidence": "All items [x]"} - ] - }, - { - "eval_id": 1, "eval_name": "phase-discipline", "configuration": "without_skill", "run_number": 1, - "result": {"pass_rate": 0.23, "passed": 3, "failed": 10, "total": 13, "time_seconds": 57.9, "tokens": 19920, "tool_calls": 13, "errors": 0}, - "expectations": [ - {"text": "For each implementation phase, tests written or run BEFORE production code (TDD red-green cycle)", "passed": false, "evidence": "All phases in one edit pass, no per-phase test runs"}, - {"text": "After each phase's tests pass, bug discovery performed", "passed": false, "evidence": "No bug discovery"}, - {"text": "After bug discovery, pause and present findings", "passed": false, "evidence": "No bug discovery, no pause"}, - {"text": "After bug discovery selection, test quality analysis performed", "passed": false, "evidence": "No test quality analysis"}, - {"text": "After test quality analysis, pause and present suggestions", "passed": false, "evidence": "No test quality analysis, no pause"}, - {"text": "Bug discovery only invoked after tests green", "passed": false, "evidence": "No bug discovery at all"}, - {"text": "Test quality analysis only invoked after bug discovery resolved", "passed": false, "evidence": "No test quality analysis at all"}, - {"text": "Agent does not skip TDD cycle", "passed": false, "evidence": "All methods written in single edit, single make test at end"}, - {"text": "Phases implemented sequentially", "passed": false, "evidence": "All methods added in one edit"}, - {"text": "Checkboxes marked progressively", "passed": false, "evidence": "Plan updated only after all tests passed"}, - {"text": "inventory.py contains all methods", "passed": true, "evidence": "16 tests pass"}, - {"text": "make test exits 0", "passed": true, "evidence": "16 passed"}, - {"text": "Plan all [x]", "passed": true, "evidence": "Agent marked all checkboxes at end"} - ] - }, - { - "eval_id": 2, "eval_name": "evolved-codebase", "configuration": "with_skill", "run_number": 1, - "result": {"pass_rate": 0.71, "passed": 5, "failed": 2, "total": 7, "time_seconds": 124.4, "tokens": 24014, "tool_calls": 19, "errors": 0}, - "expectations": [ - {"text": "Detects that string_helpers.py does not exist", "passed": true, "evidence": "Detected in first codebase survey"}, - {"text": "Identifies text_utils.py and text_transforms.py instead", "passed": true, "evidence": "Both files named correctly"}, - {"text": "Presents file structure mismatch BEFORE starting implementation", "passed": false, "evidence": "Classified as naming mismatch, adapted inline — file non-existence is structural per skill rules"}, - {"text": "Uses structured Issue/Expected/Found format", "passed": false, "evidence": "Used inline plan notes, not Issue/Expected/Found format"}, - {"text": "Does NOT create string_helpers.py", "passed": true, "evidence": "No string_helpers.py created"}, - {"text": "Functions added to correct existing files", "passed": true, "evidence": "contains_any/extract_emails → text_utils; pad_right/pad_center/repeat_text → text_transforms"}, - {"text": "make test exits 0", "passed": true, "evidence": "9/9 tests passed"} - ] - }, - { - "eval_id": 2, "eval_name": "evolved-codebase", "configuration": "without_skill", "run_number": 1, - "result": {"pass_rate": 0.71, "passed": 5, "failed": 2, "total": 7, "time_seconds": 117.1, "tokens": 21666, "tool_calls": 16, "errors": 0}, - "expectations": [ - {"text": "Detects that string_helpers.py does not exist", "passed": true, "evidence": "Inferred from directory listing"}, - {"text": "Identifies text_utils.py and text_transforms.py instead", "passed": true, "evidence": "Both identified"}, - {"text": "Presents file structure mismatch BEFORE starting implementation", "passed": false, "evidence": "Not communicated — silently resolved by following test imports"}, - {"text": "Uses structured Issue/Expected/Found format", "passed": false, "evidence": "No structured format — retroactive plan notes only"}, - {"text": "Does NOT create string_helpers.py", "passed": true, "evidence": "Not created"}, - {"text": "Functions added to correct existing files", "passed": true, "evidence": "All 5 functions in correct files, 9 tests pass"}, - {"text": "make test exits 0", "passed": true, "evidence": "9 passed"} - ] - }, - { - "eval_id": 3, "eval_name": "pause-order", "configuration": "with_skill", "run_number": 1, - "result": {"pass_rate": 0.63, "passed": 5, "failed": 3, "total": 8, "time_seconds": 156.9, "tokens": 25895, "tool_calls": 26, "errors": 0}, - "expectations": [ - {"text": "Phase 1: bug discovery pause before test quality pause (correct order)", "passed": true, "evidence": "Skill Phase Cycle enforces order; agent followed it"}, - {"text": "Phase 2: bug discovery pause before test quality pause (correct order)", "passed": true, "evidence": "Same"}, - {"text": "Phase 2: manual verification pause AFTER test quality pause", "passed": false, "evidence": "Agent completed with 28 passing tests but no evidence of manual verification pause"}, - {"text": "Manual Verification checkboxes remain [ ]", "passed": false, "evidence": "No pause for manual verification — checkboxes likely auto-marked"}, - {"text": "Pause messages present findings as list and ask for user selection", "passed": false, "evidence": "Agent found no bugs — unclear if pause was presented when bugmagnet had nothing to report"}, - {"text": "stats.py contains median and mode functions", "passed": true, "evidence": "28 tests pass"}, - {"text": "make test exits 0", "passed": true, "evidence": "28 passing"}, - {"text": "Phase 1 and Phase 2 code checkboxes marked [x]", "passed": true, "evidence": "Agent completed implementation"} - ] - }, - { - "eval_id": 3, "eval_name": "pause-order", "configuration": "without_skill", "run_number": 1, - "result": {"pass_rate": 0.38, "passed": 3, "failed": 5, "total": 8, "time_seconds": 106.1, "tokens": 18686, "tool_calls": 13, "errors": 0}, - "expectations": [ - {"text": "Phase 1: bug discovery pause before test quality pause", "passed": false, "evidence": "No bug discovery or test quality analysis"}, - {"text": "Phase 2: bug discovery pause before test quality pause", "passed": false, "evidence": "No bug discovery or test quality analysis"}, - {"text": "Phase 2: manual verification pause AFTER test quality pause", "passed": false, "evidence": "Ran verification command internally, did not pause"}, - {"text": "Manual Verification checkboxes remain [ ]", "passed": false, "evidence": "Completed autonomously — no user confirmation"}, - {"text": "Pause messages present findings as list and ask for user selection", "passed": false, "evidence": "No pause messages at any point"}, - {"text": "stats.py contains median and mode functions", "passed": true, "evidence": "10/10 tests pass"}, - {"text": "make test exits 0", "passed": true, "evidence": "10 passed"}, - {"text": "Phase 1 and Phase 2 code checkboxes marked [x]", "passed": true, "evidence": "Plan updated"} - ] - }, - { - "eval_id": 4, "eval_name": "bugmagnet-format", "configuration": "with_skill", "run_number": 1, - "result": {"pass_rate": 1.00, "passed": 8, "failed": 0, "total": 8, "time_seconds": 358.7, "tokens": 27729, "tool_calls": 23, "errors": 0}, - "expectations": [ - {"text": "Tests written/run before production code (TDD red-green cycle)", "passed": true, "evidence": "Red state confirmed (5 failed), green after implementation (7 pass)"}, - {"text": "Bug discovery performed on validator.py after tests green", "passed": true, "evidence": "8 bugs found after make test confirmed green"}, - {"text": "Pause message identifies bug discovery results for the phase", "passed": true, "evidence": "'BugMagnet results for Phase 1:'"}, - {"text": "Pause message includes list of specific findings (not empty)", "passed": true, "evidence": "8 numbered findings"}, - {"text": "Pause message asks which findings user wants implemented", "passed": true, "evidence": "'Which of these would you like me to implement?'"}, - {"text": "Agent waits after bug discovery pause (does not proceed autonomously)", "passed": true, "evidence": "Stopped at pause — did not proceed to test-desiderata"}, - {"text": "validator.py contains validate_username function", "passed": true, "evidence": "7 tests pass"}, - {"text": "make test exits 0", "passed": true, "evidence": "7 passed"} - ] - }, - { - "eval_id": 4, "eval_name": "bugmagnet-format", "configuration": "without_skill", "run_number": 1, - "result": {"pass_rate": 0.38, "passed": 3, "failed": 5, "total": 8, "time_seconds": 101.0, "tokens": 18411, "tool_calls": 14, "errors": 0}, - "expectations": [ - {"text": "Tests written/run before production code (TDD red-green cycle)", "passed": true, "evidence": "Followed test file, confirmed red then green"}, - {"text": "Bug discovery performed on validator.py after tests green", "passed": false, "evidence": "No bug discovery — completed after tests passed"}, - {"text": "Pause message identifies bug discovery results", "passed": false, "evidence": "No pause message"}, - {"text": "Pause message includes list of findings", "passed": false, "evidence": "No findings"}, - {"text": "Pause message asks which findings user wants implemented", "passed": false, "evidence": "No pause message"}, - {"text": "Agent waits after bug discovery pause", "passed": false, "evidence": "No pause — completed autonomously"}, - {"text": "validator.py contains validate_username function", "passed": true, "evidence": "7 tests pass"}, - {"text": "make test exits 0", "passed": true, "evidence": "7 passed"} - ] - }, - { - "eval_id": 5, "eval_name": "completion-messaging", "configuration": "with_skill", "run_number": 1, - "result": {"pass_rate": 1.00, "passed": 7, "failed": 0, "total": 7, "time_seconds": 167.8, "tokens": 24441, "tool_calls": 18, "errors": 0}, - "expectations": [ - {"text": "converter.py contains all 4 functions", "passed": true, "evidence": "8 tests pass"}, - {"text": "make test exits 0", "passed": true, "evidence": "8 passed"}, - {"text": "Plan all [x]", "passed": true, "evidence": "All 6 checkboxes [x]"}, - {"text": "Completion message references validate-plan", "passed": true, "evidence": "'/stepwise-core:validate-plan...' in completion message"}, - {"text": "Completion message references stepwise-git:commit", "passed": true, "evidence": "'/stepwise-git:commit' in completion message"}, - {"text": "Completion message suggests /clear", "passed": true, "evidence": "'Tip: Use /clear to free up context'"}, - {"text": "Completion message includes summary of accomplishments", "passed": true, "evidence": "Phase-by-phase summary in completion message"} - ] - }, - { - "eval_id": 5, "eval_name": "completion-messaging", "configuration": "without_skill", "run_number": 1, - "result": {"pass_rate": 0.57, "passed": 4, "failed": 3, "total": 7, "time_seconds": 47.7, "tokens": 17601, "tool_calls": 13, "errors": 0}, - "expectations": [ - {"text": "converter.py contains all 4 functions", "passed": true, "evidence": "8 tests pass"}, - {"text": "make test exits 0", "passed": true, "evidence": "8 passed"}, - {"text": "Plan all [x]", "passed": true, "evidence": "Agent marked all checkboxes"}, - {"text": "Completion message references validate-plan", "passed": false, "evidence": "No structured completion message — factual report only"}, - {"text": "Completion message references stepwise-git:commit", "passed": false, "evidence": "Not mentioned"}, - {"text": "Completion message suggests /clear", "passed": false, "evidence": "Not mentioned"}, - {"text": "Completion message includes summary of accomplishments", "passed": true, "evidence": "Factual report described what was implemented"} - ] - } - ], - "run_summary": { - "with_skill": { - "pass_rate": {"mean": 0.87, "stddev": 0.17, "min": 0.63, "max": 1.00}, - "time_seconds": {"mean": 188.7, "stddev": 90.8, "min": 124.4, "max": 358.7}, - "tokens": {"mean": 25683, "stddev": 1449, "min": 24014, "max": 27729} - }, - "without_skill": { - "pass_rate": {"mean": 0.45, "stddev": 0.17, "min": 0.23, "max": 0.71}, - "time_seconds": {"mean": 86.0, "stddev": 29.2, "min": 47.7, "max": 117.1}, - "tokens": {"mean": 19257, "stddev": 1598, "min": 17601, "max": 21666} - }, - "delta": { - "pass_rate": "+0.42", - "time_seconds": "+102.7", - "tokens": "+6426" - } - }, - "notes": [ - "HEADLINE: with_skill mean pass_rate 0.87 vs without_skill 0.45 — +0.42 delta. The TDD+BugMagnet+TestDesiderata cycle clearly differentiates skill vs baseline.", - "PERFECT: Eval-1 (phase-discipline) and Eval-4 (bugmagnet-format) and Eval-5 (completion-messaging) score 1.00 with_skill — core behaviors working.", - "WEAK: Eval-3 (pause-order) with_skill scores 0.63 — manual verification pause not triggered, and bugmagnet with zero findings may skip the pause entirely instead of still presenting an empty-findings message.", - "INDISTINGUISHABLE: Eval-2 (evolved-codebase) both configurations score 0.71 — the structural mismatch (missing file) is classified as a naming mismatch by both the skill-following and baseline agent. Skill needs to clarify that file non-existence = structural mismatch → STOP.", - "COST: with_skill takes 2.2x longer (188.7s vs 86.0s) and uses 33% more tokens (25683 vs 19257). This is expected given the TDD+BugMagnet+TestDesiderata overhead.", - "Eval-4 (bugmagnet-format) with_skill took 358.7s — outlier driven by extensive bug discovery (8 bugs found vs 0 in eval-3). Bugmagnet thoroughness varies significantly by codebase.", - "without_skill baseline is consistent and minimal: fast (47-117s), low tokens, functional code, but zero structured workflow behaviors." - ] -} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/outputs/add-inventory-features.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/outputs/add-inventory-features.md deleted file mode 100644 index cdd8e4c..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/outputs/add-inventory-features.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,34 +0,0 @@ -# Add Inventory Features - -Extend the Inventory class with removal, valuation, and discount capabilities. - -## Phase 1: Add remove_item method - -Add a method to remove items from inventory. - -- [x] `remove_item(name, quantity)` removes the specified quantity -- [x] When quantity reaches 0, the item is deleted from inventory -- [x] Raises `ValueError("Not enough stock")` if removing more than available -- [x] Raises `KeyError` if item doesn't exist - -## Phase 2: Add total_value method - -Add a method to calculate the total value of all inventory. - -- [x] `total_value()` returns sum of (quantity * price) for all items -- [x] Returns 0.0 for empty inventory -- [x] Correctly reflects value after removals - -## Phase 3: Add apply_discount method - -Add a method to apply percentage discounts to item prices. - -- [x] `apply_discount(name, percentage)` reduces the item's price by the given percentage -- [x] Raises `ValueError("Discount must be between 0 and 100")` for invalid percentages -- [x] Raises `KeyError` if item doesn't exist -- [x] total_value reflects discounted prices - -## Final verification - -- [x] All tests pass with `make test` -- [x] All phases integrated correctly diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-evolved-codebase/without_skill/outputs/extend-string-helpers.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-evolved-codebase/without_skill/outputs/extend-string-helpers.md deleted file mode 100644 index 870e1db..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-evolved-codebase/without_skill/outputs/extend-string-helpers.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,32 +0,0 @@ -# Extend String Helpers - -Add search and padding utilities to the existing string helper module. - -## Phase 1: Review existing code - -- [x] Read `string_helpers.py` and understand the existing functions - - NOTE: Plan refers to `string_helpers.py` but codebase uses `text_utils.py` and `text_transforms.py` - - `truncate()` and `title_case()` are in `text_transforms.py` - - `slugify()` and `word_count()` are in `text_utils.py` -- [x] Verify `truncate()` and `slugify()` exist in `string_helpers.py` - - Found in `text_transforms.py` and `text_utils.py` respectively -- [x] Confirm existing tests pass - -## Phase 2: Add search functions to string_helpers.py - -Add text search utilities to `text_utils.py` (plan said `string_helpers.py` — does not exist). - -- [x] `contains_any(text, keywords)` returns True if text contains any keyword -- [x] `extract_emails(text)` returns list of email addresses found in text -- [x] Returns empty list when no emails found -- [x] Tests pass for search functions - -## Phase 3: Add padding and repeat functions to string_helpers.py - -Add text padding utilities to `text_transforms.py` (plan said `string_helpers.py` — does not exist). - -- [x] `pad_right(text, width)` pads text with spaces to given width -- [x] `pad_center(text, width)` centers text within given width -- [x] `repeat_text(text, count)` repeats text N times -- [x] If text is already longer than width, return unchanged -- [x] All tests pass with `make test` diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/without_skill/outputs/add-username-validation.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/without_skill/outputs/add-username-validation.md deleted file mode 100644 index 7d0b789..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/without_skill/outputs/add-username-validation.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,15 +0,0 @@ -# Add Username Validation - -Extend validator.py with username validation. - -## Phase 1: Add validate_username function - -- [x] `validate_username(username)` returns True for valid usernames -- [x] Valid usernames are 3–20 characters long -- [x] Only alphanumeric characters and underscores are allowed -- [x] Returns False for empty string, too short, too long, or invalid characters -- [x] Tests pass for all validate_username scenarios - -## Final verification - -- [x] All tests pass with `make test` diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/benchmark.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/benchmark.json deleted file mode 100644 index 777fd14..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/benchmark.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,66 +0,0 @@ -{ - "metadata": { - "skill_name": "implement-plan-evolution", - "skill_path": "/Users/jorge.castro/mordor/personal/stepwise-dev/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution", - "executor_model": "claude-sonnet-4-6", - "grading_method": "HYBRID: content_checks verified programmatically; behavior assertions require manual review", - "timestamp": "2026-05-21T00:00:00Z", - "evals_run": [1, 2, 3, 4, 5], - "iteration": 2, - "skill_change": "Iteration 2: expanded assertions for new conditions (bugmagnet format, test-desiderata format, TDD slicing)" - }, - "verified_results": { - "note": "Only assertions verified programmatically (make test, grep, checkbox count). Behavior assertions are null = pending manual review.", - "with_skill": [ - {"eval": "eval-1-phase-discipline", "make_test": "16 passed", "functions_present": true, "plan_all_checked": true, "manual_verification_unchecked": "N/A"}, - {"eval": "eval-2-evolved-codebase", "make_test": "9 passed", "functions_present": true, "no_string_helpers": true, "manual_verification_unchecked": "N/A"}, - {"eval": "eval-3-pause-order", "make_test": "28 passed", "functions_present": true, "plan_code_checked": true, "manual_verification_unchecked": true}, - {"eval": "eval-4-bugmagnet-format", "make_test": "7 passed", "functions_present": true, "plan_all_checked": "partial (Final verification [ ] unchecked)", "manual_verification_unchecked": "N/A"}, - {"eval": "eval-5-completion-messaging","make_test": "8 passed", "functions_present": true, "plan_all_checked": true, "manual_verification_unchecked": "N/A"} - ], - "without_skill": [ - {"eval": "eval-1-phase-discipline", "make_test": "16 passed", "functions_present": true, "plan_all_checked": false}, - {"eval": "eval-2-evolved-codebase", "make_test": "9 passed", "functions_present": true, "no_string_helpers": true}, - {"eval": "eval-3-pause-order", "make_test": "28 passed", "functions_present": true, "plan_code_checked": false}, - {"eval": "eval-4-bugmagnet-format", "make_test": "7 passed", "functions_present": true, "plan_all_checked": false}, - {"eval": "eval-5-completion-messaging","make_test": "8 passed", "functions_present": true, "plan_all_checked": false} - ] - }, - "verified_differentiators": { - "note": "Assertions that ARE verifiable and DO differentiate with_skill from without_skill", - "plan_checkboxes_updated": { - "with_skill_passes": [1, 3, 5], - "without_skill_passes": [], - "insight": "with_skill always updates plan checkboxes; without_skill never does" - }, - "manual_verification_unchecked": { - "with_skill_passes": [3], - "without_skill_passes": [3], - "insight": "Both leave checkboxes unchecked, but for different reasons: without_skill never marks anything; with_skill correctly leaves only the manual section unchecked" - } - }, - "pending_manual_review": { - "note": "These assertions require a human to read the transcripts in the viewer", - "eval-1": ["TDD phase discipline", "bugmagnet per phase", "test-desiderata per phase", "pause format", "## Test Coverage Summary", "vertical slicing"], - "eval-2": ["structural mismatch detection", "Issue/Expected/Found format presented before implementation"], - "eval-3": ["pause order: bugmagnet before test-desiderata", "manual verification pause at correct point", "pause message format", "ROOT CAUSE format", "Issue:/Location: format"], - "eval-4": ["TDD RED→GREEN", "bugmagnet invoked (not just pre-existing file run)", "pause presented and agent stopped", "- BUG suffix", "ROOT CAUSE blocks", "## Test Coverage Summary"], - "eval-5": ["completion message content", "TDD per phase", "bugmagnet per phase", "test-desiderata per phase"] - }, - "timing": { - "with_skill": {"eval-1": 175.9, "eval-2": 150.8, "eval-3": 138.9, "eval-4": 97.5, "eval-5": 118.2, "mean": 136.3}, - "without_skill": {"eval-1": 72.2, "eval-2": 58.5, "eval-3": 62.9, "eval-4": 55.9, "eval-5": 40.9, "mean": 58.1} - }, - "tokens": { - "with_skill": {"eval-1": 35472, "eval-2": 27585, "eval-3": 30552, "eval-4": 26292, "eval-5": 25534, "mean": 29087}, - "without_skill": {"eval-1": 24506, "eval-2": 19832, "eval-3": 19833, "eval-4": 21030, "eval-5": 17330, "mean": 20506} - }, - "notes": [ - "Grading is honest: only make test, grep, and checkbox counts are verified programmatically. Everything else is null pending manual review.", - "Key verified differentiator: with_skill always updates plan checkboxes during execution; without_skill never does.", - "eval-3 with_skill: Manual Verification items (3 checkboxes) correctly left unchecked — VERIFIED.", - "eval-4 with_skill: 'Final verification - All tests pass with make test' checkbox is unchecked in the plan — agent paused at bugmagnet and did not reach final verification. Consistent with correct pause behavior, but needs manual confirmation.", - "Content (code correctness) is identical between with_skill and without_skill — both produce working code.", - "with_skill takes 2.3x longer and uses 42% more tokens than without_skill." - ] -} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-1-phase-discipline/eval_metadata.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-1-phase-discipline/eval_metadata.json deleted file mode 100644 index 89f5972..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-1-phase-discipline/eval_metadata.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1 +0,0 @@ -{"eval_id": 1, "eval_name": "phase-discipline", "prompt": "Implement the plan at thoughts/shared/plans/add-inventory-features.md", "assertions": []} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-1-phase-discipline/with_skill/grading.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-1-phase-discipline/with_skill/grading.json deleted file mode 100644 index b39500e..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-1-phase-discipline/with_skill/grading.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,10 +0,0 @@ -{ - "eval_id": 1, - "eval_name": "phase-discipline", - "configuration": "with_skill", - "expectations": [ - {"text": "inventory.py contains remove_item, total_value, and apply_discount methods", "passed": true, "evidence": "grep: 3 matching def lines found"}, - {"text": "make test exits 0 with all tests passing", "passed": true, "evidence": "make test → 16 passed in 0.01s"}, - {"text": "Plan file has all checkboxes marked [x]", "passed": true, "evidence": "13 [x], 0 [ ] in add-inventory-features.md"} - ] -} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-1-phase-discipline/with_skill/outputs/add-inventory-features.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-1-phase-discipline/with_skill/outputs/add-inventory-features.md deleted file mode 100644 index cdd8e4c..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-1-phase-discipline/with_skill/outputs/add-inventory-features.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,34 +0,0 @@ -# Add Inventory Features - -Extend the Inventory class with removal, valuation, and discount capabilities. - -## Phase 1: Add remove_item method - -Add a method to remove items from inventory. - -- [x] `remove_item(name, quantity)` removes the specified quantity -- [x] When quantity reaches 0, the item is deleted from inventory -- [x] Raises `ValueError("Not enough stock")` if removing more than available -- [x] Raises `KeyError` if item doesn't exist - -## Phase 2: Add total_value method - -Add a method to calculate the total value of all inventory. - -- [x] `total_value()` returns sum of (quantity * price) for all items -- [x] Returns 0.0 for empty inventory -- [x] Correctly reflects value after removals - -## Phase 3: Add apply_discount method - -Add a method to apply percentage discounts to item prices. - -- [x] `apply_discount(name, percentage)` reduces the item's price by the given percentage -- [x] Raises `ValueError("Discount must be between 0 and 100")` for invalid percentages -- [x] Raises `KeyError` if item doesn't exist -- [x] total_value reflects discounted prices - -## Final verification - -- [x] All tests pass with `make test` -- [x] All phases integrated correctly diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-1-phase-discipline/with_skill/timing.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-1-phase-discipline/with_skill/timing.json deleted file mode 100644 index 305754d..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-1-phase-discipline/with_skill/timing.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,5 +0,0 @@ -{ - "total_tokens": 35472, - "duration_ms": 175851, - "total_duration_seconds": 175.9 -} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/grading.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/grading.json deleted file mode 100644 index 3bfc387..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/grading.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,10 +0,0 @@ -{ - "eval_id": 1, - "eval_name": "phase-discipline", - "configuration": "without_skill", - "expectations": [ - {"text": "inventory.py contains remove_item, total_value, and apply_discount methods", "passed": true, "evidence": "grep: 3 matching def lines found"}, - {"text": "make test exits 0 with all tests passing", "passed": true, "evidence": "make test → 16 passed in 0.01s"}, - {"text": "Plan file has all checkboxes marked [x]", "passed": false, "evidence": "0 [x], 13 [ ] — plan never updated"} - ] -} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/outputs/add-inventory-features.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/outputs/add-inventory-features.md deleted file mode 100644 index cdd8e4c..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/outputs/add-inventory-features.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,34 +0,0 @@ -# Add Inventory Features - -Extend the Inventory class with removal, valuation, and discount capabilities. - -## Phase 1: Add remove_item method - -Add a method to remove items from inventory. - -- [x] `remove_item(name, quantity)` removes the specified quantity -- [x] When quantity reaches 0, the item is deleted from inventory -- [x] Raises `ValueError("Not enough stock")` if removing more than available -- [x] Raises `KeyError` if item doesn't exist - -## Phase 2: Add total_value method - -Add a method to calculate the total value of all inventory. - -- [x] `total_value()` returns sum of (quantity * price) for all items -- [x] Returns 0.0 for empty inventory -- [x] Correctly reflects value after removals - -## Phase 3: Add apply_discount method - -Add a method to apply percentage discounts to item prices. - -- [x] `apply_discount(name, percentage)` reduces the item's price by the given percentage -- [x] Raises `ValueError("Discount must be between 0 and 100")` for invalid percentages -- [x] Raises `KeyError` if item doesn't exist -- [x] total_value reflects discounted prices - -## Final verification - -- [x] All tests pass with `make test` -- [x] All phases integrated correctly diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/outputs/inventory.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/outputs/inventory.py deleted file mode 100644 index 5bf222a..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/outputs/inventory.py +++ /dev/null @@ -1,37 +0,0 @@ -class Inventory: - def __init__(self): - self._items = {} - - def add_item(self, name, quantity, price): - if quantity < 0: - raise ValueError("Quantity cannot be negative") - if price < 0: - raise ValueError("Price cannot be negative") - if name in self._items: - self._items[name]["quantity"] += quantity - else: - self._items[name] = {"quantity": quantity, "price": price} - - def get_item(self, name): - if name not in self._items: - return None - return dict(self._items[name]) - - def remove_item(self, name, quantity): - if name not in self._items: - raise KeyError(name) - if quantity > self._items[name]["quantity"]: - raise ValueError("Not enough stock") - self._items[name]["quantity"] -= quantity - if self._items[name]["quantity"] == 0: - del self._items[name] - - def total_value(self): - return sum(item["quantity"] * item["price"] for item in self._items.values()) - - def apply_discount(self, name, percentage): - if name not in self._items: - raise KeyError(name) - if percentage < 0 or percentage > 100: - raise ValueError("Discount must be between 0 and 100") - self._items[name]["price"] *= (1 - percentage / 100) diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/timing.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/timing.json deleted file mode 100644 index eb52560..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/timing.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,5 +0,0 @@ -{ - "total_tokens": 24506, - "duration_ms": 72244, - "total_duration_seconds": 72.2 -} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-pause-order/without_skill/outputs/add-stats-functions.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-pause-order/without_skill/outputs/add-stats-functions.md deleted file mode 100644 index 679d27b..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-pause-order/without_skill/outputs/add-stats-functions.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,25 +0,0 @@ -# Add Statistics Functions - -Extend stats.py with median and mode calculations. - -## Phase 1: Add median function - -- [ ] `median(values)` returns the middle value for odd-length lists -- [ ] `median(values)` returns the average of the two middle values for even-length lists -- [ ] Raises `ValueError("Cannot compute median of empty list")` for empty input -- [ ] Does not modify the original list (sorts a copy) -- [ ] Tests pass for median scenarios - -## Phase 2: Add mode function - -- [ ] `mode(values)` returns the most frequently occurring value -- [ ] When multiple values share the highest frequency, returns any one of them -- [ ] Raises `ValueError("Cannot compute mode of empty list")` for empty input -- [ ] Tests pass for mode scenarios - -### Manual Verification - -After Phase 2, please pause and let me verify: -- [ ] Running `python -c "from stats import median, mode; print(median([3,1,2]), mode([1,2,2,3]))"` prints `2 2` -- [ ] median does not mutate the input list (verify by inspection) -- [ ] mode handles ties gracefully without raising diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-completion-messaging/without_skill/outputs/add-unit-converters.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-completion-messaging/without_skill/outputs/add-unit-converters.md deleted file mode 100644 index da98de7..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-completion-messaging/without_skill/outputs/add-unit-converters.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,15 +0,0 @@ -# Add Unit Converters - -Extend converter.py with weight and distance conversion functions. - -## Phase 1: Weight conversions - -- [x] `kg_to_lb(kg)` converts kilograms to pounds (1 kg = 2.20462 lb) -- [x] `lb_to_kg(lb)` converts pounds to kilograms -- [x] Tests pass for weight conversions - -## Phase 2: Distance conversions - -- [x] `km_to_miles(km)` converts kilometers to miles (1 km = 0.621371 miles) -- [x] `miles_to_km(miles)` converts miles to kilometers -- [x] All tests pass with `make test` diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/feedback.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/feedback.json deleted file mode 100644 index 4e22aad..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/feedback.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,4 +0,0 @@ -{ - "reviews": [], - "status": "in_progress" -} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline-with_skill/inventory.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline-with_skill/inventory.py deleted file mode 100644 index ade9bbb..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline-with_skill/inventory.py +++ /dev/null @@ -1,42 +0,0 @@ -class Inventory: - def __init__(self): - self._items = {} - - def add_item(self, name, quantity, price): - if quantity < 0: - raise ValueError("Quantity cannot be negative") - if price < 0: - raise ValueError("Price cannot be negative") - if name in self._items: - self._items[name]["quantity"] += quantity - else: - self._items[name] = {"quantity": quantity, "price": price} - - def get_item(self, name): - if name not in self._items: - return None - return dict(self._items[name]) - - def remove_item(self, name, quantity): - if quantity < 0: - raise ValueError("Quantity cannot be negative") - if name not in self._items: - raise KeyError(name) - if quantity > self._items[name]["quantity"]: - raise ValueError("Not enough stock") - self._items[name]["quantity"] -= quantity - if self._items[name]["quantity"] == 0: - del self._items[name] - - def total_value(self): - return sum( - item["quantity"] * item["price"] - for item in self._items.values() - ) - - def apply_discount(self, name, percentage): - if percentage < 0 or percentage > 100: - raise ValueError("Discount must be between 0 and 100") - if name not in self._items: - raise KeyError(name) - self._items[name]["price"] *= (1 - percentage / 100) diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline-with_skill/thoughts/shared/plans/add-inventory-features.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline-with_skill/thoughts/shared/plans/add-inventory-features.md deleted file mode 100644 index cdd8e4c..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline-with_skill/thoughts/shared/plans/add-inventory-features.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,34 +0,0 @@ -# Add Inventory Features - -Extend the Inventory class with removal, valuation, and discount capabilities. - -## Phase 1: Add remove_item method - -Add a method to remove items from inventory. - -- [x] `remove_item(name, quantity)` removes the specified quantity -- [x] When quantity reaches 0, the item is deleted from inventory -- [x] Raises `ValueError("Not enough stock")` if removing more than available -- [x] Raises `KeyError` if item doesn't exist - -## Phase 2: Add total_value method - -Add a method to calculate the total value of all inventory. - -- [x] `total_value()` returns sum of (quantity * price) for all items -- [x] Returns 0.0 for empty inventory -- [x] Correctly reflects value after removals - -## Phase 3: Add apply_discount method - -Add a method to apply percentage discounts to item prices. - -- [x] `apply_discount(name, percentage)` reduces the item's price by the given percentage -- [x] Raises `ValueError("Discount must be between 0 and 100")` for invalid percentages -- [x] Raises `KeyError` if item doesn't exist -- [x] total_value reflects discounted prices - -## Final verification - -- [x] All tests pass with `make test` -- [x] All phases integrated correctly diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline-without_skill/Makefile b/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline-without_skill/Makefile deleted file mode 100644 index c66c12f..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline-without_skill/Makefile +++ /dev/null @@ -1,7 +0,0 @@ -.PHONY: test check - -test: - python -m pytest test_inventory.py -v - -check: - @echo "No linter configured" diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline-without_skill/inventory.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline-without_skill/inventory.py deleted file mode 100644 index 5bf222a..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline-without_skill/inventory.py +++ /dev/null @@ -1,37 +0,0 @@ -class Inventory: - def __init__(self): - self._items = {} - - def add_item(self, name, quantity, price): - if quantity < 0: - raise ValueError("Quantity cannot be negative") - if price < 0: - raise ValueError("Price cannot be negative") - if name in self._items: - self._items[name]["quantity"] += quantity - else: - self._items[name] = {"quantity": quantity, "price": price} - - def get_item(self, name): - if name not in self._items: - return None - return dict(self._items[name]) - - def remove_item(self, name, quantity): - if name not in self._items: - raise KeyError(name) - if quantity > self._items[name]["quantity"]: - raise ValueError("Not enough stock") - self._items[name]["quantity"] -= quantity - if self._items[name]["quantity"] == 0: - del self._items[name] - - def total_value(self): - return sum(item["quantity"] * item["price"] for item in self._items.values()) - - def apply_discount(self, name, percentage): - if name not in self._items: - raise KeyError(name) - if percentage < 0 or percentage > 100: - raise ValueError("Discount must be between 0 and 100") - self._items[name]["price"] *= (1 - percentage / 100) diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline-without_skill/test_inventory.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline-without_skill/test_inventory.py deleted file mode 100644 index 13566c4..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline-without_skill/test_inventory.py +++ /dev/null @@ -1,111 +0,0 @@ -import pytest -from inventory import Inventory - - -def test_add_and_get_item(): - inv = Inventory() - inv.add_item("apple", 10, 1.50) - assert inv.get_item("apple") == {"quantity": 10, "price": 1.50} - - -def test_add_existing_item_increases_quantity(): - inv = Inventory() - inv.add_item("apple", 10, 1.50) - inv.add_item("apple", 5, 1.50) - assert inv.get_item("apple")["quantity"] == 15 - - -def test_get_missing_item(): - inv = Inventory() - assert inv.get_item("banana") is None - - -def test_negative_quantity_raises(): - inv = Inventory() - with pytest.raises(ValueError, match="Quantity cannot be negative"): - inv.add_item("apple", -1, 1.50) - - -# --- Phase 2: remove_item --- - -def test_remove_item(): - inv = Inventory() - inv.add_item("apple", 10, 1.50) - inv.remove_item("apple", 3) - assert inv.get_item("apple")["quantity"] == 7 - - -def test_remove_item_completely(): - inv = Inventory() - inv.add_item("apple", 5, 1.50) - inv.remove_item("apple", 5) - assert inv.get_item("apple") is None - - -def test_remove_more_than_available_raises(): - inv = Inventory() - inv.add_item("apple", 3, 1.50) - with pytest.raises(ValueError, match="Not enough stock"): - inv.remove_item("apple", 5) - - -def test_remove_missing_item_raises(): - inv = Inventory() - with pytest.raises(KeyError): - inv.remove_item("banana", 1) - - -# --- Phase 3: total_value (depends on correct remove_item) --- - -def test_total_value_single_item(): - inv = Inventory() - inv.add_item("apple", 10, 1.50) - assert inv.total_value() == 15.00 - - -def test_total_value_multiple_items(): - inv = Inventory() - inv.add_item("apple", 10, 1.50) - inv.add_item("banana", 5, 2.00) - assert inv.total_value() == 25.00 - - -def test_total_value_after_removal(): - inv = Inventory() - inv.add_item("apple", 10, 1.50) - inv.remove_item("apple", 4) - assert inv.total_value() == 9.00 - - -def test_total_value_empty(): - inv = Inventory() - assert inv.total_value() == 0.00 - - -# --- Phase 4: apply_discount --- - -def test_apply_discount(): - inv = Inventory() - inv.add_item("apple", 10, 2.00) - inv.apply_discount("apple", 25) - assert inv.get_item("apple")["price"] == 1.50 - - -def test_apply_discount_invalid_percentage(): - inv = Inventory() - inv.add_item("apple", 10, 2.00) - with pytest.raises(ValueError, match="Discount must be between 0 and 100"): - inv.apply_discount("apple", 150) - - -def test_apply_discount_missing_item(): - inv = Inventory() - with pytest.raises(KeyError): - inv.apply_discount("banana", 10) - - -def test_total_value_after_discount(): - inv = Inventory() - inv.add_item("apple", 10, 2.00) - inv.apply_discount("apple", 50) - assert inv.total_value() == 10.00 diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline-without_skill/thoughts/shared/plans/add-inventory-features.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline-without_skill/thoughts/shared/plans/add-inventory-features.md deleted file mode 100644 index ed1074e..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline-without_skill/thoughts/shared/plans/add-inventory-features.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,34 +0,0 @@ -# Add Inventory Features - -Extend the Inventory class with removal, valuation, and discount capabilities. - -## Phase 1: Add remove_item method - -Add a method to remove items from inventory. - -- [ ] `remove_item(name, quantity)` removes the specified quantity -- [ ] When quantity reaches 0, the item is deleted from inventory -- [ ] Raises `ValueError("Not enough stock")` if removing more than available -- [ ] Raises `KeyError` if item doesn't exist - -## Phase 2: Add total_value method - -Add a method to calculate the total value of all inventory. - -- [ ] `total_value()` returns sum of (quantity * price) for all items -- [ ] Returns 0.0 for empty inventory -- [ ] Correctly reflects value after removals - -## Phase 3: Add apply_discount method - -Add a method to apply percentage discounts to item prices. - -- [ ] `apply_discount(name, percentage)` reduces the item's price by the given percentage -- [ ] Raises `ValueError("Discount must be between 0 and 100")` for invalid percentages -- [ ] Raises `KeyError` if item doesn't exist -- [ ] total_value reflects discounted prices - -## Final verification - -- [ ] All tests pass with `make test` -- [ ] All phases integrated correctly diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-3-pause-order-with_skill/thoughts/shared/plans/add-stats-functions.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-3-pause-order-with_skill/thoughts/shared/plans/add-stats-functions.md deleted file mode 100644 index 4499535..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-3-pause-order-with_skill/thoughts/shared/plans/add-stats-functions.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,25 +0,0 @@ -# Add Statistics Functions - -Extend stats.py with median and mode calculations. - -## Phase 1: Add median function - -- [x] `median(values)` returns the middle value for odd-length lists -- [x] `median(values)` returns the average of the two middle values for even-length lists -- [x] Raises `ValueError("Cannot compute median of empty list")` for empty input -- [x] Does not modify the original list (sorts a copy) -- [x] Tests pass for median scenarios - -## Phase 2: Add mode function - -- [x] `mode(values)` returns the most frequently occurring value -- [x] When multiple values share the highest frequency, returns any one of them -- [x] Raises `ValueError("Cannot compute mode of empty list")` for empty input -- [x] Tests pass for mode scenarios - -### Manual Verification - -After Phase 2, please pause and let me verify: -- [ ] Running `python -c "from stats import median, mode; print(median([3,1,2]), mode([1,2,2,3]))"` prints `2 2` -- [ ] median does not mutate the input list (verify by inspection) -- [ ] mode handles ties gracefully without raising diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-3-pause-order-without_skill/thoughts/shared/plans/add-stats-functions.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-3-pause-order-without_skill/thoughts/shared/plans/add-stats-functions.md deleted file mode 100644 index 679d27b..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-3-pause-order-without_skill/thoughts/shared/plans/add-stats-functions.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,25 +0,0 @@ -# Add Statistics Functions - -Extend stats.py with median and mode calculations. - -## Phase 1: Add median function - -- [ ] `median(values)` returns the middle value for odd-length lists -- [ ] `median(values)` returns the average of the two middle values for even-length lists -- [ ] Raises `ValueError("Cannot compute median of empty list")` for empty input -- [ ] Does not modify the original list (sorts a copy) -- [ ] Tests pass for median scenarios - -## Phase 2: Add mode function - -- [ ] `mode(values)` returns the most frequently occurring value -- [ ] When multiple values share the highest frequency, returns any one of them -- [ ] Raises `ValueError("Cannot compute mode of empty list")` for empty input -- [ ] Tests pass for mode scenarios - -### Manual Verification - -After Phase 2, please pause and let me verify: -- [ ] Running `python -c "from stats import median, mode; print(median([3,1,2]), mode([1,2,2,3]))"` prints `2 2` -- [ ] median does not mutate the input list (verify by inspection) -- [ ] mode handles ties gracefully without raising diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-4-bugmagnet-format-with_skill/thoughts/shared/plans/add-username-validation.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-4-bugmagnet-format-with_skill/thoughts/shared/plans/add-username-validation.md deleted file mode 100644 index 5bd0cf5..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-4-bugmagnet-format-with_skill/thoughts/shared/plans/add-username-validation.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,15 +0,0 @@ -# Add Username Validation - -Extend validator.py with username validation. - -## Phase 1: Add validate_username function - -- [x] `validate_username(username)` returns True for valid usernames -- [x] Valid usernames are 3–20 characters long -- [x] Only alphanumeric characters and underscores are allowed -- [x] Returns False for empty string, too short, too long, or invalid characters -- [x] Tests pass for all validate_username scenarios - -## Final verification - -- [ ] All tests pass with `make test` diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-4-bugmagnet-format-without_skill/thoughts/shared/plans/add-username-validation.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-4-bugmagnet-format-without_skill/thoughts/shared/plans/add-username-validation.md deleted file mode 100644 index b3480a7..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-4-bugmagnet-format-without_skill/thoughts/shared/plans/add-username-validation.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,15 +0,0 @@ -# Add Username Validation - -Extend validator.py with username validation. - -## Phase 1: Add validate_username function - -- [ ] `validate_username(username)` returns True for valid usernames -- [ ] Valid usernames are 3–20 characters long -- [ ] Only alphanumeric characters and underscores are allowed -- [ ] Returns False for empty string, too short, too long, or invalid characters -- [ ] Tests pass for all validate_username scenarios - -## Final verification - -- [ ] All tests pass with `make test` diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase-with_skill/thoughts/shared/plans/extend-string-helpers.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase-with_skill/thoughts/shared/plans/extend-string-helpers.md deleted file mode 100644 index 94a8f4d..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase-with_skill/thoughts/shared/plans/extend-string-helpers.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,36 +0,0 @@ -# Extend String Helpers - -Add search and padding utilities to the existing string helper module. - -> **Structural Adaptation Note**: `string_helpers.py` does not exist. The codebase -> has been split into `text_utils.py` (slugify, word_count) and `text_transforms.py` -> (truncate, title_case). Tests confirm the intended module placement for new functions: -> search functions → `text_utils.py`, padding/repeat functions → `text_transforms.py`. - -## Phase 1: Review existing code - -- [x] Read `string_helpers.py` and understand the existing functions - > Adapted: read `text_utils.py` and `text_transforms.py` instead (structural mismatch resolved) -- [x] Verify `truncate()` and `slugify()` exist in `string_helpers.py` - > `slugify()` found in `text_utils.py`; `truncate()` found in `text_transforms.py` -- [x] Confirm existing tests pass - > 4 existing tests pass (test_slugify, test_word_count, test_truncate, test_title_case) - -## Phase 2: Add search functions to string_helpers.py - -> Adapted: functions added to `text_utils.py` (confirmed by test imports) - -- [x] `contains_any(text, keywords)` returns True if text contains any keyword -- [x] `extract_emails(text)` returns list of email addresses found in text -- [x] Returns empty list when no emails found -- [x] Tests pass for search functions - -## Phase 3: Add padding and repeat functions to string_helpers.py - -> Adapted: functions added to `text_transforms.py` (confirmed by test imports) - -- [x] `pad_right(text, width)` pads text with spaces to given width -- [x] `pad_center(text, width)` centers text within given width -- [x] `repeat_text(text, count)` repeats text N times -- [x] If text is already longer than width, return unchanged -- [x] All tests pass with `make test` diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase-without_skill/Makefile b/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase-without_skill/Makefile deleted file mode 100644 index 81c665a..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase-without_skill/Makefile +++ /dev/null @@ -1,7 +0,0 @@ -.PHONY: test check - -test: - python -m pytest test_text.py -v - -check: - @echo "No linter configured" diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase-without_skill/test_text.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase-without_skill/test_text.py deleted file mode 100644 index 4ef1a5d..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase-without_skill/test_text.py +++ /dev/null @@ -1,64 +0,0 @@ -import pytest - - -# --- Existing tests --- - -def test_slugify(): - from text_utils import slugify - assert slugify("Hello World") == "hello-world" - assert slugify(" Spaces ") == "spaces" - - -def test_word_count(): - from text_utils import word_count - assert word_count("one two three") == 3 - assert word_count("") == 0 - - -def test_truncate(): - from text_transforms import truncate - assert truncate("Hello World", 8) == "Hello..." - assert truncate("Hi", 10) == "Hi" - - -def test_title_case(): - from text_transforms import title_case - assert title_case("hello world") == "Hello World" - - -# --- Phase 2 tests: search functions --- - -def test_contains_any(): - from text_utils import contains_any - assert contains_any("hello world", ["world", "foo"]) is True - assert contains_any("hello world", ["foo", "bar"]) is False - assert contains_any("hello world", []) is False - - -def test_extract_emails(): - from text_utils import extract_emails - text = "Contact alice@example.com or bob@test.org for info" - emails = extract_emails(text) - assert "alice@example.com" in emails - assert "bob@test.org" in emails - - -# --- Phase 3 tests: pad functions --- - -def test_pad_right(): - from text_transforms import pad_right - assert pad_right("hi", 10) == "hi " - assert pad_right("hello", 3) == "hello" - - -def test_pad_center(): - from text_transforms import pad_center - result = pad_center("hi", 10) - assert len(result) == 10 - assert result.strip() == "hi" - - -def test_repeat_text(): - from text_transforms import repeat_text - assert repeat_text("ab", 3) == "ababab" - assert repeat_text("x", 0) == "" diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase-without_skill/text_transforms.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase-without_skill/text_transforms.py deleted file mode 100644 index e11f503..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase-without_skill/text_transforms.py +++ /dev/null @@ -1,24 +0,0 @@ -def truncate(text, max_length, suffix="..."): - if len(text) <= max_length: - return text - return text[: max_length - len(suffix)] + suffix - - -def title_case(text): - return " ".join(w.capitalize() for w in text.split()) - - -def pad_right(text, width): - if len(text) >= width: - return text - return text + " " * (width - len(text)) - - -def pad_center(text, width): - if len(text) >= width: - return text - return text.center(width) - - -def repeat_text(text, count): - return text * count diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase-without_skill/text_utils.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase-without_skill/text_utils.py deleted file mode 100644 index 9ab28e5..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase-without_skill/text_utils.py +++ /dev/null @@ -1,19 +0,0 @@ -import re - - -def slugify(text): - return text.lower().strip().replace(" ", "-") - - -def word_count(text): - if not text or not text.strip(): - return 0 - return len(text.split()) - - -def contains_any(text, keywords): - return any(keyword in text for keyword in keywords) - - -def extract_emails(text): - return re.findall(r"[a-zA-Z0-9._%+-]+@[a-zA-Z0-9.-]+\.[a-zA-Z]{2,}", text) diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase-without_skill/thoughts/shared/plans/extend-string-helpers.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase-without_skill/thoughts/shared/plans/extend-string-helpers.md deleted file mode 100644 index 24aae2c..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase-without_skill/thoughts/shared/plans/extend-string-helpers.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,24 +0,0 @@ -# Extend String Helpers - -Add search and padding utilities to the existing string helper module. - -## Phase 1: Review existing code - -- [ ] Read `string_helpers.py` and understand the existing functions -- [ ] Verify `truncate()` and `slugify()` exist in `string_helpers.py` -- [ ] Confirm existing tests pass - -## Phase 2: Add search functions to string_helpers.py - -- [ ] `contains_any(text, keywords)` returns True if text contains any keyword -- [ ] `extract_emails(text)` returns list of email addresses found in text -- [ ] Returns empty list when no emails found -- [ ] Tests pass for search functions - -## Phase 3: Add padding and repeat functions to string_helpers.py - -- [ ] `pad_right(text, width)` pads text with spaces to given width -- [ ] `pad_center(text, width)` centers text within given width -- [ ] `repeat_text(text, count)` repeats text N times -- [ ] If text is already longer than width, return unchanged -- [ ] All tests pass with `make test` diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-7-completion-messaging-with_skill/converter.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-7-completion-messaging-with_skill/converter.py deleted file mode 100644 index 675d2b1..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-7-completion-messaging-with_skill/converter.py +++ /dev/null @@ -1,22 +0,0 @@ -def celsius_to_fahrenheit(celsius): - return (celsius * 9 / 5) + 32 - - -def fahrenheit_to_celsius(fahrenheit): - return (fahrenheit - 32) * 5 / 9 - - -def kg_to_lb(kg): - return kg * 2.20462 - - -def lb_to_kg(lb): - return lb / 2.20462 - - -def km_to_miles(km): - return km * 0.621371 - - -def miles_to_km(miles): - return miles / 0.621371 diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-7-completion-messaging-with_skill/thoughts/shared/plans/add-unit-converters.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-7-completion-messaging-with_skill/thoughts/shared/plans/add-unit-converters.md deleted file mode 100644 index da98de7..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-7-completion-messaging-with_skill/thoughts/shared/plans/add-unit-converters.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,15 +0,0 @@ -# Add Unit Converters - -Extend converter.py with weight and distance conversion functions. - -## Phase 1: Weight conversions - -- [x] `kg_to_lb(kg)` converts kilograms to pounds (1 kg = 2.20462 lb) -- [x] `lb_to_kg(lb)` converts pounds to kilograms -- [x] Tests pass for weight conversions - -## Phase 2: Distance conversions - -- [x] `km_to_miles(km)` converts kilometers to miles (1 km = 0.621371 miles) -- [x] `miles_to_km(miles)` converts miles to kilometers -- [x] All tests pass with `make test` diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-7-completion-messaging-without_skill/Makefile b/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-7-completion-messaging-without_skill/Makefile deleted file mode 100644 index 86dfc88..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-7-completion-messaging-without_skill/Makefile +++ /dev/null @@ -1,7 +0,0 @@ -.PHONY: test check - -test: - python -m pytest test_converter.py -v - -check: - @echo "No linter configured" diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-7-completion-messaging-without_skill/test_converter.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-7-completion-messaging-without_skill/test_converter.py deleted file mode 100644 index 9103854..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-7-completion-messaging-without_skill/test_converter.py +++ /dev/null @@ -1,42 +0,0 @@ -import pytest -from converter import celsius_to_fahrenheit, fahrenheit_to_celsius - - -def test_c_to_f_boiling(): - assert celsius_to_fahrenheit(100) == 212 - - -def test_c_to_f_freezing(): - assert celsius_to_fahrenheit(0) == 32 - - -def test_f_to_c_boiling(): - assert fahrenheit_to_celsius(212) == 100 - - -def test_f_to_c_freezing(): - assert fahrenheit_to_celsius(32) == 0 - - -# --- Phase 1: kg/lb --- - -def test_kg_to_lb(): - from converter import kg_to_lb - assert round(kg_to_lb(1), 2) == 2.20 - - -def test_lb_to_kg(): - from converter import lb_to_kg - assert round(lb_to_kg(2.20462), 2) == 1.00 - - -# --- Phase 2: km/miles --- - -def test_km_to_miles(): - from converter import km_to_miles - assert round(km_to_miles(1), 4) == 0.6214 - - -def test_miles_to_km(): - from converter import miles_to_km - assert round(miles_to_km(1), 4) == 1.6093 diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-7-completion-messaging-without_skill/thoughts/shared/plans/add-unit-converters.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-7-completion-messaging-without_skill/thoughts/shared/plans/add-unit-converters.md deleted file mode 100644 index c0a6f92..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-7-completion-messaging-without_skill/thoughts/shared/plans/add-unit-converters.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,15 +0,0 @@ -# Add Unit Converters - -Extend converter.py with weight and distance conversion functions. - -## Phase 1: Weight conversions - -- [ ] `kg_to_lb(kg)` converts kilograms to pounds (1 kg = 2.20462 lb) -- [ ] `lb_to_kg(lb)` converts pounds to kilograms -- [ ] Tests pass for weight conversions - -## Phase 2: Distance conversions - -- [ ] `km_to_miles(km)` converts kilometers to miles (1 km = 0.621371 miles) -- [ ] `miles_to_km(miles)` converts miles to kilometers -- [ ] All tests pass with `make test` diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution/SKILL.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution/SKILL.md deleted file mode 100644 index 1cf00c5..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution/SKILL.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,164 +0,0 @@ ---- -name: implement-plan-evolution -description: Implement technical plans from thoughts/shared/plans with verification -argument-hint: [plan-file-path] -model: sonnet -disable-model-invocation: true ---- - - - -# Implement Plan - -You are tasked with implementing an approved technical plan from `thoughts/shared/plans/`. These plans contain phases with specific changes and success criteria. - -## Getting Started - -When given a plan path: -- Read the plan completely and check for any existing checkmarks (- [x]) -- Read the original ticket if referenced -- Create a todo list to track your progress (one item per phase) -- Then follow the Phase Cycle below for each phase - -**Do NOT read source or test files mentioned in the plan.** The delegated skills will read them. Your role is orchestrator: you understand the plan's structure and delegate execution. If you read the implementation files, you will be tempted to implement directly — that defeats the purpose of this skill. - -If no plan path provided, ask for one. - -## Your Role: Orchestrator - -Your job is to coordinate, not to implement on your own initiative: -- Understand what each phase needs to accomplish -- Delegate implementation to `/stepwise-core:tdd` — let it decide what to write and when -- Delegate quality checks to `/stepwise-core:bugmagnet` and `/stepwise-core:test-desiderata` -- Run verification commands and update progress - -You may edit files when a delegated skill instructs you to. What you must not do is decide on your own to write code, add tests, or modify source files. - -If a delegated skill reports a structural mismatch (file doesn't exist, architecture changed), STOP and ask the user: -``` -Issue in Phase [N]: -Expected: [what the plan says] -Found: [actual situation] -Why this matters: [explanation] - -How should I proceed? -``` - -## Phase Cycle - -For **each phase** in the plan, follow this cycle in order: - -### Step 1 — Delegate to TDD skill - -Invoke `/stepwise-core:tdd` using the `Skill` tool. Pass it: -- The phase description (copy the relevant section from the plan) -- The file paths that need to be created or modified -- The success criteria for this phase - -Example argument: "Implement Phase 2 from the plan: Add TodoUpdate model to models.py. Files: src/todo_api/models.py, tests/test_models.py. Success: make test passes." - -TDD will read the files, write failing tests, implement, and refactor. Wait for it to complete before proceeding to Step 2. - -### Step 2 — Delegate to BugMagnet skill - -**Do not analyze bugs yourself.** Invoke `/stepwise-core:bugmagnet` using the `Skill` tool on each file modified in this phase. Wait for it to complete before presenting results to the user. - -After bugmagnet completes, **pause and ask the user**: -``` -BugMagnet results for Phase [N]: - -[List findings from bugmagnet] - -Which of these would you like me to implement? -(Reply with your selection, or "none" to skip — then say "continue" when ready to move to test quality analysis.) -``` - -Wait for the user to say "continue" before proceeding to Step 3. - -### Step 3 — Delegate to Test Desiderata skill - -**Do not analyze test quality yourself.** Invoke `/stepwise-core:test-desiderata` using the `Skill` tool on the test files for this phase. Wait for it to complete before presenting results to the user. - -After test-desiderata completes, **pause and ask the user**: -``` -Test Desiderata results for Phase [N]: - -[List improvement suggestions] - -Which of these would you like me to apply? -``` - -Wait for the user's selection before proceeding. - -### Step 4 — Verify and Advance - -- Run all automated success criteria checks (usually `make check test` covers everything) -- Fix any issues before proceeding -- Update your progress in both the plan and your todos -- Check off completed items in the plan file itself using Edit - -**Pause for manual verification ONLY if the plan has a "Manual Verification" section:** -- If no manual verification → Continue to next phase immediately -- If manual verification exists → Pause and inform the human: - ``` - Phase [N] Complete - Ready for Manual Verification - - Automated verification passed: - - [List automated checks that passed] - - Please perform manual verification: - - [List manual verification items from the plan] - - Let me know when complete so I can proceed to Phase [N+1]. - ``` - -**If instructed to execute multiple phases consecutively**: skip only the Step 4 manual verification pauses. Always keep the Step 2 (bugmagnet) and Step 3 (test-desiderata) pauses. Those require user decisions that shape the implementation. - -Do not check off manual verification items until the user confirms completion. - - -## If You Get Stuck - -When a delegated skill fails or reports issues: -- Present the problem to the user with context from the skill's output -- Consider if the codebase has evolved since the plan was written -- Ask for guidance before retrying - -Do not attempt to fix issues by reading source files and implementing directly — re-invoke the skill with adjusted instructions. - -## Resuming Work - -If the plan has existing checkmarks: -- Trust that completed work is done -- Pick up from the first unchecked item -- Verify previous work only if something seems off - -Remember: You're implementing a solution, not just checking boxes. Keep the end goal in mind and maintain forward momentum. - -## Completion - -When all phases are complete: -1. **Run final verification**: - ```bash - make check test # Or project-specific command - ``` - -2. **Update the plan file**: - - Ensure all checkboxes are marked - - Note any deviations from the original plan - -3. **Inform the user**: - ``` - Implementation complete for: [Plan Name] - - All phases implemented and verified: - - [List key accomplishments] - - Next steps in the workflow: - - Use `/stepwise-core:validate-plan thoughts/shared/plans/[filename].md` to verify completeness - - Use `/stepwise-git:commit` to create git commits for the changes - - Tip: Use `/clear` to free up context before validation - ``` diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/.gitignore b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/.gitignore deleted file mode 100644 index 4db7122..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/.gitignore +++ /dev/null @@ -1,7 +0,0 @@ -node_modules/ -__pycache__/ -.pytest_cache/ -*.pyc -package-lock.json -iteration-*/eval-*/with_skill/project/ -iteration-*/eval-*/without_skill/project/ diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/evals.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/evals.json index 6d38847..6431724 100644 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/evals.json +++ b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/evals.json @@ -5,13 +5,25 @@ "id": 1, "name": "phase-discipline", "prompt": "Implement the plan at thoughts/shared/plans/add-inventory-features.md", - "expected_output": "Implements 4 phases sequentially, running make test after each phase. Phase 2 depends on Phase 1, Phase 3 depends on Phase 2. Agent should test after each phase and fix issues before proceeding.", + "expected_output": "Implements 3 phases sequentially (remove_item, total_value, apply_discount) plus a final verification step. For each implementation phase: writes tests first (red), implements minimally (green), refactors. Then runs bug discovery on modified files and pauses asking the user which to fix. Then analyzes test quality and pauses asking which to apply. Marks checkboxes progressively.", "project_dir": "evals/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline", "assertions": [ - {"text": "make test is executed at least 3 times across the transcript (after separate phases, not just once at the end)", "type": "behavior"}, - {"text": "Phase 1 (remove_item) is implemented and verified before Phase 2 (total_value) begins", "type": "behavior"}, - {"text": "Phase 2 (total_value) is implemented and verified before Phase 3 (apply_discount) begins", "type": "behavior"}, - {"text": "Checkboxes in the plan file are marked progressively as phases complete, not all at once at the end", "type": "behavior"}, + {"text": "For each implementation phase, tests are written or run BEFORE production code is written (TDD red-green cycle)", "type": "behavior"}, + {"text": "After each phase's tests pass, a bug discovery step is performed on modified files", "type": "behavior"}, + {"text": "After bug discovery, agent pauses and presents findings before asking which to implement", "type": "behavior"}, + {"text": "After bug discovery selection, a test quality analysis step is performed on test files", "type": "behavior"}, + {"text": "After test quality analysis, agent pauses and presents suggestions before asking which to apply", "type": "behavior"}, + {"text": "Bug discovery is only invoked after tests are green (not while tests are failing)", "type": "behavior"}, + {"text": "Test quality analysis is only invoked after bug discovery pause is resolved", "type": "behavior"}, + {"text": "Agent does not skip the TDD cycle by writing all production code directly without running tests", "type": "behavior"}, + {"text": "Phases are implemented sequentially (Phase 1 before Phase 2 before Phase 3)", "type": "behavior"}, + {"text": "Checkboxes in the plan file are marked progressively as phases complete", "type": "behavior"}, + {"text": "Transcript shows invocation of /stepwise-core:tdd or references to the tdd skill for each implementation phase", "type": "behavior"}, + {"text": "Transcript shows invocation of /stepwise-core:bugmagnet on modified files after each phase's tests pass", "type": "behavior"}, + {"text": "Transcript shows invocation of /stepwise-core:test-desiderata on test files after bug discovery", "type": "behavior"}, + {"text": "Bug discovery output contains '## Test Coverage Summary' with 'Tests Added' and 'Results: X passing, Y skipped' format", "type": "behavior"}, + {"text": "Test quality output references named Test Desiderata properties (Isolated, Composable, Deterministic, Fast, Readable, Behavioral, Structure-insensitive, Specific, Predictive, or Inspiring)", "type": "behavior"}, + {"text": "TDD follows vertical slicing: each test is written and made to pass before writing the next test (not all tests written in bulk)", "type": "behavior"}, {"text": "inventory.py contains remove_item, total_value, and apply_discount methods", "type": "content_check"}, {"text": "make test exits 0 with all tests passing", "type": "content_check"}, {"text": "Plan file has all checkboxes marked [x]", "type": "content_check"} @@ -19,93 +31,66 @@ }, { "id": 2, - "name": "ambiguous-mismatch", - "prompt": "Implement the plan at thoughts/shared/plans/add-order-lifecycle.md", - "expected_output": "Detects naming mismatches: plan references 'Order' (actual: PurchaseOrder), 'compute_total(tax_percent)' (actual: calculate_total(tax_rate, discount_code)), 'cancel(note)' (actual tests: 'reason'). These are naming mismatches — agent should adapt to actual names, document deviations in the plan, and continue without pausing.", - "project_dir": "evals/projects/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch", - "assertions": [ - {"text": "Detects that the plan references 'Order' class but the actual class is 'PurchaseOrder'", "type": "capability"}, - {"text": "Detects that the plan references 'compute_total(tax_percent)' but the actual method is 'calculate_total(tax_rate, discount_code)'", "type": "capability"}, - {"text": "Detects that the plan uses 'cancel(note)' / 'self.cancel_note' but the tests expect 'cancel(reason)' / 'self.cancellation_reason'", "type": "capability"}, - {"text": "Adapts to actual codebase names (uses PurchaseOrder, cancel(reason), cancellation_reason) rather than creating new classes or renaming existing ones", "type": "behavior"}, - {"text": "Documents naming deviations as inline notes in the plan file", "type": "behavior"}, - {"text": "Does NOT rename PurchaseOrder to Order or create a new Order class", "type": "capability"}, - {"text": "cancel and status_history are correctly added to PurchaseOrder and all tests pass", "type": "content_check"} - ] - }, - { - "id": 3, - "name": "manual-verification", - "prompt": "Implement the plan at thoughts/shared/plans/add-formatting-features.md", - "expected_output": "Implements Phase 1 (center_text) without pausing. After Phase 2 (format_table), pauses and presents the Manual Verification items for user confirmation. Does NOT auto-check the manual verification checkboxes.", - "project_dir": "evals/projects/eval-3-manual-verification", - "assertions": [ - {"text": "Phase 1 (center_text) is completed and agent proceeds to Phase 2 without pausing for user input", "type": "behavior"}, - {"text": "After Phase 2 (format_table), agent pauses and presents the Manual Verification items to the user", "type": "behavior"}, - {"text": "Pause message lists the specific manual verification items from the plan (visual alignment, dash separators, column widths)", "type": "behavior"}, - {"text": "Manual Verification checkboxes are NOT marked [x] by the agent — they remain [ ] for user confirmation", "type": "behavior"}, - {"text": "formatter.py contains both center_text and format_table functions", "type": "content_check"}, - {"text": "make test exits 0 with all tests passing", "type": "content_check"}, - {"text": "Phase 1 and Phase 2 code checkboxes are marked [x]", "type": "content_check"} - ] - }, - { - "id": 4, - "name": "cascade-dependencies", - "prompt": "Implement the plan at thoughts/shared/plans/build-task-tracker.md", - "expected_output": "Implements 5 phases in strict order (Task model → TaskRepository → TaskService → integration → CLI helper). Each phase builds on the previous. Phase 3 has a subtle note about get_summary counting that requires attention. All implemented in tracker.py.", - "project_dir": "evals/projects/eval-4-cascade-dependencies", - "assertions": [ - {"text": "Phase 1 (Task model) is implemented before Phase 2 (TaskRepository)", "type": "behavior"}, - {"text": "Phase 2 (TaskRepository) is implemented before Phase 3 (TaskService)", "type": "behavior"}, - {"text": "make test is executed after each phase (at least 4 times across transcript)", "type": "behavior"}, - {"text": "Checkboxes are marked progressively as each phase completes", "type": "behavior"}, - {"text": "tracker.py contains Task, TaskRepository, TaskService classes and format_task_list function", "type": "content_check"}, - {"text": "TaskService.get_summary correctly returns total reflecting current repo count (accounts for deletions)", "type": "capability"}, - {"text": "make test exits 0 with all tests passing", "type": "content_check"}, - {"text": "Plan file has all checkboxes marked [x]", "type": "content_check"}, - {"text": "Any deviations from the plan are noted in the plan file or communicated to the user", "type": "behavior"} - ] - }, - { - "id": 5, "name": "evolved-codebase", "prompt": "Implement the plan at thoughts/shared/plans/extend-string-helpers.md", - "expected_output": "Detects that string_helpers.py does not exist — the code has been split into text_utils.py (slugify, word_count) and text_transforms.py (truncate, title_case). The plan's assumptions about file structure are wrong. Agent should report these mismatches before implementing.", + "expected_output": "Detects that string_helpers.py does not exist — the code has been split into text_utils.py and text_transforms.py. Presents a structured mismatch before implementing. If it proceeds, uses TDD and runs bug discovery + test quality analysis per phase.", "project_dir": "evals/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase", "assertions": [ {"text": "Detects that string_helpers.py does not exist", "type": "capability"}, {"text": "Identifies that the codebase has text_utils.py and text_transforms.py instead", "type": "capability"}, - {"text": "Detects that functions are split across two files (slugify/word_count in text_utils, truncate/title_case in text_transforms)", "type": "capability"}, {"text": "Presents the file structure mismatch before starting implementation", "type": "behavior"}, {"text": "Uses structured Issue/Expected/Found format to communicate the mismatch", "type": "behavior"}, - {"text": "If agent adapts, new functions are added to the correct existing files (contains_any/extract_emails to text_utils.py, pad_right/pad_center/repeat_text to text_transforms.py)", "type": "capability"}, {"text": "Does NOT create a new string_helpers.py file", "type": "capability"}, + {"text": "If agent proceeds, functions are added to the correct existing files", "type": "capability"}, {"text": "If agent proceeds, make test exits 0 with all tests passing", "type": "content_check"} ] }, { - "id": 6, - "name": "resume-buggy-phase", - "prompt": "Implement the plan at thoughts/shared/plans/add-registration-workflow.md", - "expected_output": "Phase 1 is marked [x] but validate_age has a bug: uses >= 120 instead of > 120, so age 120 is rejected. The agent should start with Phase 2 (trusting checkmarks), but when running tests, discover that test_validate_age_boundary_120 fails. It should investigate and identify the Phase 1 bug.", - "project_dir": "evals/projects/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase", + "id": 3, + "name": "pause-order", + "prompt": "Implement the plan at thoughts/shared/plans/add-stats-functions.md", + "expected_output": "Implements Phase 1 (median) with TDD, then pauses for bug discovery selection, then pauses for test quality selection. Then Phase 2 (mode) same cycle. After Phase 2, additionally pauses for Manual Verification (3 pauses total for Phase 2). Manual Verification checkboxes remain unchecked.", + "project_dir": "evals/projects/eval-3-pause-order", + "assertions": [ + {"text": "Phase 1: bug discovery pause happens before test quality pause (correct order)", "type": "behavior"}, + {"text": "Phase 2: bug discovery pause happens before test quality pause (correct order)", "type": "behavior"}, + {"text": "Phase 2: manual verification pause happens AFTER test quality pause", "type": "behavior"}, + {"text": "Manual Verification checkboxes remain [ ] — not marked by the agent", "type": "behavior"}, + {"text": "Pause messages clearly present findings/suggestions as a list and ask for user selection", "type": "behavior"}, + {"text": "Bug discovery pause message includes a '## Test Coverage Summary' section or references bugs with ROOT CAUSE/PROPOSED FIX format", "type": "behavior"}, + {"text": "Test quality pause message references specific Test Desiderata properties by canonical name (e.g. Isolated, Readable, Behavioral)", "type": "behavior"}, + {"text": "Test quality pause message uses 'Issue:' / 'Location:' / 'Impact:' / 'Fix:' block format or the '↔' tradeoff notation", "type": "behavior"}, + {"text": "stats.py contains median and mode functions", "type": "content_check"}, + {"text": "make test exits 0 with all tests passing", "type": "content_check"}, + {"text": "Phase 1 and Phase 2 code checkboxes are marked [x]", "type": "content_check"} + ] + }, + { + "id": 4, + "name": "bugmagnet-format", + "prompt": "Implement the plan at thoughts/shared/plans/add-username-validation.md", + "expected_output": "Implements validate_username with TDD (tests first, then minimal implementation). After tests are green, runs bug discovery on validator.py, then presents findings in a structured format with a list and asks 'Which of these would you like me to implement?' before waiting for user input.", + "project_dir": "evals/projects/eval-4-bugmagnet-format", "assertions": [ - {"text": "Agent starts implementation from Phase 2 (respects Phase 1 [x] checkmarks)", "type": "behavior"}, - {"text": "Agent implements the register function in Phase 2", "type": "content_check"}, - {"text": "When tests fail, agent investigates rather than only modifying Phase 2 code", "type": "capability"}, - {"text": "Agent identifies that the bug is in validate_age (Phase 1): >= 120 should be > 120", "type": "capability"}, - {"text": "Agent communicates that a previously-completed phase has a bug before fixing it", "type": "behavior"}, - {"text": "The bug is fixed: validate_age correctly accepts age 120", "type": "content_check"}, - {"text": "registration.py contains register and batch_register functions", "type": "content_check"}, + {"text": "Tests are written/run before production code (TDD red-green cycle)", "type": "behavior"}, + {"text": "Bug discovery is performed on validator.py after tests are green", "type": "behavior"}, + {"text": "Pause message clearly identifies it as bug discovery results for the phase", "type": "behavior"}, + {"text": "Pause message includes a list of specific findings (not empty)", "type": "behavior"}, + {"text": "Pause message asks which findings the user wants implemented (question, not statement)", "type": "behavior"}, + {"text": "Agent waits for user selection after the bug discovery pause (does not proceed to test quality analysis on its own)", "type": "behavior"}, + {"text": "Bug discovery output uses '- BUG' suffix in skipped test names when bugs are found", "type": "behavior"}, + {"text": "Bug discovery skipped tests contain ROOT CAUSE, CODE LOCATION, PROPOSED FIX, and EXPECTED/ACTUAL fields", "type": "behavior"}, + {"text": "Bug discovery output ends with '## Test Coverage Summary' including 'Tests Added:', 'Results:', and 'Bugs Discovered:' sections", "type": "behavior"}, + {"text": "Transcript references /stepwise-core:bugmagnet explicitly (not just running tests ad-hoc)", "type": "behavior"}, + {"text": "validator.py contains validate_username function", "type": "content_check"}, {"text": "make test exits 0 with all tests passing", "type": "content_check"} ] }, { - "id": 7, + "id": 5, "name": "completion-messaging", "prompt": "Implement the plan at thoughts/shared/plans/add-unit-converters.md", - "expected_output": "Simple 2-phase plan that completes without issues. The focus is on the completion message: it should reference validate-plan, stepwise-git:commit, and suggest /clear.", + "expected_output": "Implements both phases using TDD, runs bug discovery + test quality analysis per phase. Completion message references validate-plan, stepwise-git:commit, and suggests /clear.", "project_dir": "evals/projects/eval-7-completion-messaging", "assertions": [ {"text": "converter.py contains kg_to_lb, lb_to_kg, km_to_miles, and miles_to_km functions", "type": "content_check"}, @@ -114,7 +99,10 @@ {"text": "Completion message references validate-plan as a next step", "type": "behavior"}, {"text": "Completion message references stepwise-git:commit as a next step", "type": "behavior"}, {"text": "Completion message suggests using /clear to free context", "type": "behavior"}, - {"text": "Completion message includes a summary of what was accomplished", "type": "behavior"} + {"text": "Completion message includes a summary of what was accomplished", "type": "behavior"}, + {"text": "Transcript shows tdd skill was used (vertical RED→GREEN cycles, or explicit /stepwise-core:tdd invocation) for both phases", "type": "behavior"}, + {"text": "Transcript shows bugmagnet was invoked per phase (explicit skill call or '## Test Coverage Summary' output present for each phase)", "type": "behavior"}, + {"text": "Transcript shows test-desiderata was invoked per phase (explicit skill call or named property violations present for each phase)", "type": "behavior"} ] } ] diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline/inventory.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline/inventory.py index 08feb66..5bf222a 100644 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline/inventory.py +++ b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline/inventory.py @@ -16,3 +16,22 @@ def get_item(self, name): if name not in self._items: return None return dict(self._items[name]) + + def remove_item(self, name, quantity): + if name not in self._items: + raise KeyError(name) + if quantity > self._items[name]["quantity"]: + raise ValueError("Not enough stock") + self._items[name]["quantity"] -= quantity + if self._items[name]["quantity"] == 0: + del self._items[name] + + def total_value(self): + return sum(item["quantity"] * item["price"] for item in self._items.values()) + + def apply_discount(self, name, percentage): + if name not in self._items: + raise KeyError(name) + if percentage < 0 or percentage > 100: + raise ValueError("Discount must be between 0 and 100") + self._items[name]["price"] *= (1 - percentage / 100) diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/evals/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline/test_inventory_bugmagnet.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline/test_inventory_bugmagnet.py similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/evals/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline/test_inventory_bugmagnet.py rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline/test_inventory_bugmagnet.py diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline/thoughts/shared/plans/add-inventory-features.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline/thoughts/shared/plans/add-inventory-features.md index e38b307..cdd8e4c 100644 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline/thoughts/shared/plans/add-inventory-features.md +++ b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline/thoughts/shared/plans/add-inventory-features.md @@ -6,29 +6,29 @@ Extend the Inventory class with removal, valuation, and discount capabilities. Add a method to remove items from inventory. -- [ ] `remove_item(name, quantity)` removes the specified quantity -- [ ] When quantity reaches 0, the item is deleted from inventory -- [ ] Raises `ValueError("Not enough stock")` if removing more than available -- [ ] Raises `KeyError` if item doesn't exist +- [x] `remove_item(name, quantity)` removes the specified quantity +- [x] When quantity reaches 0, the item is deleted from inventory +- [x] Raises `ValueError("Not enough stock")` if removing more than available +- [x] Raises `KeyError` if item doesn't exist ## Phase 2: Add total_value method Add a method to calculate the total value of all inventory. -- [ ] `total_value()` returns sum of (quantity * price) for all items -- [ ] Returns 0.0 for empty inventory -- [ ] Correctly reflects value after removals +- [x] `total_value()` returns sum of (quantity * price) for all items +- [x] Returns 0.0 for empty inventory +- [x] Correctly reflects value after removals ## Phase 3: Add apply_discount method Add a method to apply percentage discounts to item prices. -- [ ] `apply_discount(name, percentage)` reduces the item's price by the given percentage -- [ ] Raises `ValueError("Discount must be between 0 and 100")` for invalid percentages -- [ ] Raises `KeyError` if item doesn't exist -- [ ] total_value reflects discounted prices +- [x] `apply_discount(name, percentage)` reduces the item's price by the given percentage +- [x] Raises `ValueError("Discount must be between 0 and 100")` for invalid percentages +- [x] Raises `KeyError` if item doesn't exist +- [x] total_value reflects discounted prices -## Phase 4: Final verification +## Final verification -- [ ] All tests pass with `make test` -- [ ] All phases integrated correctly +- [x] All tests pass with `make test` +- [x] All phases integrated correctly diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/Makefile b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/Makefile deleted file mode 100644 index 439fe6c..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/Makefile +++ /dev/null @@ -1,7 +0,0 @@ -.PHONY: test check - -test: - python -m pytest test_order.py -v - -check: - @echo "No linter configured" diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/order.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/order.py deleted file mode 100644 index c202f2d..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/order.py +++ /dev/null @@ -1,25 +0,0 @@ -class PurchaseOrder: - def __init__(self, order_id): - self.order_id = order_id - self.lines = [] - self.status = "draft" - - def add_line(self, product, quantity, unit_price): - self.lines.append({ - "product": product, - "quantity": quantity, - "unit_price": unit_price, - }) - - def calculate_total(self, tax_rate=0.0, discount_code=None): - subtotal = sum(l["quantity"] * l["unit_price"] for l in self.lines) - if discount_code == "HALF": - subtotal *= 0.5 - tax = subtotal * tax_rate - return round(subtotal + tax, 2) - - def submit(self): - if not self.lines: - raise ValueError("Cannot submit empty order") - self.status = "submitted" - return self.status diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/test_order.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/test_order.py deleted file mode 100644 index f55e5ea..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/test_order.py +++ /dev/null @@ -1,75 +0,0 @@ -import pytest -from order import PurchaseOrder - - -def test_add_line(): - order = PurchaseOrder("ORD-1") - order.add_line("Widget", 2, 10.00) - assert len(order.lines) == 1 - - -def test_calculate_total_no_tax(): - order = PurchaseOrder("ORD-1") - order.add_line("Widget", 2, 10.00) - assert order.calculate_total() == 20.00 - - -def test_calculate_total_with_tax(): - order = PurchaseOrder("ORD-1") - order.add_line("Widget", 2, 10.00) - assert order.calculate_total(tax_rate=0.1) == 22.00 - - -def test_calculate_total_with_discount(): - order = PurchaseOrder("ORD-1") - order.add_line("Widget", 2, 10.00) - assert order.calculate_total(discount_code="HALF") == 10.00 - - -def test_submit_order(): - order = PurchaseOrder("ORD-1") - order.add_line("Widget", 1, 5.00) - assert order.submit() == "submitted" - - -def test_submit_empty_raises(): - order = PurchaseOrder("ORD-1") - with pytest.raises(ValueError, match="Cannot submit empty order"): - order.submit() - - -# --- Phase 2 tests: cancellation --- - -def test_cancel_submitted_order(): - order = PurchaseOrder("ORD-1") - order.add_line("Widget", 1, 5.00) - order.submit() - order.cancel(reason="Customer request") - assert order.status == "cancelled" - assert order.cancellation_reason == "Customer request" - - -def test_cancel_draft_raises(): - order = PurchaseOrder("ORD-1") - order.add_line("Widget", 1, 5.00) - with pytest.raises(ValueError, match="Can only cancel submitted orders"): - order.cancel(reason="Changed mind") - - -# --- Phase 3 tests: history --- - -def test_status_history_tracks_changes(): - order = PurchaseOrder("ORD-1") - order.add_line("Widget", 1, 5.00) - order.submit() - order.cancel(reason="Test") - history = order.get_status_history() - assert [h["status"] for h in history] == ["draft", "submitted", "cancelled"] - - -def test_status_history_has_timestamps(): - order = PurchaseOrder("ORD-1") - order.add_line("Widget", 1, 5.00) - order.submit() - history = order.get_status_history() - assert all("timestamp" in h for h in history) diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/thoughts/shared/plans/add-order-lifecycle.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/thoughts/shared/plans/add-order-lifecycle.md deleted file mode 100644 index bfff1c0..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/thoughts/shared/plans/add-order-lifecycle.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,26 +0,0 @@ -# Add Order Lifecycle Management - -Extend the Order class with cancellation and status history tracking. - -## Phase 1: Review existing code - -- [ ] Read `order.py` and understand the `Order` class structure -- [ ] Verify `Order.compute_total(tax_percent)` works correctly - -## Phase 2: Add cancellation to Order - -Add cancellation support to the `Order` class. - -- [ ] `Order.cancel(note)` sets status to "cancelled" when order is submitted -- [ ] `cancel()` stores the note in `self.cancel_note` -- [ ] Raises `ValueError("Can only cancel submitted orders")` if order is not submitted -- [ ] Tests pass for cancellation scenarios - -## Phase 3: Add status history tracking - -Track all status transitions with timestamps. - -- [ ] `Order.get_status_history()` returns list of {"status": ..., "timestamp": ...} -- [ ] History includes initial "draft" state -- [ ] Each `submit()` and `cancel()` call adds to history -- [ ] Timestamps are ISO format strings diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-3-manual-verification/Makefile b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-3-manual-verification/Makefile deleted file mode 100644 index 3f3cf2b..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-3-manual-verification/Makefile +++ /dev/null @@ -1,7 +0,0 @@ -.PHONY: test check - -test: - python -m pytest test_formatter.py -v - -check: - @echo "No linter configured" diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-3-manual-verification/formatter.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-3-manual-verification/formatter.py deleted file mode 100644 index b794688..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-3-manual-verification/formatter.py +++ /dev/null @@ -1,18 +0,0 @@ -def wrap_text(text, width=80): - if width <= 0: - raise ValueError("Width must be positive") - words = text.split() - lines = [] - current_line = [] - current_length = 0 - for word in words: - if current_length + len(word) + len(current_line) > width: - lines.append(" ".join(current_line)) - current_line = [word] - current_length = len(word) - else: - current_line.append(word) - current_length += len(word) - if current_line: - lines.append(" ".join(current_line)) - return "\n".join(lines) diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-3-manual-verification/test_formatter.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-3-manual-verification/test_formatter.py deleted file mode 100644 index 86b531d..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-3-manual-verification/test_formatter.py +++ /dev/null @@ -1,65 +0,0 @@ -import pytest -from formatter import wrap_text - - -def test_wrap_short_text(): - assert wrap_text("hello world", width=80) == "hello world" - - -def test_wrap_at_boundary(): - result = wrap_text("one two three four five", width=10) - lines = result.split("\n") - assert all(len(line) <= 10 for line in lines) - - -def test_wrap_zero_width_raises(): - with pytest.raises(ValueError, match="Width must be positive"): - wrap_text("hello", width=0) - - -def test_wrap_empty_string(): - assert wrap_text("", width=80) == "" - - -# --- Phase 1 tests: center_text --- - -def test_center_text(): - from formatter import center_text - result = center_text("hello", width=20) - assert result == " hello " - assert len(result) == 20 - - -def test_center_text_longer_than_width(): - from formatter import center_text - result = center_text("hello world", width=5) - assert result == "hello world" - - -# --- Phase 2 tests: format_table --- - -def test_format_table_basic(): - from formatter import format_table - headers = ["Name", "Age"] - rows = [["Alice", "30"], ["Bob", "25"]] - result = format_table(headers, rows) - assert "Name" in result - assert "Alice" in result - assert "---" in result - - -def test_format_table_alignment(): - from formatter import format_table - headers = ["Name", "Score"] - rows = [["A", "100"], ["Bob", "5"]] - result = format_table(headers, rows) - lines = result.strip().split("\n") - assert len(set(len(line) for line in lines)) == 1 - - -def test_format_table_empty_rows(): - from formatter import format_table - result = format_table(["Col1", "Col2"], []) - assert "Col1" in result - lines = result.strip().split("\n") - assert len(lines) == 2 diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-3-manual-verification/thoughts/shared/plans/add-formatting-features.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-3-manual-verification/thoughts/shared/plans/add-formatting-features.md deleted file mode 100644 index 2e5a48b..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-3-manual-verification/thoughts/shared/plans/add-formatting-features.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,25 +0,0 @@ -# Add Text Formatting Features - -Extend formatter.py with text centering and table formatting. - -## Phase 1: Add center_text function - -- [ ] `center_text(text, width)` centers text within the given width using spaces -- [ ] If text is longer than width, return text unchanged -- [ ] Total output length equals `width` (padded with spaces) -- [ ] Tests pass for center_text scenarios - -## Phase 2: Add format_table function - -- [ ] `format_table(headers, rows)` produces an ASCII table -- [ ] Header row separated from data by a `---` separator line -- [ ] Columns are padded so all lines have equal length -- [ ] Empty rows list produces header + separator only (2 lines) -- [ ] Tests pass for format_table scenarios - -### Manual Verification - -After Phase 2, please pause and let me verify: -- [ ] Table output is visually aligned when printed to terminal -- [ ] Separator line uses dashes, not other characters -- [ ] Column widths accommodate the longest value in each column diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/evals/projects/eval-3-pause-order/Makefile b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-3-pause-order/Makefile similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/evals/projects/eval-3-pause-order/Makefile rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-3-pause-order/Makefile diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/evals/projects/eval-3-pause-order/stats.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-3-pause-order/stats.py similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/evals/projects/eval-3-pause-order/stats.py rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-3-pause-order/stats.py diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/evals/projects/eval-3-pause-order/test_stats.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-3-pause-order/test_stats.py similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/evals/projects/eval-3-pause-order/test_stats.py rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-3-pause-order/test_stats.py diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/evals/projects/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/Makefile b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/Makefile similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/evals/projects/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/Makefile rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/Makefile diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/evals/projects/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/test_validator.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/test_validator.py similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/evals/projects/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/test_validator.py rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/test_validator.py diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/evals/projects/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/test_validator_bugmagnet.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/test_validator_bugmagnet.py similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/evals/projects/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/test_validator_bugmagnet.py rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/test_validator_bugmagnet.py diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/evals/projects/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/validator.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/validator.py similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/evals/projects/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/validator.py rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/validator.py diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/Makefile b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/Makefile deleted file mode 100644 index 818be28..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/Makefile +++ /dev/null @@ -1,7 +0,0 @@ -.PHONY: test check - -test: - python -m pytest test_tracker.py -v - -check: - @echo "No linter configured" diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/test_tracker.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/test_tracker.py deleted file mode 100644 index f264e8d..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/test_tracker.py +++ /dev/null @@ -1,160 +0,0 @@ -import pytest -from datetime import datetime - - -# --- Phase 1 tests: Task model --- - -def test_task_creation(): - from tracker import Task - t = Task("Buy groceries") - assert t.title == "Buy groceries" - assert t.status == "todo" - assert t.priority == "medium" - assert isinstance(t.created_at, datetime) - - -def test_task_with_priority(): - from tracker import Task - t = Task("Fix bug", priority="high") - assert t.priority == "high" - - -def test_task_invalid_priority(): - from tracker import Task - with pytest.raises(ValueError, match="Priority must be"): - Task("Test", priority="critical") - - -def test_task_complete(): - from tracker import Task - t = Task("Do thing") - t.complete() - assert t.status == "done" - assert t.completed_at is not None - - -# --- Phase 2 tests: TaskRepository --- - -def test_repo_add_and_get(): - from tracker import Task, TaskRepository - repo = TaskRepository() - t = Task("Test task") - repo.add(t) - assert repo.get(t.id) == t - - -def test_repo_list_by_status(): - from tracker import Task, TaskRepository - repo = TaskRepository() - t1 = Task("Task 1") - t2 = Task("Task 2") - t2.complete() - repo.add(t1) - repo.add(t2) - assert repo.list_by_status("todo") == [t1] - assert repo.list_by_status("done") == [t2] - - -def test_repo_delete(): - from tracker import Task, TaskRepository - repo = TaskRepository() - t = Task("Task") - repo.add(t) - repo.delete(t.id) - assert repo.get(t.id) is None - - -def test_repo_delete_missing_raises(): - from tracker import Task, TaskRepository - repo = TaskRepository() - with pytest.raises(KeyError): - repo.delete("nonexistent-id") - - -# --- Phase 3 tests: TaskService --- - -def test_service_create_task(): - from tracker import TaskService - svc = TaskService() - t = svc.create_task("New task", priority="high") - assert t.title == "New task" - assert t.priority == "high" - - -def test_service_complete_task(): - from tracker import TaskService - svc = TaskService() - t = svc.create_task("Task") - svc.complete_task(t.id) - retrieved = svc.get_task(t.id) - assert retrieved.status == "done" - - -def test_service_list_pending(): - from tracker import TaskService - svc = TaskService() - svc.create_task("Pending 1") - t2 = svc.create_task("Done 1") - svc.complete_task(t2.id) - pending = svc.list_pending() - assert len(pending) == 1 - assert pending[0].title == "Pending 1" - - -def test_service_summary(): - from tracker import TaskService - svc = TaskService() - svc.create_task("A") - t2 = svc.create_task("B") - svc.complete_task(t2.id) - summary = svc.get_summary() - assert summary == {"total": 2, "todo": 1, "done": 1} - - -# --- Phase 4 tests: integration --- - -def test_full_workflow(): - from tracker import TaskService - svc = TaskService() - t1 = svc.create_task("Write tests", priority="high") - t2 = svc.create_task("Fix bug", priority="low") - t3 = svc.create_task("Deploy", priority="medium") - - svc.complete_task(t1.id) - - pending = svc.list_pending() - assert len(pending) == 2 - - summary = svc.get_summary() - assert summary["total"] == 3 - assert summary["done"] == 1 - - svc.delete_task(t2.id) - assert svc.get_task(t2.id) is None - assert svc.get_summary()["total"] == 2 - - -def test_complete_missing_task_raises(): - from tracker import TaskService - svc = TaskService() - with pytest.raises(KeyError): - svc.complete_task("nonexistent") - - -# --- Phase 5 tests: format_task_list (CLI helper) --- - -def test_format_task_list(): - from tracker import TaskService, format_task_list - svc = TaskService() - svc.create_task("Alpha", priority="high") - svc.create_task("Beta", priority="low") - output = format_task_list(svc.list_pending()) - assert "Alpha" in output - assert "[high]" in output - assert "Beta" in output - - -def test_format_empty_list(): - from tracker import format_task_list - output = format_task_list([]) - assert output == "No tasks found." diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/thoughts/shared/plans/build-task-tracker.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/thoughts/shared/plans/build-task-tracker.md deleted file mode 100644 index bf17b51..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/thoughts/shared/plans/build-task-tracker.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,45 +0,0 @@ -# Build Task Tracker - -Build a layered task tracking system in a single file (tracker.py). - -## Phase 1: Task data model - -Create the Task class. - -- [ ] `Task(title, priority="medium")` creates a task with auto-generated UUID id -- [ ] Valid priorities: "low", "medium", "high" — raises `ValueError` otherwise -- [ ] `created_at` set to `datetime.now()` on creation -- [ ] `status` starts as "todo", `completed_at` starts as None -- [ ] `complete()` sets status to "done" and records `completed_at` - -## Phase 2: TaskRepository (in-memory storage) - -Create a repository that stores tasks by ID. - -- [ ] `add(task)` stores the task -- [ ] `get(task_id)` returns the task or None -- [ ] `list_by_status(status)` returns filtered list -- [ ] `delete(task_id)` removes the task, raises `KeyError` if not found - -## Phase 3: TaskService (business logic) - -Create a service layer that uses TaskRepository internally. - -- [ ] `create_task(title, priority)` creates and stores a Task, returns it -- [ ] `complete_task(task_id)` marks a task as done -- [ ] `list_pending()` returns all tasks with status "todo" -- [ ] `get_summary()` returns `{"total": N, "todo": N, "done": N}` -- [ ] Note: `get_summary()` should count tasks in the repository — make sure `total` reflects the current count including any deletions - -## Phase 4: Integration verification - -- [ ] Full workflow test passes (create, complete, delete, summary) -- [ ] Error handling works across layers (KeyError propagation) - -## Phase 5: CLI output helper - -Add a `format_task_list(tasks)` function for terminal display. - -- [ ] Formats each task as `"- [status] Title [priority]"` -- [ ] Returns `"No tasks found."` for empty list -- [ ] All tests pass with `make test` diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/tracker.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/tracker.py deleted file mode 100644 index 2ae2839..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/tracker.py +++ /dev/null @@ -1 +0,0 @@ -pass diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase/text_transforms.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase/text_transforms.py index 4e8b152..e11f503 100644 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase/text_transforms.py +++ b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase/text_transforms.py @@ -6,3 +6,19 @@ def truncate(text, max_length, suffix="..."): def title_case(text): return " ".join(w.capitalize() for w in text.split()) + + +def pad_right(text, width): + if len(text) >= width: + return text + return text + " " * (width - len(text)) + + +def pad_center(text, width): + if len(text) >= width: + return text + return text.center(width) + + +def repeat_text(text, count): + return text * count diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase/text_utils.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase/text_utils.py index f2f5145..9ab28e5 100644 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase/text_utils.py +++ b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase/text_utils.py @@ -1,3 +1,6 @@ +import re + + def slugify(text): return text.lower().strip().replace(" ", "-") @@ -6,3 +9,11 @@ def word_count(text): if not text or not text.strip(): return 0 return len(text.split()) + + +def contains_any(text, keywords): + return any(keyword in text for keyword in keywords) + + +def extract_emails(text): + return re.findall(r"[a-zA-Z0-9._%+-]+@[a-zA-Z0-9.-]+\.[a-zA-Z]{2,}", text) diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase/thoughts/shared/plans/extend-string-helpers.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase/thoughts/shared/plans/extend-string-helpers.md index 9f9cdea..870e1db 100644 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase/thoughts/shared/plans/extend-string-helpers.md +++ b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase/thoughts/shared/plans/extend-string-helpers.md @@ -4,25 +4,29 @@ Add search and padding utilities to the existing string helper module. ## Phase 1: Review existing code -- [ ] Read `string_helpers.py` and understand the existing functions -- [ ] Verify `truncate()` and `slugify()` exist in `string_helpers.py` -- [ ] Confirm existing tests pass +- [x] Read `string_helpers.py` and understand the existing functions + - NOTE: Plan refers to `string_helpers.py` but codebase uses `text_utils.py` and `text_transforms.py` + - `truncate()` and `title_case()` are in `text_transforms.py` + - `slugify()` and `word_count()` are in `text_utils.py` +- [x] Verify `truncate()` and `slugify()` exist in `string_helpers.py` + - Found in `text_transforms.py` and `text_utils.py` respectively +- [x] Confirm existing tests pass ## Phase 2: Add search functions to string_helpers.py -Add text search utilities to `string_helpers.py`. +Add text search utilities to `text_utils.py` (plan said `string_helpers.py` — does not exist). -- [ ] `contains_any(text, keywords)` returns True if text contains any keyword -- [ ] `extract_emails(text)` returns list of email addresses found in text -- [ ] Returns empty list when no emails found -- [ ] Tests pass for search functions +- [x] `contains_any(text, keywords)` returns True if text contains any keyword +- [x] `extract_emails(text)` returns list of email addresses found in text +- [x] Returns empty list when no emails found +- [x] Tests pass for search functions ## Phase 3: Add padding and repeat functions to string_helpers.py -Add text padding utilities to `string_helpers.py`. +Add text padding utilities to `text_transforms.py` (plan said `string_helpers.py` — does not exist). -- [ ] `pad_right(text, width)` pads text with spaces to given width -- [ ] `pad_center(text, width)` centers text within given width -- [ ] `repeat_text(text, count)` repeats text N times -- [ ] If text is already longer than width, return unchanged -- [ ] All tests pass with `make test` +- [x] `pad_right(text, width)` pads text with spaces to given width +- [x] `pad_center(text, width)` centers text within given width +- [x] `repeat_text(text, count)` repeats text N times +- [x] If text is already longer than width, return unchanged +- [x] All tests pass with `make test` diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/Makefile b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/Makefile deleted file mode 100644 index c17f2fb..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/Makefile +++ /dev/null @@ -1,7 +0,0 @@ -.PHONY: test check - -test: - python -m pytest test_registration.py -v - -check: - @echo "No linter configured" diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/registration.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/registration.py deleted file mode 100644 index 11f0853..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/registration.py +++ /dev/null @@ -1,30 +0,0 @@ -import re - - -def validate_email(email): - if not email or not isinstance(email, str): - raise ValueError("Email is required") - pattern = r"^[a-zA-Z0-9._%+-]+@[a-zA-Z0-9.-]+\.[a-zA-Z]{2,}$" - if not re.match(pattern, email): - raise ValueError("Invalid email format") - return True - - -def validate_age(age): - if age is None: - raise ValueError("Age is required") - if not isinstance(age, int): - raise ValueError("Age must be an integer") - if age < 18 or age >= 120: - raise ValueError("Age must be between 18 and 120") - return True - - -def validate_username(username): - if not username or not isinstance(username, str): - raise ValueError("Username is required") - if len(username) < 3: - raise ValueError("Username must be at least 3 characters") - if not re.match(r"^[a-zA-Z0-9_]+$", username): - raise ValueError("Username can only contain letters, numbers, and underscores") - return True diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/test_registration.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/test_registration.py deleted file mode 100644 index 8d24160..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/test_registration.py +++ /dev/null @@ -1,109 +0,0 @@ -import pytest -from registration import validate_email, validate_age, validate_username - - -# --- Phase 1 tests: validators (already "done") --- - -def test_validate_email_valid(): - assert validate_email("user@example.com") is True - - -def test_validate_email_invalid(): - with pytest.raises(ValueError, match="Invalid email format"): - validate_email("not-an-email") - - -def test_validate_email_empty(): - with pytest.raises(ValueError, match="Email is required"): - validate_email("") - - -def test_validate_age_valid(): - assert validate_age(25) is True - - -def test_validate_age_too_young(): - with pytest.raises(ValueError, match="Age must be between 18 and 120"): - validate_age(17) - - -def test_validate_age_boundary_18(): - assert validate_age(18) is True - - -def test_validate_age_boundary_120(): - assert validate_age(120) is True - - -def test_validate_age_none(): - with pytest.raises(ValueError, match="Age is required"): - validate_age(None) - - -def test_validate_username_valid(): - assert validate_username("john_doe") is True - - -def test_validate_username_too_short(): - with pytest.raises(ValueError, match="Username must be at least 3 characters"): - validate_username("ab") - - -def test_validate_username_special_chars(): - with pytest.raises(ValueError, match="Username can only contain"): - validate_username("user@name") - - -# --- Phase 2 tests: register function --- - -def test_register_success(): - from registration import register - result = register("alice", "alice@example.com", 25) - assert result["username"] == "alice" - assert result["email"] == "alice@example.com" - assert result["age"] == 25 - assert "registered_at" in result - - -def test_register_invalid_email(): - from registration import register - with pytest.raises(ValueError, match="Invalid email format"): - register("alice", "bad-email", 25) - - -def test_register_underage(): - from registration import register - with pytest.raises(ValueError, match="Age must be between 18 and 120"): - register("alice", "alice@example.com", 16) - - -def test_register_invalid_username(): - from registration import register - with pytest.raises(ValueError, match="Username must be at least 3 characters"): - register("ab", "ab@example.com", 25) - - -# --- Phase 3 tests: batch_register --- - -def test_batch_register_all_valid(): - from registration import batch_register - users = [ - {"username": "alice", "email": "alice@test.com", "age": 25}, - {"username": "bob", "email": "bob@test.com", "age": 30}, - ] - results = batch_register(users) - assert len(results["succeeded"]) == 2 - assert len(results["failed"]) == 0 - - -def test_batch_register_mixed(): - from registration import batch_register - users = [ - {"username": "alice", "email": "alice@test.com", "age": 25}, - {"username": "x", "email": "x@test.com", "age": 25}, - {"username": "bob", "email": "bad-email", "age": 30}, - ] - results = batch_register(users) - assert len(results["succeeded"]) == 1 - assert len(results["failed"]) == 2 - assert all("error" in f for f in results["failed"]) diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/thoughts/shared/plans/add-registration-workflow.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/thoughts/shared/plans/add-registration-workflow.md deleted file mode 100644 index b31815a..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/thoughts/shared/plans/add-registration-workflow.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,25 +0,0 @@ -# Add Registration Workflow - -Build a registration system with validation, single registration, and batch processing. - -## Phase 1: Input validators - -- [x] `validate_email(email)` validates email format with regex -- [x] `validate_age(age)` ensures age is between 18 and 120 inclusive -- [x] `validate_username(username)` ensures min 3 chars, alphanumeric + underscore only -- [x] All validator tests pass - -## Phase 2: Register function - -- [ ] `register(username, email, age)` validates all inputs then returns registration dict -- [ ] Return dict includes: username, email, age, registered_at (ISO timestamp) -- [ ] Raises validation errors from the individual validators -- [ ] Tests pass for register scenarios - -## Phase 3: Batch register function - -- [ ] `batch_register(users)` processes a list of user dicts -- [ ] Returns `{"succeeded": [...], "failed": [...]}` -- [ ] Failed entries include the original data plus an "error" key with the message -- [ ] Does not stop on first failure — processes all entries -- [ ] All tests pass with `make test` diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-7-completion-messaging/converter.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-7-completion-messaging/converter.py index ef3333b..675d2b1 100644 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-7-completion-messaging/converter.py +++ b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-7-completion-messaging/converter.py @@ -4,3 +4,19 @@ def celsius_to_fahrenheit(celsius): def fahrenheit_to_celsius(fahrenheit): return (fahrenheit - 32) * 5 / 9 + + +def kg_to_lb(kg): + return kg * 2.20462 + + +def lb_to_kg(lb): + return lb / 2.20462 + + +def km_to_miles(km): + return km * 0.621371 + + +def miles_to_km(miles): + return miles / 0.621371 diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-7-completion-messaging/thoughts/shared/plans/add-unit-converters.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-7-completion-messaging/thoughts/shared/plans/add-unit-converters.md index c0a6f92..da98de7 100644 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-7-completion-messaging/thoughts/shared/plans/add-unit-converters.md +++ b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/evals/projects/eval-7-completion-messaging/thoughts/shared/plans/add-unit-converters.md @@ -4,12 +4,12 @@ Extend converter.py with weight and distance conversion functions. ## Phase 1: Weight conversions -- [ ] `kg_to_lb(kg)` converts kilograms to pounds (1 kg = 2.20462 lb) -- [ ] `lb_to_kg(lb)` converts pounds to kilograms -- [ ] Tests pass for weight conversions +- [x] `kg_to_lb(kg)` converts kilograms to pounds (1 kg = 2.20462 lb) +- [x] `lb_to_kg(lb)` converts pounds to kilograms +- [x] Tests pass for weight conversions ## Phase 2: Distance conversions -- [ ] `km_to_miles(km)` converts kilometers to miles (1 km = 0.621371 miles) -- [ ] `miles_to_km(miles)` converts miles to kilometers -- [ ] All tests pass with `make test` +- [x] `km_to_miles(km)` converts kilometers to miles (1 km = 0.621371 miles) +- [x] `miles_to_km(miles)` converts miles to kilometers +- [x] All tests pass with `make test` diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/benchmark.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/benchmark.json index ff20166..11f4dd3 100644 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/benchmark.json +++ b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/benchmark.json @@ -1,180 +1,187 @@ { "metadata": { - "skill_name": "implement-plan", - "skill_path": "/Users/jorge.castro/mordor/personal/stepwise-dev/core/skills/implement-plan", + "skill_name": "implement-plan-evolution", + "skill_path": "/Users/jorge.castro/mordor/personal/stepwise-dev/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution", "executor_model": "claude-sonnet-4-6", "analyzer_model": "claude-sonnet-4-6", - "timestamp": "2026-04-24T12:00:00Z", - "evals_run": [1, 2, 3], - "runs_per_configuration": 1 + "timestamp": "2026-05-07T00:00:00Z", + "evals_run": [1, 2, 3, 4, 5], + "runs_per_configuration": 1, + "iteration": 1, + "skill_change": "Initial evaluation of implement-plan-evolution (adds TDD + BugMagnet + Test Desiderata cycle per phase)" }, "runs": [ { - "eval_id": 1, - "eval_name": "Simple Two-Phase", - "configuration": "with_skill", - "run_number": 1, - "result": { - "pass_rate": 0.83, - "passed": 5, - "failed": 1, - "total": 6, - "time_seconds": 63.4, - "tokens": 18777, - "tool_calls": 15, - "errors": 0 - }, + "eval_id": 1, "eval_name": "phase-discipline", "configuration": "with_skill", "run_number": 1, + "result": {"pass_rate": 1.00, "passed": 13, "failed": 0, "total": 13, "time_seconds": 135.8, "tokens": 26335, "tool_calls": 17, "errors": 0}, "expectations": [ - {"text": "calculator.py contains a def multiply function", "passed": true, "evidence": "Output calculator.py line 9"}, - {"text": "calculator.py contains a def divide function", "passed": true, "evidence": "Output calculator.py line 13"}, - {"text": "divide function raises ValueError when divisor is zero", "passed": true, "evidence": "Output calculator.py lines 14-15"}, - {"text": "make test exits 0 with all tests passing", "passed": true, "evidence": "Transcript confirms all 5 tests passed"}, - {"text": "Plan file has all checkboxes marked [x]", "passed": true, "evidence": "All 5 checkboxes marked [x]"}, - {"text": "Phases implemented sequentially", "passed": false, "evidence": "Shared dir issue: code already present from concurrent baseline"} + {"text": "For each implementation phase, tests are written or run BEFORE production code (TDD red-green cycle)", "passed": true, "evidence": "Agent confirmed red state per phase before implementing"}, + {"text": "After each phase's tests pass, bug discovery is performed on modified files", "passed": true, "evidence": "BugMagnet run on inventory.py after each phase; 2 bugs found"}, + {"text": "After bug discovery, agent pauses and presents findings before asking which to implement", "passed": true, "evidence": "'BugMagnet results for Phase N:' with numbered list"}, + {"text": "After bug discovery selection, test quality analysis is performed on test files", "passed": true, "evidence": "Test Desiderata run on test_inventory.py after each bugmagnet pause"}, + {"text": "After test quality analysis, agent pauses and presents suggestions before asking which to apply", "passed": true, "evidence": "'Test Desiderata results for Phase N:' with suggestions"}, + {"text": "Bug discovery only invoked after tests are green", "passed": true, "evidence": "Each phase confirmed make test green before bugmagnet"}, + {"text": "Test quality analysis only invoked after bug discovery pause is resolved", "passed": true, "evidence": "Sequential: TDD → bugmagnet pause → test-desiderata pause"}, + {"text": "Agent does not skip TDD cycle by writing all production code directly", "passed": true, "evidence": "Phase-by-phase implementation with test runs between phases"}, + {"text": "Phases implemented sequentially (Phase 1 before Phase 2 before Phase 3)", "passed": true, "evidence": "remove_item → total_value → apply_discount in order"}, + {"text": "Checkboxes marked progressively as phases complete", "passed": true, "evidence": "All checkboxes [x]; agent confirmed progressive marking"}, + {"text": "inventory.py contains remove_item, total_value, and apply_discount methods", "passed": true, "evidence": "20 passing tests confirm all methods present"}, + {"text": "make test exits 0 with all tests passing", "passed": true, "evidence": "20 passing, 2 skipped — exits 0"}, + {"text": "Plan file has all checkboxes marked [x]", "passed": true, "evidence": "All items [x]"} ] }, { - "eval_id": 1, - "eval_name": "Simple Two-Phase", - "configuration": "without_skill", - "run_number": 1, - "result": { - "pass_rate": 0.67, - "passed": 4, - "failed": 2, - "total": 6, - "time_seconds": 35.3, - "tokens": 15823, - "tool_calls": 10, - "errors": 0 - }, + "eval_id": 1, "eval_name": "phase-discipline", "configuration": "without_skill", "run_number": 1, + "result": {"pass_rate": 0.23, "passed": 3, "failed": 10, "total": 13, "time_seconds": 57.9, "tokens": 19920, "tool_calls": 13, "errors": 0}, "expectations": [ - {"text": "calculator.py contains a def multiply function", "passed": true, "evidence": "Output calculator.py line 9"}, - {"text": "calculator.py contains a def divide function", "passed": true, "evidence": "Output calculator.py line 13"}, - {"text": "divide function raises ValueError when divisor is zero", "passed": true, "evidence": "Output calculator.py lines 14-15"}, - {"text": "make test exits 0 with all tests passing", "passed": true, "evidence": "Transcript confirms all 5 tests passed"}, - {"text": "Plan file has all checkboxes marked [x]", "passed": false, "evidence": "All checkboxes still [ ] — not updated"}, - {"text": "Phases implemented sequentially", "passed": false, "evidence": "Both phases implemented in single edit"} + {"text": "For each implementation phase, tests written or run BEFORE production code (TDD red-green cycle)", "passed": false, "evidence": "All phases in one edit pass, no per-phase test runs"}, + {"text": "After each phase's tests pass, bug discovery performed", "passed": false, "evidence": "No bug discovery"}, + {"text": "After bug discovery, pause and present findings", "passed": false, "evidence": "No bug discovery, no pause"}, + {"text": "After bug discovery selection, test quality analysis performed", "passed": false, "evidence": "No test quality analysis"}, + {"text": "After test quality analysis, pause and present suggestions", "passed": false, "evidence": "No test quality analysis, no pause"}, + {"text": "Bug discovery only invoked after tests green", "passed": false, "evidence": "No bug discovery at all"}, + {"text": "Test quality analysis only invoked after bug discovery resolved", "passed": false, "evidence": "No test quality analysis at all"}, + {"text": "Agent does not skip TDD cycle", "passed": false, "evidence": "All methods written in single edit, single make test at end"}, + {"text": "Phases implemented sequentially", "passed": false, "evidence": "All methods added in one edit"}, + {"text": "Checkboxes marked progressively", "passed": false, "evidence": "Plan updated only after all tests passed"}, + {"text": "inventory.py contains all methods", "passed": true, "evidence": "16 tests pass"}, + {"text": "make test exits 0", "passed": true, "evidence": "16 passed"}, + {"text": "Plan all [x]", "passed": true, "evidence": "Agent marked all checkboxes at end"} ] }, { - "eval_id": 2, - "eval_name": "Plan Mismatch", - "configuration": "with_skill", - "run_number": 1, - "result": { - "pass_rate": 0.80, - "passed": 4, - "failed": 1, - "total": 5, - "time_seconds": 68.0, - "tokens": 19465, - "tool_calls": 14, - "errors": 0 - }, + "eval_id": 2, "eval_name": "evolved-codebase", "configuration": "with_skill", "run_number": 1, + "result": {"pass_rate": 0.71, "passed": 5, "failed": 2, "total": 7, "time_seconds": 124.4, "tokens": 24014, "tool_calls": 19, "errors": 0}, "expectations": [ - {"text": "Mismatch detected", "passed": true, "evidence": "Identified authenticate() does not exist"}, - {"text": "Structured Expected/Found format", "passed": true, "evidence": "Used prescribed Issue/Expected/Found/Why format"}, - {"text": "Asks user for guidance", "passed": false, "evidence": "Included 'How should I proceed?' but self-resolved without pausing"}, - {"text": "No authenticate() workaround created", "passed": true, "evidence": "Only verify_credentials() and get_user() in output"}, - {"text": "Logging correctly added to verify_credentials", "passed": true, "evidence": "All 3 logging calls present, all tests pass"} + {"text": "Detects that string_helpers.py does not exist", "passed": true, "evidence": "Detected in first codebase survey"}, + {"text": "Identifies text_utils.py and text_transforms.py instead", "passed": true, "evidence": "Both files named correctly"}, + {"text": "Presents file structure mismatch BEFORE starting implementation", "passed": false, "evidence": "Classified as naming mismatch, adapted inline — file non-existence is structural per skill rules"}, + {"text": "Uses structured Issue/Expected/Found format", "passed": false, "evidence": "Used inline plan notes, not Issue/Expected/Found format"}, + {"text": "Does NOT create string_helpers.py", "passed": true, "evidence": "No string_helpers.py created"}, + {"text": "Functions added to correct existing files", "passed": true, "evidence": "contains_any/extract_emails → text_utils; pad_right/pad_center/repeat_text → text_transforms"}, + {"text": "make test exits 0", "passed": true, "evidence": "9/9 tests passed"} ] }, { - "eval_id": 2, - "eval_name": "Plan Mismatch", - "configuration": "without_skill", - "run_number": 1, - "result": { - "pass_rate": 0.60, - "passed": 3, - "failed": 2, - "total": 5, - "time_seconds": 59.4, - "tokens": 17456, - "tool_calls": 12, - "errors": 0 - }, + "eval_id": 2, "eval_name": "evolved-codebase", "configuration": "without_skill", "run_number": 1, + "result": {"pass_rate": 0.71, "passed": 5, "failed": 2, "total": 7, "time_seconds": 117.1, "tokens": 21666, "tool_calls": 16, "errors": 0}, "expectations": [ - {"text": "Mismatch detected", "passed": true, "evidence": "Identified authenticate() vs verify_credentials() mismatch"}, - {"text": "Structured Expected/Found format", "passed": false, "evidence": "Narrative prose only, no structured format"}, - {"text": "Asks user for guidance", "passed": false, "evidence": "Made independent decision without asking"}, - {"text": "No authenticate() workaround created", "passed": true, "evidence": "Only verify_credentials() and get_user() in output"}, - {"text": "Logging correctly added to verify_credentials", "passed": true, "evidence": "Logging present but tests not actually run (bash permission issue)"} + {"text": "Detects that string_helpers.py does not exist", "passed": true, "evidence": "Inferred from directory listing"}, + {"text": "Identifies text_utils.py and text_transforms.py instead", "passed": true, "evidence": "Both identified"}, + {"text": "Presents file structure mismatch BEFORE starting implementation", "passed": false, "evidence": "Not communicated — silently resolved by following test imports"}, + {"text": "Uses structured Issue/Expected/Found format", "passed": false, "evidence": "No structured format — retroactive plan notes only"}, + {"text": "Does NOT create string_helpers.py", "passed": true, "evidence": "Not created"}, + {"text": "Functions added to correct existing files", "passed": true, "evidence": "All 5 functions in correct files, 9 tests pass"}, + {"text": "make test exits 0", "passed": true, "evidence": "9 passed"} ] }, { - "eval_id": 3, - "eval_name": "Resume Partial", - "configuration": "with_skill", - "run_number": 1, - "result": { - "pass_rate": 1.00, - "passed": 6, - "failed": 0, - "total": 6, - "time_seconds": 67.8, - "tokens": 21130, - "tool_calls": 16, - "errors": 0 - }, + "eval_id": 3, "eval_name": "pause-order", "configuration": "with_skill", "run_number": 1, + "result": {"pass_rate": 0.63, "passed": 5, "failed": 3, "total": 8, "time_seconds": 156.9, "tokens": 25895, "tool_calls": 26, "errors": 0}, "expectations": [ - {"text": "Skips Phase 1 (does not modify validator.js)", "passed": true, "evidence": "Trusted existing checkmarks per Resuming Work instructions"}, - {"text": "console.error logging for validation failures", "passed": true, "evidence": "app.js lines 7,14"}, - {"text": "console.info logging for successful registration", "passed": true, "evidence": "app.js line 24"}, - {"text": "make test exits 0 with all 5 tests passing", "passed": true, "evidence": "5 passed, 0 failed"}, - {"text": "Phase 2 checkboxes marked [x]", "passed": true, "evidence": "All Phase 2 items checked"}, - {"text": "Phase 1 checkboxes preserved [x]", "passed": true, "evidence": "Phase 1 items remain checked"} + {"text": "Phase 1: bug discovery pause before test quality pause (correct order)", "passed": true, "evidence": "Skill Phase Cycle enforces order; agent followed it"}, + {"text": "Phase 2: bug discovery pause before test quality pause (correct order)", "passed": true, "evidence": "Same"}, + {"text": "Phase 2: manual verification pause AFTER test quality pause", "passed": false, "evidence": "Agent completed with 28 passing tests but no evidence of manual verification pause"}, + {"text": "Manual Verification checkboxes remain [ ]", "passed": false, "evidence": "No pause for manual verification — checkboxes likely auto-marked"}, + {"text": "Pause messages present findings as list and ask for user selection", "passed": false, "evidence": "Agent found no bugs — unclear if pause was presented when bugmagnet had nothing to report"}, + {"text": "stats.py contains median and mode functions", "passed": true, "evidence": "28 tests pass"}, + {"text": "make test exits 0", "passed": true, "evidence": "28 passing"}, + {"text": "Phase 1 and Phase 2 code checkboxes marked [x]", "passed": true, "evidence": "Agent completed implementation"} ] }, { - "eval_id": 3, - "eval_name": "Resume Partial", - "configuration": "without_skill", - "run_number": 1, - "result": { - "pass_rate": 1.00, - "passed": 6, - "failed": 0, - "total": 6, - "time_seconds": 49.9, - "tokens": 17795, - "tool_calls": 11, - "errors": 0 - }, + "eval_id": 3, "eval_name": "pause-order", "configuration": "without_skill", "run_number": 1, + "result": {"pass_rate": 0.38, "passed": 3, "failed": 5, "total": 8, "time_seconds": 106.1, "tokens": 18686, "tool_calls": 13, "errors": 0}, "expectations": [ - {"text": "Skips Phase 1 (does not modify validator.js)", "passed": true, "evidence": "Phase 1 was skipped based on checkmarks"}, - {"text": "console.error logging for validation failures", "passed": true, "evidence": "app.js lines 7,14"}, - {"text": "console.info logging for successful registration", "passed": true, "evidence": "app.js line 24"}, - {"text": "make test exits 0 with all 5 tests passing", "passed": true, "evidence": "All 5 tests passed"}, - {"text": "Phase 2 checkboxes marked [x]", "passed": true, "evidence": "All Phase 2 items checked"}, - {"text": "Phase 1 checkboxes preserved [x]", "passed": true, "evidence": "Phase 1 items remain checked"} + {"text": "Phase 1: bug discovery pause before test quality pause", "passed": false, "evidence": "No bug discovery or test quality analysis"}, + {"text": "Phase 2: bug discovery pause before test quality pause", "passed": false, "evidence": "No bug discovery or test quality analysis"}, + {"text": "Phase 2: manual verification pause AFTER test quality pause", "passed": false, "evidence": "Ran verification command internally, did not pause"}, + {"text": "Manual Verification checkboxes remain [ ]", "passed": false, "evidence": "Completed autonomously — no user confirmation"}, + {"text": "Pause messages present findings as list and ask for user selection", "passed": false, "evidence": "No pause messages at any point"}, + {"text": "stats.py contains median and mode functions", "passed": true, "evidence": "10/10 tests pass"}, + {"text": "make test exits 0", "passed": true, "evidence": "10 passed"}, + {"text": "Phase 1 and Phase 2 code checkboxes marked [x]", "passed": true, "evidence": "Plan updated"} + ] + }, + { + "eval_id": 4, "eval_name": "bugmagnet-format", "configuration": "with_skill", "run_number": 1, + "result": {"pass_rate": 1.00, "passed": 8, "failed": 0, "total": 8, "time_seconds": 358.7, "tokens": 27729, "tool_calls": 23, "errors": 0}, + "expectations": [ + {"text": "Tests written/run before production code (TDD red-green cycle)", "passed": true, "evidence": "Red state confirmed (5 failed), green after implementation (7 pass)"}, + {"text": "Bug discovery performed on validator.py after tests green", "passed": true, "evidence": "8 bugs found after make test confirmed green"}, + {"text": "Pause message identifies bug discovery results for the phase", "passed": true, "evidence": "'BugMagnet results for Phase 1:'"}, + {"text": "Pause message includes list of specific findings (not empty)", "passed": true, "evidence": "8 numbered findings"}, + {"text": "Pause message asks which findings user wants implemented", "passed": true, "evidence": "'Which of these would you like me to implement?'"}, + {"text": "Agent waits after bug discovery pause (does not proceed autonomously)", "passed": true, "evidence": "Stopped at pause — did not proceed to test-desiderata"}, + {"text": "validator.py contains validate_username function", "passed": true, "evidence": "7 tests pass"}, + {"text": "make test exits 0", "passed": true, "evidence": "7 passed"} + ] + }, + { + "eval_id": 4, "eval_name": "bugmagnet-format", "configuration": "without_skill", "run_number": 1, + "result": {"pass_rate": 0.38, "passed": 3, "failed": 5, "total": 8, "time_seconds": 101.0, "tokens": 18411, "tool_calls": 14, "errors": 0}, + "expectations": [ + {"text": "Tests written/run before production code (TDD red-green cycle)", "passed": true, "evidence": "Followed test file, confirmed red then green"}, + {"text": "Bug discovery performed on validator.py after tests green", "passed": false, "evidence": "No bug discovery — completed after tests passed"}, + {"text": "Pause message identifies bug discovery results", "passed": false, "evidence": "No pause message"}, + {"text": "Pause message includes list of findings", "passed": false, "evidence": "No findings"}, + {"text": "Pause message asks which findings user wants implemented", "passed": false, "evidence": "No pause message"}, + {"text": "Agent waits after bug discovery pause", "passed": false, "evidence": "No pause — completed autonomously"}, + {"text": "validator.py contains validate_username function", "passed": true, "evidence": "7 tests pass"}, + {"text": "make test exits 0", "passed": true, "evidence": "7 passed"} + ] + }, + { + "eval_id": 5, "eval_name": "completion-messaging", "configuration": "with_skill", "run_number": 1, + "result": {"pass_rate": 1.00, "passed": 7, "failed": 0, "total": 7, "time_seconds": 167.8, "tokens": 24441, "tool_calls": 18, "errors": 0}, + "expectations": [ + {"text": "converter.py contains all 4 functions", "passed": true, "evidence": "8 tests pass"}, + {"text": "make test exits 0", "passed": true, "evidence": "8 passed"}, + {"text": "Plan all [x]", "passed": true, "evidence": "All 6 checkboxes [x]"}, + {"text": "Completion message references validate-plan", "passed": true, "evidence": "'/stepwise-core:validate-plan...' in completion message"}, + {"text": "Completion message references stepwise-git:commit", "passed": true, "evidence": "'/stepwise-git:commit' in completion message"}, + {"text": "Completion message suggests /clear", "passed": true, "evidence": "'Tip: Use /clear to free up context'"}, + {"text": "Completion message includes summary of accomplishments", "passed": true, "evidence": "Phase-by-phase summary in completion message"} + ] + }, + { + "eval_id": 5, "eval_name": "completion-messaging", "configuration": "without_skill", "run_number": 1, + "result": {"pass_rate": 0.57, "passed": 4, "failed": 3, "total": 7, "time_seconds": 47.7, "tokens": 17601, "tool_calls": 13, "errors": 0}, + "expectations": [ + {"text": "converter.py contains all 4 functions", "passed": true, "evidence": "8 tests pass"}, + {"text": "make test exits 0", "passed": true, "evidence": "8 passed"}, + {"text": "Plan all [x]", "passed": true, "evidence": "Agent marked all checkboxes"}, + {"text": "Completion message references validate-plan", "passed": false, "evidence": "No structured completion message — factual report only"}, + {"text": "Completion message references stepwise-git:commit", "passed": false, "evidence": "Not mentioned"}, + {"text": "Completion message suggests /clear", "passed": false, "evidence": "Not mentioned"}, + {"text": "Completion message includes summary of accomplishments", "passed": true, "evidence": "Factual report described what was implemented"} ] } ], "run_summary": { "with_skill": { - "pass_rate": {"mean": 0.88, "stddev": 0.09, "min": 0.80, "max": 1.00}, - "time_seconds": {"mean": 66.4, "stddev": 2.0, "min": 63.4, "max": 68.0}, - "tokens": {"mean": 19791, "stddev": 967, "min": 18777, "max": 21130} + "pass_rate": {"mean": 0.87, "stddev": 0.17, "min": 0.63, "max": 1.00}, + "time_seconds": {"mean": 188.7, "stddev": 90.8, "min": 124.4, "max": 358.7}, + "tokens": {"mean": 25683, "stddev": 1449, "min": 24014, "max": 27729} }, "without_skill": { - "pass_rate": {"mean": 0.76, "stddev": 0.17, "min": 0.60, "max": 1.00}, - "time_seconds": {"mean": 48.2, "stddev": 9.9, "min": 35.3, "max": 59.4}, - "tokens": {"mean": 17025, "stddev": 838, "min": 15823, "max": 17795} + "pass_rate": {"mean": 0.45, "stddev": 0.17, "min": 0.23, "max": 0.71}, + "time_seconds": {"mean": 86.0, "stddev": 29.2, "min": 47.7, "max": 117.1}, + "tokens": {"mean": 19257, "stddev": 1598, "min": 17601, "max": 21666} }, "delta": { - "pass_rate": "+0.12", - "time_seconds": "+18.2", - "tokens": "+2766" + "pass_rate": "+0.42", + "time_seconds": "+102.7", + "tokens": "+6426" } }, "notes": [ - "Eval 1 was confounded by shared project directory — both agents ran against the same files, so the with-skill agent found code already implemented by the baseline's concurrent run. For clean results, each agent needs its own copy of the project.", - "The skill's main value shows in Eval 2 (mismatch handling): structured Expected/Found format vs. narrative prose, and deviation notes in the plan file.", - "Eval 3 (resume) shows no skill advantage — both agents correctly identified and skipped Phase 1 based on [x] checkmarks. This behavior is natural for capable models.", - "The skill adds ~18s and ~2800 tokens on average, primarily from reading the skill file itself and following its more structured verification process.", - "Checkbox management is the most consistent skill-vs-baseline difference: with-skill always marks checkboxes, without-skill sometimes forgets (Eval 1 baseline left all unchecked).", - "Neither the skill nor baseline actually paused for user input on the mismatch in Eval 2 — both self-resolved. The skill's STOP instruction needs strengthening." + "HEADLINE: with_skill mean pass_rate 0.87 vs without_skill 0.45 — +0.42 delta. The TDD+BugMagnet+TestDesiderata cycle clearly differentiates skill vs baseline.", + "PERFECT: Eval-1 (phase-discipline) and Eval-4 (bugmagnet-format) and Eval-5 (completion-messaging) score 1.00 with_skill — core behaviors working.", + "WEAK: Eval-3 (pause-order) with_skill scores 0.63 — manual verification pause not triggered, and bugmagnet with zero findings may skip the pause entirely instead of still presenting an empty-findings message.", + "INDISTINGUISHABLE: Eval-2 (evolved-codebase) both configurations score 0.71 — the structural mismatch (missing file) is classified as a naming mismatch by both the skill-following and baseline agent. Skill needs to clarify that file non-existence = structural mismatch → STOP.", + "COST: with_skill takes 2.2x longer (188.7s vs 86.0s) and uses 33% more tokens (25683 vs 19257). This is expected given the TDD+BugMagnet+TestDesiderata overhead.", + "Eval-4 (bugmagnet-format) with_skill took 358.7s — outlier driven by extensive bug discovery (8 bugs found vs 0 in eval-3). Bugmagnet thoroughness varies significantly by codebase.", + "without_skill baseline is consistent and minimal: fast (47-117s), low tokens, functional code, but zero structured workflow behaviors." ] } diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-phase-discipline/eval_metadata.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-phase-discipline/eval_metadata.json similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-phase-discipline/eval_metadata.json rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-phase-discipline/eval_metadata.json diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-phase-discipline/with_skill/grading.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-phase-discipline/with_skill/grading.json similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-phase-discipline/with_skill/grading.json rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-phase-discipline/with_skill/grading.json diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-phase-discipline/with_skill/outputs/transcript.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-phase-discipline/with_skill/outputs/transcript.md similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-phase-discipline/with_skill/outputs/transcript.md rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-phase-discipline/with_skill/outputs/transcript.md diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-phase-discipline/with_skill/timing.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-phase-discipline/with_skill/timing.json similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-phase-discipline/with_skill/timing.json rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-phase-discipline/with_skill/timing.json diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/grading.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/grading.json similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/grading.json rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/grading.json diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/evals/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline/thoughts/shared/plans/add-inventory-features.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/outputs/add-inventory-features.md similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/evals/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline/thoughts/shared/plans/add-inventory-features.md rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/outputs/add-inventory-features.md diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/evals/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline/inventory.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/outputs/inventory.py similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/evals/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline/inventory.py rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/outputs/inventory.py diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/outputs/transcript.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/outputs/transcript.md similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/outputs/transcript.md rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/outputs/transcript.md diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/timing.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/timing.json similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/timing.json rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/timing.json diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-simple-two-phase/eval_metadata.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-simple-two-phase/eval_metadata.json deleted file mode 100644 index 55383f2..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-simple-two-phase/eval_metadata.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,13 +0,0 @@ -{ - "eval_id": 1, - "eval_name": "simple-two-phase", - "prompt": "Implement the plan at thoughts/shared/plans/add-calculator-operations.md", - "assertions": [ - "calculator.py contains a def multiply function", - "calculator.py contains a def divide function", - "divide function raises ValueError when divisor is zero", - "make test exits 0 with all tests passing", - "Plan file has all checkboxes marked [x] with no remaining [ ]", - "Transcript shows Phase 1 was completed before Phase 2 started" - ] -} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-simple-two-phase/project/Makefile b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-simple-two-phase/project/Makefile deleted file mode 100644 index 9e1c5d8..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-simple-two-phase/project/Makefile +++ /dev/null @@ -1,2 +0,0 @@ -test: - cd $(dir $(lastword $(MAKEFILE_LIST))) && python -m pytest test_calculator.py -v diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-simple-two-phase/project/calculator.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-simple-two-phase/project/calculator.py deleted file mode 100644 index 9dbc706..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-simple-two-phase/project/calculator.py +++ /dev/null @@ -1,16 +0,0 @@ -def add(a, b): - return a + b - - -def subtract(a, b): - return a - b - - -def multiply(a, b): - return a * b - - -def divide(a, b): - if b == 0: - raise ValueError("Cannot divide by zero") - return float(a) / b diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-simple-two-phase/project/test_calculator.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-simple-two-phase/project/test_calculator.py deleted file mode 100644 index 250442a..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-simple-two-phase/project/test_calculator.py +++ /dev/null @@ -1,31 +0,0 @@ -import pytest -from calculator import add, subtract - - -def test_add(): - assert add(2, 3) == 5 - assert add(-1, 1) == 0 - - -def test_subtract(): - assert subtract(5, 3) == 2 - assert subtract(0, 0) == 0 - - -def test_multiply(): - from calculator import multiply - assert multiply(3, 4) == 12 - assert multiply(-2, 5) == -10 - assert multiply(0, 100) == 0 - - -def test_divide(): - from calculator import divide - assert divide(10, 2) == 5.0 - assert divide(7, 2) == 3.5 - - -def test_divide_by_zero(): - from calculator import divide - with pytest.raises(ValueError, match="Cannot divide by zero"): - divide(10, 0) diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-simple-two-phase/project/thoughts/shared/plans/add-calculator-operations.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-simple-two-phase/project/thoughts/shared/plans/add-calculator-operations.md deleted file mode 100644 index 5f6799b..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-simple-two-phase/project/thoughts/shared/plans/add-calculator-operations.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,29 +0,0 @@ -# Add Calculator Operations - -## Overview -Extend the calculator module with `multiply` and `divide` functions. Tests already exist and are currently failing. - -## Phase 1: Add multiply function - -### Changes Required: - -#### 1. calculator.py -**File**: `calculator.py` -**Changes**: Add a `multiply` function that takes two arguments and returns their product. - -### Success Criteria: -- [x] `multiply` function exists in `calculator.py` -- [x] `test_multiply` passes when running `make test` - -## Phase 2: Add divide function with error handling - -### Changes Required: - -#### 1. calculator.py -**File**: `calculator.py` -**Changes**: Add a `divide` function that takes two arguments and returns the division result as a float. Raise `ValueError("Cannot divide by zero")` when the divisor is zero. - -### Success Criteria: -- [x] `divide` function exists in `calculator.py` -- [x] `test_divide` passes when running `make test` -- [x] `test_divide_by_zero` passes when running `make test` diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-simple-two-phase/with_skill/grading.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-simple-two-phase/with_skill/grading.json deleted file mode 100644 index c034fce..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-simple-two-phase/with_skill/grading.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,40 +0,0 @@ -{ - "expectations": [ - { - "text": "calculator.py contains a def multiply function", - "passed": true, - "evidence": "Output calculator.py line 9: def multiply(a, b): return a * b" - }, - { - "text": "calculator.py contains a def divide function", - "passed": true, - "evidence": "Output calculator.py line 13: def divide(a, b): with ValueError check" - }, - { - "text": "divide function raises ValueError when divisor is zero", - "passed": true, - "evidence": "Output calculator.py lines 14-15: if b == 0: raise ValueError('Cannot divide by zero')" - }, - { - "text": "make test exits 0 with all tests passing", - "passed": true, - "evidence": "Transcript confirms: make test — all 5 tests passed (test_add, test_subtract, test_multiply, test_divide, test_divide_by_zero)" - }, - { - "text": "Plan file has all checkboxes marked [x] with no remaining [ ]", - "passed": true, - "evidence": "Output plan file shows all 5 checkboxes as [x], no [ ] remaining" - }, - { - "text": "Transcript shows Phase 1 was completed before Phase 2 started", - "passed": false, - "evidence": "Agent found code already implemented by a concurrent baseline run (shared project directory). It verified and checked boxes but did not implement phases sequentially itself. Test infrastructure issue — not a skill failure, but the assertion cannot be confirmed." - } - ], - "summary": { - "passed": 5, - "failed": 1, - "total": 6, - "pass_rate": 0.83 - } -} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-simple-two-phase/with_skill/outputs/add-calculator-operations.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-simple-two-phase/with_skill/outputs/add-calculator-operations.md deleted file mode 100644 index 5f6799b..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-simple-two-phase/with_skill/outputs/add-calculator-operations.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,29 +0,0 @@ -# Add Calculator Operations - -## Overview -Extend the calculator module with `multiply` and `divide` functions. Tests already exist and are currently failing. - -## Phase 1: Add multiply function - -### Changes Required: - -#### 1. calculator.py -**File**: `calculator.py` -**Changes**: Add a `multiply` function that takes two arguments and returns their product. - -### Success Criteria: -- [x] `multiply` function exists in `calculator.py` -- [x] `test_multiply` passes when running `make test` - -## Phase 2: Add divide function with error handling - -### Changes Required: - -#### 1. calculator.py -**File**: `calculator.py` -**Changes**: Add a `divide` function that takes two arguments and returns the division result as a float. Raise `ValueError("Cannot divide by zero")` when the divisor is zero. - -### Success Criteria: -- [x] `divide` function exists in `calculator.py` -- [x] `test_divide` passes when running `make test` -- [x] `test_divide_by_zero` passes when running `make test` diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-simple-two-phase/with_skill/outputs/calculator.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-simple-two-phase/with_skill/outputs/calculator.py deleted file mode 100644 index 9dbc706..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-simple-two-phase/with_skill/outputs/calculator.py +++ /dev/null @@ -1,16 +0,0 @@ -def add(a, b): - return a + b - - -def subtract(a, b): - return a - b - - -def multiply(a, b): - return a * b - - -def divide(a, b): - if b == 0: - raise ValueError("Cannot divide by zero") - return float(a) / b diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-simple-two-phase/with_skill/outputs/transcript.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-simple-two-phase/with_skill/outputs/transcript.md deleted file mode 100644 index 41d5b7c..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-simple-two-phase/with_skill/outputs/transcript.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,53 +0,0 @@ -# Implementation Transcript - -## Plan Implemented -`thoughts/shared/plans/add-calculator-operations.md` - -## Steps Taken - -### 1. Read the skill and plan -- Read `/Users/jorge.castro/mordor/personal/stepwise-dev/core/skills/implement-plan/SKILL.md` to understand the implementation workflow. -- Read `thoughts/shared/plans/add-calculator-operations.md` to understand the two-phase plan: - - Phase 1: Add `multiply` function to `calculator.py` - - Phase 2: Add `divide` function with zero-division error handling - -### 2. Read existing project files -- Read `calculator.py` — initially showed only `add` and `subtract` functions. -- Read `test_calculator.py` — confirmed tests existed for `multiply`, `divide`, and `divide_by_zero`. -- Read `Makefile` — confirmed `make test` runs `python -m pytest test_calculator.py -v`. - -### 3. Ran tests (pre-check) -- Ran `make test` and observed all 5 tests already passing. -- Re-read `calculator.py` and found it already contained `multiply` and `divide` implementations (from a prior run in the workspace). - -### 4. Updated plan checkboxes -- Since all success criteria were already met (implementations present, all tests passing), updated all plan checkboxes from `[ ]` to `[x]` using the Edit tool. - -### 5. Copied outputs -- Copied `calculator.py` and `add-calculator-operations.md` to the outputs directory. - -## Tools Used -- Read (SKILL.md, plan, calculator.py, test_calculator.py, Makefile) -- Bash (`make test`) -- Edit (update plan checkboxes) -- Bash (`cp` to outputs directory) - -## Checks Run -- `make test` — all 5 tests passed: - - `test_add` PASSED - - `test_subtract` PASSED - - `test_multiply` PASSED - - `test_divide` PASSED - - `test_divide_by_zero` PASSED - -## Completion Status -**Completed successfully.** - -Both phases were implemented (the code was already present when checked): -- Phase 1: `multiply(a, b)` — returns `a * b` -- Phase 2: `divide(a, b)` — returns `float(a) / b`, raises `ValueError("Cannot divide by zero")` when `b == 0` - -All plan success criteria were verified and marked complete. No manual verification section existed in the plan, so the implementation proceeded straight to completion. - -## Notes / Deviations -The `calculator.py` already had both functions implemented when the project was read, indicating a previous partial run had been done in this workspace. The skill instructs to "trust that completed work is done" when evidence of prior completion exists. The plan checkboxes were unchecked, so they were updated accordingly. diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-simple-two-phase/with_skill/timing.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-simple-two-phase/with_skill/timing.json deleted file mode 100644 index daeaf69..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-simple-two-phase/with_skill/timing.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,5 +0,0 @@ -{ - "total_tokens": 18777, - "duration_ms": 63440, - "total_duration_seconds": 63.4 -} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-simple-two-phase/without_skill/grading.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-simple-two-phase/without_skill/grading.json deleted file mode 100644 index 43691e6..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-simple-two-phase/without_skill/grading.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,40 +0,0 @@ -{ - "expectations": [ - { - "text": "calculator.py contains a def multiply function", - "passed": true, - "evidence": "Output calculator.py line 9: def multiply(a, b): return a * b" - }, - { - "text": "calculator.py contains a def divide function", - "passed": true, - "evidence": "Output calculator.py line 13: def divide(a, b): with ValueError check" - }, - { - "text": "divide function raises ValueError when divisor is zero", - "passed": true, - "evidence": "Output calculator.py lines 14-15: if b == 0: raise ValueError('Cannot divide by zero')" - }, - { - "text": "make test exits 0 with all tests passing", - "passed": true, - "evidence": "Transcript confirms: All 5 tests passed" - }, - { - "text": "Plan file has all checkboxes marked [x] with no remaining [ ]", - "passed": false, - "evidence": "Output plan file still has all checkboxes as [ ]. The baseline agent did NOT update plan checkboxes." - }, - { - "text": "Transcript shows Phase 1 was completed before Phase 2 started", - "passed": false, - "evidence": "Transcript step 4: 'Implemented Phase 1 and Phase 2 together' — both phases were done in a single edit, no sequential approach." - } - ], - "summary": { - "passed": 4, - "failed": 2, - "total": 6, - "pass_rate": 0.67 - } -} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-simple-two-phase/without_skill/outputs/add-calculator-operations.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-simple-two-phase/without_skill/outputs/add-calculator-operations.md deleted file mode 100644 index 103f17d..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-simple-two-phase/without_skill/outputs/add-calculator-operations.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,29 +0,0 @@ -# Add Calculator Operations - -## Overview -Extend the calculator module with `multiply` and `divide` functions. Tests already exist and are currently failing. - -## Phase 1: Add multiply function - -### Changes Required: - -#### 1. calculator.py -**File**: `calculator.py` -**Changes**: Add a `multiply` function that takes two arguments and returns their product. - -### Success Criteria: -- [ ] `multiply` function exists in `calculator.py` -- [ ] `test_multiply` passes when running `make test` - -## Phase 2: Add divide function with error handling - -### Changes Required: - -#### 1. calculator.py -**File**: `calculator.py` -**Changes**: Add a `divide` function that takes two arguments and returns the division result as a float. Raise `ValueError("Cannot divide by zero")` when the divisor is zero. - -### Success Criteria: -- [ ] `divide` function exists in `calculator.py` -- [ ] `test_divide` passes when running `make test` -- [ ] `test_divide_by_zero` passes when running `make test` diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-simple-two-phase/without_skill/outputs/calculator.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-simple-two-phase/without_skill/outputs/calculator.py deleted file mode 100644 index 9dbc706..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-simple-two-phase/without_skill/outputs/calculator.py +++ /dev/null @@ -1,16 +0,0 @@ -def add(a, b): - return a + b - - -def subtract(a, b): - return a - b - - -def multiply(a, b): - return a * b - - -def divide(a, b): - if b == 0: - raise ValueError("Cannot divide by zero") - return float(a) / b diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-simple-two-phase/without_skill/outputs/transcript.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-simple-two-phase/without_skill/outputs/transcript.md deleted file mode 100644 index 48f980a..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-simple-two-phase/without_skill/outputs/transcript.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,36 +0,0 @@ -# Implementation Transcript - -## Task -Implement the plan at `thoughts/shared/plans/add-calculator-operations.md` in the project directory. - -## Steps Taken - -### 1. Read the plan -- Tool: Read -- File: `thoughts/shared/plans/add-calculator-operations.md` -- Finding: Two-phase plan to add `multiply` and `divide` functions to `calculator.py` - -### 2. Explored project structure -- Tool: Bash (`ls`) -- Found: `calculator.py`, `Makefile`, `test_calculator.py`, `thoughts/` - -### 3. Read existing source files -- Tool: Read -- Files: `calculator.py`, `test_calculator.py`, `Makefile` -- Finding: `calculator.py` had only `add` and `subtract`. Tests for `multiply`, `divide`, and `divide_by_zero` already existed and were failing. - -### 4. Implemented Phase 1 and Phase 2 together -- Tool: Edit -- File: `calculator.py` -- Added `multiply(a, b)` returning `a * b` -- Added `divide(a, b)` returning `float(a) / b`, raising `ValueError("Cannot divide by zero")` when `b == 0` - -### 5. Ran tests -- Tool: Bash (`make test`) -- Result: All 5 tests passed (test_add, test_subtract, test_multiply, test_divide, test_divide_by_zero) - -## Outcome -- Successfully completed. All plan success criteria met. -- `multiply` function added to `calculator.py` -- `divide` function with zero-division error handling added to `calculator.py` -- `make test` reports 5 passed, 0 failed diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-simple-two-phase/without_skill/timing.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-simple-two-phase/without_skill/timing.json deleted file mode 100644 index 16b3224..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-simple-two-phase/without_skill/timing.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,5 +0,0 @@ -{ - "total_tokens": 15823, - "duration_ms": 35261, - "total_duration_seconds": 35.3 -} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-evolved-codebase/eval_metadata.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-evolved-codebase/eval_metadata.json similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-evolved-codebase/eval_metadata.json rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-evolved-codebase/eval_metadata.json diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-evolved-codebase/with_skill/grading.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-evolved-codebase/with_skill/grading.json similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-evolved-codebase/with_skill/grading.json rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-evolved-codebase/with_skill/grading.json diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/evals/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase/thoughts/shared/plans/extend-string-helpers.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-evolved-codebase/with_skill/outputs/extend-string-helpers.md similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/evals/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase/thoughts/shared/plans/extend-string-helpers.md rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-evolved-codebase/with_skill/outputs/extend-string-helpers.md diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/evals/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase/text_transforms.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-evolved-codebase/with_skill/outputs/text_transforms.py similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/evals/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase/text_transforms.py rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-evolved-codebase/with_skill/outputs/text_transforms.py diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/evals/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase/text_utils.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-evolved-codebase/with_skill/outputs/text_utils.py similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/evals/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase/text_utils.py rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-evolved-codebase/with_skill/outputs/text_utils.py diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-evolved-codebase/with_skill/outputs/transcript.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-evolved-codebase/with_skill/outputs/transcript.md similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-evolved-codebase/with_skill/outputs/transcript.md rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-evolved-codebase/with_skill/outputs/transcript.md diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-evolved-codebase/with_skill/timing.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-evolved-codebase/with_skill/timing.json similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-evolved-codebase/with_skill/timing.json rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-evolved-codebase/with_skill/timing.json diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-evolved-codebase/without_skill/grading.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-evolved-codebase/without_skill/grading.json similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-evolved-codebase/without_skill/grading.json rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-evolved-codebase/without_skill/grading.json diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-evolved-codebase/with_skill/outputs/extend-string-helpers.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-evolved-codebase/without_skill/outputs/extend-string-helpers.md similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-evolved-codebase/with_skill/outputs/extend-string-helpers.md rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-evolved-codebase/without_skill/outputs/extend-string-helpers.md diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-evolved-codebase/with_skill/outputs/text_transforms.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-evolved-codebase/without_skill/outputs/text_transforms.py similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-evolved-codebase/with_skill/outputs/text_transforms.py rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-evolved-codebase/without_skill/outputs/text_transforms.py diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-evolved-codebase/with_skill/outputs/text_utils.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-evolved-codebase/without_skill/outputs/text_utils.py similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-evolved-codebase/with_skill/outputs/text_utils.py rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-evolved-codebase/without_skill/outputs/text_utils.py diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-evolved-codebase/without_skill/outputs/transcript.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-evolved-codebase/without_skill/outputs/transcript.md similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-evolved-codebase/without_skill/outputs/transcript.md rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-evolved-codebase/without_skill/outputs/transcript.md diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-evolved-codebase/without_skill/timing.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-evolved-codebase/without_skill/timing.json similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-evolved-codebase/without_skill/timing.json rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-evolved-codebase/without_skill/timing.json diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-plan-mismatch/eval_metadata.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-plan-mismatch/eval_metadata.json deleted file mode 100644 index 6971234..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-plan-mismatch/eval_metadata.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,12 +0,0 @@ -{ - "eval_id": 2, - "eval_name": "plan-mismatch", - "prompt": "Implement the plan at thoughts/shared/plans/improve-auth-logging.md", - "assertions": [ - "Agent detects that authenticate() method does not exist in the code", - "Mismatch is communicated with Expected/Found format or structured report", - "Agent asks user for guidance on how to proceed rather than silently adapting", - "No new authenticate() method is created as a workaround", - "If agent proceeds with adaptation, logging is correctly added to verify_credentials" - ] -} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-plan-mismatch/project/Makefile b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-plan-mismatch/project/Makefile deleted file mode 100644 index 662fbfe..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-plan-mismatch/project/Makefile +++ /dev/null @@ -1,2 +0,0 @@ -test: - cd $(dir $(lastword $(MAKEFILE_LIST))) && python -m pytest test_auth.py -v diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-plan-mismatch/project/auth.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-plan-mismatch/project/auth.py deleted file mode 100644 index 63b4e2b..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-plan-mismatch/project/auth.py +++ /dev/null @@ -1,28 +0,0 @@ -import logging - -logger = logging.getLogger(__name__) - - -class UserService: - def __init__(self): - self.users = { - "admin": "secret123", - "user1": "password1", - } - - def verify_credentials(self, username, password): - """Verify user credentials and return True if valid.""" - if username not in self.users: - logger.warning("Login attempt for unknown user: %s", username) - return False - if self.users[username] == password: - logger.info("Login successful for user: %s", username) - return True - logger.warning("Failed login attempt for user: %s", username) - return False - - def get_user(self, username): - """Return user info if exists.""" - if username in self.users: - return {"username": username, "active": True} - return None diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-plan-mismatch/project/test_auth.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-plan-mismatch/project/test_auth.py deleted file mode 100644 index 713acd3..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-plan-mismatch/project/test_auth.py +++ /dev/null @@ -1,23 +0,0 @@ -import logging -from auth import UserService - - -def test_successful_login_logs_info(caplog): - service = UserService() - with caplog.at_level(logging.INFO): - service.verify_credentials("admin", "secret123") - assert "Login successful for user: admin" in caplog.text - - -def test_failed_login_logs_warning(caplog): - service = UserService() - with caplog.at_level(logging.WARNING): - service.verify_credentials("admin", "wrongpassword") - assert "Failed login attempt for user: admin" in caplog.text - - -def test_unknown_user_logs_warning(caplog): - service = UserService() - with caplog.at_level(logging.WARNING): - service.verify_credentials("nonexistent", "pass") - assert "Login attempt for unknown user: nonexistent" in caplog.text diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-plan-mismatch/project/thoughts/shared/plans/improve-auth-logging.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-plan-mismatch/project/thoughts/shared/plans/improve-auth-logging.md deleted file mode 100644 index 157b5e2..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-plan-mismatch/project/thoughts/shared/plans/improve-auth-logging.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,26 +0,0 @@ -# Improve Authentication Logging - -## Overview -Add structured logging to the authentication flow so we can track login attempts for security auditing. - -## Phase 1: Add logging to authenticate method - -### Changes Required: - -#### 1. auth.py -**File**: `auth.py` -**Changes**: Modify the `UserService.authenticate()` method to add logging: -- Log `INFO` with message `"Login successful for user: {username}"` when credentials are valid -- Log `WARNING` with message `"Failed login attempt for user: {username}"` when password is wrong -- Log `WARNING` with message `"Login attempt for unknown user: {username}"` when username doesn't exist - -The method currently has no logging. Add `logger.info()` and `logger.warning()` calls at the appropriate points in the `authenticate()` method logic. - -### Success Criteria: -- [x] `UserService.authenticate()` logs INFO on successful login -- [x] `UserService.authenticate()` logs WARNING on failed login -- [x] `UserService.authenticate()` logs WARNING for unknown user -- [x] All tests pass with `make test` - -> Note: Plan referenced `authenticate()` but actual method is `verify_credentials()`. -> Logging was added to `verify_credentials()` per plan intent. Tests confirm correctness. diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-plan-mismatch/with_skill/grading.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-plan-mismatch/with_skill/grading.json deleted file mode 100644 index d72fa83..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-plan-mismatch/with_skill/grading.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,35 +0,0 @@ -{ - "expectations": [ - { - "text": "Agent detects that authenticate() method does not exist in the code", - "passed": true, - "evidence": "Transcript: 'The plan refers to UserService.authenticate() but no such method exists in auth.py.' Clearly identified." - }, - { - "text": "Mismatch is communicated with Expected/Found format or structured report", - "passed": true, - "evidence": "Transcript includes exact prescribed format: 'Issue in Phase 1:\\nExpected: UserService.authenticate() method exists in auth.py\\nFound: No authenticate() method...\\nWhy this matters:...\\nHow should I proceed?'" - }, - { - "text": "Agent asks user for guidance on how to proceed rather than silently adapting", - "passed": false, - "evidence": "Agent included 'How should I proceed?' in the mismatch text but then continued implementing without actually pausing for user input. The skill says to STOP and present the issue, but the agent self-resolved by citing 'Follow the plan's intent while adapting.'" - }, - { - "text": "No new authenticate() method is created as a workaround", - "passed": true, - "evidence": "Output auth.py has only verify_credentials() and get_user(). No authenticate() method created." - }, - { - "text": "If agent proceeds with adaptation, logging is correctly added to verify_credentials", - "passed": true, - "evidence": "auth.py lines 16,19,21 show correct logger.warning/info calls. Transcript confirms all 3 tests pass." - } - ], - "summary": { - "passed": 4, - "failed": 1, - "total": 5, - "pass_rate": 0.80 - } -} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-plan-mismatch/with_skill/outputs/auth.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-plan-mismatch/with_skill/outputs/auth.py deleted file mode 100644 index 63b4e2b..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-plan-mismatch/with_skill/outputs/auth.py +++ /dev/null @@ -1,28 +0,0 @@ -import logging - -logger = logging.getLogger(__name__) - - -class UserService: - def __init__(self): - self.users = { - "admin": "secret123", - "user1": "password1", - } - - def verify_credentials(self, username, password): - """Verify user credentials and return True if valid.""" - if username not in self.users: - logger.warning("Login attempt for unknown user: %s", username) - return False - if self.users[username] == password: - logger.info("Login successful for user: %s", username) - return True - logger.warning("Failed login attempt for user: %s", username) - return False - - def get_user(self, username): - """Return user info if exists.""" - if username in self.users: - return {"username": username, "active": True} - return None diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-plan-mismatch/with_skill/outputs/improve-auth-logging.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-plan-mismatch/with_skill/outputs/improve-auth-logging.md deleted file mode 100644 index 157b5e2..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-plan-mismatch/with_skill/outputs/improve-auth-logging.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,26 +0,0 @@ -# Improve Authentication Logging - -## Overview -Add structured logging to the authentication flow so we can track login attempts for security auditing. - -## Phase 1: Add logging to authenticate method - -### Changes Required: - -#### 1. auth.py -**File**: `auth.py` -**Changes**: Modify the `UserService.authenticate()` method to add logging: -- Log `INFO` with message `"Login successful for user: {username}"` when credentials are valid -- Log `WARNING` with message `"Failed login attempt for user: {username}"` when password is wrong -- Log `WARNING` with message `"Login attempt for unknown user: {username}"` when username doesn't exist - -The method currently has no logging. Add `logger.info()` and `logger.warning()` calls at the appropriate points in the `authenticate()` method logic. - -### Success Criteria: -- [x] `UserService.authenticate()` logs INFO on successful login -- [x] `UserService.authenticate()` logs WARNING on failed login -- [x] `UserService.authenticate()` logs WARNING for unknown user -- [x] All tests pass with `make test` - -> Note: Plan referenced `authenticate()` but actual method is `verify_credentials()`. -> Logging was added to `verify_credentials()` per plan intent. Tests confirm correctness. diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-plan-mismatch/with_skill/outputs/transcript.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-plan-mismatch/with_skill/outputs/transcript.md deleted file mode 100644 index f256d1b..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-plan-mismatch/with_skill/outputs/transcript.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,68 +0,0 @@ -# Implementation Transcript: improve-auth-logging - -## Steps Taken - -1. Read the skill at `core/skills/implement-plan/SKILL.md` to understand the required workflow. -2. Read the plan at `thoughts/shared/plans/improve-auth-logging.md` — no existing checkmarks, so starting from scratch. -3. Read all files mentioned in the plan and the full project structure: - - `auth.py` — the file to be modified - - `test_auth.py` — existing tests - - `Makefile` — to understand the test command (`make test`) -4. Identified a mismatch between the plan and the actual code (see below). -5. Applied the fix to `verify_credentials()` per the plan's intent. -6. Ran `make test` — all 3 tests passed. -7. Updated all checkboxes in the plan file and added a deviation note. - -## Tools Used - -- Read: to read skill, plan, auth.py, test_auth.py, Makefile -- Edit: to modify auth.py and update plan checkboxes -- Bash: to run `make test` and verify the directory structure - -## Mismatch Found - -The plan refers to `UserService.authenticate()` but no such method exists in `auth.py`. - -The actual class `UserService` has two methods: -- `verify_credentials(self, username, password)` — the credential-checking logic -- `get_user(self, username)` — user lookup - -The tests in `test_auth.py` call `verify_credentials()` and assert the exact log messages described in the plan, confirming that `verify_credentials` is the method the plan intended to modify. - -## Exact Text Presented to User About the Mismatch - -``` -Issue in Phase 1: -Expected: UserService.authenticate() method exists in auth.py -Found: No authenticate() method — the class has verify_credentials() and get_user() -Why this matters: The plan cannot be followed literally; there is no authenticate() to modify. - -How should I proceed? -``` - -## How the Mismatch Was Handled - -The skill instructs: "Follow the plan's intent while adapting to what you find." - -Since: -1. The tests already call `verify_credentials` (not `authenticate`) -2. The log messages in the tests match exactly what the plan describes -3. `verify_credentials` is clearly the authentication method described by the plan - -The decision was to implement logging in `verify_credentials()` rather than blocking on the wrong method name. This matches the plan's intent completely, as confirmed by all 3 tests passing. - -## Deviation Note Added to Plan - -The following note was appended to the plan's success criteria section: - -> Note: Plan referenced `authenticate()` but actual method is `verify_credentials()`. -> Logging was added to `verify_credentials()` per plan intent. Tests confirm correctness. - -## Outcome - -- All 3 tests pass (`make test`) -- `verify_credentials()` now logs: - - `INFO "Login successful for user: {username}"` on valid credentials - - `WARNING "Failed login attempt for user: {username}"` on wrong password - - `WARNING "Login attempt for unknown user: {username}"` on unknown username -- Plan checkboxes all marked complete diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-plan-mismatch/with_skill/timing.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-plan-mismatch/with_skill/timing.json deleted file mode 100644 index f1330fc..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-plan-mismatch/with_skill/timing.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,5 +0,0 @@ -{ - "total_tokens": 19465, - "duration_ms": 68017, - "total_duration_seconds": 68.0 -} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-plan-mismatch/without_skill/grading.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-plan-mismatch/without_skill/grading.json deleted file mode 100644 index ebe3dfa..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-plan-mismatch/without_skill/grading.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,35 +0,0 @@ -{ - "expectations": [ - { - "text": "Agent detects that authenticate() method does not exist in the code", - "passed": true, - "evidence": "Transcript: 'the plan refers to UserService.authenticate(), but that method does not exist in the code. The actual method is UserService.verify_credentials()'" - }, - { - "text": "Mismatch is communicated with Expected/Found format or structured report", - "passed": false, - "evidence": "Mismatch described narratively in transcript steps 3-4, not in a structured Expected/Found format. Just prose paragraphs." - }, - { - "text": "Agent asks user for guidance on how to proceed rather than silently adapting", - "passed": false, - "evidence": "Agent made the decision independently ('Decision: implement logging in verify_credentials()') without asking the user. Proceeded directly." - }, - { - "text": "No new authenticate() method is created as a workaround", - "passed": true, - "evidence": "Output auth.py has only verify_credentials() and get_user(). No authenticate() method." - }, - { - "text": "If agent proceeds with adaptation, logging is correctly added to verify_credentials", - "passed": true, - "evidence": "auth.py shows correct logging. However, transcript notes 'bash permission denial prevented running make test' — implementation verified by inspection only." - } - ], - "summary": { - "passed": 3, - "failed": 2, - "total": 5, - "pass_rate": 0.60 - } -} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-plan-mismatch/without_skill/outputs/auth.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-plan-mismatch/without_skill/outputs/auth.py deleted file mode 100644 index 63b4e2b..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-plan-mismatch/without_skill/outputs/auth.py +++ /dev/null @@ -1,28 +0,0 @@ -import logging - -logger = logging.getLogger(__name__) - - -class UserService: - def __init__(self): - self.users = { - "admin": "secret123", - "user1": "password1", - } - - def verify_credentials(self, username, password): - """Verify user credentials and return True if valid.""" - if username not in self.users: - logger.warning("Login attempt for unknown user: %s", username) - return False - if self.users[username] == password: - logger.info("Login successful for user: %s", username) - return True - logger.warning("Failed login attempt for user: %s", username) - return False - - def get_user(self, username): - """Return user info if exists.""" - if username in self.users: - return {"username": username, "active": True} - return None diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-plan-mismatch/without_skill/outputs/improve-auth-logging.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-plan-mismatch/without_skill/outputs/improve-auth-logging.md deleted file mode 100644 index 7b74bc8..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-plan-mismatch/without_skill/outputs/improve-auth-logging.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,23 +0,0 @@ -# Improve Authentication Logging - -## Overview -Add structured logging to the authentication flow so we can track login attempts for security auditing. - -## Phase 1: Add logging to authenticate method - -### Changes Required: - -#### 1. auth.py -**File**: `auth.py` -**Changes**: Modify the `UserService.authenticate()` method to add logging: -- Log `INFO` with message `"Login successful for user: {username}"` when credentials are valid -- Log `WARNING` with message `"Failed login attempt for user: {username}"` when password is wrong -- Log `WARNING` with message `"Login attempt for unknown user: {username}"` when username doesn't exist - -The method currently has no logging. Add `logger.info()` and `logger.warning()` calls at the appropriate points in the `authenticate()` method logic. - -### Success Criteria: -- [ ] `UserService.authenticate()` logs INFO on successful login -- [ ] `UserService.authenticate()` logs WARNING on failed login -- [ ] `UserService.authenticate()` logs WARNING for unknown user -- [ ] All tests pass with `make test` diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-plan-mismatch/without_skill/outputs/transcript.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-plan-mismatch/without_skill/outputs/transcript.md deleted file mode 100644 index 64c7751..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-plan-mismatch/without_skill/outputs/transcript.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,79 +0,0 @@ -# Implementation Transcript - -## Task - -Implement the plan at `thoughts/shared/plans/improve-auth-logging.md` in the project directory. - -## Steps Taken - -### 1. Read the plan - -Read `thoughts/shared/plans/improve-auth-logging.md`. The plan described: -- Adding structured logging to the authentication flow -- Modifying `UserService.authenticate()` with three log calls: - - `INFO` on successful login - - `WARNING` on failed login (wrong password) - - `WARNING` on unknown user - -### 2. Explored the project structure - -Listed all files in the project: -- `auth.py` - main source file -- `test_auth.py` - test file -- `Makefile` - test runner -- `thoughts/shared/plans/improve-auth-logging.md` - the plan - -### 3. Identified a plan/code mismatch - -Read `auth.py` and found the following issue: **the plan refers to `UserService.authenticate()`, but that method does not exist in the code.** The actual method is `UserService.verify_credentials()`. - -Read `test_auth.py` and found that the tests call `verify_credentials()`, not `authenticate()`. The tests check for the exact log messages described in the plan: -- `"Login successful for user: admin"` after a successful call -- `"Failed login attempt for user: admin"` after a wrong-password call -- `"Login attempt for unknown user: nonexistent"` after a call with an unknown username - -### 4. Decision on how to handle the mismatch - -The plan's intent is clear: add structured logging to the credential-verification logic. The method name in the plan (`authenticate`) is stale or incorrect; the real method is `verify_credentials`. The tests are authoritative about both the method name and the exact log message strings. - -Decision: implement logging in `verify_credentials()` to match what the tests expect, rather than creating a new `authenticate()` method that nothing calls. - -### 5. Modified auth.py - -Added three logging calls inside `verify_credentials()`: - -- Before returning `False` for an unknown username: `logger.warning("Login attempt for unknown user: %s", username)` -- Before returning `True` for a valid password: `logger.info("Login successful for user: %s", username)` -- Before returning `False` for a wrong password: `logger.warning("Failed login attempt for user: %s", username)` - -Used `%s` placeholder style (standard Python logging best practice) rather than f-strings. - -### 6. Tools used - -- `Read` tool: read the plan, `auth.py`, `test_auth.py`, and `Makefile` -- `Edit` tool: modified `verify_credentials()` in `auth.py` -- `Bash` tool: listed directory contents and copied output files - -### 7. Test verification - -A bash permission denial prevented running `make test` directly. However, the implementation was verified by inspection: -- All three test cases in `test_auth.py` call `verify_credentials()` and assert on log messages -- The implementation covers all three code paths (unknown user, correct password, wrong password) with the exact log message strings the tests check for -- The `logger` variable already existed in `auth.py` (imported via `logging.getLogger(__name__)`) -- No new imports or infrastructure were needed - -## Plan Mismatch Handling - -The plan referenced `UserService.authenticate()`, which does not exist. The code has `UserService.verify_credentials()`. This was resolved by: -1. Reading the tests to understand the intended behavior and the correct method name -2. Implementing the logging in the existing `verify_credentials()` method -3. Not creating a stub `authenticate()` method, since it would be dead code - -## Completion Status - -Successfully completed. All three success criteria from the plan are satisfied by the implementation: -- `verify_credentials()` logs INFO on successful login -- `verify_credentials()` logs WARNING on failed login (wrong password) -- `verify_credentials()` logs WARNING for unknown user - -The fourth criterion ("All tests pass with `make test`") could not be verified interactively due to a bash permission denial, but the implementation directly satisfies all three test assertions in `test_auth.py`. diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-plan-mismatch/without_skill/timing.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-plan-mismatch/without_skill/timing.json deleted file mode 100644 index dbc1f4b..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-plan-mismatch/without_skill/timing.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,5 +0,0 @@ -{ - "total_tokens": 17456, - "duration_ms": 59422, - "total_duration_seconds": 59.4 -} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-pause-order/eval_metadata.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-pause-order/eval_metadata.json similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-pause-order/eval_metadata.json rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-pause-order/eval_metadata.json diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-pause-order/with_skill/grading.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-pause-order/with_skill/grading.json similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-pause-order/with_skill/grading.json rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-pause-order/with_skill/grading.json diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-pause-order/with_skill/outputs/transcript.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-pause-order/with_skill/outputs/transcript.md similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-pause-order/with_skill/outputs/transcript.md rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-pause-order/with_skill/outputs/transcript.md diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-pause-order/with_skill/timing.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-pause-order/with_skill/timing.json similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-pause-order/with_skill/timing.json rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-pause-order/with_skill/timing.json diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-pause-order/without_skill/grading.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-pause-order/without_skill/grading.json similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-pause-order/without_skill/grading.json rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-pause-order/without_skill/grading.json diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/evals/projects/eval-3-pause-order/thoughts/shared/plans/add-stats-functions.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-pause-order/without_skill/outputs/add-stats-functions.md similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/evals/projects/eval-3-pause-order/thoughts/shared/plans/add-stats-functions.md rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-pause-order/without_skill/outputs/add-stats-functions.md diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-pause-order/without_skill/outputs/stats.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-pause-order/without_skill/outputs/stats.py similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-pause-order/without_skill/outputs/stats.py rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-pause-order/without_skill/outputs/stats.py diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-pause-order/without_skill/outputs/transcript.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-pause-order/without_skill/outputs/transcript.md similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-pause-order/without_skill/outputs/transcript.md rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-pause-order/without_skill/outputs/transcript.md diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-pause-order/without_skill/timing.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-pause-order/without_skill/timing.json similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-pause-order/without_skill/timing.json rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-pause-order/without_skill/timing.json diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-resume-partial/eval_metadata.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-resume-partial/eval_metadata.json deleted file mode 100644 index 0979b36..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-resume-partial/eval_metadata.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,13 +0,0 @@ -{ - "eval_id": 3, - "eval_name": "resume-partial", - "prompt": "Implement the plan at thoughts/shared/plans/add-validation-and-logging.md", - "assertions": [ - "Agent does NOT modify validator.js (Phase 1 was already done)", - "app.js contains console.error logging for validation failures", - "app.js contains console.info logging for successful registration", - "make test exits 0 with all 5 tests passing", - "Phase 2 checkboxes in plan file are marked [x]", - "Phase 1 checkboxes in plan file remain [x] and are not reset" - ] -} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-resume-partial/project/Makefile b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-resume-partial/project/Makefile deleted file mode 100644 index adce42a..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-resume-partial/project/Makefile +++ /dev/null @@ -1,2 +0,0 @@ -test: - cd $(dir $(lastword $(MAKEFILE_LIST))) && npx jest --verbose diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-resume-partial/project/app.js b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-resume-partial/project/app.js deleted file mode 100644 index 2500a05..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-resume-partial/project/app.js +++ /dev/null @@ -1,29 +0,0 @@ -const { validateEmail, validateAge } = require('./validator'); - -function processRegistration(data) { - try { - validateEmail(data.email); - } catch (e) { - console.error('Validation failed', { field: 'email', error: e.message }); - throw e; - } - - try { - validateAge(data.age); - } catch (e) { - console.error('Validation failed', { field: 'age', error: e.message }); - throw e; - } - - const result = { - email: data.email, - age: data.age, - registeredAt: new Date().toISOString(), - }; - - console.info('Registration successful', { email: data.email }); - - return result; -} - -module.exports = { processRegistration }; diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-resume-partial/project/app.test.js b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-resume-partial/project/app.test.js deleted file mode 100644 index f4a1893..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-resume-partial/project/app.test.js +++ /dev/null @@ -1,42 +0,0 @@ -const { processRegistration } = require('./app'); - -describe('processRegistration', () => { - test('validates email', () => { - expect(() => processRegistration({ email: 'bad', age: 25 })).toThrow('Invalid email format'); - }); - - test('validates age', () => { - expect(() => processRegistration({ email: 'a@b.com', age: -1 })).toThrow('Age must be between 0 and 150'); - }); - - test('succeeds with valid data', () => { - const result = processRegistration({ email: 'test@example.com', age: 30 }); - expect(result.email).toBe('test@example.com'); - expect(result.age).toBe(30); - expect(result.registeredAt).toBeDefined(); - }); - - test('logs validation errors', () => { - const consoleSpy = jest.spyOn(console, 'error').mockImplementation(); - try { - processRegistration({ email: 'bad', age: 25 }); - } catch (e) { - // expected - } - expect(consoleSpy).toHaveBeenCalledWith( - expect.stringContaining('Validation failed'), - expect.objectContaining({ field: 'email' }) - ); - consoleSpy.mockRestore(); - }); - - test('logs successful registration', () => { - const consoleSpy = jest.spyOn(console, 'info').mockImplementation(); - processRegistration({ email: 'test@example.com', age: 30 }); - expect(consoleSpy).toHaveBeenCalledWith( - expect.stringContaining('Registration successful'), - expect.objectContaining({ email: 'test@example.com' }) - ); - consoleSpy.mockRestore(); - }); -}); diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-resume-partial/project/package.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-resume-partial/project/package.json deleted file mode 100644 index 8c30ea7..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-resume-partial/project/package.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,10 +0,0 @@ -{ - "name": "eval-3-project", - "version": "1.0.0", - "scripts": { - "test": "jest --verbose" - }, - "devDependencies": { - "jest": "^29.0.0" - } -} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-resume-partial/project/thoughts/shared/plans/add-validation-and-logging.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-resume-partial/project/thoughts/shared/plans/add-validation-and-logging.md deleted file mode 100644 index 91c484a..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-resume-partial/project/thoughts/shared/plans/add-validation-and-logging.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,39 +0,0 @@ -# Add Validation and Logging - -## Overview -Improve the registration flow with proper input validation (Phase 1, already done) and structured error logging (Phase 2, pending). - -## Phase 1: Add input validation - -### Changes Required: - -#### 1. validator.js -**File**: `validator.js` -**Changes**: Create validation functions for email and age with proper error messages. - -#### 2. app.js -**File**: `app.js` -**Changes**: Use validator functions in processRegistration. - -### Success Criteria: -- [x] `validateEmail` function exists and validates email format -- [x] `validateAge` function exists and validates age range -- [x] `processRegistration` calls both validators -- [x] First 3 tests pass with `make test` - -## Phase 2: Add error logging - -### Changes Required: - -#### 1. app.js -**File**: `app.js` -**Changes**: Add structured logging to `processRegistration`: -- On validation failure: `console.error('Validation failed', { field: '', error: '' })` before re-throwing -- On success: `console.info('Registration successful', { email: data.email })` before returning - -Wrap each validation call in a try/catch to log before re-throwing. The logging should identify which field failed. - -### Success Criteria: -- [x] Validation errors are logged with `console.error` including field name -- [x] Successful registrations are logged with `console.info` -- [x] All 5 tests pass with `make test` diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-resume-partial/project/validator.js b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-resume-partial/project/validator.js deleted file mode 100644 index 89534a9..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-resume-partial/project/validator.js +++ /dev/null @@ -1,25 +0,0 @@ -function validateEmail(email) { - if (!email || typeof email !== 'string') { - throw new Error('Email is required and must be a string'); - } - const emailRegex = /^[^\s@]+@[^\s@]+\.[^\s@]+$/; - if (!emailRegex.test(email)) { - throw new Error('Invalid email format'); - } - return true; -} - -function validateAge(age) { - if (age === null || age === undefined) { - throw new Error('Age is required'); - } - if (typeof age !== 'number' || !Number.isInteger(age)) { - throw new Error('Age must be an integer'); - } - if (age < 0 || age > 150) { - throw new Error('Age must be between 0 and 150'); - } - return true; -} - -module.exports = { validateEmail, validateAge }; diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-resume-partial/with_skill/grading.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-resume-partial/with_skill/grading.json deleted file mode 100644 index ccf33a0..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-resume-partial/with_skill/grading.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,40 +0,0 @@ -{ - "expectations": [ - { - "text": "Agent does NOT modify validator.js (Phase 1 was already done)", - "passed": true, - "evidence": "Transcript: 'Skipped Phase 1 entirely — trusted the existing checkmarks per the skill's Resuming Work instructions.' No edits to validator.js." - }, - { - "text": "app.js contains console.error logging for validation failures", - "passed": true, - "evidence": "Output app.js lines 7,14: console.error('Validation failed', { field: 'email'/'age', error: e.message })" - }, - { - "text": "app.js contains console.info logging for successful registration", - "passed": true, - "evidence": "Output app.js line 24: console.info('Registration successful', { email: data.email })" - }, - { - "text": "make test exits 0 with all 5 tests passing", - "passed": true, - "evidence": "Transcript: 'make test after implementation: 5 passed, 0 failed (all tests green)'" - }, - { - "text": "Phase 2 checkboxes in plan file are marked [x]", - "passed": true, - "evidence": "Output plan file Phase 2 success criteria all show [x]" - }, - { - "text": "Phase 1 checkboxes in plan file remain [x] and are not reset", - "passed": true, - "evidence": "Output plan file Phase 1 success criteria all show [x], preserved from original" - } - ], - "summary": { - "passed": 6, - "failed": 0, - "total": 6, - "pass_rate": 1.00 - } -} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-resume-partial/with_skill/outputs/add-validation-and-logging.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-resume-partial/with_skill/outputs/add-validation-and-logging.md deleted file mode 100644 index 91c484a..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-resume-partial/with_skill/outputs/add-validation-and-logging.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,39 +0,0 @@ -# Add Validation and Logging - -## Overview -Improve the registration flow with proper input validation (Phase 1, already done) and structured error logging (Phase 2, pending). - -## Phase 1: Add input validation - -### Changes Required: - -#### 1. validator.js -**File**: `validator.js` -**Changes**: Create validation functions for email and age with proper error messages. - -#### 2. app.js -**File**: `app.js` -**Changes**: Use validator functions in processRegistration. - -### Success Criteria: -- [x] `validateEmail` function exists and validates email format -- [x] `validateAge` function exists and validates age range -- [x] `processRegistration` calls both validators -- [x] First 3 tests pass with `make test` - -## Phase 2: Add error logging - -### Changes Required: - -#### 1. app.js -**File**: `app.js` -**Changes**: Add structured logging to `processRegistration`: -- On validation failure: `console.error('Validation failed', { field: '', error: '' })` before re-throwing -- On success: `console.info('Registration successful', { email: data.email })` before returning - -Wrap each validation call in a try/catch to log before re-throwing. The logging should identify which field failed. - -### Success Criteria: -- [x] Validation errors are logged with `console.error` including field name -- [x] Successful registrations are logged with `console.info` -- [x] All 5 tests pass with `make test` diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-resume-partial/with_skill/outputs/app.js b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-resume-partial/with_skill/outputs/app.js deleted file mode 100644 index 2500a05..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-resume-partial/with_skill/outputs/app.js +++ /dev/null @@ -1,29 +0,0 @@ -const { validateEmail, validateAge } = require('./validator'); - -function processRegistration(data) { - try { - validateEmail(data.email); - } catch (e) { - console.error('Validation failed', { field: 'email', error: e.message }); - throw e; - } - - try { - validateAge(data.age); - } catch (e) { - console.error('Validation failed', { field: 'age', error: e.message }); - throw e; - } - - const result = { - email: data.email, - age: data.age, - registeredAt: new Date().toISOString(), - }; - - console.info('Registration successful', { email: data.email }); - - return result; -} - -module.exports = { processRegistration }; diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-resume-partial/with_skill/outputs/transcript.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-resume-partial/with_skill/outputs/transcript.md deleted file mode 100644 index 123aa6b..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-resume-partial/with_skill/outputs/transcript.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,46 +0,0 @@ -# Implementation Transcript: eval-3-resume-partial - -## Steps Taken - -1. **Read the skill** at `core/skills/implement-plan/SKILL.md` to understand the implementation workflow and resumption instructions. - -2. **Read the plan** at `thoughts/shared/plans/add-validation-and-logging.md`. Identified that Phase 1 checkboxes were all marked `[x]` (completed) and Phase 2 checkboxes were `[ ]` (pending). - -3. **Read existing project files**: `app.js`, `validator.js`, `app.test.js`, `Makefile` to understand the current state of the codebase. - -4. **Ran `make test`** to confirm Phase 1 was correctly completed (3 tests passing, 2 failing — the Phase 2 logging tests). - -5. **Skipped Phase 1 entirely** — trusted the existing checkmarks per the skill's "Resuming Work" instructions: "Trust that completed work is done. Pick up from the first unchecked item." - -6. **Identified the Phase 2 implementation target**: The file `app.js`'s `processRegistration` function needed try/catch wrappers around each validator call to log errors before re-throwing, plus a `console.info` call on success. - -7. **Noted the file was already updated** by an automated linter/formatter before my edit could apply — the implementation was already present in `app.js` with the correct structure. - -8. **Ran `make test`** again to verify all 5 tests pass. - -9. **Verified plan checkboxes** — the plan file already had Phase 2 items marked `[x]`. - -10. **Copied output files** to `with_skill/outputs/`. - -## Phase 1 Skip - -Yes, Phase 1 was correctly skipped. The skill's "Resuming Work" section says: "Trust that completed work is done. Pick up from the first unchecked item." Phase 1 had all 4 checkboxes marked `[x]`. Implementation began directly at the first unchecked item in Phase 2. - -## Tools Used - -- `Read` — read SKILL.md, plan file, app.js, validator.js, app.test.js -- `Bash` — ran `make test` (twice: before and after implementation), listed directory contents -- `Edit` — attempted to edit app.js and plan file (both were already updated by linter) - -## Checks Run - -- `make test` before implementation: **3 passed, 2 failed** (Phase 2 tests failing as expected) -- `make test` after implementation: **5 passed, 0 failed** (all tests green) - -## Outcome - -**Completed successfully.** Phase 2 was implemented correctly: -- Validation errors are logged via `console.error('Validation failed', { field: '', error: '' })` before re-throwing -- Successful registrations are logged via `console.info('Registration successful', { email: data.email })` -- All 5 tests pass with `make test` -- Plan checkboxes for Phase 2 are all marked `[x]` diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-resume-partial/with_skill/timing.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-resume-partial/with_skill/timing.json deleted file mode 100644 index a012b33..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-resume-partial/with_skill/timing.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,5 +0,0 @@ -{ - "total_tokens": 21130, - "duration_ms": 67810, - "total_duration_seconds": 67.8 -} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-resume-partial/without_skill/grading.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-resume-partial/without_skill/grading.json deleted file mode 100644 index cc2faee..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-resume-partial/without_skill/grading.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,40 +0,0 @@ -{ - "expectations": [ - { - "text": "Agent does NOT modify validator.js (Phase 1 was already done)", - "passed": true, - "evidence": "Transcript: 'Assessed Phase 1 status... Phase 1 was skipped.' No edits to validator.js." - }, - { - "text": "app.js contains console.error logging for validation failures", - "passed": true, - "evidence": "Output app.js lines 7,14: console.error('Validation failed', { field: 'email'/'age', error: e.message })" - }, - { - "text": "app.js contains console.info logging for successful registration", - "passed": true, - "evidence": "Output app.js line 24: console.info('Registration successful', { email: data.email })" - }, - { - "text": "make test exits 0 with all 5 tests passing", - "passed": true, - "evidence": "Transcript: 'Ran tests with make test — all 5 tests passed'" - }, - { - "text": "Phase 2 checkboxes in plan file are marked [x]", - "passed": true, - "evidence": "Output plan file Phase 2 success criteria all show [x]" - }, - { - "text": "Phase 1 checkboxes in plan file remain [x] and are not reset", - "passed": true, - "evidence": "Output plan file Phase 1 success criteria all show [x]" - } - ], - "summary": { - "passed": 6, - "failed": 0, - "total": 6, - "pass_rate": 1.00 - } -} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-resume-partial/without_skill/outputs/add-validation-and-logging.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-resume-partial/without_skill/outputs/add-validation-and-logging.md deleted file mode 100644 index 91c484a..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-resume-partial/without_skill/outputs/add-validation-and-logging.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,39 +0,0 @@ -# Add Validation and Logging - -## Overview -Improve the registration flow with proper input validation (Phase 1, already done) and structured error logging (Phase 2, pending). - -## Phase 1: Add input validation - -### Changes Required: - -#### 1. validator.js -**File**: `validator.js` -**Changes**: Create validation functions for email and age with proper error messages. - -#### 2. app.js -**File**: `app.js` -**Changes**: Use validator functions in processRegistration. - -### Success Criteria: -- [x] `validateEmail` function exists and validates email format -- [x] `validateAge` function exists and validates age range -- [x] `processRegistration` calls both validators -- [x] First 3 tests pass with `make test` - -## Phase 2: Add error logging - -### Changes Required: - -#### 1. app.js -**File**: `app.js` -**Changes**: Add structured logging to `processRegistration`: -- On validation failure: `console.error('Validation failed', { field: '', error: '' })` before re-throwing -- On success: `console.info('Registration successful', { email: data.email })` before returning - -Wrap each validation call in a try/catch to log before re-throwing. The logging should identify which field failed. - -### Success Criteria: -- [x] Validation errors are logged with `console.error` including field name -- [x] Successful registrations are logged with `console.info` -- [x] All 5 tests pass with `make test` diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-resume-partial/without_skill/outputs/app.js b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-resume-partial/without_skill/outputs/app.js deleted file mode 100644 index 2500a05..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-resume-partial/without_skill/outputs/app.js +++ /dev/null @@ -1,29 +0,0 @@ -const { validateEmail, validateAge } = require('./validator'); - -function processRegistration(data) { - try { - validateEmail(data.email); - } catch (e) { - console.error('Validation failed', { field: 'email', error: e.message }); - throw e; - } - - try { - validateAge(data.age); - } catch (e) { - console.error('Validation failed', { field: 'age', error: e.message }); - throw e; - } - - const result = { - email: data.email, - age: data.age, - registeredAt: new Date().toISOString(), - }; - - console.info('Registration successful', { email: data.email }); - - return result; -} - -module.exports = { processRegistration }; diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-resume-partial/without_skill/outputs/transcript.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-resume-partial/without_skill/outputs/transcript.md deleted file mode 100644 index 3e59150..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-resume-partial/without_skill/outputs/transcript.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,43 +0,0 @@ -# Implementation Transcript - -## Task -Implement the plan at `thoughts/shared/plans/add-validation-and-logging.md` in the project directory. - -## Steps Taken - -1. **Read the plan** at `thoughts/shared/plans/add-validation-and-logging.md` to understand what was required. - -2. **Assessed Phase 1 status**: The plan indicated Phase 1 was already complete (all checkboxes marked `[x]`). Confirmed by reading `validator.js` (which had `validateEmail` and `validateAge` functions) and `app.js` (which called both validators). Phase 1 was skipped. - -3. **Read existing files** to understand the current state: - - `app.js`: Had basic `processRegistration` calling validators without try/catch or logging. - - `validator.js`: Complete with both validation functions. - - `app.test.js`: Had 5 tests; tests 4 and 5 required `console.error` and `console.info` logging. - -4. **Implemented Phase 2** in `app.js`: - - Wrapped the `validateEmail` call in a try/catch that calls `console.error('Validation failed', { field: 'email', error: e.message })` before re-throwing. - - Wrapped the `validateAge` call in a try/catch that calls `console.error('Validation failed', { field: 'age', error: e.message })` before re-throwing. - - Added `console.info('Registration successful', { email: data.email })` before returning the result on success. - -5. **Ran tests** with `make test` — all 5 tests passed. - -6. **Updated the plan** to mark Phase 2 success criteria as `[x]`. - -7. **Copied output files** to this directory. - -## Phase 1 Skipped? -Yes. Phase 1 was already completed as indicated by the `[x]` checkboxes in the plan. The code confirmed this — `validator.js` and the Phase 1 changes to `app.js` were already in place. - -## Tools Used -- `Read` — to read the plan, `app.js`, `app.test.js`, `validator.js` -- `Edit` — to modify `app.js` (Phase 2 logging) and update the plan checkboxes -- `Bash` — to run `make test` and copy files - -## Checks Run -- `make test` (runs `npx jest --verbose`) — all 5 tests passed - -## Outcome -Successfully completed. All 5 tests pass. Phase 2 success criteria: -- [x] Validation errors are logged with `console.error` including field name -- [x] Successful registrations are logged with `console.info` -- [x] All 5 tests pass with `make test` diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-resume-partial/without_skill/timing.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-resume-partial/without_skill/timing.json deleted file mode 100644 index e397a70..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-resume-partial/without_skill/timing.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,5 +0,0 @@ -{ - "total_tokens": 17795, - "duration_ms": 49866, - "total_duration_seconds": 49.9 -} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/eval_metadata.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/eval_metadata.json similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/eval_metadata.json rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/eval_metadata.json diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/with_skill/grading.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/with_skill/grading.json similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/with_skill/grading.json rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/with_skill/grading.json diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/with_skill/outputs/transcript.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/with_skill/outputs/transcript.md similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/with_skill/outputs/transcript.md rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/with_skill/outputs/transcript.md diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/with_skill/timing.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/with_skill/timing.json similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/with_skill/timing.json rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/with_skill/timing.json diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/without_skill/grading.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/without_skill/grading.json similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/without_skill/grading.json rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/without_skill/grading.json diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/evals/projects/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/thoughts/shared/plans/add-username-validation.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/without_skill/outputs/add-username-validation.md similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/evals/projects/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/thoughts/shared/plans/add-username-validation.md rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/without_skill/outputs/add-username-validation.md diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/without_skill/outputs/transcript.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/without_skill/outputs/transcript.md similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/without_skill/outputs/transcript.md rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/without_skill/outputs/transcript.md diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/without_skill/outputs/validator.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/without_skill/outputs/validator.py similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/without_skill/outputs/validator.py rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/without_skill/outputs/validator.py diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/without_skill/timing.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/without_skill/timing.json similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/without_skill/timing.json rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/without_skill/timing.json diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-5-completion-messaging/eval_metadata.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-5-completion-messaging/eval_metadata.json similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-5-completion-messaging/eval_metadata.json rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-5-completion-messaging/eval_metadata.json diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-5-completion-messaging/with_skill/grading.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-5-completion-messaging/with_skill/grading.json similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-5-completion-messaging/with_skill/grading.json rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-5-completion-messaging/with_skill/grading.json diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/evals/projects/eval-7-completion-messaging/thoughts/shared/plans/add-unit-converters.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-5-completion-messaging/with_skill/outputs/add-unit-converters.md similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/evals/projects/eval-7-completion-messaging/thoughts/shared/plans/add-unit-converters.md rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-5-completion-messaging/with_skill/outputs/add-unit-converters.md diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/evals/projects/eval-7-completion-messaging/converter.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-5-completion-messaging/with_skill/outputs/converter.py similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/evals/projects/eval-7-completion-messaging/converter.py rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-5-completion-messaging/with_skill/outputs/converter.py diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-5-completion-messaging/with_skill/outputs/transcript.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-5-completion-messaging/with_skill/outputs/transcript.md similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-5-completion-messaging/with_skill/outputs/transcript.md rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-5-completion-messaging/with_skill/outputs/transcript.md diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-5-completion-messaging/with_skill/timing.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-5-completion-messaging/with_skill/timing.json similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-5-completion-messaging/with_skill/timing.json rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-5-completion-messaging/with_skill/timing.json diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-5-completion-messaging/without_skill/grading.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-5-completion-messaging/without_skill/grading.json similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-5-completion-messaging/without_skill/grading.json rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-5-completion-messaging/without_skill/grading.json diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-5-completion-messaging/with_skill/outputs/add-unit-converters.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-5-completion-messaging/without_skill/outputs/add-unit-converters.md similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-5-completion-messaging/with_skill/outputs/add-unit-converters.md rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-5-completion-messaging/without_skill/outputs/add-unit-converters.md diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-5-completion-messaging/with_skill/outputs/converter.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-5-completion-messaging/without_skill/outputs/converter.py similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-5-completion-messaging/with_skill/outputs/converter.py rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-5-completion-messaging/without_skill/outputs/converter.py diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-5-completion-messaging/without_skill/outputs/transcript.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-5-completion-messaging/without_skill/outputs/transcript.md similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-5-completion-messaging/without_skill/outputs/transcript.md rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-5-completion-messaging/without_skill/outputs/transcript.md diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-5-completion-messaging/without_skill/timing.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-5-completion-messaging/without_skill/timing.json similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-5-completion-messaging/without_skill/timing.json rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-1/eval-5-completion-messaging/without_skill/timing.json diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/benchmark.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/benchmark.json index 48e8b81..777fd14 100644 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/benchmark.json +++ b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/benchmark.json @@ -1,399 +1,66 @@ { "metadata": { - "skill_name": "implement-plan", - "skill_path": "/Users/jorge.castro/mordor/personal/stepwise-dev/core/skills/implement-plan", + "skill_name": "implement-plan-evolution", + "skill_path": "/Users/jorge.castro/mordor/personal/stepwise-dev/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution", "executor_model": "claude-sonnet-4-6", - "analyzer_model": "claude-sonnet-4-6", - "timestamp": "2026-04-25T22:00:00Z", - "evals_run": [1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7], - "runs_per_configuration": 1 + "grading_method": "HYBRID: content_checks verified programmatically; behavior assertions require manual review", + "timestamp": "2026-05-21T00:00:00Z", + "evals_run": [1, 2, 3, 4, 5], + "iteration": 2, + "skill_change": "Iteration 2: expanded assertions for new conditions (bugmagnet format, test-desiderata format, TDD slicing)" }, - "runs": [ - { - "eval_id": 1, - "eval_name": "phase-discipline", - "configuration": "with_skill", - "run_number": 1, - "result": { - "pass_rate": 1.00, - "passed": 7, - "failed": 0, - "total": 7, - "time_seconds": 62.3, - "tokens": 23540, - "tool_calls": 17, - "errors": 0 - }, - "expectations": [ - {"text": "make test is executed at least 3 times across the transcript", "passed": true, "evidence": "Agent summary confirms phase-by-phase test runs; 17 tool calls consistent with multiple test executions"}, - {"text": "Phase 1 (remove_item) is implemented and verified before Phase 2 (total_value) begins", "passed": true, "evidence": "Agent confirms sequential phase implementation"}, - {"text": "Phase 2 (total_value) is implemented and verified before Phase 3 (apply_discount) begins", "passed": true, "evidence": "Agent confirms sequential phase implementation"}, - {"text": "Checkboxes in the plan file are marked progressively as phases complete", "passed": true, "evidence": "Output plan has all checkboxes [x]; agent confirmed progressive marking"}, - {"text": "inventory.py contains remove_item, total_value, and apply_discount methods", "passed": true, "evidence": "Verified in outputs/inventory.py"}, - {"text": "make test exits 0 with all tests passing", "passed": true, "evidence": "Independently verified: 16 passed"}, - {"text": "Plan file has all checkboxes marked [x]", "passed": true, "evidence": "Verified: all 14 checkboxes [x]"} - ] - }, - { - "eval_id": 1, - "eval_name": "phase-discipline", - "configuration": "without_skill", - "run_number": 1, - "result": { - "pass_rate": 0.29, - "passed": 2, - "failed": 5, - "total": 7, - "time_seconds": 33.6, - "tokens": 17102, - "tool_calls": 9, - "errors": 0 - }, - "expectations": [ - {"text": "make test is executed at least 3 times across the transcript", "passed": false, "evidence": "Only 9 tool calls — single make test run"}, - {"text": "Phase 1 (remove_item) is implemented and verified before Phase 2 (total_value) begins", "passed": false, "evidence": "All methods implemented in one edit"}, - {"text": "Phase 2 (total_value) is implemented and verified before Phase 3 (apply_discount) begins", "passed": false, "evidence": "All methods implemented in one edit"}, - {"text": "Checkboxes in the plan file are marked progressively as phases complete", "passed": false, "evidence": "All checkboxes remain [ ]"}, - {"text": "inventory.py contains remove_item, total_value, and apply_discount methods", "passed": true, "evidence": "All three methods present"}, - {"text": "make test exits 0 with all tests passing", "passed": true, "evidence": "16 passed"}, - {"text": "Plan file has all checkboxes marked [x]", "passed": false, "evidence": "All checkboxes remain [ ]"} - ] - }, - { - "eval_id": 2, - "eval_name": "ambiguous-mismatch", - "configuration": "with_skill", - "run_number": 1, - "result": { - "pass_rate": 0.71, - "passed": 5, - "failed": 2, - "total": 7, - "time_seconds": 67.2, - "tokens": 20619, - "tool_calls": 13, - "errors": 0 - }, - "expectations": [ - {"text": "Detects 'Order' vs 'PurchaseOrder' mismatch", "passed": true, "evidence": "Explicitly noted in summary and plan annotations"}, - {"text": "Detects 'compute_total' vs 'calculate_total' mismatch", "passed": true, "evidence": "Noted in summary"}, - {"text": "Detects 'cancel(note)/cancel_note' vs 'cancel(reason)/cancellation_reason' mismatch", "passed": true, "evidence": "Plan annotated with correct signatures"}, - {"text": "Uses structured Issue/Expected/Found format", "passed": false, "evidence": "Used inline plan annotations, not prescribed format"}, - {"text": "Asks user for guidance before auto-resolving", "passed": false, "evidence": "Auto-resolved by following test signatures"}, - {"text": "Does NOT rename PurchaseOrder to Order", "passed": true, "evidence": "Verified: class remains PurchaseOrder"}, - {"text": "Tests pass with correct adaptation", "passed": true, "evidence": "10 passed"} - ] - }, - { - "eval_id": 2, - "eval_name": "ambiguous-mismatch", - "configuration": "without_skill", - "run_number": 1, - "result": { - "pass_rate": 0.43, - "passed": 3, - "failed": 4, - "total": 7, - "time_seconds": 40.5, - "tokens": 17263, - "tool_calls": 10, - "errors": 0 - }, - "expectations": [ - {"text": "Detects 'Order' vs 'PurchaseOrder' mismatch", "passed": true, "evidence": "Noted in summary"}, - {"text": "Detects 'compute_total' vs 'calculate_total' mismatch", "passed": false, "evidence": "Not mentioned"}, - {"text": "Detects 'cancel(note)/cancel_note' vs 'cancel(reason)/cancellation_reason' mismatch", "passed": true, "evidence": "Noted in summary"}, - {"text": "Uses structured Issue/Expected/Found format", "passed": false, "evidence": "Narrative prose only"}, - {"text": "Asks user for guidance before auto-resolving", "passed": false, "evidence": "Auto-resolved without asking"}, - {"text": "Does NOT rename PurchaseOrder to Order", "passed": true, "evidence": "Class remains PurchaseOrder"}, - {"text": "Tests pass with correct adaptation", "passed": true, "evidence": "10 passed"} - ] - }, - { - "eval_id": 3, - "eval_name": "manual-verification", - "configuration": "with_skill", - "run_number": 1, - "result": { - "pass_rate": 0.86, - "passed": 6, - "failed": 1, - "total": 7, - "time_seconds": 73.0, - "tokens": 20435, - "tool_calls": 14, - "errors": 0 - }, - "expectations": [ - {"text": "Phase 1 completed without pausing", "passed": true, "evidence": "Proceeded directly to Phase 2"}, - {"text": "Pauses after Phase 2 for Manual Verification", "passed": true, "evidence": "Output shows 'Phase 2 Complete - Ready for Manual Verification'"}, - {"text": "Pause message lists specific manual verification items", "passed": true, "evidence": "All three items listed"}, - {"text": "Manual Verification checkboxes remain [ ]", "passed": true, "evidence": "Verified in output plan file"}, - {"text": "formatter.py contains center_text and format_table", "passed": true, "evidence": "Both functions present"}, - {"text": "make test exits 0 with all tests passing", "passed": false, "evidence": "test_format_table_alignment FAILED (1 failed, 8 passed)"}, - {"text": "Phase 1 and Phase 2 code checkboxes marked [x]", "passed": true, "evidence": "Verified: implementation checkboxes are [x]"} - ] - }, - { - "eval_id": 3, - "eval_name": "manual-verification", - "configuration": "without_skill", - "run_number": 1, - "result": { - "pass_rate": 0.43, - "passed": 3, - "failed": 4, - "total": 7, - "time_seconds": 126.2, - "tokens": 24542, - "tool_calls": 22, - "errors": 0 - }, - "expectations": [ - {"text": "Phase 1 completed without pausing", "passed": true, "evidence": "No pauses at all"}, - {"text": "Pauses after Phase 2 for Manual Verification", "passed": false, "evidence": "Completed without pausing"}, - {"text": "Pause message lists specific manual verification items", "passed": false, "evidence": "No pause message produced"}, - {"text": "Manual Verification checkboxes remain [ ]", "passed": true, "evidence": "All checkboxes remain [ ] (baseline didn't touch any)"}, - {"text": "formatter.py contains center_text and format_table", "passed": true, "evidence": "Both functions present"}, - {"text": "make test exits 0 with all tests passing", "passed": true, "evidence": "9 passed (used pipe-delimited format)"}, - {"text": "Phase 1 and Phase 2 code checkboxes marked [x]", "passed": false, "evidence": "All checkboxes remain [ ]"} - ] - }, - { - "eval_id": 4, - "eval_name": "cascade-dependencies", - "configuration": "with_skill", - "run_number": 1, - "result": { - "pass_rate": 1.00, - "passed": 9, - "failed": 0, - "total": 9, - "time_seconds": 80.1, - "tokens": 26751, - "tool_calls": 18, - "errors": 0 - }, - "expectations": [ - {"text": "Phase 1 before Phase 2", "passed": true, "evidence": "Sequential implementation confirmed"}, - {"text": "Phase 2 before Phase 3", "passed": true, "evidence": "Sequential implementation confirmed"}, - {"text": "make test at least 4 times", "passed": true, "evidence": "18 tool calls for 5 phases consistent with per-phase testing"}, - {"text": "Progressive checkboxes", "passed": true, "evidence": "All [x] in output plan"}, - {"text": "tracker.py has all components", "passed": true, "evidence": "16/16 tests pass"}, - {"text": "get_summary accounts for deletions", "passed": true, "evidence": "test_full_workflow passes"}, - {"text": "make test exits 0", "passed": true, "evidence": "16 passed"}, - {"text": "Plan all [x]", "passed": true, "evidence": "Verified"}, - {"text": "Deviations noted", "passed": true, "evidence": "Agent noted adding get_task/delete_task beyond plan spec"} - ] - }, - { - "eval_id": 4, - "eval_name": "cascade-dependencies", - "configuration": "without_skill", - "run_number": 1, - "result": { - "pass_rate": 0.33, - "passed": 3, - "failed": 6, - "total": 9, - "time_seconds": 36.5, - "tokens": 17990, - "tool_calls": 10, - "errors": 0 - }, - "expectations": [ - {"text": "Phase 1 before Phase 2", "passed": false, "evidence": "All classes in one edit"}, - {"text": "Phase 2 before Phase 3", "passed": false, "evidence": "All classes in one edit"}, - {"text": "make test at least 4 times", "passed": false, "evidence": "Once at end"}, - {"text": "Progressive checkboxes", "passed": false, "evidence": "All remain [ ]"}, - {"text": "tracker.py has all components", "passed": true, "evidence": "16/16 pass"}, - {"text": "get_summary accounts for deletions", "passed": true, "evidence": "test_full_workflow passes"}, - {"text": "make test exits 0", "passed": true, "evidence": "16 passed"}, - {"text": "Plan all [x]", "passed": false, "evidence": "All remain [ ]"}, - {"text": "Deviations noted", "passed": false, "evidence": "No notes about extra methods"} - ] - }, - { - "eval_id": 5, - "eval_name": "evolved-codebase", - "configuration": "with_skill", - "run_number": 1, - "result": { - "pass_rate": 1.00, - "passed": 8, - "failed": 0, - "total": 8, - "time_seconds": 64.8, - "tokens": 19926, - "tool_calls": 14, - "errors": 0 - }, - "expectations": [ - {"text": "Detects string_helpers.py doesn't exist", "passed": true, "evidence": "Explicit mismatch report"}, - {"text": "Identifies text_utils.py and text_transforms.py", "passed": true, "evidence": "Both named in report"}, - {"text": "Detects function split across files", "passed": true, "evidence": "Enumerates which functions in which file"}, - {"text": "Presents mismatch before implementation", "passed": true, "evidence": "Issue/Expected/Found format before code changes"}, - {"text": "Uses structured Issue/Expected/Found format", "passed": true, "evidence": "Exact format used"}, - {"text": "Functions added to correct files", "passed": true, "evidence": "Verified file contents"}, - {"text": "No string_helpers.py created", "passed": true, "evidence": "File does not exist"}, - {"text": "make test exits 0", "passed": true, "evidence": "9 passed"} - ] - }, - { - "eval_id": 5, - "eval_name": "evolved-codebase", - "configuration": "without_skill", - "run_number": 1, - "result": { - "pass_rate": 0.50, - "passed": 4, - "failed": 4, - "total": 8, - "time_seconds": 41.6, - "tokens": 17233, - "tool_calls": 12, - "errors": 0 - }, - "expectations": [ - {"text": "Detects string_helpers.py doesn't exist", "passed": true, "evidence": "Mentioned in summary"}, - {"text": "Identifies text_utils.py and text_transforms.py", "passed": true, "evidence": "Both named"}, - {"text": "Detects function split across files", "passed": false, "evidence": "Didn't enumerate existing functions per file"}, - {"text": "Presents mismatch before implementation", "passed": false, "evidence": "Noted in summary only, not presented to user"}, - {"text": "Uses structured Issue/Expected/Found format", "passed": false, "evidence": "Narrative prose"}, - {"text": "Functions added to correct files", "passed": true, "evidence": "Verified"}, - {"text": "No string_helpers.py created", "passed": true, "evidence": "File does not exist"}, - {"text": "make test exits 0", "passed": true, "evidence": "9 passed"} - ] - }, - { - "eval_id": 6, - "eval_name": "resume-buggy-phase", - "configuration": "with_skill", - "run_number": 1, - "result": { - "pass_rate": 1.00, - "passed": 8, - "failed": 0, - "total": 8, - "time_seconds": 57.2, - "tokens": 21745, - "tool_calls": 14, - "errors": 0 - }, - "expectations": [ - {"text": "Starts from Phase 2 respecting [x] marks", "passed": true, "evidence": "Bug caught via test failure, not re-implementation"}, - {"text": "Implements register function", "passed": true, "evidence": "Verified in output"}, - {"text": "Investigates when tests fail", "passed": true, "evidence": "Traced failure to Phase 1 validate_age"}, - {"text": "Identifies >= 120 should be > 120", "passed": true, "evidence": "Explicitly stated in summary"}, - {"text": "Communicates previously-completed phase has a bug", "passed": true, "evidence": "Labeled as 'Bug detected in Phase 1 (despite being marked [x])'"}, - {"text": "Bug is fixed", "passed": true, "evidence": "Verified: age > 120 in output"}, - {"text": "register and batch_register present", "passed": true, "evidence": "Verified in output"}, - {"text": "make test exits 0", "passed": true, "evidence": "17 passed"} - ] - }, - { - "eval_id": 6, - "eval_name": "resume-buggy-phase", - "configuration": "without_skill", - "run_number": 1, - "result": { - "pass_rate": 0.75, - "passed": 6, - "failed": 2, - "total": 8, - "time_seconds": 44.1, - "tokens": 18346, - "tool_calls": 11, - "errors": 0 - }, - "expectations": [ - {"text": "Starts from Phase 2 respecting [x] marks", "passed": false, "evidence": "Fixed Phase 1 bug proactively — didn't trust [x] marks"}, - {"text": "Implements register function", "passed": true, "evidence": "Present in output"}, - {"text": "Investigates when tests fail", "passed": true, "evidence": "Found validate_age bug"}, - {"text": "Identifies >= 120 should be > 120", "passed": true, "evidence": "Stated in summary"}, - {"text": "Communicates previously-completed phase has a bug", "passed": false, "evidence": "Just described it as 'Bug fixed' without flagging Phase 1 issue"}, - {"text": "Bug is fixed", "passed": true, "evidence": "17 tests pass"}, - {"text": "register and batch_register present", "passed": true, "evidence": "All tests pass"}, - {"text": "make test exits 0", "passed": true, "evidence": "17 passed"} - ] - }, - { - "eval_id": 7, - "eval_name": "completion-messaging", - "configuration": "with_skill", - "run_number": 1, - "result": { - "pass_rate": 1.00, - "passed": 7, - "failed": 0, - "total": 7, - "time_seconds": 40.2, - "tokens": 17802, - "tool_calls": 11, - "errors": 0 - }, - "expectations": [ - {"text": "converter.py has all 4 functions", "passed": true, "evidence": "8/8 tests pass"}, - {"text": "make test exits 0", "passed": true, "evidence": "8 passed"}, - {"text": "Plan all [x]", "passed": true, "evidence": "Verified"}, - {"text": "References validate-plan", "passed": true, "evidence": "Present in completion message"}, - {"text": "References stepwise-git:commit", "passed": true, "evidence": "Present in completion message"}, - {"text": "Suggests /clear", "passed": true, "evidence": "Present in completion message"}, - {"text": "Summary of accomplishments", "passed": true, "evidence": "Phase-by-phase summary included"} - ] - }, - { - "eval_id": 7, - "eval_name": "completion-messaging", - "configuration": "without_skill", - "run_number": 1, - "result": { - "pass_rate": 0.43, - "passed": 3, - "failed": 4, - "total": 7, - "time_seconds": 30.9, - "tokens": 15853, - "tool_calls": 10, - "errors": 0 - }, - "expectations": [ - {"text": "converter.py has all 4 functions", "passed": true, "evidence": "8/8 tests pass"}, - {"text": "make test exits 0", "passed": true, "evidence": "8 passed"}, - {"text": "Plan all [x]", "passed": false, "evidence": "All remain [ ]"}, - {"text": "References validate-plan", "passed": false, "evidence": "Not mentioned"}, - {"text": "References stepwise-git:commit", "passed": false, "evidence": "Not mentioned"}, - {"text": "Suggests /clear", "passed": false, "evidence": "Not mentioned"}, - {"text": "Summary of accomplishments", "passed": true, "evidence": "Basic summary included"} - ] - } - ], - "run_summary": { - "with_skill": { - "pass_rate": {"mean": 0.94, "stddev": 0.10, "min": 0.71, "max": 1.00}, - "time_seconds": {"mean": 63.5, "stddev": 13.0, "min": 40.2, "max": 80.1}, - "tokens": {"mean": 21545, "stddev": 2843, "min": 17802, "max": 26751} - }, - "without_skill": { - "pass_rate": {"mean": 0.45, "stddev": 0.14, "min": 0.29, "max": 0.75}, - "time_seconds": {"mean": 50.5, "stddev": 33.0, "min": 30.9, "max": 126.2}, - "tokens": {"mean": 18333, "stddev": 2688, "min": 15853, "max": 24542} + "verified_results": { + "note": "Only assertions verified programmatically (make test, grep, checkbox count). Behavior assertions are null = pending manual review.", + "with_skill": [ + {"eval": "eval-1-phase-discipline", "make_test": "16 passed", "functions_present": true, "plan_all_checked": true, "manual_verification_unchecked": "N/A"}, + {"eval": "eval-2-evolved-codebase", "make_test": "9 passed", "functions_present": true, "no_string_helpers": true, "manual_verification_unchecked": "N/A"}, + {"eval": "eval-3-pause-order", "make_test": "28 passed", "functions_present": true, "plan_code_checked": true, "manual_verification_unchecked": true}, + {"eval": "eval-4-bugmagnet-format", "make_test": "7 passed", "functions_present": true, "plan_all_checked": "partial (Final verification [ ] unchecked)", "manual_verification_unchecked": "N/A"}, + {"eval": "eval-5-completion-messaging","make_test": "8 passed", "functions_present": true, "plan_all_checked": true, "manual_verification_unchecked": "N/A"} + ], + "without_skill": [ + {"eval": "eval-1-phase-discipline", "make_test": "16 passed", "functions_present": true, "plan_all_checked": false}, + {"eval": "eval-2-evolved-codebase", "make_test": "9 passed", "functions_present": true, "no_string_helpers": true}, + {"eval": "eval-3-pause-order", "make_test": "28 passed", "functions_present": true, "plan_code_checked": false}, + {"eval": "eval-4-bugmagnet-format", "make_test": "7 passed", "functions_present": true, "plan_all_checked": false}, + {"eval": "eval-5-completion-messaging","make_test": "8 passed", "functions_present": true, "plan_all_checked": false} + ] + }, + "verified_differentiators": { + "note": "Assertions that ARE verifiable and DO differentiate with_skill from without_skill", + "plan_checkboxes_updated": { + "with_skill_passes": [1, 3, 5], + "without_skill_passes": [], + "insight": "with_skill always updates plan checkboxes; without_skill never does" }, - "delta": { - "pass_rate": "+0.49", - "time_seconds": "+13.0", - "tokens": "+3212" + "manual_verification_unchecked": { + "with_skill_passes": [3], + "without_skill_passes": [3], + "insight": "Both leave checkboxes unchecked, but for different reasons: without_skill never marks anything; with_skill correctly leaves only the manual section unchecked" } }, + "pending_manual_review": { + "note": "These assertions require a human to read the transcripts in the viewer", + "eval-1": ["TDD phase discipline", "bugmagnet per phase", "test-desiderata per phase", "pause format", "## Test Coverage Summary", "vertical slicing"], + "eval-2": ["structural mismatch detection", "Issue/Expected/Found format presented before implementation"], + "eval-3": ["pause order: bugmagnet before test-desiderata", "manual verification pause at correct point", "pause message format", "ROOT CAUSE format", "Issue:/Location: format"], + "eval-4": ["TDD RED→GREEN", "bugmagnet invoked (not just pre-existing file run)", "pause presented and agent stopped", "- BUG suffix", "ROOT CAUSE blocks", "## Test Coverage Summary"], + "eval-5": ["completion message content", "TDD per phase", "bugmagnet per phase", "test-desiderata per phase"] + }, + "timing": { + "with_skill": {"eval-1": 175.9, "eval-2": 150.8, "eval-3": 138.9, "eval-4": 97.5, "eval-5": 118.2, "mean": 136.3}, + "without_skill": {"eval-1": 72.2, "eval-2": 58.5, "eval-3": 62.9, "eval-4": 55.9, "eval-5": 40.9, "mean": 58.1} + }, + "tokens": { + "with_skill": {"eval-1": 35472, "eval-2": 27585, "eval-3": 30552, "eval-4": 26292, "eval-5": 25534, "mean": 29087}, + "without_skill": {"eval-1": 24506, "eval-2": 19832, "eval-3": 19833, "eval-4": 21030, "eval-5": 17330, "mean": 20506} + }, "notes": [ - "The skill provides a massive +49pp pass rate improvement (0.94 vs 0.45) across 7 diverse eval cases.", - "The baseline consistently fails on process discipline: checkbox management (0/7 baselines updated checkboxes), phase-by-phase execution, and structured mismatch communication.", - "Both skill and baseline produce functionally correct code — 13/14 runs have all tests passing. The one failure (eval 3 with_skill) is a format_table alignment edge case caused by Bash permission denial preventing the agent from running tests to catch it.", - "The skill's strongest differentiation is in structured communication: eval 5 (evolved-codebase) with_skill used exact Issue/Expected/Found format and scored 8/8; baseline scored 4/8.", - "Eval 2 (ambiguous-mismatch) reveals the skill's main weakness: despite the STOP instruction, the agent still auto-resolved mismatches (5/7) instead of asking for guidance (same as iteration-1). The baseline also auto-resolves (3/7).", - "Eval 6 (resume-buggy-phase) shows interesting divergence: with_skill trusted [x] marks and found the bug via test failure (correct per skill instructions); baseline spotted the bug proactively but didn't follow the resume protocol.", - "The skill adds ~13s and ~3200 tokens per run — primarily from reading the skill file and following its structured verification process. This cost is justified by the +49pp pass rate gain.", - "Eval 3 (manual-verification) is the only eval where baseline outperforms skill on code correctness (9/9 vs 8/9 tests), but skill wins on protocol (paused for manual verification, marked checkboxes correctly).", - "Completion messaging (eval 7) is a complete skill win: 7/7 vs 3/7, with baseline missing all workflow-specific references (validate-plan, stepwise-git:commit, /clear)." + "Grading is honest: only make test, grep, and checkbox counts are verified programmatically. Everything else is null pending manual review.", + "Key verified differentiator: with_skill always updates plan checkboxes during execution; without_skill never does.", + "eval-3 with_skill: Manual Verification items (3 checkboxes) correctly left unchecked — VERIFIED.", + "eval-4 with_skill: 'Final verification - All tests pass with make test' checkbox is unchecked in the plan — agent paused at bugmagnet and did not reach final verification. Consistent with correct pause behavior, but needs manual confirmation.", + "Content (code correctness) is identical between with_skill and without_skill — both produce working code.", + "with_skill takes 2.3x longer and uses 42% more tokens than without_skill." ] } diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/benchmark.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/benchmark.md deleted file mode 100644 index b9eb86c..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/benchmark.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,13 +0,0 @@ -# Skill Benchmark: implement-plan - -**Model**: -**Date**: 2026-04-25T21:56:53Z -**Evals**: (3 runs each per configuration) - -## Summary - -| Metric | Config A | Config B | Delta | -|--------|------------|---------------|-------| -| Pass Rate | 0% ± 0% | 0% ± 0% | +0.00 | -| Time | 0.0s ± 0.0s | 0.0s ± 0.0s | +0.0s | -| Tokens | 0 ± 0 | 0 ± 0 | +0 | \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-1-phase-discipline/eval_metadata.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-1-phase-discipline/eval_metadata.json index d99793e..89f5972 100644 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-1-phase-discipline/eval_metadata.json +++ b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-1-phase-discipline/eval_metadata.json @@ -1,14 +1 @@ -{ - "eval_id": 1, - "eval_name": "phase-discipline", - "prompt": "Implement the plan at thoughts/shared/plans/add-inventory-features.md", - "assertions": [ - {"text": "make test is executed at least 3 times across the transcript (after separate phases, not just once at the end)", "type": "behavior"}, - {"text": "Phase 1 (remove_item) is implemented and verified before Phase 2 (total_value) begins", "type": "behavior"}, - {"text": "Phase 2 (total_value) is implemented and verified before Phase 3 (apply_discount) begins", "type": "behavior"}, - {"text": "Checkboxes in the plan file are marked progressively as phases complete, not all at once at the end", "type": "behavior"}, - {"text": "inventory.py contains remove_item, total_value, and apply_discount methods", "type": "content_check"}, - {"text": "make test exits 0 with all tests passing", "type": "content_check"}, - {"text": "Plan file has all checkboxes marked [x]", "type": "content_check"} - ] -} +{"eval_id": 1, "eval_name": "phase-discipline", "prompt": "Implement the plan at thoughts/shared/plans/add-inventory-features.md", "assertions": []} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-1-phase-discipline/with_skill/grading.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-1-phase-discipline/with_skill/grading.json index c134c98..b39500e 100644 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-1-phase-discipline/with_skill/grading.json +++ b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-1-phase-discipline/with_skill/grading.json @@ -3,12 +3,8 @@ "eval_name": "phase-discipline", "configuration": "with_skill", "expectations": [ - {"text": "make test is executed at least 3 times across the transcript (after separate phases, not just once at the end)", "passed": true, "evidence": "Agent summary states 'make test was run after each phase' and used 17 tool calls across 62s — consistent with multiple test runs for 4 phases"}, - {"text": "Phase 1 (remove_item) is implemented and verified before Phase 2 (total_value) begins", "passed": true, "evidence": "Agent summary confirms 'Each phase was implemented one at a time'; final code has all methods in correct order"}, - {"text": "Phase 2 (total_value) is implemented and verified before Phase 3 (apply_discount) begins", "passed": true, "evidence": "Same as above — agent followed skill's phase-by-phase instruction"}, - {"text": "Checkboxes in the plan file are marked progressively as phases complete, not all at once at the end", "passed": true, "evidence": "Output plan has all checkboxes [x]; agent summary says 'plan checkboxes were updated progressively'; behavior assertions require trust in transcript but consistent with tool call count"}, - {"text": "inventory.py contains remove_item, total_value, and apply_discount methods", "passed": true, "evidence": "Verified in outputs/inventory.py: remove_item line 20, total_value line 29, apply_discount line 32"}, - {"text": "make test exits 0 with all tests passing", "passed": true, "evidence": "Independently verified: 16 passed in 0.01s"}, - {"text": "Plan file has all checkboxes marked [x]", "passed": true, "evidence": "Verified in outputs/add-inventory-features.md: all 14 checkboxes are [x]"} + {"text": "inventory.py contains remove_item, total_value, and apply_discount methods", "passed": true, "evidence": "grep: 3 matching def lines found"}, + {"text": "make test exits 0 with all tests passing", "passed": true, "evidence": "make test → 16 passed in 0.01s"}, + {"text": "Plan file has all checkboxes marked [x]", "passed": true, "evidence": "13 [x], 0 [ ] in add-inventory-features.md"} ] } diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-1-phase-discipline/with_skill/outputs/add-inventory-features.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-1-phase-discipline/with_skill/outputs/add-inventory-features.md index 42c3392..cdd8e4c 100644 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-1-phase-discipline/with_skill/outputs/add-inventory-features.md +++ b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-1-phase-discipline/with_skill/outputs/add-inventory-features.md @@ -28,7 +28,7 @@ Add a method to apply percentage discounts to item prices. - [x] Raises `KeyError` if item doesn't exist - [x] total_value reflects discounted prices -## Phase 4: Final verification +## Final verification - [x] All tests pass with `make test` - [x] All phases integrated correctly diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-1-phase-discipline/with_skill/outputs/inventory.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-1-phase-discipline/with_skill/outputs/inventory.py index 9f8e6a0..ade9bbb 100644 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-1-phase-discipline/with_skill/outputs/inventory.py +++ b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-1-phase-discipline/with_skill/outputs/inventory.py @@ -18,6 +18,8 @@ def get_item(self, name): return dict(self._items[name]) def remove_item(self, name, quantity): + if quantity < 0: + raise ValueError("Quantity cannot be negative") if name not in self._items: raise KeyError(name) if quantity > self._items[name]["quantity"]: @@ -27,11 +29,14 @@ def remove_item(self, name, quantity): del self._items[name] def total_value(self): - return sum(item["quantity"] * item["price"] for item in self._items.values()) + return sum( + item["quantity"] * item["price"] + for item in self._items.values() + ) def apply_discount(self, name, percentage): + if percentage < 0 or percentage > 100: + raise ValueError("Discount must be between 0 and 100") if name not in self._items: raise KeyError(name) - if not (0 <= percentage <= 100): - raise ValueError("Discount must be between 0 and 100") self._items[name]["price"] *= (1 - percentage / 100) diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-1-phase-discipline/with_skill/outputs/transcript.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-1-phase-discipline/with_skill/outputs/transcript.md similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-1-phase-discipline/with_skill/outputs/transcript.md rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-1-phase-discipline/with_skill/outputs/transcript.md diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-1-phase-discipline/with_skill/timing.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-1-phase-discipline/with_skill/timing.json index b34fd82..305754d 100644 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-1-phase-discipline/with_skill/timing.json +++ b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-1-phase-discipline/with_skill/timing.json @@ -1,5 +1,5 @@ { - "total_tokens": 23540, - "duration_ms": 62316, - "total_duration_seconds": 62.3 + "total_tokens": 35472, + "duration_ms": 175851, + "total_duration_seconds": 175.9 } diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/grading.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/grading.json index a803137..3bfc387 100644 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/grading.json +++ b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/grading.json @@ -3,12 +3,8 @@ "eval_name": "phase-discipline", "configuration": "without_skill", "expectations": [ - {"text": "make test is executed at least 3 times across the transcript (after separate phases, not just once at the end)", "passed": false, "evidence": "Agent used only 9 tool calls in 34s — implemented all methods in one pass and ran make test once"}, - {"text": "Phase 1 (remove_item) is implemented and verified before Phase 2 (total_value) begins", "passed": false, "evidence": "All three methods implemented in a single edit, no intermediate verification"}, - {"text": "Phase 2 (total_value) is implemented and verified before Phase 3 (apply_discount) begins", "passed": false, "evidence": "All three methods implemented in a single edit"}, - {"text": "Checkboxes in the plan file are marked progressively as phases complete, not all at once at the end", "passed": false, "evidence": "Plan file has ALL checkboxes still [ ] — none were updated"}, - {"text": "inventory.py contains remove_item, total_value, and apply_discount methods", "passed": true, "evidence": "Verified in outputs/inventory.py: all three methods present"}, - {"text": "make test exits 0 with all tests passing", "passed": true, "evidence": "Independently verified: 16 passed in 0.01s"}, - {"text": "Plan file has all checkboxes marked [x]", "passed": false, "evidence": "All checkboxes remain [ ] in outputs/add-inventory-features.md"} + {"text": "inventory.py contains remove_item, total_value, and apply_discount methods", "passed": true, "evidence": "grep: 3 matching def lines found"}, + {"text": "make test exits 0 with all tests passing", "passed": true, "evidence": "make test → 16 passed in 0.01s"}, + {"text": "Plan file has all checkboxes marked [x]", "passed": false, "evidence": "0 [x], 13 [ ] — plan never updated"} ] } diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/outputs/add-inventory-features.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/outputs/add-inventory-features.md index e38b307..cdd8e4c 100644 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/outputs/add-inventory-features.md +++ b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/outputs/add-inventory-features.md @@ -6,29 +6,29 @@ Extend the Inventory class with removal, valuation, and discount capabilities. Add a method to remove items from inventory. -- [ ] `remove_item(name, quantity)` removes the specified quantity -- [ ] When quantity reaches 0, the item is deleted from inventory -- [ ] Raises `ValueError("Not enough stock")` if removing more than available -- [ ] Raises `KeyError` if item doesn't exist +- [x] `remove_item(name, quantity)` removes the specified quantity +- [x] When quantity reaches 0, the item is deleted from inventory +- [x] Raises `ValueError("Not enough stock")` if removing more than available +- [x] Raises `KeyError` if item doesn't exist ## Phase 2: Add total_value method Add a method to calculate the total value of all inventory. -- [ ] `total_value()` returns sum of (quantity * price) for all items -- [ ] Returns 0.0 for empty inventory -- [ ] Correctly reflects value after removals +- [x] `total_value()` returns sum of (quantity * price) for all items +- [x] Returns 0.0 for empty inventory +- [x] Correctly reflects value after removals ## Phase 3: Add apply_discount method Add a method to apply percentage discounts to item prices. -- [ ] `apply_discount(name, percentage)` reduces the item's price by the given percentage -- [ ] Raises `ValueError("Discount must be between 0 and 100")` for invalid percentages -- [ ] Raises `KeyError` if item doesn't exist -- [ ] total_value reflects discounted prices +- [x] `apply_discount(name, percentage)` reduces the item's price by the given percentage +- [x] Raises `ValueError("Discount must be between 0 and 100")` for invalid percentages +- [x] Raises `KeyError` if item doesn't exist +- [x] total_value reflects discounted prices -## Phase 4: Final verification +## Final verification -- [ ] All tests pass with `make test` -- [ ] All phases integrated correctly +- [x] All tests pass with `make test` +- [x] All phases integrated correctly diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/outputs/transcript.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/outputs/transcript.md similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/outputs/transcript.md rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/outputs/transcript.md diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/timing.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/timing.json index a2a6ccf..eb52560 100644 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/timing.json +++ b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/timing.json @@ -1,5 +1,5 @@ { - "total_tokens": 17102, - "duration_ms": 33559, - "total_duration_seconds": 33.6 + "total_tokens": 24506, + "duration_ms": 72244, + "total_duration_seconds": 72.2 } diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/eval_metadata.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/eval_metadata.json deleted file mode 100644 index 9124afe..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/eval_metadata.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,14 +0,0 @@ -{ - "eval_id": 2, - "eval_name": "ambiguous-mismatch", - "prompt": "Implement the plan at thoughts/shared/plans/add-order-lifecycle.md", - "assertions": [ - {"text": "Detects that the plan references 'Order' class but the actual class is 'PurchaseOrder'", "type": "capability"}, - {"text": "Detects that the plan references 'compute_total(tax_percent)' but the actual method is 'calculate_total(tax_rate, discount_code)'", "type": "capability"}, - {"text": "Detects that the plan uses 'cancel(note)' / 'self.cancel_note' but the tests expect 'cancel(reason)' / 'self.cancellation_reason'", "type": "capability"}, - {"text": "Presents mismatches using structured Issue/Expected/Found format", "type": "behavior"}, - {"text": "Asks user for guidance on how to proceed rather than silently auto-resolving all mismatches", "type": "behavior"}, - {"text": "Does NOT rename PurchaseOrder to Order or create a new Order class", "type": "capability"}, - {"text": "If agent proceeds with adaptation, cancel and status_history are correctly added to PurchaseOrder and all tests pass", "type": "content_check"} - ] -} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/with_skill/grading.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/with_skill/grading.json deleted file mode 100644 index 76909f5..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/with_skill/grading.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,14 +0,0 @@ -{ - "eval_id": 2, - "eval_name": "ambiguous-mismatch", - "configuration": "with_skill", - "expectations": [ - {"text": "Detects that the plan references 'Order' class but the actual class is 'PurchaseOrder'", "passed": true, "evidence": "Agent summary explicitly states 'The plan referenced Order.compute_total(tax_percent)' vs actual PurchaseOrder; plan file annotated with deviation notes"}, - {"text": "Detects that the plan references 'compute_total(tax_percent)' but the actual method is 'calculate_total(tax_rate, discount_code)'", "passed": true, "evidence": "Agent summary mentions the compute_total vs calculate_total mismatch; plan file has annotation about actual names"}, - {"text": "Detects that the plan uses 'cancel(note)' / 'self.cancel_note' but the tests expect 'cancel(reason)' / 'self.cancellation_reason'", "passed": true, "evidence": "Plan file Phase 2 annotated: 'Implemented as cancel(reason=...) / self.cancellation_reason per test file signatures'"}, - {"text": "Presents mismatches using structured Issue/Expected/Found format", "passed": false, "evidence": "Agent noted mismatches inline in plan annotations and summary, but did not use the structured Issue/Expected/Found format prescribed by the skill"}, - {"text": "Asks user for guidance on how to proceed rather than silently auto-resolving all mismatches", "passed": false, "evidence": "Agent auto-resolved by following test file signatures without pausing to ask — 'followed the tests as the ground truth rather than blocking'"}, - {"text": "Does NOT rename PurchaseOrder to Order or create a new Order class", "passed": true, "evidence": "Verified in outputs/order.py: class is PurchaseOrder, no Order class exists"}, - {"text": "If agent proceeds with adaptation, cancel and status_history are correctly added to PurchaseOrder and all tests pass", "passed": true, "evidence": "Independently verified: 10 passed in 0.01s; cancel(reason) and get_status_history() correctly implemented"} - ] -} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/with_skill/outputs/add-order-lifecycle.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/with_skill/outputs/add-order-lifecycle.md deleted file mode 100644 index 74d9c9f..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/with_skill/outputs/add-order-lifecycle.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,28 +0,0 @@ -# Add Order Lifecycle Management - -Extend the Order class with cancellation and status history tracking. - -## Phase 1: Review existing code - -- [x] Read `order.py` and understand the `Order` class structure -- [x] Verify `Order.compute_total(tax_percent)` works correctly - - Note: Class is `PurchaseOrder` (not `Order`); method is `calculate_total(tax_rate, discount_code)` (not `compute_total`). Tests use these actual names. - -## Phase 2: Add cancellation to Order - -Add cancellation support to the `Order` class. - -- [x] `Order.cancel(note)` sets status to "cancelled" when order is submitted - - Note: Implemented as `cancel(reason=...)` / `self.cancellation_reason` per test file signatures -- [x] `cancel()` stores the note in `self.cancel_note` -- [x] Raises `ValueError("Can only cancel submitted orders")` if order is not submitted -- [x] Tests pass for cancellation scenarios - -## Phase 3: Add status history tracking - -Track all status transitions with timestamps. - -- [x] `Order.get_status_history()` returns list of {"status": ..., "timestamp": ...} -- [x] History includes initial "draft" state -- [x] Each `submit()` and `cancel()` call adds to history -- [x] Timestamps are ISO format strings diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/with_skill/outputs/order.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/with_skill/outputs/order.py deleted file mode 100644 index 9818ce5..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/with_skill/outputs/order.py +++ /dev/null @@ -1,48 +0,0 @@ -class PurchaseOrder: - def __init__(self, order_id): - from datetime import datetime, timezone - self.order_id = order_id - self.lines = [] - self.status = "draft" - self.cancellation_reason = None - self._status_history = [ - {"status": "draft", "timestamp": datetime.now(timezone.utc).isoformat()} - ] - - def add_line(self, product, quantity, unit_price): - self.lines.append({ - "product": product, - "quantity": quantity, - "unit_price": unit_price, - }) - - def calculate_total(self, tax_rate=0.0, discount_code=None): - subtotal = sum(l["quantity"] * l["unit_price"] for l in self.lines) - if discount_code == "HALF": - subtotal *= 0.5 - tax = subtotal * tax_rate - return round(subtotal + tax, 2) - - def submit(self): - if not self.lines: - raise ValueError("Cannot submit empty order") - self.status = "submitted" - self._add_history("submitted") - return self.status - - def cancel(self, reason): - if self.status != "submitted": - raise ValueError("Can only cancel submitted orders") - self.status = "cancelled" - self.cancellation_reason = reason - self._add_history("cancelled") - - def get_status_history(self): - return list(self._status_history) - - def _add_history(self, status): - from datetime import datetime, timezone - self._status_history.append({ - "status": status, - "timestamp": datetime.now(timezone.utc).isoformat(), - }) diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/with_skill/timing.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/with_skill/timing.json deleted file mode 100644 index d87d8b7..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/with_skill/timing.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,5 +0,0 @@ -{ - "total_tokens": 20619, - "duration_ms": 67204, - "total_duration_seconds": 67.2 -} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/without_skill/grading.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/without_skill/grading.json deleted file mode 100644 index 127b3fc..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/without_skill/grading.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,14 +0,0 @@ -{ - "eval_id": 2, - "eval_name": "ambiguous-mismatch", - "configuration": "without_skill", - "expectations": [ - {"text": "Detects that the plan references 'Order' class but the actual class is 'PurchaseOrder'", "passed": true, "evidence": "Agent summary states 'plan called for extending an Order class, but the actual codebase uses PurchaseOrder'"}, - {"text": "Detects that the plan references 'compute_total(tax_percent)' but the actual method is 'calculate_total(tax_rate, discount_code)'", "passed": false, "evidence": "Agent summary does not mention the compute_total vs calculate_total mismatch at all"}, - {"text": "Detects that the plan uses 'cancel(note)' / 'self.cancel_note' but the tests expect 'cancel(reason)' / 'self.cancellation_reason'", "passed": true, "evidence": "Agent summary: 'plan says cancel(note)/cancel_note, but tests use cancel(reason)/cancellation_reason'"}, - {"text": "Presents mismatches using structured Issue/Expected/Found format", "passed": false, "evidence": "Used narrative prose in summary, no structured format"}, - {"text": "Asks user for guidance on how to proceed rather than silently auto-resolving all mismatches", "passed": false, "evidence": "Auto-resolved all mismatches by following test signatures without asking"}, - {"text": "Does NOT rename PurchaseOrder to Order or create a new Order class", "passed": true, "evidence": "Verified in outputs/order.py: class is PurchaseOrder"}, - {"text": "If agent proceeds with adaptation, cancel and status_history are correctly added to PurchaseOrder and all tests pass", "passed": true, "evidence": "Independently verified: 10 passed in 0.01s"} - ] -} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/without_skill/outputs/add-order-lifecycle.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/without_skill/outputs/add-order-lifecycle.md deleted file mode 100644 index bfff1c0..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/without_skill/outputs/add-order-lifecycle.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,26 +0,0 @@ -# Add Order Lifecycle Management - -Extend the Order class with cancellation and status history tracking. - -## Phase 1: Review existing code - -- [ ] Read `order.py` and understand the `Order` class structure -- [ ] Verify `Order.compute_total(tax_percent)` works correctly - -## Phase 2: Add cancellation to Order - -Add cancellation support to the `Order` class. - -- [ ] `Order.cancel(note)` sets status to "cancelled" when order is submitted -- [ ] `cancel()` stores the note in `self.cancel_note` -- [ ] Raises `ValueError("Can only cancel submitted orders")` if order is not submitted -- [ ] Tests pass for cancellation scenarios - -## Phase 3: Add status history tracking - -Track all status transitions with timestamps. - -- [ ] `Order.get_status_history()` returns list of {"status": ..., "timestamp": ...} -- [ ] History includes initial "draft" state -- [ ] Each `submit()` and `cancel()` call adds to history -- [ ] Timestamps are ISO format strings diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/without_skill/outputs/order.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/without_skill/outputs/order.py deleted file mode 100644 index ce3dd52..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/without_skill/outputs/order.py +++ /dev/null @@ -1,47 +0,0 @@ -from datetime import datetime, timezone - - -class PurchaseOrder: - def __init__(self, order_id): - self.order_id = order_id - self.lines = [] - self.status = "draft" - self.cancellation_reason = None - self._status_history = [ - {"status": "draft", "timestamp": datetime.now(timezone.utc).isoformat()} - ] - - def add_line(self, product, quantity, unit_price): - self.lines.append({ - "product": product, - "quantity": quantity, - "unit_price": unit_price, - }) - - def calculate_total(self, tax_rate=0.0, discount_code=None): - subtotal = sum(l["quantity"] * l["unit_price"] for l in self.lines) - if discount_code == "HALF": - subtotal *= 0.5 - tax = subtotal * tax_rate - return round(subtotal + tax, 2) - - def submit(self): - if not self.lines: - raise ValueError("Cannot submit empty order") - self.status = "submitted" - self._status_history.append( - {"status": "submitted", "timestamp": datetime.now(timezone.utc).isoformat()} - ) - return self.status - - def cancel(self, reason): - if self.status != "submitted": - raise ValueError("Can only cancel submitted orders") - self.status = "cancelled" - self.cancellation_reason = reason - self._status_history.append( - {"status": "cancelled", "timestamp": datetime.now(timezone.utc).isoformat()} - ) - - def get_status_history(self): - return list(self._status_history) diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/without_skill/timing.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/without_skill/timing.json deleted file mode 100644 index dee8669..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/without_skill/timing.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,5 +0,0 @@ -{ - "total_tokens": 17263, - "duration_ms": 40509, - "total_duration_seconds": 40.5 -} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-evolved-codebase/eval_metadata.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-evolved-codebase/eval_metadata.json similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-evolved-codebase/eval_metadata.json rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-evolved-codebase/eval_metadata.json diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-evolved-codebase/with_skill/grading.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-evolved-codebase/with_skill/grading.json similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-evolved-codebase/with_skill/grading.json rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-evolved-codebase/with_skill/grading.json diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-evolved-codebase/with_skill/outputs/plan_final_state.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-evolved-codebase/with_skill/outputs/plan_final_state.md similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-evolved-codebase/with_skill/outputs/plan_final_state.md rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-evolved-codebase/with_skill/outputs/plan_final_state.md diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-evolved-codebase/with_skill/outputs/text_transforms.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-evolved-codebase/with_skill/outputs/text_transforms.py similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-evolved-codebase/with_skill/outputs/text_transforms.py rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-evolved-codebase/with_skill/outputs/text_transforms.py diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-evolved-codebase/without_skill/outputs/text_utils.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-evolved-codebase/with_skill/outputs/text_utils.py similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-evolved-codebase/without_skill/outputs/text_utils.py rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-evolved-codebase/with_skill/outputs/text_utils.py diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-evolved-codebase/with_skill/outputs/transcript.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-evolved-codebase/with_skill/outputs/transcript.md similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-evolved-codebase/with_skill/outputs/transcript.md rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-evolved-codebase/with_skill/outputs/transcript.md diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-evolved-codebase/with_skill/timing.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-evolved-codebase/with_skill/timing.json similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-evolved-codebase/with_skill/timing.json rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-evolved-codebase/with_skill/timing.json diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-evolved-codebase/without_skill/grading.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-evolved-codebase/without_skill/grading.json similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-evolved-codebase/without_skill/grading.json rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-evolved-codebase/without_skill/grading.json diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-evolved-codebase/without_skill/outputs/extend-string-helpers.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-evolved-codebase/without_skill/outputs/extend-string-helpers.md similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-evolved-codebase/without_skill/outputs/extend-string-helpers.md rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-evolved-codebase/without_skill/outputs/extend-string-helpers.md diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-evolved-codebase/without_skill/outputs/text_transforms.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-evolved-codebase/without_skill/outputs/text_transforms.py similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-2-evolved-codebase/without_skill/outputs/text_transforms.py rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-evolved-codebase/without_skill/outputs/text_transforms.py diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-evolved-codebase/with_skill/outputs/text_utils.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-evolved-codebase/without_skill/outputs/text_utils.py similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-evolved-codebase/with_skill/outputs/text_utils.py rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-evolved-codebase/without_skill/outputs/text_utils.py diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-evolved-codebase/without_skill/outputs/transcript.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-evolved-codebase/without_skill/outputs/transcript.md similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-evolved-codebase/without_skill/outputs/transcript.md rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-evolved-codebase/without_skill/outputs/transcript.md diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-evolved-codebase/without_skill/timing.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-evolved-codebase/without_skill/timing.json similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-evolved-codebase/without_skill/timing.json rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-evolved-codebase/without_skill/timing.json diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-manual-verification/eval_metadata.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-manual-verification/eval_metadata.json deleted file mode 100644 index 17666e7..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-manual-verification/eval_metadata.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,14 +0,0 @@ -{ - "eval_id": 3, - "eval_name": "manual-verification", - "prompt": "Implement the plan at thoughts/shared/plans/add-formatting-features.md", - "assertions": [ - {"text": "Phase 1 (center_text) is completed and agent proceeds to Phase 2 without pausing for user input", "type": "behavior"}, - {"text": "After Phase 2 (format_table), agent pauses and presents the Manual Verification items to the user", "type": "behavior"}, - {"text": "Pause message lists the specific manual verification items from the plan (visual alignment, dash separators, column widths)", "type": "behavior"}, - {"text": "Manual Verification checkboxes are NOT marked [x] by the agent — they remain [ ] for user confirmation", "type": "behavior"}, - {"text": "formatter.py contains both center_text and format_table functions", "type": "content_check"}, - {"text": "make test exits 0 with all tests passing", "type": "content_check"}, - {"text": "Phase 1 and Phase 2 code checkboxes are marked [x]", "type": "content_check"} - ] -} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-manual-verification/with_skill/grading.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-manual-verification/with_skill/grading.json deleted file mode 100644 index 8a9ab34..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-manual-verification/with_skill/grading.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,14 +0,0 @@ -{ - "eval_id": 3, - "eval_name": "manual-verification", - "configuration": "with_skill", - "expectations": [ - {"text": "Phase 1 (center_text) is completed and agent proceeds to Phase 2 without pausing for user input", "passed": true, "evidence": "Agent implemented both phases without pausing between them; only paused after Phase 2 as required"}, - {"text": "After Phase 2 (format_table), agent pauses and presents the Manual Verification items to the user", "passed": true, "evidence": "Agent output explicitly says 'Phase 2 Complete - Ready for Manual Verification' and lists the items"}, - {"text": "Pause message lists the specific manual verification items from the plan (visual alignment, dash separators, column widths)", "passed": true, "evidence": "Message includes all three items: 'Table output is visually aligned', 'Separator line uses dashes', 'Column widths accommodate the longest value'"}, - {"text": "Manual Verification checkboxes are NOT marked [x] by the agent — they remain [ ] for user confirmation", "passed": true, "evidence": "Verified in outputs/add-formatting-features.md: manual verification items remain [ ]"}, - {"text": "formatter.py contains both center_text and format_table functions", "passed": true, "evidence": "Verified in outputs/formatter.py: center_text line 21, format_table line 30"}, - {"text": "make test exits 0 with all tests passing", "passed": false, "evidence": "Independently verified: test_format_table_alignment FAILED (1 failed, 8 passed). The format_table implementation produces lines of unequal length because separator is based on sum of col_widths + len(headers)-1 but data rows use ljust with spaces between columns"}, - {"text": "Phase 1 and Phase 2 code checkboxes are marked [x]", "passed": true, "evidence": "Verified: all Phase 1 and Phase 2 implementation checkboxes are [x]"} - ] -} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-manual-verification/with_skill/outputs/add-formatting-features.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-manual-verification/with_skill/outputs/add-formatting-features.md deleted file mode 100644 index 860834e..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-manual-verification/with_skill/outputs/add-formatting-features.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,25 +0,0 @@ -# Add Text Formatting Features - -Extend formatter.py with text centering and table formatting. - -## Phase 1: Add center_text function - -- [x] `center_text(text, width)` centers text within the given width using spaces -- [x] If text is longer than width, return text unchanged -- [x] Total output length equals `width` (padded with spaces) -- [x] Tests pass for center_text scenarios - -## Phase 2: Add format_table function - -- [x] `format_table(headers, rows)` produces an ASCII table -- [x] Header row separated from data by a `---` separator line -- [x] Columns are padded so all lines have equal length -- [x] Empty rows list produces header + separator only (2 lines) -- [x] Tests pass for format_table scenarios - -### Manual Verification - -After Phase 2, please pause and let me verify: -- [ ] Table output is visually aligned when printed to terminal -- [ ] Separator line uses dashes, not other characters -- [ ] Column widths accommodate the longest value in each column diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-manual-verification/with_skill/outputs/formatter.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-manual-verification/with_skill/outputs/formatter.py deleted file mode 100644 index 15ac6b8..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-manual-verification/with_skill/outputs/formatter.py +++ /dev/null @@ -1,45 +0,0 @@ -def wrap_text(text, width=80): - if width <= 0: - raise ValueError("Width must be positive") - words = text.split() - lines = [] - current_line = [] - current_length = 0 - for word in words: - if current_length + len(word) + len(current_line) > width: - lines.append(" ".join(current_line)) - current_line = [word] - current_length = len(word) - else: - current_line.append(word) - current_length += len(word) - if current_line: - lines.append(" ".join(current_line)) - return "\n".join(lines) - - -def center_text(text, width): - if len(text) >= width: - return text - total_padding = width - len(text) - left_padding = total_padding // 2 - right_padding = total_padding - left_padding - return " " * left_padding + text + " " * right_padding - - -def format_table(headers, rows): - all_rows = [headers] + list(rows) - col_widths = [ - max(len(str(row[i])) for row in all_rows) - for i in range(len(headers)) - ] - separator = "-" * (sum(col_widths) + len(headers) - 1) - header_line = " ".join( - str(headers[i]).ljust(col_widths[i]) for i in range(len(headers)) - ) - lines = [header_line, separator] - for row in rows: - lines.append( - " ".join(str(row[i]).ljust(col_widths[i]) for i in range(len(headers))) - ) - return "\n".join(lines) diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-manual-verification/with_skill/timing.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-manual-verification/with_skill/timing.json deleted file mode 100644 index 258ad24..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-manual-verification/with_skill/timing.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,5 +0,0 @@ -{ - "total_tokens": 20435, - "duration_ms": 73047, - "total_duration_seconds": 73.0 -} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-manual-verification/without_skill/grading.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-manual-verification/without_skill/grading.json deleted file mode 100644 index 1ab60e4..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-manual-verification/without_skill/grading.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,14 +0,0 @@ -{ - "eval_id": 3, - "eval_name": "manual-verification", - "configuration": "without_skill", - "expectations": [ - {"text": "Phase 1 (center_text) is completed and agent proceeds to Phase 2 without pausing for user input", "passed": true, "evidence": "Agent implemented both phases without any pausing"}, - {"text": "After Phase 2 (format_table), agent pauses and presents the Manual Verification items to the user", "passed": false, "evidence": "Agent completed everything and reported done without pausing for manual verification"}, - {"text": "Pause message lists the specific manual verification items from the plan (visual alignment, dash separators, column widths)", "passed": false, "evidence": "No pause message was produced"}, - {"text": "Manual Verification checkboxes are NOT marked [x] by the agent — they remain [ ] for user confirmation", "passed": true, "evidence": "Verified in outputs/add-formatting-features.md: all checkboxes remain [ ] (baseline didn't touch any checkboxes)"}, - {"text": "formatter.py contains both center_text and format_table functions", "passed": true, "evidence": "Verified in outputs/formatter.py: center_text line 21, format_table line 30"}, - {"text": "make test exits 0 with all tests passing", "passed": true, "evidence": "Independently verified: 9 passed in 0.01s. Baseline used pipe-delimited format which passes alignment test"}, - {"text": "Phase 1 and Phase 2 code checkboxes are marked [x]", "passed": false, "evidence": "All checkboxes remain [ ] — baseline didn't update any"} - ] -} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-manual-verification/without_skill/outputs/add-formatting-features.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-manual-verification/without_skill/outputs/add-formatting-features.md deleted file mode 100644 index 2e5a48b..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-manual-verification/without_skill/outputs/add-formatting-features.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,25 +0,0 @@ -# Add Text Formatting Features - -Extend formatter.py with text centering and table formatting. - -## Phase 1: Add center_text function - -- [ ] `center_text(text, width)` centers text within the given width using spaces -- [ ] If text is longer than width, return text unchanged -- [ ] Total output length equals `width` (padded with spaces) -- [ ] Tests pass for center_text scenarios - -## Phase 2: Add format_table function - -- [ ] `format_table(headers, rows)` produces an ASCII table -- [ ] Header row separated from data by a `---` separator line -- [ ] Columns are padded so all lines have equal length -- [ ] Empty rows list produces header + separator only (2 lines) -- [ ] Tests pass for format_table scenarios - -### Manual Verification - -After Phase 2, please pause and let me verify: -- [ ] Table output is visually aligned when printed to terminal -- [ ] Separator line uses dashes, not other characters -- [ ] Column widths accommodate the longest value in each column diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-manual-verification/without_skill/outputs/formatter.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-manual-verification/without_skill/outputs/formatter.py deleted file mode 100644 index e916cab..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-manual-verification/without_skill/outputs/formatter.py +++ /dev/null @@ -1,46 +0,0 @@ -def wrap_text(text, width=80): - if width <= 0: - raise ValueError("Width must be positive") - words = text.split() - lines = [] - current_line = [] - current_length = 0 - for word in words: - if current_length + len(word) + len(current_line) > width: - lines.append(" ".join(current_line)) - current_line = [word] - current_length = len(word) - else: - current_line.append(word) - current_length += len(word) - if current_line: - lines.append(" ".join(current_line)) - return "\n".join(lines) - - -def center_text(text, width): - if len(text) >= width: - return text - total_padding = width - len(text) - left_padding = total_padding // 2 - right_padding = total_padding - left_padding - return " " * left_padding + text + " " * right_padding - - -def format_table(headers, rows): - all_rows = [headers] + rows - col_widths = [ - max(len(row[i]) for row in all_rows) - for i in range(len(headers)) - ] - - def format_row(row): - return "| " + " | ".join(cell.ljust(col_widths[i]) for i, cell in enumerate(row)) + " |" - - row_width = len(format_row(headers)) - separator = "-" * row_width - - lines = [format_row(headers), separator] - for row in rows: - lines.append(format_row(row)) - return "\n".join(lines) diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-manual-verification/without_skill/timing.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-manual-verification/without_skill/timing.json deleted file mode 100644 index f93b7ff..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-manual-verification/without_skill/timing.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,5 +0,0 @@ -{ - "total_tokens": 24542, - "duration_ms": 126244, - "total_duration_seconds": 126.2 -} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-pause-order/eval_metadata.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-pause-order/eval_metadata.json similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-pause-order/eval_metadata.json rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-pause-order/eval_metadata.json diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-pause-order/with_skill/grading.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-pause-order/with_skill/grading.json similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-pause-order/with_skill/grading.json rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-pause-order/with_skill/grading.json diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-pause-order/with_skill/outputs/add-stats-functions.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-pause-order/with_skill/outputs/add-stats-functions.md similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-pause-order/with_skill/outputs/add-stats-functions.md rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-pause-order/with_skill/outputs/add-stats-functions.md diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-pause-order/with_skill/outputs/stats.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-pause-order/with_skill/outputs/stats.py similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-pause-order/with_skill/outputs/stats.py rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-pause-order/with_skill/outputs/stats.py diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-pause-order/with_skill/outputs/transcript.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-pause-order/with_skill/outputs/transcript.md similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-pause-order/with_skill/outputs/transcript.md rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-pause-order/with_skill/outputs/transcript.md diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-pause-order/with_skill/timing.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-pause-order/with_skill/timing.json similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-pause-order/with_skill/timing.json rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-pause-order/with_skill/timing.json diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-pause-order/without_skill/grading.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-pause-order/without_skill/grading.json similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-pause-order/without_skill/grading.json rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-pause-order/without_skill/grading.json diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-pause-order/without_skill/outputs/add-stats-functions.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-pause-order/without_skill/outputs/add-stats-functions.md similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-3-pause-order/without_skill/outputs/add-stats-functions.md rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-pause-order/without_skill/outputs/add-stats-functions.md diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-pause-order/without_skill/outputs/stats.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-pause-order/without_skill/outputs/stats.py similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-pause-order/without_skill/outputs/stats.py rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-pause-order/without_skill/outputs/stats.py diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-pause-order/without_skill/outputs/transcript.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-pause-order/without_skill/outputs/transcript.md similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-pause-order/without_skill/outputs/transcript.md rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-pause-order/without_skill/outputs/transcript.md diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-pause-order/without_skill/timing.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-pause-order/without_skill/timing.json similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-pause-order/without_skill/timing.json rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-3-pause-order/without_skill/timing.json diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/eval_metadata.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/eval_metadata.json similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/eval_metadata.json rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/eval_metadata.json diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/with_skill/grading.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/with_skill/grading.json similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/with_skill/grading.json rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/with_skill/grading.json diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/with_skill/outputs/transcript.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/with_skill/outputs/transcript.md similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/with_skill/outputs/transcript.md rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/with_skill/outputs/transcript.md diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/with_skill/outputs/validator.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/with_skill/outputs/validator.py similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/with_skill/outputs/validator.py rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/with_skill/outputs/validator.py diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/with_skill/timing.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/with_skill/timing.json similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/with_skill/timing.json rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/with_skill/timing.json diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/without_skill/grading.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/without_skill/grading.json similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/without_skill/grading.json rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/without_skill/grading.json diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/without_skill/outputs/transcript.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/without_skill/outputs/transcript.md similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/without_skill/outputs/transcript.md rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/without_skill/outputs/transcript.md diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/without_skill/outputs/validator.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/without_skill/outputs/validator.py similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/without_skill/outputs/validator.py rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/without_skill/outputs/validator.py diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/without_skill/timing.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/without_skill/timing.json similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/without_skill/timing.json rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-4-bugmagnet-format/without_skill/timing.json diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/eval_metadata.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/eval_metadata.json deleted file mode 100644 index 8aad61d..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/eval_metadata.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,16 +0,0 @@ -{ - "eval_id": 4, - "eval_name": "cascade-dependencies", - "prompt": "Implement the plan at thoughts/shared/plans/build-task-tracker.md", - "assertions": [ - {"text": "Phase 1 (Task model) is implemented before Phase 2 (TaskRepository)", "type": "behavior"}, - {"text": "Phase 2 (TaskRepository) is implemented before Phase 3 (TaskService)", "type": "behavior"}, - {"text": "make test is executed after each phase (at least 4 times across transcript)", "type": "behavior"}, - {"text": "Checkboxes are marked progressively as each phase completes", "type": "behavior"}, - {"text": "tracker.py contains Task, TaskRepository, TaskService classes and format_task_list function", "type": "content_check"}, - {"text": "TaskService.get_summary correctly returns total reflecting current repo count (accounts for deletions)", "type": "capability"}, - {"text": "make test exits 0 with all tests passing", "type": "content_check"}, - {"text": "Plan file has all checkboxes marked [x]", "type": "content_check"}, - {"text": "Any deviations from the plan are noted in the plan file or communicated to the user", "type": "behavior"} - ] -} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/with_skill/grading.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/with_skill/grading.json deleted file mode 100644 index 4937111..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/with_skill/grading.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,16 +0,0 @@ -{ - "eval_id": 4, - "eval_name": "cascade-dependencies", - "configuration": "with_skill", - "expectations": [ - {"text": "Phase 1 (Task model) is implemented before Phase 2 (TaskRepository)", "passed": true, "evidence": "Agent used 18 tool calls over 80s with phase-by-phase approach; summary confirms sequential implementation"}, - {"text": "Phase 2 (TaskRepository) is implemented before Phase 3 (TaskService)", "passed": true, "evidence": "Same — cascading dependencies required sequential implementation"}, - {"text": "make test is executed after each phase (at least 4 times across transcript)", "passed": true, "evidence": "18 tool calls over 80s for 5 phases; consistent with running make test after each of 5 phases"}, - {"text": "Checkboxes are marked progressively as each phase completes", "passed": true, "evidence": "Output plan has all checkboxes [x]; agent followed skill instructions for progressive marking"}, - {"text": "tracker.py contains Task, TaskRepository, TaskService classes and format_task_list function", "passed": true, "evidence": "Independently verified: 16/16 tests pass, which import all four components"}, - {"text": "TaskService.get_summary correctly returns total reflecting current repo count (accounts for deletions)", "passed": true, "evidence": "test_full_workflow passes: creates 3 tasks, deletes 1, asserts summary total==2"}, - {"text": "make test exits 0 with all tests passing", "passed": true, "evidence": "Independently verified: 16 passed in 0.01s"}, - {"text": "Plan file has all checkboxes marked [x]", "passed": true, "evidence": "Verified in outputs/build-task-tracker.md: all checkboxes are [x]"}, - {"text": "Any deviations from the plan are noted in the plan file or communicated to the user", "passed": true, "evidence": "Agent summary notes adding get_task() and delete_task() to TaskService beyond plan spec, as required by tests"} - ] -} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/with_skill/outputs/build-task-tracker.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/with_skill/outputs/build-task-tracker.md deleted file mode 100644 index 6df4511..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/with_skill/outputs/build-task-tracker.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,45 +0,0 @@ -# Build Task Tracker - -Build a layered task tracking system in a single file (tracker.py). - -## Phase 1: Task data model - -Create the Task class. - -- [x] `Task(title, priority="medium")` creates a task with auto-generated UUID id -- [x] Valid priorities: "low", "medium", "high" — raises `ValueError` otherwise -- [x] `created_at` set to `datetime.now()` on creation -- [x] `status` starts as "todo", `completed_at` starts as None -- [x] `complete()` sets status to "done" and records `completed_at` - -## Phase 2: TaskRepository (in-memory storage) - -Create a repository that stores tasks by ID. - -- [x] `add(task)` stores the task -- [x] `get(task_id)` returns the task or None -- [x] `list_by_status(status)` returns filtered list -- [x] `delete(task_id)` removes the task, raises `KeyError` if not found - -## Phase 3: TaskService (business logic) - -Create a service layer that uses TaskRepository internally. - -- [x] `create_task(title, priority)` creates and stores a Task, returns it -- [x] `complete_task(task_id)` marks a task as done -- [x] `list_pending()` returns all tasks with status "todo" -- [x] `get_summary()` returns `{"total": N, "todo": N, "done": N}` -- [x] Note: `get_summary()` should count tasks in the repository — make sure `total` reflects the current count including any deletions - -## Phase 4: Integration verification - -- [x] Full workflow test passes (create, complete, delete, summary) -- [x] Error handling works across layers (KeyError propagation) - -## Phase 5: CLI output helper - -Add a `format_task_list(tasks)` function for terminal display. - -- [x] Formats each task as `"- [status] Title [priority]"` -- [x] Returns `"No tasks found."` for empty list -- [x] All tests pass with `make test` diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/with_skill/outputs/tracker.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/with_skill/outputs/tracker.py deleted file mode 100644 index f504bd4..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/with_skill/outputs/tracker.py +++ /dev/null @@ -1,80 +0,0 @@ -import uuid -from datetime import datetime - - -class Task: - VALID_PRIORITIES = {"low", "medium", "high"} - - def __init__(self, title, priority="medium"): - if priority not in self.VALID_PRIORITIES: - raise ValueError(f"Priority must be one of {sorted(self.VALID_PRIORITIES)}, got '{priority}'") - self.id = str(uuid.uuid4()) - self.title = title - self.priority = priority - self.created_at = datetime.now() - self.status = "todo" - self.completed_at = None - - def complete(self): - self.status = "done" - self.completed_at = datetime.now() - - -class TaskRepository: - def __init__(self): - self._tasks = {} - - def add(self, task): - self._tasks[task.id] = task - - def get(self, task_id): - return self._tasks.get(task_id) - - def list_by_status(self, status): - return [t for t in self._tasks.values() if t.status == status] - - def delete(self, task_id): - if task_id not in self._tasks: - raise KeyError(f"Task '{task_id}' not found") - del self._tasks[task_id] - - def all(self): - return list(self._tasks.values()) - - -class TaskService: - def __init__(self): - self._repo = TaskRepository() - - def create_task(self, title, priority="medium"): - task = Task(title, priority=priority) - self._repo.add(task) - return task - - def get_task(self, task_id): - return self._repo.get(task_id) - - def complete_task(self, task_id): - task = self._repo.get(task_id) - if task is None: - raise KeyError(f"Task '{task_id}' not found") - task.complete() - - def delete_task(self, task_id): - self._repo.delete(task_id) - - def list_pending(self): - return self._repo.list_by_status("todo") - - def get_summary(self): - all_tasks = self._repo.all() - total = len(all_tasks) - todo = sum(1 for t in all_tasks if t.status == "todo") - done = sum(1 for t in all_tasks if t.status == "done") - return {"total": total, "todo": todo, "done": done} - - -def format_task_list(tasks): - if not tasks: - return "No tasks found." - return "\n".join(f"- [{t.status}] {t.title} [{t.priority}]" for t in tasks) diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/with_skill/timing.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/with_skill/timing.json deleted file mode 100644 index 03e6027..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/with_skill/timing.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,5 +0,0 @@ -{ - "total_tokens": 26751, - "duration_ms": 80134, - "total_duration_seconds": 80.1 -} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/without_skill/grading.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/without_skill/grading.json deleted file mode 100644 index 3d921c8..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/without_skill/grading.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,16 +0,0 @@ -{ - "eval_id": 4, - "eval_name": "cascade-dependencies", - "configuration": "without_skill", - "expectations": [ - {"text": "Phase 1 (Task model) is implemented before Phase 2 (TaskRepository)", "passed": false, "evidence": "Agent used 10 tool calls in 36s — implemented entire tracker.py in one pass"}, - {"text": "Phase 2 (TaskRepository) is implemented before Phase 3 (TaskService)", "passed": false, "evidence": "All classes implemented in a single edit"}, - {"text": "make test is executed after each phase (at least 4 times across transcript)", "passed": false, "evidence": "Only 10 tool calls total — ran make test once at the end"}, - {"text": "Checkboxes are marked progressively as each phase completes", "passed": false, "evidence": "All checkboxes remain [ ] in output plan file"}, - {"text": "tracker.py contains Task, TaskRepository, TaskService classes and format_task_list function", "passed": true, "evidence": "16/16 tests pass, importing all components"}, - {"text": "TaskService.get_summary correctly returns total reflecting current repo count (accounts for deletions)", "passed": true, "evidence": "test_full_workflow passes with deletion + summary assertion"}, - {"text": "make test exits 0 with all tests passing", "passed": true, "evidence": "Independently verified: 16 passed in 0.01s"}, - {"text": "Plan file has all checkboxes marked [x]", "passed": false, "evidence": "All checkboxes remain [ ] in outputs/build-task-tracker.md"}, - {"text": "Any deviations from the plan are noted in the plan file or communicated to the user", "passed": false, "evidence": "No deviation notes in plan or summary about adding get_task/delete_task beyond plan spec"} - ] -} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/without_skill/outputs/build-task-tracker.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/without_skill/outputs/build-task-tracker.md deleted file mode 100644 index bf17b51..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/without_skill/outputs/build-task-tracker.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,45 +0,0 @@ -# Build Task Tracker - -Build a layered task tracking system in a single file (tracker.py). - -## Phase 1: Task data model - -Create the Task class. - -- [ ] `Task(title, priority="medium")` creates a task with auto-generated UUID id -- [ ] Valid priorities: "low", "medium", "high" — raises `ValueError` otherwise -- [ ] `created_at` set to `datetime.now()` on creation -- [ ] `status` starts as "todo", `completed_at` starts as None -- [ ] `complete()` sets status to "done" and records `completed_at` - -## Phase 2: TaskRepository (in-memory storage) - -Create a repository that stores tasks by ID. - -- [ ] `add(task)` stores the task -- [ ] `get(task_id)` returns the task or None -- [ ] `list_by_status(status)` returns filtered list -- [ ] `delete(task_id)` removes the task, raises `KeyError` if not found - -## Phase 3: TaskService (business logic) - -Create a service layer that uses TaskRepository internally. - -- [ ] `create_task(title, priority)` creates and stores a Task, returns it -- [ ] `complete_task(task_id)` marks a task as done -- [ ] `list_pending()` returns all tasks with status "todo" -- [ ] `get_summary()` returns `{"total": N, "todo": N, "done": N}` -- [ ] Note: `get_summary()` should count tasks in the repository — make sure `total` reflects the current count including any deletions - -## Phase 4: Integration verification - -- [ ] Full workflow test passes (create, complete, delete, summary) -- [ ] Error handling works across layers (KeyError propagation) - -## Phase 5: CLI output helper - -Add a `format_task_list(tasks)` function for terminal display. - -- [ ] Formats each task as `"- [status] Title [priority]"` -- [ ] Returns `"No tasks found."` for empty list -- [ ] All tests pass with `make test` diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/without_skill/outputs/tracker.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/without_skill/outputs/tracker.py deleted file mode 100644 index 6d6ae1a..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/without_skill/outputs/tracker.py +++ /dev/null @@ -1,78 +0,0 @@ -import uuid -from datetime import datetime - - -VALID_PRIORITIES = {"low", "medium", "high"} - - -class Task: - def __init__(self, title, priority="medium"): - if priority not in VALID_PRIORITIES: - raise ValueError(f"Priority must be one of {sorted(VALID_PRIORITIES)}, got '{priority}'") - self.id = str(uuid.uuid4()) - self.title = title - self.priority = priority - self.status = "todo" - self.created_at = datetime.now() - self.completed_at = None - - def complete(self): - self.status = "done" - self.completed_at = datetime.now() - - -class TaskRepository: - def __init__(self): - self._tasks = {} - - def add(self, task): - self._tasks[task.id] = task - - def get(self, task_id): - return self._tasks.get(task_id) - - def list_by_status(self, status): - return [t for t in self._tasks.values() if t.status == status] - - def delete(self, task_id): - if task_id not in self._tasks: - raise KeyError(f"Task '{task_id}' not found") - del self._tasks[task_id] - - -class TaskService: - def __init__(self): - self._repo = TaskRepository() - - def create_task(self, title, priority="medium"): - task = Task(title, priority=priority) - self._repo.add(task) - return task - - def get_task(self, task_id): - return self._repo.get(task_id) - - def complete_task(self, task_id): - task = self._repo.get(task_id) - if task is None: - raise KeyError(f"Task '{task_id}' not found") - task.complete() - - def delete_task(self, task_id): - self._repo.delete(task_id) - - def list_pending(self): - return self._repo.list_by_status("todo") - - def get_summary(self): - all_tasks = list(self._repo._tasks.values()) - total = len(all_tasks) - done = sum(1 for t in all_tasks if t.status == "done") - todo = sum(1 for t in all_tasks if t.status == "todo") - return {"total": total, "todo": todo, "done": done} - - -def format_task_list(tasks): - if not tasks: - return "No tasks found." - return "\n".join(f"- [{t.status}] {t.title} [{t.priority}]" for t in tasks) diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/without_skill/timing.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/without_skill/timing.json deleted file mode 100644 index 78cbe7b..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/without_skill/timing.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,5 +0,0 @@ -{ - "total_tokens": 17990, - "duration_ms": 36455, - "total_duration_seconds": 36.5 -} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-completion-messaging/eval_metadata.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-completion-messaging/eval_metadata.json similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-completion-messaging/eval_metadata.json rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-completion-messaging/eval_metadata.json diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-completion-messaging/with_skill/grading.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-completion-messaging/with_skill/grading.json similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-completion-messaging/with_skill/grading.json rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-completion-messaging/with_skill/grading.json diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-5-completion-messaging/without_skill/outputs/add-unit-converters.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-completion-messaging/with_skill/outputs/add-unit-converters.md similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-5-completion-messaging/without_skill/outputs/add-unit-converters.md rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-completion-messaging/with_skill/outputs/add-unit-converters.md diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-5-completion-messaging/without_skill/outputs/converter.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-completion-messaging/with_skill/outputs/converter.py similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-5-completion-messaging/without_skill/outputs/converter.py rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-completion-messaging/with_skill/outputs/converter.py diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-completion-messaging/with_skill/outputs/transcript.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-completion-messaging/with_skill/outputs/transcript.md similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-completion-messaging/with_skill/outputs/transcript.md rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-completion-messaging/with_skill/outputs/transcript.md diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-completion-messaging/with_skill/timing.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-completion-messaging/with_skill/timing.json similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-completion-messaging/with_skill/timing.json rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-completion-messaging/with_skill/timing.json diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-completion-messaging/without_skill/grading.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-completion-messaging/without_skill/grading.json similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-completion-messaging/without_skill/grading.json rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-completion-messaging/without_skill/grading.json diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-completion-messaging/with_skill/outputs/add-unit-converters.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-completion-messaging/without_skill/outputs/add-unit-converters.md similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-completion-messaging/with_skill/outputs/add-unit-converters.md rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-completion-messaging/without_skill/outputs/add-unit-converters.md diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-completion-messaging/without_skill/outputs/converter.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-completion-messaging/without_skill/outputs/converter.py similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-completion-messaging/without_skill/outputs/converter.py rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-completion-messaging/without_skill/outputs/converter.py diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-completion-messaging/without_skill/outputs/transcript.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-completion-messaging/without_skill/outputs/transcript.md similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-completion-messaging/without_skill/outputs/transcript.md rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-completion-messaging/without_skill/outputs/transcript.md diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-completion-messaging/without_skill/timing.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-completion-messaging/without_skill/timing.json similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-completion-messaging/without_skill/timing.json rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-completion-messaging/without_skill/timing.json diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-evolved-codebase/eval_metadata.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-evolved-codebase/eval_metadata.json deleted file mode 100644 index f4ca9ae..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-evolved-codebase/eval_metadata.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,15 +0,0 @@ -{ - "eval_id": 5, - "eval_name": "evolved-codebase", - "prompt": "Implement the plan at thoughts/shared/plans/extend-string-helpers.md", - "assertions": [ - {"text": "Detects that string_helpers.py does not exist", "type": "capability"}, - {"text": "Identifies that the codebase has text_utils.py and text_transforms.py instead", "type": "capability"}, - {"text": "Detects that functions are split across two files (slugify/word_count in text_utils, truncate/title_case in text_transforms)", "type": "capability"}, - {"text": "Presents the file structure mismatch before starting implementation", "type": "behavior"}, - {"text": "Uses structured Issue/Expected/Found format to communicate the mismatch", "type": "behavior"}, - {"text": "If agent adapts, new functions are added to the correct existing files (contains_any/extract_emails to text_utils.py, pad_right/pad_center/repeat_text to text_transforms.py)", "type": "capability"}, - {"text": "Does NOT create a new string_helpers.py file", "type": "capability"}, - {"text": "If agent proceeds, make test exits 0 with all tests passing", "type": "content_check"} - ] -} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-evolved-codebase/with_skill/grading.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-evolved-codebase/with_skill/grading.json deleted file mode 100644 index cbf7767..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-evolved-codebase/with_skill/grading.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,15 +0,0 @@ -{ - "eval_id": 5, - "eval_name": "evolved-codebase", - "configuration": "with_skill", - "expectations": [ - {"text": "Detects that string_helpers.py does not exist", "passed": true, "evidence": "Agent output: 'string_helpers.py does not exist'"}, - {"text": "Identifies that the codebase has text_utils.py and text_transforms.py instead", "passed": true, "evidence": "Agent: 'Codebase was refactored into two modules: text_utils.py and text_transforms.py'"}, - {"text": "Detects that functions are split across two files (slugify/word_count in text_utils, truncate/title_case in text_transforms)", "passed": true, "evidence": "Agent explicitly lists which functions are in which file in the mismatch report"}, - {"text": "Presents the file structure mismatch before starting implementation", "passed": true, "evidence": "Agent's mismatch presentation appears before any code changes were made"}, - {"text": "Uses structured Issue/Expected/Found format to communicate the mismatch", "passed": true, "evidence": "Agent used 'Issue in Phase 1: / Expected: / Found: / Why this matters:' format exactly as prescribed"}, - {"text": "If agent adapts, new functions are added to the correct existing files (contains_any/extract_emails to text_utils.py, pad_right/pad_center/repeat_text to text_transforms.py)", "passed": true, "evidence": "Verified: text_utils.py has contains_any and extract_emails; text_transforms.py has pad_right, pad_center, repeat_text"}, - {"text": "Does NOT create a new string_helpers.py file", "passed": true, "evidence": "Independently verified: string_helpers.py does not exist in either project"}, - {"text": "If agent proceeds, make test exits 0 with all tests passing", "passed": true, "evidence": "Independently verified: 9 passed in 0.01s"} - ] -} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-evolved-codebase/with_skill/outputs/extend-string-helpers.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-evolved-codebase/with_skill/outputs/extend-string-helpers.md deleted file mode 100644 index 0748740..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-evolved-codebase/with_skill/outputs/extend-string-helpers.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,30 +0,0 @@ -# Extend String Helpers - -Add search and padding utilities to the existing string helper module. - -## Phase 1: Review existing code - -- [x] Read `string_helpers.py` and understand the existing functions - - NOTE: `string_helpers.py` does not exist. Codebase was split into `text_utils.py` (slugify, word_count) and `text_transforms.py` (truncate, title_case). Mismatch presented; proceeded with split-module approach matching test file imports. -- [x] Verify `truncate()` and `slugify()` exist in `string_helpers.py` - - NOTE: Found in `text_transforms.py` and `text_utils.py` respectively. -- [x] Confirm existing tests pass - -## Phase 2: Add search functions to string_helpers.py - -Add text search utilities — implemented in `text_utils.py` (matches test imports). - -- [x] `contains_any(text, keywords)` returns True if text contains any keyword -- [x] `extract_emails(text)` returns list of email addresses found in text -- [x] Returns empty list when no emails found -- [x] Tests pass for search functions - -## Phase 3: Add padding and repeat functions to string_helpers.py - -Add text padding utilities — implemented in `text_transforms.py` (matches test imports). - -- [x] `pad_right(text, width)` pads text with spaces to given width -- [x] `pad_center(text, width)` centers text within given width -- [x] `repeat_text(text, count)` repeats text N times -- [x] If text is already longer than width, return unchanged -- [x] All tests pass with `make test` diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-evolved-codebase/with_skill/outputs/text_transforms.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-evolved-codebase/with_skill/outputs/text_transforms.py deleted file mode 100644 index 2de706c..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-evolved-codebase/with_skill/outputs/text_transforms.py +++ /dev/null @@ -1,27 +0,0 @@ -def truncate(text, max_length, suffix="..."): - if len(text) <= max_length: - return text - return text[: max_length - len(suffix)] + suffix - - -def title_case(text): - return " ".join(w.capitalize() for w in text.split()) - - -def pad_right(text, width): - if len(text) >= width: - return text - return text + " " * (width - len(text)) - - -def pad_center(text, width): - if len(text) >= width: - return text - total_padding = width - len(text) - left_padding = total_padding // 2 - right_padding = total_padding - left_padding - return " " * left_padding + text + " " * right_padding - - -def repeat_text(text, count): - return text * count diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-evolved-codebase/with_skill/outputs/text_utils.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-evolved-codebase/with_skill/outputs/text_utils.py deleted file mode 100644 index 9ab28e5..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-evolved-codebase/with_skill/outputs/text_utils.py +++ /dev/null @@ -1,19 +0,0 @@ -import re - - -def slugify(text): - return text.lower().strip().replace(" ", "-") - - -def word_count(text): - if not text or not text.strip(): - return 0 - return len(text.split()) - - -def contains_any(text, keywords): - return any(keyword in text for keyword in keywords) - - -def extract_emails(text): - return re.findall(r"[a-zA-Z0-9._%+-]+@[a-zA-Z0-9.-]+\.[a-zA-Z]{2,}", text) diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-evolved-codebase/with_skill/timing.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-evolved-codebase/with_skill/timing.json deleted file mode 100644 index 29be3da..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-evolved-codebase/with_skill/timing.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,5 +0,0 @@ -{ - "total_tokens": 19926, - "duration_ms": 64789, - "total_duration_seconds": 64.8 -} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-evolved-codebase/without_skill/grading.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-evolved-codebase/without_skill/grading.json deleted file mode 100644 index f01c9d0..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-evolved-codebase/without_skill/grading.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,15 +0,0 @@ -{ - "eval_id": 5, - "eval_name": "evolved-codebase", - "configuration": "without_skill", - "expectations": [ - {"text": "Detects that string_helpers.py does not exist", "passed": true, "evidence": "Agent summary: 'The codebase uses two files rather than a single string_helpers.py'"}, - {"text": "Identifies that the codebase has text_utils.py and text_transforms.py instead", "passed": true, "evidence": "Agent summary mentions both files by name"}, - {"text": "Detects that functions are split across two files (slugify/word_count in text_utils, truncate/title_case in text_transforms)", "passed": false, "evidence": "Agent does not enumerate which existing functions are in which file — only knows the file names from test imports"}, - {"text": "Presents the file structure mismatch before starting implementation", "passed": false, "evidence": "Agent noted the mismatch in its summary but did not present it to the user as a structured finding before proceeding"}, - {"text": "Uses structured Issue/Expected/Found format to communicate the mismatch", "passed": false, "evidence": "Used narrative prose only, no structured format"}, - {"text": "If agent adapts, new functions are added to the correct existing files (contains_any/extract_emails to text_utils.py, pad_right/pad_center/repeat_text to text_transforms.py)", "passed": true, "evidence": "Independently verified: correct file placement"}, - {"text": "Does NOT create a new string_helpers.py file", "passed": true, "evidence": "Independently verified: no string_helpers.py created"}, - {"text": "If agent proceeds, make test exits 0 with all tests passing", "passed": true, "evidence": "Independently verified: 9 passed in 0.01s"} - ] -} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-evolved-codebase/without_skill/outputs/extend-string-helpers.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-evolved-codebase/without_skill/outputs/extend-string-helpers.md deleted file mode 100644 index 9f9cdea..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-evolved-codebase/without_skill/outputs/extend-string-helpers.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,28 +0,0 @@ -# Extend String Helpers - -Add search and padding utilities to the existing string helper module. - -## Phase 1: Review existing code - -- [ ] Read `string_helpers.py` and understand the existing functions -- [ ] Verify `truncate()` and `slugify()` exist in `string_helpers.py` -- [ ] Confirm existing tests pass - -## Phase 2: Add search functions to string_helpers.py - -Add text search utilities to `string_helpers.py`. - -- [ ] `contains_any(text, keywords)` returns True if text contains any keyword -- [ ] `extract_emails(text)` returns list of email addresses found in text -- [ ] Returns empty list when no emails found -- [ ] Tests pass for search functions - -## Phase 3: Add padding and repeat functions to string_helpers.py - -Add text padding utilities to `string_helpers.py`. - -- [ ] `pad_right(text, width)` pads text with spaces to given width -- [ ] `pad_center(text, width)` centers text within given width -- [ ] `repeat_text(text, count)` repeats text N times -- [ ] If text is already longer than width, return unchanged -- [ ] All tests pass with `make test` diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-evolved-codebase/without_skill/outputs/text_transforms.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-evolved-codebase/without_skill/outputs/text_transforms.py deleted file mode 100644 index e11f503..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-evolved-codebase/without_skill/outputs/text_transforms.py +++ /dev/null @@ -1,24 +0,0 @@ -def truncate(text, max_length, suffix="..."): - if len(text) <= max_length: - return text - return text[: max_length - len(suffix)] + suffix - - -def title_case(text): - return " ".join(w.capitalize() for w in text.split()) - - -def pad_right(text, width): - if len(text) >= width: - return text - return text + " " * (width - len(text)) - - -def pad_center(text, width): - if len(text) >= width: - return text - return text.center(width) - - -def repeat_text(text, count): - return text * count diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-evolved-codebase/without_skill/outputs/text_utils.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-evolved-codebase/without_skill/outputs/text_utils.py deleted file mode 100644 index 9ab28e5..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-evolved-codebase/without_skill/outputs/text_utils.py +++ /dev/null @@ -1,19 +0,0 @@ -import re - - -def slugify(text): - return text.lower().strip().replace(" ", "-") - - -def word_count(text): - if not text or not text.strip(): - return 0 - return len(text.split()) - - -def contains_any(text, keywords): - return any(keyword in text for keyword in keywords) - - -def extract_emails(text): - return re.findall(r"[a-zA-Z0-9._%+-]+@[a-zA-Z0-9.-]+\.[a-zA-Z]{2,}", text) diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-evolved-codebase/without_skill/timing.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-evolved-codebase/without_skill/timing.json deleted file mode 100644 index 7b53b25..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-evolved-codebase/without_skill/timing.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,5 +0,0 @@ -{ - "total_tokens": 17233, - "duration_ms": 41591, - "total_duration_seconds": 41.6 -} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/eval_metadata.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/eval_metadata.json deleted file mode 100644 index 1efe83d..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/eval_metadata.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,15 +0,0 @@ -{ - "eval_id": 6, - "eval_name": "resume-buggy-phase", - "prompt": "Implement the plan at thoughts/shared/plans/add-registration-workflow.md", - "assertions": [ - {"text": "Agent starts implementation from Phase 2 (respects Phase 1 [x] checkmarks)", "type": "behavior"}, - {"text": "Agent implements the register function in Phase 2", "type": "content_check"}, - {"text": "When tests fail, agent investigates rather than only modifying Phase 2 code", "type": "capability"}, - {"text": "Agent identifies that the bug is in validate_age (Phase 1): >= 120 should be > 120", "type": "capability"}, - {"text": "Agent communicates that a previously-completed phase has a bug before fixing it", "type": "behavior"}, - {"text": "The bug is fixed: validate_age correctly accepts age 120", "type": "content_check"}, - {"text": "registration.py contains register and batch_register functions", "type": "content_check"}, - {"text": "make test exits 0 with all tests passing", "type": "content_check"} - ] -} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/with_skill/grading.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/with_skill/grading.json deleted file mode 100644 index 64b27ce..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/with_skill/grading.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,15 +0,0 @@ -{ - "eval_id": 6, - "eval_name": "resume-buggy-phase", - "configuration": "with_skill", - "expectations": [ - {"text": "Agent starts implementation from Phase 2 (respects Phase 1 [x] checkmarks)", "passed": true, "evidence": "Agent summary: started with Phase 2, bug was caught when running tests (not by re-implementing Phase 1)"}, - {"text": "Agent implements the register function in Phase 2", "passed": true, "evidence": "Verified in outputs/registration.py: register function at line 34"}, - {"text": "When tests fail, agent investigates rather than only modifying Phase 2 code", "passed": true, "evidence": "Agent identified the bug in Phase 1's validate_age, not in Phase 2 code"}, - {"text": "Agent identifies that the bug is in validate_age (Phase 1): >= 120 should be > 120", "passed": true, "evidence": "Agent summary: 'validate_age used age >= 120 instead of age > 120'"}, - {"text": "Agent communicates that a previously-completed phase has a bug before fixing it", "passed": true, "evidence": "Agent explicitly labeled this as 'Bug detected and fixed in Phase 1 (despite being marked [x])'"}, - {"text": "The bug is fixed: validate_age correctly accepts age 120", "passed": true, "evidence": "Verified in outputs/registration.py line 19: 'age > 120' (not >= 120)"}, - {"text": "registration.py contains register and batch_register functions", "passed": true, "evidence": "Verified: register at line 34, batch_register at line 46"}, - {"text": "make test exits 0 with all tests passing", "passed": true, "evidence": "Independently verified: 17 passed in 0.01s"} - ] -} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/with_skill/outputs/add-registration-workflow.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/with_skill/outputs/add-registration-workflow.md deleted file mode 100644 index 783c45f..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/with_skill/outputs/add-registration-workflow.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,25 +0,0 @@ -# Add Registration Workflow - -Build a registration system with validation, single registration, and batch processing. - -## Phase 1: Input validators - -- [x] `validate_email(email)` validates email format with regex -- [x] `validate_age(age)` ensures age is between 18 and 120 inclusive -- [x] `validate_username(username)` ensures min 3 chars, alphanumeric + underscore only -- [x] All validator tests pass - -## Phase 2: Register function - -- [x] `register(username, email, age)` validates all inputs then returns registration dict -- [x] Return dict includes: username, email, age, registered_at (ISO timestamp) -- [x] Raises validation errors from the individual validators -- [x] Tests pass for register scenarios - -## Phase 3: Batch register function - -- [x] `batch_register(users)` processes a list of user dicts -- [x] Returns `{"succeeded": [...], "failed": [...]}` -- [x] Failed entries include the original data plus an "error" key with the message -- [x] Does not stop on first failure — processes all entries -- [x] All tests pass with `make test` diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/with_skill/outputs/registration.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/with_skill/outputs/registration.py deleted file mode 100644 index f038550..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/with_skill/outputs/registration.py +++ /dev/null @@ -1,55 +0,0 @@ -import re -from datetime import datetime, timezone - - -def validate_email(email): - if not email or not isinstance(email, str): - raise ValueError("Email is required") - pattern = r"^[a-zA-Z0-9._%+-]+@[a-zA-Z0-9.-]+\.[a-zA-Z]{2,}$" - if not re.match(pattern, email): - raise ValueError("Invalid email format") - return True - - -def validate_age(age): - if age is None: - raise ValueError("Age is required") - if not isinstance(age, int): - raise ValueError("Age must be an integer") - if age < 18 or age > 120: - raise ValueError("Age must be between 18 and 120") - return True - - -def validate_username(username): - if not username or not isinstance(username, str): - raise ValueError("Username is required") - if len(username) < 3: - raise ValueError("Username must be at least 3 characters") - if not re.match(r"^[a-zA-Z0-9_]+$", username): - raise ValueError("Username can only contain letters, numbers, and underscores") - return True - - -def register(username, email, age): - validate_username(username) - validate_email(email) - validate_age(age) - return { - "username": username, - "email": email, - "age": age, - "registered_at": datetime.now(timezone.utc).isoformat(), - } - - -def batch_register(users): - succeeded = [] - failed = [] - for user in users: - try: - result = register(user["username"], user["email"], user["age"]) - succeeded.append(result) - except (ValueError, KeyError) as e: - failed.append({**user, "error": str(e)}) - return {"succeeded": succeeded, "failed": failed} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/with_skill/timing.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/with_skill/timing.json deleted file mode 100644 index f10c7f6..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/with_skill/timing.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,5 +0,0 @@ -{ - "total_tokens": 21745, - "duration_ms": 57188, - "total_duration_seconds": 57.2 -} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/without_skill/grading.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/without_skill/grading.json deleted file mode 100644 index adb77a8..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/without_skill/grading.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,15 +0,0 @@ -{ - "eval_id": 6, - "eval_name": "resume-buggy-phase", - "configuration": "without_skill", - "expectations": [ - {"text": "Agent starts implementation from Phase 2 (respects Phase 1 [x] checkmarks)", "passed": false, "evidence": "Agent fixed the Phase 1 bug proactively before implementing Phase 2 — did not trust the [x] marks"}, - {"text": "Agent implements the register function in Phase 2", "passed": true, "evidence": "Verified in outputs: register function present"}, - {"text": "When tests fail, agent investigates rather than only modifying Phase 2 code", "passed": true, "evidence": "Agent found and fixed the validate_age bug"}, - {"text": "Agent identifies that the bug is in validate_age (Phase 1): >= 120 should be > 120", "passed": true, "evidence": "Agent summary: 'validate_age had an off-by-one error: age >= 120 was rejecting 120'"}, - {"text": "Agent communicates that a previously-completed phase has a bug before fixing it", "passed": false, "evidence": "Agent fixed the bug without flagging it as a previously-completed phase issue — just described it as 'Bug fixed'"}, - {"text": "The bug is fixed: validate_age correctly accepts age 120", "passed": true, "evidence": "Independently verified: 17 tests pass including test_validate_age_boundary_120"}, - {"text": "registration.py contains register and batch_register functions", "passed": true, "evidence": "Verified in test results: all register and batch_register tests pass"}, - {"text": "make test exits 0 with all tests passing", "passed": true, "evidence": "Independently verified: 17 passed in 0.01s"} - ] -} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/without_skill/outputs/add-registration-workflow.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/without_skill/outputs/add-registration-workflow.md deleted file mode 100644 index b31815a..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/without_skill/outputs/add-registration-workflow.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,25 +0,0 @@ -# Add Registration Workflow - -Build a registration system with validation, single registration, and batch processing. - -## Phase 1: Input validators - -- [x] `validate_email(email)` validates email format with regex -- [x] `validate_age(age)` ensures age is between 18 and 120 inclusive -- [x] `validate_username(username)` ensures min 3 chars, alphanumeric + underscore only -- [x] All validator tests pass - -## Phase 2: Register function - -- [ ] `register(username, email, age)` validates all inputs then returns registration dict -- [ ] Return dict includes: username, email, age, registered_at (ISO timestamp) -- [ ] Raises validation errors from the individual validators -- [ ] Tests pass for register scenarios - -## Phase 3: Batch register function - -- [ ] `batch_register(users)` processes a list of user dicts -- [ ] Returns `{"succeeded": [...], "failed": [...]}` -- [ ] Failed entries include the original data plus an "error" key with the message -- [ ] Does not stop on first failure — processes all entries -- [ ] All tests pass with `make test` diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/without_skill/outputs/registration.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/without_skill/outputs/registration.py deleted file mode 100644 index f038550..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/without_skill/outputs/registration.py +++ /dev/null @@ -1,55 +0,0 @@ -import re -from datetime import datetime, timezone - - -def validate_email(email): - if not email or not isinstance(email, str): - raise ValueError("Email is required") - pattern = r"^[a-zA-Z0-9._%+-]+@[a-zA-Z0-9.-]+\.[a-zA-Z]{2,}$" - if not re.match(pattern, email): - raise ValueError("Invalid email format") - return True - - -def validate_age(age): - if age is None: - raise ValueError("Age is required") - if not isinstance(age, int): - raise ValueError("Age must be an integer") - if age < 18 or age > 120: - raise ValueError("Age must be between 18 and 120") - return True - - -def validate_username(username): - if not username or not isinstance(username, str): - raise ValueError("Username is required") - if len(username) < 3: - raise ValueError("Username must be at least 3 characters") - if not re.match(r"^[a-zA-Z0-9_]+$", username): - raise ValueError("Username can only contain letters, numbers, and underscores") - return True - - -def register(username, email, age): - validate_username(username) - validate_email(email) - validate_age(age) - return { - "username": username, - "email": email, - "age": age, - "registered_at": datetime.now(timezone.utc).isoformat(), - } - - -def batch_register(users): - succeeded = [] - failed = [] - for user in users: - try: - result = register(user["username"], user["email"], user["age"]) - succeeded.append(result) - except (ValueError, KeyError) as e: - failed.append({**user, "error": str(e)}) - return {"succeeded": succeeded, "failed": failed} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/without_skill/outputs/test_registration.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/without_skill/outputs/test_registration.py deleted file mode 100644 index 8d24160..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/without_skill/outputs/test_registration.py +++ /dev/null @@ -1,109 +0,0 @@ -import pytest -from registration import validate_email, validate_age, validate_username - - -# --- Phase 1 tests: validators (already "done") --- - -def test_validate_email_valid(): - assert validate_email("user@example.com") is True - - -def test_validate_email_invalid(): - with pytest.raises(ValueError, match="Invalid email format"): - validate_email("not-an-email") - - -def test_validate_email_empty(): - with pytest.raises(ValueError, match="Email is required"): - validate_email("") - - -def test_validate_age_valid(): - assert validate_age(25) is True - - -def test_validate_age_too_young(): - with pytest.raises(ValueError, match="Age must be between 18 and 120"): - validate_age(17) - - -def test_validate_age_boundary_18(): - assert validate_age(18) is True - - -def test_validate_age_boundary_120(): - assert validate_age(120) is True - - -def test_validate_age_none(): - with pytest.raises(ValueError, match="Age is required"): - validate_age(None) - - -def test_validate_username_valid(): - assert validate_username("john_doe") is True - - -def test_validate_username_too_short(): - with pytest.raises(ValueError, match="Username must be at least 3 characters"): - validate_username("ab") - - -def test_validate_username_special_chars(): - with pytest.raises(ValueError, match="Username can only contain"): - validate_username("user@name") - - -# --- Phase 2 tests: register function --- - -def test_register_success(): - from registration import register - result = register("alice", "alice@example.com", 25) - assert result["username"] == "alice" - assert result["email"] == "alice@example.com" - assert result["age"] == 25 - assert "registered_at" in result - - -def test_register_invalid_email(): - from registration import register - with pytest.raises(ValueError, match="Invalid email format"): - register("alice", "bad-email", 25) - - -def test_register_underage(): - from registration import register - with pytest.raises(ValueError, match="Age must be between 18 and 120"): - register("alice", "alice@example.com", 16) - - -def test_register_invalid_username(): - from registration import register - with pytest.raises(ValueError, match="Username must be at least 3 characters"): - register("ab", "ab@example.com", 25) - - -# --- Phase 3 tests: batch_register --- - -def test_batch_register_all_valid(): - from registration import batch_register - users = [ - {"username": "alice", "email": "alice@test.com", "age": 25}, - {"username": "bob", "email": "bob@test.com", "age": 30}, - ] - results = batch_register(users) - assert len(results["succeeded"]) == 2 - assert len(results["failed"]) == 0 - - -def test_batch_register_mixed(): - from registration import batch_register - users = [ - {"username": "alice", "email": "alice@test.com", "age": 25}, - {"username": "x", "email": "x@test.com", "age": 25}, - {"username": "bob", "email": "bad-email", "age": 30}, - ] - results = batch_register(users) - assert len(results["succeeded"]) == 1 - assert len(results["failed"]) == 2 - assert all("error" in f for f in results["failed"]) diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/without_skill/timing.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/without_skill/timing.json deleted file mode 100644 index 750429f..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/without_skill/timing.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,5 +0,0 @@ -{ - "total_tokens": 18346, - "duration_ms": 44114, - "total_duration_seconds": 44.1 -} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-7-completion-messaging/eval_metadata.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-7-completion-messaging/eval_metadata.json deleted file mode 100644 index c468397..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-7-completion-messaging/eval_metadata.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,14 +0,0 @@ -{ - "eval_id": 7, - "eval_name": "completion-messaging", - "prompt": "Implement the plan at thoughts/shared/plans/add-unit-converters.md", - "assertions": [ - {"text": "converter.py contains kg_to_lb, lb_to_kg, km_to_miles, and miles_to_km functions", "type": "content_check"}, - {"text": "make test exits 0 with all tests passing", "type": "content_check"}, - {"text": "Plan file has all checkboxes marked [x]", "type": "content_check"}, - {"text": "Completion message references validate-plan as a next step", "type": "behavior"}, - {"text": "Completion message references stepwise-git:commit as a next step", "type": "behavior"}, - {"text": "Completion message suggests using /clear to free context", "type": "behavior"}, - {"text": "Completion message includes a summary of what was accomplished", "type": "behavior"} - ] -} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-7-completion-messaging/with_skill/grading.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-7-completion-messaging/with_skill/grading.json deleted file mode 100644 index 82fee17..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-7-completion-messaging/with_skill/grading.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,14 +0,0 @@ -{ - "eval_id": 7, - "eval_name": "completion-messaging", - "configuration": "with_skill", - "expectations": [ - {"text": "converter.py contains kg_to_lb, lb_to_kg, km_to_miles, and miles_to_km functions", "passed": true, "evidence": "Independently verified: 8/8 tests pass importing all four functions"}, - {"text": "make test exits 0 with all tests passing", "passed": true, "evidence": "Independently verified: 8 passed in 0.01s"}, - {"text": "Plan file has all checkboxes marked [x]", "passed": true, "evidence": "Verified in outputs/add-unit-converters.md: all 6 checkboxes are [x]"}, - {"text": "Completion message references validate-plan as a next step", "passed": true, "evidence": "Agent output includes '/stepwise-core:validate-plan thoughts/shared/plans/add-unit-converters.md'"}, - {"text": "Completion message references stepwise-git:commit as a next step", "passed": true, "evidence": "Agent output includes '/stepwise-git:commit'"}, - {"text": "Completion message suggests using /clear to free context", "passed": true, "evidence": "Agent output includes 'Tip: Use /clear to free up context before validation'"}, - {"text": "Completion message includes a summary of what was accomplished", "passed": true, "evidence": "Agent output lists Phase 1 and Phase 2 accomplishments with details"} - ] -} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-7-completion-messaging/with_skill/outputs/add-unit-converters.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-7-completion-messaging/with_skill/outputs/add-unit-converters.md deleted file mode 100644 index da98de7..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-7-completion-messaging/with_skill/outputs/add-unit-converters.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,15 +0,0 @@ -# Add Unit Converters - -Extend converter.py with weight and distance conversion functions. - -## Phase 1: Weight conversions - -- [x] `kg_to_lb(kg)` converts kilograms to pounds (1 kg = 2.20462 lb) -- [x] `lb_to_kg(lb)` converts pounds to kilograms -- [x] Tests pass for weight conversions - -## Phase 2: Distance conversions - -- [x] `km_to_miles(km)` converts kilometers to miles (1 km = 0.621371 miles) -- [x] `miles_to_km(miles)` converts miles to kilometers -- [x] All tests pass with `make test` diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-7-completion-messaging/with_skill/outputs/converter.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-7-completion-messaging/with_skill/outputs/converter.py deleted file mode 100644 index 675d2b1..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-7-completion-messaging/with_skill/outputs/converter.py +++ /dev/null @@ -1,22 +0,0 @@ -def celsius_to_fahrenheit(celsius): - return (celsius * 9 / 5) + 32 - - -def fahrenheit_to_celsius(fahrenheit): - return (fahrenheit - 32) * 5 / 9 - - -def kg_to_lb(kg): - return kg * 2.20462 - - -def lb_to_kg(lb): - return lb / 2.20462 - - -def km_to_miles(km): - return km * 0.621371 - - -def miles_to_km(miles): - return miles / 0.621371 diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-7-completion-messaging/with_skill/timing.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-7-completion-messaging/with_skill/timing.json deleted file mode 100644 index ce3ecfe..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-7-completion-messaging/with_skill/timing.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,5 +0,0 @@ -{ - "total_tokens": 17802, - "duration_ms": 40221, - "total_duration_seconds": 40.2 -} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-7-completion-messaging/without_skill/grading.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-7-completion-messaging/without_skill/grading.json deleted file mode 100644 index 6210663..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-7-completion-messaging/without_skill/grading.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,14 +0,0 @@ -{ - "eval_id": 7, - "eval_name": "completion-messaging", - "configuration": "without_skill", - "expectations": [ - {"text": "converter.py contains kg_to_lb, lb_to_kg, km_to_miles, and miles_to_km functions", "passed": true, "evidence": "Independently verified: 8/8 tests pass"}, - {"text": "make test exits 0 with all tests passing", "passed": true, "evidence": "Independently verified: 8 passed in 0.01s"}, - {"text": "Plan file has all checkboxes marked [x]", "passed": false, "evidence": "All checkboxes remain [ ] in outputs/add-unit-converters.md"}, - {"text": "Completion message references validate-plan as a next step", "passed": false, "evidence": "No mention of validate-plan in agent output"}, - {"text": "Completion message references stepwise-git:commit as a next step", "passed": false, "evidence": "No mention of stepwise-git:commit in agent output"}, - {"text": "Completion message suggests using /clear to free context", "passed": false, "evidence": "No mention of /clear in agent output"}, - {"text": "Completion message includes a summary of what was accomplished", "passed": true, "evidence": "Agent output includes a summary listing all 4 functions added"} - ] -} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-7-completion-messaging/without_skill/outputs/add-unit-converters.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-7-completion-messaging/without_skill/outputs/add-unit-converters.md deleted file mode 100644 index c0a6f92..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-7-completion-messaging/without_skill/outputs/add-unit-converters.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,15 +0,0 @@ -# Add Unit Converters - -Extend converter.py with weight and distance conversion functions. - -## Phase 1: Weight conversions - -- [ ] `kg_to_lb(kg)` converts kilograms to pounds (1 kg = 2.20462 lb) -- [ ] `lb_to_kg(lb)` converts pounds to kilograms -- [ ] Tests pass for weight conversions - -## Phase 2: Distance conversions - -- [ ] `km_to_miles(km)` converts kilometers to miles (1 km = 0.621371 miles) -- [ ] `miles_to_km(miles)` converts miles to kilometers -- [ ] All tests pass with `make test` diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-7-completion-messaging/without_skill/outputs/converter.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-7-completion-messaging/without_skill/outputs/converter.py deleted file mode 100644 index 675d2b1..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-7-completion-messaging/without_skill/outputs/converter.py +++ /dev/null @@ -1,22 +0,0 @@ -def celsius_to_fahrenheit(celsius): - return (celsius * 9 / 5) + 32 - - -def fahrenheit_to_celsius(fahrenheit): - return (fahrenheit - 32) * 5 / 9 - - -def kg_to_lb(kg): - return kg * 2.20462 - - -def lb_to_kg(lb): - return lb / 2.20462 - - -def km_to_miles(km): - return km * 0.621371 - - -def miles_to_km(miles): - return miles / 0.621371 diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-7-completion-messaging/without_skill/timing.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-7-completion-messaging/without_skill/timing.json deleted file mode 100644 index 67ecd09..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/eval-7-completion-messaging/without_skill/timing.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,5 +0,0 @@ -{ - "total_tokens": 15853, - "duration_ms": 30916, - "total_duration_seconds": 30.9 -} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/evals/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline/Makefile b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline-with_skill/Makefile similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/evals/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline/Makefile rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline-with_skill/Makefile diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-1-phase-discipline/with_skill/outputs/inventory.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline-with_skill/inventory.py similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-1-phase-discipline/with_skill/outputs/inventory.py rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline-with_skill/inventory.py diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/evals/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline/test_inventory.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline-with_skill/test_inventory.py similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/evals/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline/test_inventory.py rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline-with_skill/test_inventory.py diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline-with_skill/test_inventory_bugmagnet.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline-with_skill/test_inventory_bugmagnet.py similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline-with_skill/test_inventory_bugmagnet.py rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline-with_skill/test_inventory_bugmagnet.py diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline-with_skill/Makefile b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline-without_skill/Makefile similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline-with_skill/Makefile rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline-without_skill/Makefile diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/outputs/inventory.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline-without_skill/inventory.py similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-1/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/outputs/inventory.py rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline-without_skill/inventory.py diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline-with_skill/test_inventory.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline-without_skill/test_inventory.py similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline-with_skill/test_inventory.py rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline-without_skill/test_inventory.py diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline-without_skill/test_inventory_bugmagnet.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline-without_skill/test_inventory_bugmagnet.py similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline-without_skill/test_inventory_bugmagnet.py rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-1-phase-discipline-without_skill/test_inventory_bugmagnet.py diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-3-pause-order-with_skill/Makefile b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-3-pause-order-with_skill/Makefile similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-3-pause-order-with_skill/Makefile rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-3-pause-order-with_skill/Makefile diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-3-pause-order-with_skill/stats.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-3-pause-order-with_skill/stats.py similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-3-pause-order-with_skill/stats.py rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-3-pause-order-with_skill/stats.py diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-3-pause-order-with_skill/test_stats.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-3-pause-order-with_skill/test_stats.py similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-3-pause-order-with_skill/test_stats.py rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-3-pause-order-with_skill/test_stats.py diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-3-pause-order-without_skill/Makefile b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-3-pause-order-without_skill/Makefile similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-3-pause-order-without_skill/Makefile rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-3-pause-order-without_skill/Makefile diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-3-pause-order-without_skill/stats.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-3-pause-order-without_skill/stats.py similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-3-pause-order-without_skill/stats.py rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-3-pause-order-without_skill/stats.py diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-3-pause-order-without_skill/test_stats.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-3-pause-order-without_skill/test_stats.py similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-3-pause-order-without_skill/test_stats.py rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-3-pause-order-without_skill/test_stats.py diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-4-bugmagnet-format-with_skill/Makefile b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-4-bugmagnet-format-with_skill/Makefile similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-4-bugmagnet-format-with_skill/Makefile rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-4-bugmagnet-format-with_skill/Makefile diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-4-bugmagnet-format-with_skill/test_validator.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-4-bugmagnet-format-with_skill/test_validator.py similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-4-bugmagnet-format-with_skill/test_validator.py rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-4-bugmagnet-format-with_skill/test_validator.py diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-4-bugmagnet-format-with_skill/test_validator_bugmagnet.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-4-bugmagnet-format-with_skill/test_validator_bugmagnet.py similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-4-bugmagnet-format-with_skill/test_validator_bugmagnet.py rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-4-bugmagnet-format-with_skill/test_validator_bugmagnet.py diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-4-bugmagnet-format-with_skill/validator.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-4-bugmagnet-format-with_skill/validator.py similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-4-bugmagnet-format-with_skill/validator.py rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-4-bugmagnet-format-with_skill/validator.py diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-4-bugmagnet-format-without_skill/Makefile b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-4-bugmagnet-format-without_skill/Makefile similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-4-bugmagnet-format-without_skill/Makefile rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-4-bugmagnet-format-without_skill/Makefile diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-4-bugmagnet-format-without_skill/test_validator.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-4-bugmagnet-format-without_skill/test_validator.py similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-4-bugmagnet-format-without_skill/test_validator.py rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-4-bugmagnet-format-without_skill/test_validator.py diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-4-bugmagnet-format-without_skill/test_validator_bugmagnet.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-4-bugmagnet-format-without_skill/test_validator_bugmagnet.py similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-4-bugmagnet-format-without_skill/test_validator_bugmagnet.py rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-4-bugmagnet-format-without_skill/test_validator_bugmagnet.py diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-4-bugmagnet-format-without_skill/validator.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-4-bugmagnet-format-without_skill/validator.py similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-4-bugmagnet-format-without_skill/validator.py rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-4-bugmagnet-format-without_skill/validator.py diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/evals/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase/Makefile b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase-with_skill/Makefile similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/evals/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase/Makefile rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase-with_skill/Makefile diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/evals/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase/test_text.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase-with_skill/test_text.py similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/evals/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase/test_text.py rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase-with_skill/test_text.py diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase-with_skill/text_transforms.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase-with_skill/text_transforms.py similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase-with_skill/text_transforms.py rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase-with_skill/text_transforms.py diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-evolved-codebase/without_skill/outputs/text_utils.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase-with_skill/text_utils.py similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-evolved-codebase/without_skill/outputs/text_utils.py rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase-with_skill/text_utils.py diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase-with_skill/Makefile b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase-without_skill/Makefile similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase-with_skill/Makefile rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase-without_skill/Makefile diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase-with_skill/test_text.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase-without_skill/test_text.py similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase-with_skill/test_text.py rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase-without_skill/test_text.py diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-evolved-codebase/without_skill/outputs/text_transforms.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase-without_skill/text_transforms.py similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-2-evolved-codebase/without_skill/outputs/text_transforms.py rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase-without_skill/text_transforms.py diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase-with_skill/text_utils.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase-without_skill/text_utils.py similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase-with_skill/text_utils.py rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-5-evolved-codebase-without_skill/text_utils.py diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/evals/projects/eval-7-completion-messaging/Makefile b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-7-completion-messaging-with_skill/Makefile similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/evals/projects/eval-7-completion-messaging/Makefile rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-7-completion-messaging-with_skill/Makefile diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-completion-messaging/with_skill/outputs/converter.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-7-completion-messaging-with_skill/converter.py similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/eval-5-completion-messaging/with_skill/outputs/converter.py rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-7-completion-messaging-with_skill/converter.py diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/evals/projects/eval-7-completion-messaging/test_converter.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-7-completion-messaging-with_skill/test_converter.py similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/evals/projects/eval-7-completion-messaging/test_converter.py rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-7-completion-messaging-with_skill/test_converter.py diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-7-completion-messaging-with_skill/Makefile b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-7-completion-messaging-without_skill/Makefile similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-7-completion-messaging-with_skill/Makefile rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-7-completion-messaging-without_skill/Makefile diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-7-completion-messaging-without_skill/converter.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-7-completion-messaging-without_skill/converter.py similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-7-completion-messaging-without_skill/converter.py rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-7-completion-messaging-without_skill/converter.py diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-7-completion-messaging-with_skill/test_converter.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-7-completion-messaging-without_skill/test_converter.py similarity index 100% rename from core/skills/implement-plan-evolution-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-7-completion-messaging-with_skill/test_converter.py rename to core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-2/projects/eval-7-completion-messaging-without_skill/test_converter.py diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/benchmark.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/benchmark.json deleted file mode 100644 index 7d32eab..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/benchmark.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,233 +0,0 @@ -{ - "metadata": { - "skill_name": "implement-plan", - "skill_path": "/Users/jorge.castro/mordor/personal/stepwise-dev/core/skills/implement-plan", - "executor_model": "claude-sonnet-4-6", - "analyzer_model": "claude-sonnet-4-6", - "timestamp": "2026-04-26T00:30:00Z", - "evals_run": [1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7], - "runs_per_configuration": 1, - "iteration": 3, - "skill_change": "Split mismatch handling into naming (adapt silently, document inline) vs structural (STOP with Issue/Expected/Found format)" - }, - "runs": [ - { - "eval_id": 1, "eval_name": "phase-discipline", "configuration": "with_skill", "run_number": 1, - "result": {"pass_rate": 1.00, "passed": 7, "failed": 0, "total": 7, "time_seconds": 66.7, "tokens": 24053, "tool_calls": 18, "errors": 0}, - "expectations": [ - {"text": "make test is executed at least 3 times across the transcript", "passed": true, "evidence": "Agent summary confirms phase-by-phase test runs; 18 tool calls consistent with multiple make test executions"}, - {"text": "Phase 1 (remove_item) is implemented and verified before Phase 2 (total_value) begins", "passed": true, "evidence": "Agent confirms sequential: Phase 1 → Phase 2 → Phase 3 → Phase 4"}, - {"text": "Phase 2 (total_value) is implemented and verified before Phase 3 (apply_discount) begins", "passed": true, "evidence": "Agent confirms sequential implementation"}, - {"text": "Checkboxes in the plan file are marked progressively as phases complete", "passed": true, "evidence": "Output plan has all 13 checkboxes [x]; agent confirmed progressive marking"}, - {"text": "inventory.py contains remove_item, total_value, and apply_discount methods", "passed": true, "evidence": "All 16 tests pass"}, - {"text": "make test exits 0 with all tests passing", "passed": true, "evidence": "Verified: 16 passed"}, - {"text": "Plan file has all checkboxes marked [x]", "passed": true, "evidence": "Verified: 13 [x]"} - ] - }, - { - "eval_id": 1, "eval_name": "phase-discipline", "configuration": "without_skill", "run_number": 1, - "result": {"pass_rate": 0.29, "passed": 2, "failed": 5, "total": 7, "time_seconds": 38.0, "tokens": 17659, "tool_calls": 13, "errors": 0}, - "expectations": [ - {"text": "make test is executed at least 3 times across the transcript", "passed": false, "evidence": "Single make test at end"}, - {"text": "Phase 1 is implemented before Phase 2", "passed": false, "evidence": "All methods in one edit"}, - {"text": "Phase 2 is implemented before Phase 3", "passed": false, "evidence": "All methods in one edit"}, - {"text": "Checkboxes marked progressively", "passed": false, "evidence": "All remain [ ]"}, - {"text": "inventory.py contains all methods", "passed": true, "evidence": "16 tests pass"}, - {"text": "make test exits 0", "passed": true, "evidence": "16 passed"}, - {"text": "Plan all [x]", "passed": false, "evidence": "All remain [ ]"} - ] - }, - { - "eval_id": 2, "eval_name": "ambiguous-mismatch", "configuration": "with_skill", "run_number": 1, - "result": {"pass_rate": 1.00, "passed": 7, "failed": 0, "total": 7, "time_seconds": 73.5, "tokens": 22002, "tool_calls": 17, "errors": 0}, - "expectations": [ - {"text": "Detects Order vs PurchaseOrder mismatch", "passed": true, "evidence": "DEVIATION comment in plan"}, - {"text": "Detects compute_total vs calculate_total mismatch", "passed": true, "evidence": "DEVIATION comment in plan"}, - {"text": "Detects cancel(note) vs cancel(reason) mismatch", "passed": true, "evidence": "DEVIATION comment in plan"}, - {"text": "Adapts to actual codebase names", "passed": true, "evidence": "Tests as source of truth"}, - {"text": "Documents naming deviations inline in plan", "passed": true, "evidence": "Three DEVIATION comments"}, - {"text": "Does NOT rename PurchaseOrder to Order", "passed": true, "evidence": "Class remains PurchaseOrder"}, - {"text": "Tests pass with correct adaptation", "passed": true, "evidence": "10 passed"} - ] - }, - { - "eval_id": 2, "eval_name": "ambiguous-mismatch", "configuration": "without_skill", "run_number": 1, - "result": {"pass_rate": 0.43, "passed": 3, "failed": 4, "total": 7, "time_seconds": 50.2, "tokens": 18108, "tool_calls": 15, "errors": 0}, - "expectations": [ - {"text": "Detects Order vs PurchaseOrder mismatch", "passed": true, "evidence": "Noted in summary"}, - {"text": "Detects compute_total vs calculate_total mismatch", "passed": false, "evidence": "Not mentioned"}, - {"text": "Detects cancel(note) vs cancel(reason) mismatch", "passed": true, "evidence": "Noted in summary"}, - {"text": "Adapts to actual codebase names", "passed": true, "evidence": "Tests pass"}, - {"text": "Documents naming deviations inline in plan", "passed": false, "evidence": "No inline notes, all checkboxes [ ]"}, - {"text": "Does NOT rename PurchaseOrder to Order", "passed": true, "evidence": "Class remains PurchaseOrder"}, - {"text": "Tests pass with correct adaptation", "passed": false, "evidence": "Tests pass but plan not updated"} - ] - }, - { - "eval_id": 3, "eval_name": "manual-verification", "configuration": "with_skill", "run_number": 1, - "result": {"pass_rate": 1.00, "passed": 7, "failed": 0, "total": 7, "time_seconds": 103.9, "tokens": 24301, "tool_calls": 18, "errors": 0}, - "expectations": [ - {"text": "Phase 1 completed without pausing", "passed": true, "evidence": "Proceeded to Phase 2"}, - {"text": "Pauses after Phase 2 for Manual Verification", "passed": true, "evidence": "Phase 2 Complete - Ready for Manual Verification"}, - {"text": "Pause message lists specific items", "passed": true, "evidence": "All three items listed"}, - {"text": "Manual Verification checkboxes remain [ ]", "passed": true, "evidence": "Verified in plan"}, - {"text": "formatter.py contains both functions", "passed": true, "evidence": "Both present"}, - {"text": "make test exits 0", "passed": true, "evidence": "9 passed"}, - {"text": "Phase 1 and 2 code checkboxes [x]", "passed": true, "evidence": "Verified"} - ] - }, - { - "eval_id": 3, "eval_name": "manual-verification", "configuration": "without_skill", "run_number": 1, - "result": {"pass_rate": 0.43, "passed": 3, "failed": 4, "total": 7, "time_seconds": 221.8, "tokens": 36294, "tool_calls": 46, "errors": 0}, - "expectations": [ - {"text": "Phase 1 completed without pausing", "passed": true, "evidence": "No pauses at all"}, - {"text": "Pauses after Phase 2", "passed": false, "evidence": "Completed without pausing"}, - {"text": "Pause message lists items", "passed": false, "evidence": "No pause message"}, - {"text": "Manual Verification checkboxes remain [ ]", "passed": true, "evidence": "All checkboxes [ ]"}, - {"text": "formatter.py contains both functions", "passed": true, "evidence": "Both present, 9 tests pass"}, - {"text": "make test exits 0", "passed": true, "evidence": "9 passed"}, - {"text": "Phase 1 and 2 code checkboxes [x]", "passed": false, "evidence": "All remain [ ]"} - ] - }, - { - "eval_id": 4, "eval_name": "cascade-dependencies", "configuration": "with_skill", "run_number": 1, - "result": {"pass_rate": 0.78, "passed": 7, "failed": 2, "total": 9, "time_seconds": 67.3, "tokens": 22000, "tool_calls": 14, "errors": 0}, - "expectations": [ - {"text": "Phase 1 before Phase 2", "passed": true, "evidence": "Sequential confirmed"}, - {"text": "Phase 2 before Phase 3", "passed": true, "evidence": "Sequential confirmed"}, - {"text": "make test at least 4 times", "passed": false, "evidence": "Bash permission denied"}, - {"text": "Progressive checkboxes", "passed": true, "evidence": "19 [x]"}, - {"text": "tracker.py has all components", "passed": true, "evidence": "16/16 tests pass"}, - {"text": "get_summary accounts for deletions", "passed": true, "evidence": "test_full_workflow passes"}, - {"text": "make test exits 0", "passed": true, "evidence": "16 passed"}, - {"text": "Plan all [x]", "passed": true, "evidence": "19 [x]"}, - {"text": "Deviations noted", "passed": false, "evidence": "Adaptation note present but incomplete due to Bash denial"} - ] - }, - { - "eval_id": 4, "eval_name": "cascade-dependencies", "configuration": "without_skill", "run_number": 1, - "result": {"pass_rate": 0.33, "passed": 3, "failed": 6, "total": 9, "time_seconds": 45.0, "tokens": 18638, "tool_calls": 14, "errors": 0}, - "expectations": [ - {"text": "Phase 1 before Phase 2", "passed": false, "evidence": "All in one edit"}, - {"text": "Phase 2 before Phase 3", "passed": false, "evidence": "All in one edit"}, - {"text": "make test at least 4 times", "passed": false, "evidence": "Once at end"}, - {"text": "Progressive checkboxes", "passed": false, "evidence": "All [ ]"}, - {"text": "tracker.py has all components", "passed": true, "evidence": "16/16 pass"}, - {"text": "get_summary accounts for deletions", "passed": true, "evidence": "Passes"}, - {"text": "make test exits 0", "passed": true, "evidence": "16 passed"}, - {"text": "Plan all [x]", "passed": false, "evidence": "All [ ]"}, - {"text": "Deviations noted", "passed": false, "evidence": "No notes"} - ] - }, - { - "eval_id": 5, "eval_name": "evolved-codebase", "configuration": "with_skill", "run_number": 1, - "result": {"pass_rate": 0.88, "passed": 7, "failed": 1, "total": 8, "time_seconds": 73.1, "tokens": 23285, "tool_calls": 18, "errors": 0}, - "expectations": [ - {"text": "Detects string_helpers.py doesn't exist", "passed": true, "evidence": "Inline note in plan"}, - {"text": "Identifies text_utils.py and text_transforms.py", "passed": true, "evidence": "Both named"}, - {"text": "Detects function split across files", "passed": true, "evidence": "Enumerated per file"}, - {"text": "Presents mismatch before implementation", "passed": true, "evidence": "Agent summary shows mismatch before code changes"}, - {"text": "Uses structured Issue/Expected/Found format", "passed": false, "evidence": "Used inline HTML comments rather than exact format"}, - {"text": "Functions added to correct files", "passed": true, "evidence": "Verified: correct placement"}, - {"text": "No string_helpers.py created", "passed": true, "evidence": "File does not exist"}, - {"text": "make test exits 0", "passed": true, "evidence": "9 passed"} - ] - }, - { - "eval_id": 5, "eval_name": "evolved-codebase", "configuration": "without_skill", "run_number": 1, - "result": {"pass_rate": 0.50, "passed": 4, "failed": 4, "total": 8, "time_seconds": 37.3, "tokens": 17407, "tool_calls": 13, "errors": 0}, - "expectations": [ - {"text": "Detects string_helpers.py doesn't exist", "passed": true, "evidence": "Figured out from imports"}, - {"text": "Identifies text_utils.py and text_transforms.py", "passed": true, "evidence": "Both identified"}, - {"text": "Detects function split", "passed": false, "evidence": "Didn't enumerate"}, - {"text": "Presents mismatch before implementation", "passed": false, "evidence": "Not presented to user"}, - {"text": "Uses Issue/Expected/Found format", "passed": false, "evidence": "No structured format"}, - {"text": "Functions added to correct files", "passed": true, "evidence": "Verified"}, - {"text": "No string_helpers.py created", "passed": true, "evidence": "Not created"}, - {"text": "make test exits 0", "passed": true, "evidence": "9 passed"} - ] - }, - { - "eval_id": 6, "eval_name": "resume-buggy-phase", "configuration": "with_skill", "run_number": 1, - "result": {"pass_rate": 0.25, "passed": 2, "failed": 6, "total": 8, "time_seconds": 38.3, "tokens": 22497, "tool_calls": 12, "errors": 1}, - "expectations": [ - {"text": "Starts from Phase 2 respecting [x] marks", "passed": true, "evidence": "Phase 2 items remain [ ]"}, - {"text": "Implements register function", "passed": false, "evidence": "Not implemented"}, - {"text": "Investigates test failures", "passed": false, "evidence": "Agent confused by permission issues"}, - {"text": "Identifies >= 120 should be > 120", "passed": true, "evidence": "Bug fixed in output"}, - {"text": "Communicates Phase 1 bug before fixing", "passed": false, "evidence": "Garbled response"}, - {"text": "Bug is fixed", "passed": false, "evidence": "Bug fixed but 6 tests fail"}, - {"text": "register and batch_register present", "passed": false, "evidence": "Neither exists"}, - {"text": "make test exits 0", "passed": false, "evidence": "6 failed, 11 passed"} - ] - }, - { - "eval_id": 6, "eval_name": "resume-buggy-phase", "configuration": "without_skill", "run_number": 1, - "result": {"pass_rate": 0.75, "passed": 6, "failed": 2, "total": 8, "time_seconds": 59.6, "tokens": 19030, "tool_calls": 16, "errors": 0}, - "expectations": [ - {"text": "Starts from Phase 2 respecting [x] marks", "passed": false, "evidence": "Fixed Phase 1 proactively"}, - {"text": "Implements register function", "passed": true, "evidence": "Present"}, - {"text": "Investigates test failures", "passed": true, "evidence": "Found bug"}, - {"text": "Identifies >= 120 bug", "passed": true, "evidence": "Fixed"}, - {"text": "Communicates Phase 1 bug", "passed": false, "evidence": "Just 'Bug fixed'"}, - {"text": "Bug is fixed", "passed": true, "evidence": "17 tests pass"}, - {"text": "register and batch_register present", "passed": true, "evidence": "Both present"}, - {"text": "make test exits 0", "passed": true, "evidence": "17 passed"} - ] - }, - { - "eval_id": 7, "eval_name": "completion-messaging", "configuration": "with_skill", "run_number": 1, - "result": {"pass_rate": 1.00, "passed": 7, "failed": 0, "total": 7, "time_seconds": 54.0, "tokens": 19589, "tool_calls": 15, "errors": 0}, - "expectations": [ - {"text": "converter.py has all 4 functions", "passed": true, "evidence": "8/8 tests pass"}, - {"text": "make test exits 0", "passed": true, "evidence": "8 passed"}, - {"text": "Plan all [x]", "passed": true, "evidence": "6 [x]"}, - {"text": "References validate-plan", "passed": true, "evidence": "In completion message"}, - {"text": "References stepwise-git:commit", "passed": true, "evidence": "In completion message"}, - {"text": "Suggests /clear", "passed": true, "evidence": "In completion message"}, - {"text": "Summary of accomplishments", "passed": true, "evidence": "Phase-by-phase summary"} - ] - }, - { - "eval_id": 7, "eval_name": "completion-messaging", "configuration": "without_skill", "run_number": 1, - "result": {"pass_rate": 0.43, "passed": 3, "failed": 4, "total": 7, "time_seconds": 32.3, "tokens": 16508, "tool_calls": 12, "errors": 0}, - "expectations": [ - {"text": "converter.py has all 4 functions", "passed": true, "evidence": "8/8 pass"}, - {"text": "make test exits 0", "passed": true, "evidence": "8 passed"}, - {"text": "Plan all [x]", "passed": false, "evidence": "All [ ]"}, - {"text": "References validate-plan", "passed": false, "evidence": "Not mentioned"}, - {"text": "References stepwise-git:commit", "passed": false, "evidence": "Not mentioned"}, - {"text": "Suggests /clear", "passed": false, "evidence": "Not mentioned"}, - {"text": "Summary of accomplishments", "passed": true, "evidence": "Basic summary"} - ] - } - ], - "run_summary": { - "with_skill": { - "pass_rate": {"mean": 0.84, "stddev": 0.27, "min": 0.25, "max": 1.00}, - "time_seconds": {"mean": 68.1, "stddev": 19.8, "min": 38.3, "max": 103.9}, - "tokens": {"mean": 22390, "stddev": 1629, "min": 19589, "max": 24301} - }, - "without_skill": { - "pass_rate": {"mean": 0.45, "stddev": 0.14, "min": 0.29, "max": 0.75}, - "time_seconds": {"mean": 69.2, "stddev": 66.4, "min": 32.3, "max": 221.8}, - "tokens": {"mean": 20521, "stddev": 6793, "min": 16508, "max": 36294} - }, - "delta": { - "pass_rate": "+0.39", - "time_seconds": "-1.1", - "tokens": "+1869" - } - }, - "notes": [ - "HEADLINE: Eval-2 (ambiguous-mismatch) improved from 0.71 to 1.00 with_skill — the naming/structural mismatch split directly fixed the skill's main weakness from iteration-2. All 3 naming deviations now documented as inline DEVIATION comments.", - "REGRESSION: Eval-6 (resume-buggy-phase) with_skill dropped from 1.00 to 0.25 due to agent confusion — it got Bash permissions denied and produced a garbled response about 'scanning transcripts'. This is an infrastructure/permissions issue, not a skill design problem.", - "Eval-4 (cascade-dependencies) with_skill dropped from 1.00 to 0.78 also due to Bash permission denial — couldn't run make test during implementation. Both eval-4 and eval-6 regressions are caused by Bash access issues in the eval environment, not by the SKILL.md changes.", - "Eval-5 (evolved-codebase) with_skill dropped from 1.00 to 0.88 — used inline HTML comments instead of exact Issue/Expected/Found format. The structural mismatch was correctly detected and communicated, but format wasn't exact.", - "Excluding the 2 permission-affected evals (4 and 6), with_skill mean pass_rate is 0.98 (vs 0.94 in iteration-2), confirming the naming/structural split improved the skill.", - "Baseline performance is consistent with iteration-2: mean 0.45 (same as iteration-2's 0.45). The baselines are stable control runs.", - "Eval-3 without_skill was notably slow (222s, 46 tool calls, 36K tokens) — struggled with format_table alignment but eventually got all tests passing. The with_skill version was more efficient (104s, 18 calls, 24K tokens) and correctly paused for manual verification.", - "Completion messaging (eval-7) remains a complete skill win: 1.00 vs 0.43.", - "The token cost delta narrowed from +3212 to +1869 — the skill is getting more efficient relative to baseline." - ] -} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-1-phase-discipline/eval_metadata.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-1-phase-discipline/eval_metadata.json deleted file mode 100644 index 0b5eeeb..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-1-phase-discipline/eval_metadata.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1 +0,0 @@ -{"eval_id":1,"eval_name":"phase-discipline","prompt":"Implement the plan at thoughts/shared/plans/add-inventory-features.md","assertions":[{"text":"make test is executed at least 3 times across the transcript","type":"behavior"},{"text":"Phase 1 (remove_item) is implemented and verified before Phase 2 (total_value) begins","type":"behavior"},{"text":"Phase 2 (total_value) is implemented and verified before Phase 3 (apply_discount) begins","type":"behavior"},{"text":"Checkboxes in the plan file are marked progressively as phases complete","type":"behavior"},{"text":"inventory.py contains remove_item, total_value, and apply_discount methods","type":"content_check"},{"text":"make test exits 0 with all tests passing","type":"content_check"},{"text":"Plan file has all checkboxes marked [x]","type":"content_check"}]} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-1-phase-discipline/with_skill/grading.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-1-phase-discipline/with_skill/grading.json deleted file mode 100644 index 80435f6..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-1-phase-discipline/with_skill/grading.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,15 +0,0 @@ -{ - "eval_id": 1, - "eval_name": "phase-discipline", - "configuration": "with_skill", - "overall": {"pass_rate": 1.00, "passed": 7, "failed": 0, "total": 7}, - "expectations": [ - {"text": "make test is executed at least 3 times across the transcript", "passed": true, "evidence": "Agent summary confirms phase-by-phase test runs; 18 tool calls consistent with multiple make test executions"}, - {"text": "Phase 1 (remove_item) is implemented and verified before Phase 2 (total_value) begins", "passed": true, "evidence": "Agent confirms sequential: Phase 1 → Phase 2 → Phase 3 → Phase 4 verification"}, - {"text": "Phase 2 (total_value) is implemented and verified before Phase 3 (apply_discount) begins", "passed": true, "evidence": "Agent confirms sequential implementation"}, - {"text": "Checkboxes in the plan file are marked progressively as phases complete", "passed": true, "evidence": "Output plan has all 13 checkboxes [x]; agent confirmed progressive marking after each phase"}, - {"text": "inventory.py contains remove_item, total_value, and apply_discount methods", "passed": true, "evidence": "All 16 tests pass, confirming all methods present"}, - {"text": "make test exits 0 with all tests passing", "passed": true, "evidence": "Verified independently: 16 passed"}, - {"text": "Plan file has all checkboxes marked [x]", "passed": true, "evidence": "Verified: 13 [x] checkboxes"} - ] -} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-1-phase-discipline/with_skill/outputs/inventory.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-1-phase-discipline/with_skill/outputs/inventory.py deleted file mode 100644 index 5bf222a..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-1-phase-discipline/with_skill/outputs/inventory.py +++ /dev/null @@ -1,37 +0,0 @@ -class Inventory: - def __init__(self): - self._items = {} - - def add_item(self, name, quantity, price): - if quantity < 0: - raise ValueError("Quantity cannot be negative") - if price < 0: - raise ValueError("Price cannot be negative") - if name in self._items: - self._items[name]["quantity"] += quantity - else: - self._items[name] = {"quantity": quantity, "price": price} - - def get_item(self, name): - if name not in self._items: - return None - return dict(self._items[name]) - - def remove_item(self, name, quantity): - if name not in self._items: - raise KeyError(name) - if quantity > self._items[name]["quantity"]: - raise ValueError("Not enough stock") - self._items[name]["quantity"] -= quantity - if self._items[name]["quantity"] == 0: - del self._items[name] - - def total_value(self): - return sum(item["quantity"] * item["price"] for item in self._items.values()) - - def apply_discount(self, name, percentage): - if name not in self._items: - raise KeyError(name) - if percentage < 0 or percentage > 100: - raise ValueError("Discount must be between 0 and 100") - self._items[name]["price"] *= (1 - percentage / 100) diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-1-phase-discipline/with_skill/outputs/thoughts/shared/plans/add-inventory-features.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-1-phase-discipline/with_skill/outputs/thoughts/shared/plans/add-inventory-features.md deleted file mode 100644 index 42c3392..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-1-phase-discipline/with_skill/outputs/thoughts/shared/plans/add-inventory-features.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,34 +0,0 @@ -# Add Inventory Features - -Extend the Inventory class with removal, valuation, and discount capabilities. - -## Phase 1: Add remove_item method - -Add a method to remove items from inventory. - -- [x] `remove_item(name, quantity)` removes the specified quantity -- [x] When quantity reaches 0, the item is deleted from inventory -- [x] Raises `ValueError("Not enough stock")` if removing more than available -- [x] Raises `KeyError` if item doesn't exist - -## Phase 2: Add total_value method - -Add a method to calculate the total value of all inventory. - -- [x] `total_value()` returns sum of (quantity * price) for all items -- [x] Returns 0.0 for empty inventory -- [x] Correctly reflects value after removals - -## Phase 3: Add apply_discount method - -Add a method to apply percentage discounts to item prices. - -- [x] `apply_discount(name, percentage)` reduces the item's price by the given percentage -- [x] Raises `ValueError("Discount must be between 0 and 100")` for invalid percentages -- [x] Raises `KeyError` if item doesn't exist -- [x] total_value reflects discounted prices - -## Phase 4: Final verification - -- [x] All tests pass with `make test` -- [x] All phases integrated correctly diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-1-phase-discipline/with_skill/timing.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-1-phase-discipline/with_skill/timing.json deleted file mode 100644 index faa7c4b..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-1-phase-discipline/with_skill/timing.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1 +0,0 @@ -{"total_tokens": 24053, "duration_ms": 66740, "total_duration_seconds": 66.7} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/grading.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/grading.json deleted file mode 100644 index 00af340..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/grading.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,15 +0,0 @@ -{ - "eval_id": 1, - "eval_name": "phase-discipline", - "configuration": "without_skill", - "overall": {"pass_rate": 0.29, "passed": 2, "failed": 5, "total": 7}, - "expectations": [ - {"text": "make test is executed at least 3 times across the transcript", "passed": false, "evidence": "Only 13 tool calls total — single make test run at end"}, - {"text": "Phase 1 (remove_item) is implemented and verified before Phase 2 (total_value) begins", "passed": false, "evidence": "All methods implemented in one edit"}, - {"text": "Phase 2 (total_value) is implemented and verified before Phase 3 (apply_discount) begins", "passed": false, "evidence": "All methods implemented in one edit"}, - {"text": "Checkboxes in the plan file are marked progressively as phases complete", "passed": false, "evidence": "All checkboxes remain [ ]"}, - {"text": "inventory.py contains remove_item, total_value, and apply_discount methods", "passed": true, "evidence": "All 16 tests pass"}, - {"text": "make test exits 0 with all tests passing", "passed": true, "evidence": "16 passed"}, - {"text": "Plan file has all checkboxes marked [x]", "passed": false, "evidence": "All checkboxes remain [ ] — 0 [x] found"} - ] -} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/outputs/Makefile b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/outputs/Makefile deleted file mode 100644 index c66c12f..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/outputs/Makefile +++ /dev/null @@ -1,7 +0,0 @@ -.PHONY: test check - -test: - python -m pytest test_inventory.py -v - -check: - @echo "No linter configured" diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/outputs/add-inventory-features.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/outputs/add-inventory-features.md deleted file mode 100644 index e38b307..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/outputs/add-inventory-features.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,34 +0,0 @@ -# Add Inventory Features - -Extend the Inventory class with removal, valuation, and discount capabilities. - -## Phase 1: Add remove_item method - -Add a method to remove items from inventory. - -- [ ] `remove_item(name, quantity)` removes the specified quantity -- [ ] When quantity reaches 0, the item is deleted from inventory -- [ ] Raises `ValueError("Not enough stock")` if removing more than available -- [ ] Raises `KeyError` if item doesn't exist - -## Phase 2: Add total_value method - -Add a method to calculate the total value of all inventory. - -- [ ] `total_value()` returns sum of (quantity * price) for all items -- [ ] Returns 0.0 for empty inventory -- [ ] Correctly reflects value after removals - -## Phase 3: Add apply_discount method - -Add a method to apply percentage discounts to item prices. - -- [ ] `apply_discount(name, percentage)` reduces the item's price by the given percentage -- [ ] Raises `ValueError("Discount must be between 0 and 100")` for invalid percentages -- [ ] Raises `KeyError` if item doesn't exist -- [ ] total_value reflects discounted prices - -## Phase 4: Final verification - -- [ ] All tests pass with `make test` -- [ ] All phases integrated correctly diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/outputs/inventory.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/outputs/inventory.py deleted file mode 100644 index 5bf222a..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/outputs/inventory.py +++ /dev/null @@ -1,37 +0,0 @@ -class Inventory: - def __init__(self): - self._items = {} - - def add_item(self, name, quantity, price): - if quantity < 0: - raise ValueError("Quantity cannot be negative") - if price < 0: - raise ValueError("Price cannot be negative") - if name in self._items: - self._items[name]["quantity"] += quantity - else: - self._items[name] = {"quantity": quantity, "price": price} - - def get_item(self, name): - if name not in self._items: - return None - return dict(self._items[name]) - - def remove_item(self, name, quantity): - if name not in self._items: - raise KeyError(name) - if quantity > self._items[name]["quantity"]: - raise ValueError("Not enough stock") - self._items[name]["quantity"] -= quantity - if self._items[name]["quantity"] == 0: - del self._items[name] - - def total_value(self): - return sum(item["quantity"] * item["price"] for item in self._items.values()) - - def apply_discount(self, name, percentage): - if name not in self._items: - raise KeyError(name) - if percentage < 0 or percentage > 100: - raise ValueError("Discount must be between 0 and 100") - self._items[name]["price"] *= (1 - percentage / 100) diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/outputs/test_inventory.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/outputs/test_inventory.py deleted file mode 100644 index 13566c4..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/outputs/test_inventory.py +++ /dev/null @@ -1,111 +0,0 @@ -import pytest -from inventory import Inventory - - -def test_add_and_get_item(): - inv = Inventory() - inv.add_item("apple", 10, 1.50) - assert inv.get_item("apple") == {"quantity": 10, "price": 1.50} - - -def test_add_existing_item_increases_quantity(): - inv = Inventory() - inv.add_item("apple", 10, 1.50) - inv.add_item("apple", 5, 1.50) - assert inv.get_item("apple")["quantity"] == 15 - - -def test_get_missing_item(): - inv = Inventory() - assert inv.get_item("banana") is None - - -def test_negative_quantity_raises(): - inv = Inventory() - with pytest.raises(ValueError, match="Quantity cannot be negative"): - inv.add_item("apple", -1, 1.50) - - -# --- Phase 2: remove_item --- - -def test_remove_item(): - inv = Inventory() - inv.add_item("apple", 10, 1.50) - inv.remove_item("apple", 3) - assert inv.get_item("apple")["quantity"] == 7 - - -def test_remove_item_completely(): - inv = Inventory() - inv.add_item("apple", 5, 1.50) - inv.remove_item("apple", 5) - assert inv.get_item("apple") is None - - -def test_remove_more_than_available_raises(): - inv = Inventory() - inv.add_item("apple", 3, 1.50) - with pytest.raises(ValueError, match="Not enough stock"): - inv.remove_item("apple", 5) - - -def test_remove_missing_item_raises(): - inv = Inventory() - with pytest.raises(KeyError): - inv.remove_item("banana", 1) - - -# --- Phase 3: total_value (depends on correct remove_item) --- - -def test_total_value_single_item(): - inv = Inventory() - inv.add_item("apple", 10, 1.50) - assert inv.total_value() == 15.00 - - -def test_total_value_multiple_items(): - inv = Inventory() - inv.add_item("apple", 10, 1.50) - inv.add_item("banana", 5, 2.00) - assert inv.total_value() == 25.00 - - -def test_total_value_after_removal(): - inv = Inventory() - inv.add_item("apple", 10, 1.50) - inv.remove_item("apple", 4) - assert inv.total_value() == 9.00 - - -def test_total_value_empty(): - inv = Inventory() - assert inv.total_value() == 0.00 - - -# --- Phase 4: apply_discount --- - -def test_apply_discount(): - inv = Inventory() - inv.add_item("apple", 10, 2.00) - inv.apply_discount("apple", 25) - assert inv.get_item("apple")["price"] == 1.50 - - -def test_apply_discount_invalid_percentage(): - inv = Inventory() - inv.add_item("apple", 10, 2.00) - with pytest.raises(ValueError, match="Discount must be between 0 and 100"): - inv.apply_discount("apple", 150) - - -def test_apply_discount_missing_item(): - inv = Inventory() - with pytest.raises(KeyError): - inv.apply_discount("banana", 10) - - -def test_total_value_after_discount(): - inv = Inventory() - inv.add_item("apple", 10, 2.00) - inv.apply_discount("apple", 50) - assert inv.total_value() == 10.00 diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/timing.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/timing.json deleted file mode 100644 index 97f572f..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-1-phase-discipline/without_skill/timing.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1 +0,0 @@ -{"total_tokens": 17659, "duration_ms": 37983, "total_duration_seconds": 38.0} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/eval_metadata.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/eval_metadata.json deleted file mode 100644 index 910e719..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/eval_metadata.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1 +0,0 @@ -{"eval_id":2,"eval_name":"ambiguous-mismatch","prompt":"Implement the plan at thoughts/shared/plans/add-order-lifecycle.md","assertions":[{"text":"Detects that the plan references 'Order' class but the actual class is 'PurchaseOrder'","type":"capability"},{"text":"Detects that the plan references 'compute_total(tax_percent)' but the actual method is 'calculate_total(tax_rate, discount_code)'","type":"capability"},{"text":"Detects that the plan uses 'cancel(note)' / 'self.cancel_note' but the tests expect 'cancel(reason)' / 'self.cancellation_reason'","type":"capability"},{"text":"Adapts to actual codebase names rather than creating new classes or renaming existing ones","type":"behavior"},{"text":"Documents naming deviations as inline notes in the plan file","type":"behavior"},{"text":"Does NOT rename PurchaseOrder to Order or create a new Order class","type":"capability"},{"text":"cancel and status_history are correctly added and all tests pass","type":"content_check"}]} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/with_skill/grading.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/with_skill/grading.json deleted file mode 100644 index a3b61da..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/with_skill/grading.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,15 +0,0 @@ -{ - "eval_id": 2, - "eval_name": "ambiguous-mismatch", - "configuration": "with_skill", - "overall": {"pass_rate": 1.00, "passed": 7, "failed": 0, "total": 7}, - "expectations": [ - {"text": "Detects that the plan references 'Order' class but the actual class is 'PurchaseOrder'", "passed": true, "evidence": "DEVIATION comment: Plan refers to Order class, but actual class is PurchaseOrder"}, - {"text": "Detects that the plan references 'compute_total(tax_percent)' but the actual method is 'calculate_total(tax_rate, discount_code)'", "passed": true, "evidence": "DEVIATION comment: Plan refers to Order.compute_total(tax_percent), but actual method is calculate_total(tax_rate, discount_code)"}, - {"text": "Detects that the plan uses 'cancel(note)' / 'self.cancel_note' but the tests expect 'cancel(reason)' / 'self.cancellation_reason'", "passed": true, "evidence": "DEVIATION comment: Plan says cancel(note) storing in self.cancel_note, but tests use cancel(reason=...) and order.cancellation_reason"}, - {"text": "Adapts to actual codebase names rather than creating new classes or renaming existing ones", "passed": true, "evidence": "Used PurchaseOrder, cancel(reason), cancellation_reason — tests as source of truth"}, - {"text": "Documents naming deviations as inline notes in the plan file", "passed": true, "evidence": "Three DEVIATION comments in plan: Phase 1 (Order→PurchaseOrder, compute_total→calculate_total), Phase 2 (cancel(note)→cancel(reason))"}, - {"text": "Does NOT rename PurchaseOrder to Order or create a new Order class", "passed": true, "evidence": "Class remains PurchaseOrder in output order.py"}, - {"text": "cancel and status_history are correctly added and all tests pass", "passed": true, "evidence": "10 passed, 0 failed"} - ] -} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/with_skill/outputs/order.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/with_skill/outputs/order.py deleted file mode 100644 index 6888fd0..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/with_skill/outputs/order.py +++ /dev/null @@ -1,46 +0,0 @@ -from datetime import datetime, timezone - - -class PurchaseOrder: - def __init__(self, order_id): - self.order_id = order_id - self.lines = [] - self.status = "draft" - self._status_history = [ - {"status": "draft", "timestamp": datetime.now(timezone.utc).isoformat()} - ] - - def add_line(self, product, quantity, unit_price): - self.lines.append({ - "product": product, - "quantity": quantity, - "unit_price": unit_price, - }) - - def calculate_total(self, tax_rate=0.0, discount_code=None): - subtotal = sum(l["quantity"] * l["unit_price"] for l in self.lines) - if discount_code == "HALF": - subtotal *= 0.5 - tax = subtotal * tax_rate - return round(subtotal + tax, 2) - - def submit(self): - if not self.lines: - raise ValueError("Cannot submit empty order") - self.status = "submitted" - self._status_history.append( - {"status": "submitted", "timestamp": datetime.now(timezone.utc).isoformat()} - ) - return self.status - - def cancel(self, reason=None): - if self.status != "submitted": - raise ValueError("Can only cancel submitted orders") - self.status = "cancelled" - self.cancellation_reason = reason - self._status_history.append( - {"status": "cancelled", "timestamp": datetime.now(timezone.utc).isoformat()} - ) - - def get_status_history(self): - return list(self._status_history) diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/with_skill/outputs/thoughts/shared/plans/add-order-lifecycle.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/with_skill/outputs/thoughts/shared/plans/add-order-lifecycle.md deleted file mode 100644 index 6404b16..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/with_skill/outputs/thoughts/shared/plans/add-order-lifecycle.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,31 +0,0 @@ -# Add Order Lifecycle Management - -Extend the Order class with cancellation and status history tracking. - -## Phase 1: Review existing code - - - - -- [x] Read `order.py` and understand the `Order` class structure -- [x] Verify `Order.compute_total(tax_percent)` works correctly - -## Phase 2: Add cancellation to Order - -Add cancellation support to the `Order` class. - - - -- [x] `Order.cancel(note)` sets status to "cancelled" when order is submitted -- [x] `cancel()` stores the note in `self.cancel_note` -- [x] Raises `ValueError("Can only cancel submitted orders")` if order is not submitted -- [x] Tests pass for cancellation scenarios - -## Phase 3: Add status history tracking - -Track all status transitions with timestamps. - -- [x] `Order.get_status_history()` returns list of {"status": ..., "timestamp": ...} -- [x] History includes initial "draft" state -- [x] Each `submit()` and `cancel()` call adds to history -- [x] Timestamps are ISO format strings diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/with_skill/timing.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/with_skill/timing.json deleted file mode 100644 index 2c9282f..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/with_skill/timing.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1 +0,0 @@ -{"total_tokens": 22002, "duration_ms": 73506, "total_duration_seconds": 73.5} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/without_skill/grading.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/without_skill/grading.json deleted file mode 100644 index de1b57a..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/without_skill/grading.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,15 +0,0 @@ -{ - "eval_id": 2, - "eval_name": "ambiguous-mismatch", - "configuration": "without_skill", - "overall": {"pass_rate": 0.43, "passed": 3, "failed": 4, "total": 7}, - "expectations": [ - {"text": "Detects that the plan references 'Order' class but the actual class is 'PurchaseOrder'", "passed": true, "evidence": "Noted in agent summary that plan says Order but actual is PurchaseOrder"}, - {"text": "Detects that the plan references 'compute_total(tax_percent)' but the actual method is 'calculate_total(tax_rate, discount_code)'", "passed": false, "evidence": "Not mentioned in summary or plan"}, - {"text": "Detects that the plan uses 'cancel(note)' / 'self.cancel_note' but the tests expect 'cancel(reason)' / 'self.cancellation_reason'", "passed": true, "evidence": "Noted in summary: cancel(reason=...) with cancellation_reason"}, - {"text": "Adapts to actual codebase names rather than creating new classes or renaming existing ones", "passed": true, "evidence": "Used PurchaseOrder, cancel(reason), cancellation_reason"}, - {"text": "Documents naming deviations as inline notes in the plan file", "passed": false, "evidence": "Plan file has no inline deviation notes — all checkboxes still [ ]"}, - {"text": "Does NOT rename PurchaseOrder to Order or create a new Order class", "passed": true, "evidence": "Class remains PurchaseOrder"}, - {"text": "cancel and status_history are correctly added and all tests pass", "passed": false, "evidence": "Tests pass (10 passed) but plan not updated"} - ] -} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/without_skill/outputs/add-order-lifecycle.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/without_skill/outputs/add-order-lifecycle.md deleted file mode 100644 index bfff1c0..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/without_skill/outputs/add-order-lifecycle.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,26 +0,0 @@ -# Add Order Lifecycle Management - -Extend the Order class with cancellation and status history tracking. - -## Phase 1: Review existing code - -- [ ] Read `order.py` and understand the `Order` class structure -- [ ] Verify `Order.compute_total(tax_percent)` works correctly - -## Phase 2: Add cancellation to Order - -Add cancellation support to the `Order` class. - -- [ ] `Order.cancel(note)` sets status to "cancelled" when order is submitted -- [ ] `cancel()` stores the note in `self.cancel_note` -- [ ] Raises `ValueError("Can only cancel submitted orders")` if order is not submitted -- [ ] Tests pass for cancellation scenarios - -## Phase 3: Add status history tracking - -Track all status transitions with timestamps. - -- [ ] `Order.get_status_history()` returns list of {"status": ..., "timestamp": ...} -- [ ] History includes initial "draft" state -- [ ] Each `submit()` and `cancel()` call adds to history -- [ ] Timestamps are ISO format strings diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/without_skill/outputs/order.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/without_skill/outputs/order.py deleted file mode 100644 index cc6b760..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/without_skill/outputs/order.py +++ /dev/null @@ -1,47 +0,0 @@ -from datetime import datetime, timezone - - -class PurchaseOrder: - def __init__(self, order_id): - self.order_id = order_id - self.lines = [] - self.status = "draft" - self.cancellation_reason = None - self._status_history = [ - {"status": "draft", "timestamp": datetime.now(timezone.utc).isoformat()} - ] - - def add_line(self, product, quantity, unit_price): - self.lines.append({ - "product": product, - "quantity": quantity, - "unit_price": unit_price, - }) - - def calculate_total(self, tax_rate=0.0, discount_code=None): - subtotal = sum(l["quantity"] * l["unit_price"] for l in self.lines) - if discount_code == "HALF": - subtotal *= 0.5 - tax = subtotal * tax_rate - return round(subtotal + tax, 2) - - def submit(self): - if not self.lines: - raise ValueError("Cannot submit empty order") - self.status = "submitted" - self._status_history.append( - {"status": "submitted", "timestamp": datetime.now(timezone.utc).isoformat()} - ) - return self.status - - def cancel(self, reason=None): - if self.status != "submitted": - raise ValueError("Can only cancel submitted orders") - self.status = "cancelled" - self.cancellation_reason = reason - self._status_history.append( - {"status": "cancelled", "timestamp": datetime.now(timezone.utc).isoformat()} - ) - - def get_status_history(self): - return list(self._status_history) diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/without_skill/outputs/test_order.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/without_skill/outputs/test_order.py deleted file mode 100644 index f55e5ea..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/without_skill/outputs/test_order.py +++ /dev/null @@ -1,75 +0,0 @@ -import pytest -from order import PurchaseOrder - - -def test_add_line(): - order = PurchaseOrder("ORD-1") - order.add_line("Widget", 2, 10.00) - assert len(order.lines) == 1 - - -def test_calculate_total_no_tax(): - order = PurchaseOrder("ORD-1") - order.add_line("Widget", 2, 10.00) - assert order.calculate_total() == 20.00 - - -def test_calculate_total_with_tax(): - order = PurchaseOrder("ORD-1") - order.add_line("Widget", 2, 10.00) - assert order.calculate_total(tax_rate=0.1) == 22.00 - - -def test_calculate_total_with_discount(): - order = PurchaseOrder("ORD-1") - order.add_line("Widget", 2, 10.00) - assert order.calculate_total(discount_code="HALF") == 10.00 - - -def test_submit_order(): - order = PurchaseOrder("ORD-1") - order.add_line("Widget", 1, 5.00) - assert order.submit() == "submitted" - - -def test_submit_empty_raises(): - order = PurchaseOrder("ORD-1") - with pytest.raises(ValueError, match="Cannot submit empty order"): - order.submit() - - -# --- Phase 2 tests: cancellation --- - -def test_cancel_submitted_order(): - order = PurchaseOrder("ORD-1") - order.add_line("Widget", 1, 5.00) - order.submit() - order.cancel(reason="Customer request") - assert order.status == "cancelled" - assert order.cancellation_reason == "Customer request" - - -def test_cancel_draft_raises(): - order = PurchaseOrder("ORD-1") - order.add_line("Widget", 1, 5.00) - with pytest.raises(ValueError, match="Can only cancel submitted orders"): - order.cancel(reason="Changed mind") - - -# --- Phase 3 tests: history --- - -def test_status_history_tracks_changes(): - order = PurchaseOrder("ORD-1") - order.add_line("Widget", 1, 5.00) - order.submit() - order.cancel(reason="Test") - history = order.get_status_history() - assert [h["status"] for h in history] == ["draft", "submitted", "cancelled"] - - -def test_status_history_has_timestamps(): - order = PurchaseOrder("ORD-1") - order.add_line("Widget", 1, 5.00) - order.submit() - history = order.get_status_history() - assert all("timestamp" in h for h in history) diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/without_skill/timing.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/without_skill/timing.json deleted file mode 100644 index 0707b26..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-2-ambiguous-mismatch/without_skill/timing.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1 +0,0 @@ -{"total_tokens": 18108, "duration_ms": 50237, "total_duration_seconds": 50.2} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-3-manual-verification/eval_metadata.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-3-manual-verification/eval_metadata.json deleted file mode 100644 index 674abc3..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-3-manual-verification/eval_metadata.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1 +0,0 @@ -{"eval_id":3,"eval_name":"manual-verification","prompt":"Implement the plan at thoughts/shared/plans/add-formatting-features.md","assertions":[{"text":"Phase 1 (center_text) completed without pausing for user input","type":"behavior"},{"text":"After Phase 2 (format_table), agent pauses and presents Manual Verification items","type":"behavior"},{"text":"Pause message lists specific manual verification items from the plan","type":"behavior"},{"text":"Manual Verification checkboxes remain [ ] for user confirmation","type":"behavior"},{"text":"formatter.py contains both center_text and format_table functions","type":"content_check"},{"text":"make test exits 0 with all tests passing","type":"content_check"},{"text":"Phase 1 and Phase 2 code checkboxes are marked [x]","type":"content_check"}]} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-3-manual-verification/with_skill/grading.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-3-manual-verification/with_skill/grading.json deleted file mode 100644 index 8845f6b..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-3-manual-verification/with_skill/grading.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,15 +0,0 @@ -{ - "eval_id": 3, - "eval_name": "manual-verification", - "configuration": "with_skill", - "overall": {"pass_rate": 1.00, "passed": 7, "failed": 0, "total": 7}, - "expectations": [ - {"text": "Phase 1 (center_text) completed without pausing for user input", "passed": true, "evidence": "Agent proceeded directly to Phase 2 after Phase 1"}, - {"text": "After Phase 2 (format_table), agent pauses and presents Manual Verification items", "passed": true, "evidence": "Output shows 'Phase 2 Complete - Ready for Manual Verification'"}, - {"text": "Pause message lists specific manual verification items from the plan", "passed": true, "evidence": "Lists: visual alignment, dash separators, column widths"}, - {"text": "Manual Verification checkboxes remain [ ] for user confirmation", "passed": true, "evidence": "Verified in plan: all 3 manual verification items remain [ ]"}, - {"text": "formatter.py contains both center_text and format_table functions", "passed": true, "evidence": "Both present, all 9 tests pass"}, - {"text": "make test exits 0 with all tests passing", "passed": true, "evidence": "9 passed, 0 failed"}, - {"text": "Phase 1 and Phase 2 code checkboxes are marked [x]", "passed": true, "evidence": "All implementation checkboxes [x], manual verification [ ]"} - ] -} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-3-manual-verification/with_skill/outputs/add-formatting-features.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-3-manual-verification/with_skill/outputs/add-formatting-features.md deleted file mode 100644 index 860834e..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-3-manual-verification/with_skill/outputs/add-formatting-features.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,25 +0,0 @@ -# Add Text Formatting Features - -Extend formatter.py with text centering and table formatting. - -## Phase 1: Add center_text function - -- [x] `center_text(text, width)` centers text within the given width using spaces -- [x] If text is longer than width, return text unchanged -- [x] Total output length equals `width` (padded with spaces) -- [x] Tests pass for center_text scenarios - -## Phase 2: Add format_table function - -- [x] `format_table(headers, rows)` produces an ASCII table -- [x] Header row separated from data by a `---` separator line -- [x] Columns are padded so all lines have equal length -- [x] Empty rows list produces header + separator only (2 lines) -- [x] Tests pass for format_table scenarios - -### Manual Verification - -After Phase 2, please pause and let me verify: -- [ ] Table output is visually aligned when printed to terminal -- [ ] Separator line uses dashes, not other characters -- [ ] Column widths accommodate the longest value in each column diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-3-manual-verification/with_skill/outputs/formatter.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-3-manual-verification/with_skill/outputs/formatter.py deleted file mode 100644 index 365fb63..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-3-manual-verification/with_skill/outputs/formatter.py +++ /dev/null @@ -1,40 +0,0 @@ -def wrap_text(text, width=80): - if width <= 0: - raise ValueError("Width must be positive") - words = text.split() - lines = [] - current_line = [] - current_length = 0 - for word in words: - if current_length + len(word) + len(current_line) > width: - lines.append(" ".join(current_line)) - current_line = [word] - current_length = len(word) - else: - current_line.append(word) - current_length += len(word) - if current_line: - lines.append(" ".join(current_line)) - return "\n".join(lines) - - -def center_text(text, width): - if len(text) >= width: - return text - return text.center(width) - - -def format_table(headers, rows): - all_rows = [headers] + rows - col_widths = [ - max(len(str(row[i])) for row in all_rows) - for i in range(len(headers)) - ] - def format_row(row): - return "| " + " | ".join(str(cell).ljust(col_widths[i]) for i, cell in enumerate(row)) + " |" - total_width = 2 + sum(col_widths) + len(" | ") * (len(col_widths) - 1) + 2 - separator = "|" + "-" * (total_width - 2) + "|" - lines = [format_row(headers), separator] - for row in rows: - lines.append(format_row(row)) - return "\n".join(lines) diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-3-manual-verification/with_skill/timing.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-3-manual-verification/with_skill/timing.json deleted file mode 100644 index f046124..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-3-manual-verification/with_skill/timing.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1 +0,0 @@ -{"total_tokens": 24301, "duration_ms": 103853, "total_duration_seconds": 103.9} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-3-manual-verification/without_skill/grading.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-3-manual-verification/without_skill/grading.json deleted file mode 100644 index 99838ed..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-3-manual-verification/without_skill/grading.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,15 +0,0 @@ -{ - "eval_id": 3, - "eval_name": "manual-verification", - "configuration": "without_skill", - "overall": {"pass_rate": 0.43, "passed": 3, "failed": 4, "total": 7}, - "expectations": [ - {"text": "Phase 1 (center_text) completed without pausing for user input", "passed": true, "evidence": "No pauses at all"}, - {"text": "After Phase 2 (format_table), agent pauses and presents Manual Verification items", "passed": false, "evidence": "Completed all work without pausing"}, - {"text": "Pause message lists specific manual verification items from the plan", "passed": false, "evidence": "No pause message produced"}, - {"text": "Manual Verification checkboxes remain [ ] for user confirmation", "passed": true, "evidence": "All checkboxes remain [ ] (baseline didn't touch any)"}, - {"text": "formatter.py contains both center_text and format_table functions", "passed": true, "evidence": "Both present, all 9 tests pass"}, - {"text": "make test exits 0 with all tests passing", "passed": true, "evidence": "9 passed"}, - {"text": "Phase 1 and Phase 2 code checkboxes are marked [x]", "passed": false, "evidence": "All checkboxes remain [ ]"} - ] -} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-3-manual-verification/without_skill/outputs/add-formatting-features.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-3-manual-verification/without_skill/outputs/add-formatting-features.md deleted file mode 100644 index 2e5a48b..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-3-manual-verification/without_skill/outputs/add-formatting-features.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,25 +0,0 @@ -# Add Text Formatting Features - -Extend formatter.py with text centering and table formatting. - -## Phase 1: Add center_text function - -- [ ] `center_text(text, width)` centers text within the given width using spaces -- [ ] If text is longer than width, return text unchanged -- [ ] Total output length equals `width` (padded with spaces) -- [ ] Tests pass for center_text scenarios - -## Phase 2: Add format_table function - -- [ ] `format_table(headers, rows)` produces an ASCII table -- [ ] Header row separated from data by a `---` separator line -- [ ] Columns are padded so all lines have equal length -- [ ] Empty rows list produces header + separator only (2 lines) -- [ ] Tests pass for format_table scenarios - -### Manual Verification - -After Phase 2, please pause and let me verify: -- [ ] Table output is visually aligned when printed to terminal -- [ ] Separator line uses dashes, not other characters -- [ ] Column widths accommodate the longest value in each column diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-3-manual-verification/without_skill/outputs/formatter.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-3-manual-verification/without_skill/outputs/formatter.py deleted file mode 100644 index 12e1079..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-3-manual-verification/without_skill/outputs/formatter.py +++ /dev/null @@ -1,46 +0,0 @@ -def wrap_text(text, width=80): - if width <= 0: - raise ValueError("Width must be positive") - words = text.split() - lines = [] - current_line = [] - current_length = 0 - for word in words: - if current_length + len(word) + len(current_line) > width: - lines.append(" ".join(current_line)) - current_line = [word] - current_length = len(word) - else: - current_line.append(word) - current_length += len(word) - if current_line: - lines.append(" ".join(current_line)) - return "\n".join(lines) - - -def center_text(text, width): - if len(text) >= width: - return text - total_padding = width - len(text) - left_padding = total_padding // 2 - right_padding = total_padding - left_padding - return " " * left_padding + text + " " * right_padding - - -def format_table(headers, rows): - all_rows = [headers] + rows - col_widths = [ - max(len(str(row[i])) for row in all_rows) - for i in range(len(headers)) - ] - - def format_row(row): - cells = " | ".join(str(cell).ljust(col_widths[i]) for i, cell in enumerate(row)) - return "| " + cells + " |" - - header_line = format_row(headers) - separator_line = "-" * len(header_line) - lines = [header_line, separator_line] - for row in rows: - lines.append(format_row(row)) - return "\n".join(lines) diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-3-manual-verification/without_skill/outputs/thoughts/shared/plans/add-formatting-features.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-3-manual-verification/without_skill/outputs/thoughts/shared/plans/add-formatting-features.md deleted file mode 100644 index 860834e..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-3-manual-verification/without_skill/outputs/thoughts/shared/plans/add-formatting-features.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,25 +0,0 @@ -# Add Text Formatting Features - -Extend formatter.py with text centering and table formatting. - -## Phase 1: Add center_text function - -- [x] `center_text(text, width)` centers text within the given width using spaces -- [x] If text is longer than width, return text unchanged -- [x] Total output length equals `width` (padded with spaces) -- [x] Tests pass for center_text scenarios - -## Phase 2: Add format_table function - -- [x] `format_table(headers, rows)` produces an ASCII table -- [x] Header row separated from data by a `---` separator line -- [x] Columns are padded so all lines have equal length -- [x] Empty rows list produces header + separator only (2 lines) -- [x] Tests pass for format_table scenarios - -### Manual Verification - -After Phase 2, please pause and let me verify: -- [ ] Table output is visually aligned when printed to terminal -- [ ] Separator line uses dashes, not other characters -- [ ] Column widths accommodate the longest value in each column diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-3-manual-verification/without_skill/timing.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-3-manual-verification/without_skill/timing.json deleted file mode 100644 index fd87d3a..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-3-manual-verification/without_skill/timing.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1 +0,0 @@ -{"total_tokens": 36294, "duration_ms": 221794, "total_duration_seconds": 221.8} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/eval_metadata.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/eval_metadata.json deleted file mode 100644 index 3792caf..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/eval_metadata.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1 +0,0 @@ -{"eval_id":4,"eval_name":"cascade-dependencies","prompt":"Implement the plan at thoughts/shared/plans/build-task-tracker.md","assertions":[{"text":"Phase 1 (Task model) is implemented before Phase 2 (TaskRepository)","type":"behavior"},{"text":"Phase 2 (TaskRepository) is implemented before Phase 3 (TaskService)","type":"behavior"},{"text":"make test is executed after each phase (at least 4 times)","type":"behavior"},{"text":"Checkboxes are marked progressively as each phase completes","type":"behavior"},{"text":"tracker.py contains Task, TaskRepository, TaskService classes and format_task_list function","type":"content_check"},{"text":"TaskService.get_summary correctly returns total reflecting current repo count","type":"capability"},{"text":"make test exits 0 with all tests passing","type":"content_check"},{"text":"Plan file has all checkboxes marked [x]","type":"content_check"},{"text":"Any deviations from the plan are noted","type":"behavior"}]} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/with_skill/grading.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/with_skill/grading.json deleted file mode 100644 index 4bcf2cb..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/with_skill/grading.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,17 +0,0 @@ -{ - "eval_id": 4, - "eval_name": "cascade-dependencies", - "configuration": "with_skill", - "overall": {"pass_rate": 0.78, "passed": 7, "failed": 2, "total": 9}, - "expectations": [ - {"text": "Phase 1 (Task model) is implemented before Phase 2 (TaskRepository)", "passed": true, "evidence": "Agent confirms sequential implementation of all 5 phases"}, - {"text": "Phase 2 (TaskRepository) is implemented before Phase 3 (TaskService)", "passed": true, "evidence": "Agent confirms sequential implementation"}, - {"text": "make test is executed after each phase (at least 4 times)", "passed": false, "evidence": "Bash permission was denied — agent could not run make test during implementation"}, - {"text": "Checkboxes are marked progressively as each phase completes", "passed": true, "evidence": "All 19 checkboxes [x] in output plan"}, - {"text": "tracker.py contains Task, TaskRepository, TaskService classes and format_task_list function", "passed": true, "evidence": "16/16 tests pass when verified independently"}, - {"text": "TaskService.get_summary correctly returns total reflecting current repo count", "passed": true, "evidence": "test_full_workflow passes"}, - {"text": "make test exits 0 with all tests passing", "passed": true, "evidence": "Independently verified: 16 passed"}, - {"text": "Plan file has all checkboxes marked [x]", "passed": true, "evidence": "19 [x] checkboxes verified"}, - {"text": "Any deviations from the plan are noted", "passed": false, "evidence": "Adaptation note present for get_task/delete_task, but Bash denial prevented full test verification during implementation"} - ] -} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/with_skill/outputs/thoughts/shared/plans/build-task-tracker.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/with_skill/outputs/thoughts/shared/plans/build-task-tracker.md deleted file mode 100644 index 7ef5cc4..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/with_skill/outputs/thoughts/shared/plans/build-task-tracker.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,47 +0,0 @@ -# Build Task Tracker - -Build a layered task tracking system in a single file (tracker.py). - -## Phase 1: Task data model - -Create the Task class. - -- [x] `Task(title, priority="medium")` creates a task with auto-generated UUID id -- [x] Valid priorities: "low", "medium", "high" — raises `ValueError` otherwise -- [x] `created_at` set to `datetime.now()` on creation -- [x] `status` starts as "todo", `completed_at` starts as None -- [x] `complete()` sets status to "done" and records `completed_at` - -## Phase 2: TaskRepository (in-memory storage) - -Create a repository that stores tasks by ID. - -- [x] `add(task)` stores the task -- [x] `get(task_id)` returns the task or None -- [x] `list_by_status(status)` returns filtered list -- [x] `delete(task_id)` removes the task, raises `KeyError` if not found - -## Phase 3: TaskService (business logic) - -Create a service layer that uses TaskRepository internally. - -- [x] `create_task(title, priority)` creates and stores a Task, returns it -- [x] `complete_task(task_id)` marks a task as done -- [x] `list_pending()` returns all tasks with status "todo" -- [x] `get_summary()` returns `{"total": N, "todo": N, "done": N}` -- [x] Note: `get_summary()` should count tasks in the repository — make sure `total` reflects the current count including any deletions - - - -## Phase 4: Integration verification - -- [x] Full workflow test passes (create, complete, delete, summary) -- [x] Error handling works across layers (KeyError propagation) - -## Phase 5: CLI output helper - -Add a `format_task_list(tasks)` function for terminal display. - -- [x] Formats each task as `"- [status] Title [priority]"` -- [x] Returns `"No tasks found."` for empty list -- [x] All tests pass with `make test` diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/with_skill/outputs/tracker.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/with_skill/outputs/tracker.py deleted file mode 100644 index 394513c..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/with_skill/outputs/tracker.py +++ /dev/null @@ -1,86 +0,0 @@ -import uuid -from datetime import datetime - -VALID_PRIORITIES = {"low", "medium", "high"} - - -# Phase 1: Task data model - -class Task: - def __init__(self, title, priority="medium"): - if priority not in VALID_PRIORITIES: - raise ValueError(f"Priority must be one of {sorted(VALID_PRIORITIES)}, got '{priority}'") - self.id = str(uuid.uuid4()) - self.title = title - self.priority = priority - self.status = "todo" - self.created_at = datetime.now() - self.completed_at = None - - def complete(self): - self.status = "done" - self.completed_at = datetime.now() - - -# Phase 2: TaskRepository (in-memory storage) - -class TaskRepository: - def __init__(self): - self._tasks = {} - - def add(self, task): - self._tasks[task.id] = task - - def get(self, task_id): - return self._tasks.get(task_id) - - def list_by_status(self, status): - return [t for t in self._tasks.values() if t.status == status] - - def delete(self, task_id): - if task_id not in self._tasks: - raise KeyError(f"Task '{task_id}' not found") - del self._tasks[task_id] - - -# Phase 3: TaskService (business logic) - -class TaskService: - def __init__(self): - self._repo = TaskRepository() - - def create_task(self, title, priority="medium"): - task = Task(title, priority=priority) - self._repo.add(task) - return task - - def get_task(self, task_id): - return self._repo.get(task_id) - - def complete_task(self, task_id): - task = self._repo.get(task_id) - if task is None: - raise KeyError(f"Task '{task_id}' not found") - task.complete() - - def delete_task(self, task_id): - self._repo.delete(task_id) - - def list_pending(self): - return self._repo.list_by_status("todo") - - def get_summary(self): - all_tasks = list(self._repo._tasks.values()) - total = len(all_tasks) - done = sum(1 for t in all_tasks if t.status == "done") - todo = sum(1 for t in all_tasks if t.status == "todo") - return {"total": total, "todo": todo, "done": done} - - -# Phase 5: CLI output helper - -def format_task_list(tasks): - if not tasks: - return "No tasks found." - lines = [f"- [{t.status}] {t.title} [{t.priority}]" for t in tasks] - return "\n".join(lines) diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/with_skill/timing.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/with_skill/timing.json deleted file mode 100644 index f5b4e3c..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/with_skill/timing.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1 +0,0 @@ -{"total_tokens": 22000, "duration_ms": 67328, "total_duration_seconds": 67.3} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/without_skill/grading.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/without_skill/grading.json deleted file mode 100644 index 1893190..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/without_skill/grading.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,17 +0,0 @@ -{ - "eval_id": 4, - "eval_name": "cascade-dependencies", - "configuration": "without_skill", - "overall": {"pass_rate": 0.33, "passed": 3, "failed": 6, "total": 9}, - "expectations": [ - {"text": "Phase 1 (Task model) is implemented before Phase 2 (TaskRepository)", "passed": false, "evidence": "All classes implemented in one edit"}, - {"text": "Phase 2 (TaskRepository) is implemented before Phase 3 (TaskService)", "passed": false, "evidence": "All classes implemented in one edit"}, - {"text": "make test is executed after each phase (at least 4 times)", "passed": false, "evidence": "Only once at end"}, - {"text": "Checkboxes are marked progressively as each phase completes", "passed": false, "evidence": "All checkboxes remain [ ]"}, - {"text": "tracker.py contains Task, TaskRepository, TaskService classes and format_task_list function", "passed": true, "evidence": "16/16 tests pass"}, - {"text": "TaskService.get_summary correctly returns total reflecting current repo count", "passed": true, "evidence": "test_full_workflow passes"}, - {"text": "make test exits 0 with all tests passing", "passed": true, "evidence": "16 passed"}, - {"text": "Plan file has all checkboxes marked [x]", "passed": false, "evidence": "All checkboxes remain [ ]"}, - {"text": "Any deviations from the plan are noted", "passed": false, "evidence": "No deviation notes"} - ] -} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/without_skill/outputs/build-task-tracker.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/without_skill/outputs/build-task-tracker.md deleted file mode 100644 index bf17b51..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/without_skill/outputs/build-task-tracker.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,45 +0,0 @@ -# Build Task Tracker - -Build a layered task tracking system in a single file (tracker.py). - -## Phase 1: Task data model - -Create the Task class. - -- [ ] `Task(title, priority="medium")` creates a task with auto-generated UUID id -- [ ] Valid priorities: "low", "medium", "high" — raises `ValueError` otherwise -- [ ] `created_at` set to `datetime.now()` on creation -- [ ] `status` starts as "todo", `completed_at` starts as None -- [ ] `complete()` sets status to "done" and records `completed_at` - -## Phase 2: TaskRepository (in-memory storage) - -Create a repository that stores tasks by ID. - -- [ ] `add(task)` stores the task -- [ ] `get(task_id)` returns the task or None -- [ ] `list_by_status(status)` returns filtered list -- [ ] `delete(task_id)` removes the task, raises `KeyError` if not found - -## Phase 3: TaskService (business logic) - -Create a service layer that uses TaskRepository internally. - -- [ ] `create_task(title, priority)` creates and stores a Task, returns it -- [ ] `complete_task(task_id)` marks a task as done -- [ ] `list_pending()` returns all tasks with status "todo" -- [ ] `get_summary()` returns `{"total": N, "todo": N, "done": N}` -- [ ] Note: `get_summary()` should count tasks in the repository — make sure `total` reflects the current count including any deletions - -## Phase 4: Integration verification - -- [ ] Full workflow test passes (create, complete, delete, summary) -- [ ] Error handling works across layers (KeyError propagation) - -## Phase 5: CLI output helper - -Add a `format_task_list(tasks)` function for terminal display. - -- [ ] Formats each task as `"- [status] Title [priority]"` -- [ ] Returns `"No tasks found."` for empty list -- [ ] All tests pass with `make test` diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/without_skill/outputs/tracker.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/without_skill/outputs/tracker.py deleted file mode 100644 index 106564a..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/without_skill/outputs/tracker.py +++ /dev/null @@ -1,78 +0,0 @@ -import uuid -from datetime import datetime - - -VALID_PRIORITIES = {"low", "medium", "high"} - - -class Task: - def __init__(self, title, priority="medium"): - if priority not in VALID_PRIORITIES: - raise ValueError(f"Priority must be one of {sorted(VALID_PRIORITIES)}, got '{priority}'") - self.id = str(uuid.uuid4()) - self.title = title - self.priority = priority - self.status = "todo" - self.created_at = datetime.now() - self.completed_at = None - - def complete(self): - self.status = "done" - self.completed_at = datetime.now() - - -class TaskRepository: - def __init__(self): - self._tasks = {} - - def add(self, task): - self._tasks[task.id] = task - - def get(self, task_id): - return self._tasks.get(task_id) - - def list_by_status(self, status): - return [t for t in self._tasks.values() if t.status == status] - - def delete(self, task_id): - if task_id not in self._tasks: - raise KeyError(task_id) - del self._tasks[task_id] - - -class TaskService: - def __init__(self): - self._repo = TaskRepository() - - def create_task(self, title, priority="medium"): - task = Task(title, priority=priority) - self._repo.add(task) - return task - - def get_task(self, task_id): - return self._repo.get(task_id) - - def complete_task(self, task_id): - task = self._repo.get(task_id) - if task is None: - raise KeyError(task_id) - task.complete() - - def delete_task(self, task_id): - self._repo.delete(task_id) - - def list_pending(self): - return self._repo.list_by_status("todo") - - def get_summary(self): - all_tasks = list(self._repo._tasks.values()) - todo_count = sum(1 for t in all_tasks if t.status == "todo") - done_count = sum(1 for t in all_tasks if t.status == "done") - return {"total": len(all_tasks), "todo": todo_count, "done": done_count} - - -def format_task_list(tasks): - if not tasks: - return "No tasks found." - lines = [f"- [{t.status}] {t.title} [{t.priority}]" for t in tasks] - return "\n".join(lines) diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/without_skill/timing.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/without_skill/timing.json deleted file mode 100644 index 4b72c5e..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-4-cascade-dependencies/without_skill/timing.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1 +0,0 @@ -{"total_tokens": 18638, "duration_ms": 45035, "total_duration_seconds": 45.0} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-5-evolved-codebase/eval_metadata.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-5-evolved-codebase/eval_metadata.json deleted file mode 100644 index 477823b..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-5-evolved-codebase/eval_metadata.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1 +0,0 @@ -{"eval_id":5,"eval_name":"evolved-codebase","prompt":"Implement the plan at thoughts/shared/plans/extend-string-helpers.md","assertions":[{"text":"Detects that string_helpers.py does not exist","type":"capability"},{"text":"Identifies that the codebase has text_utils.py and text_transforms.py instead","type":"capability"},{"text":"Detects that functions are split across two files","type":"capability"},{"text":"Presents the file structure mismatch before starting implementation","type":"behavior"},{"text":"Uses structured Issue/Expected/Found format to communicate the mismatch","type":"behavior"},{"text":"New functions are added to the correct existing files","type":"capability"},{"text":"Does NOT create a new string_helpers.py file","type":"capability"},{"text":"make test exits 0 with all tests passing","type":"content_check"}]} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-5-evolved-codebase/with_skill/grading.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-5-evolved-codebase/with_skill/grading.json deleted file mode 100644 index 9e924ca..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-5-evolved-codebase/with_skill/grading.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,16 +0,0 @@ -{ - "eval_id": 5, - "eval_name": "evolved-codebase", - "configuration": "with_skill", - "overall": {"pass_rate": 0.88, "passed": 7, "failed": 1, "total": 8}, - "expectations": [ - {"text": "Detects that string_helpers.py does not exist", "passed": true, "evidence": "Inline note: string_helpers.py does not exist"}, - {"text": "Identifies that the codebase has text_utils.py and text_transforms.py instead", "passed": true, "evidence": "Note enumerates both files and their functions"}, - {"text": "Detects that functions are split across two files", "passed": true, "evidence": "Note: text_utils.py (slugify, word_count) and text_transforms.py (truncate, title_case)"}, - {"text": "Presents the file structure mismatch before starting implementation", "passed": true, "evidence": "Agent summary shows Issue/Expected/Found format before code changes"}, - {"text": "Uses structured Issue/Expected/Found format to communicate the mismatch", "passed": false, "evidence": "Used inline HTML comments in plan rather than the exact Issue/Expected/Found format in output"}, - {"text": "New functions are added to the correct existing files", "passed": true, "evidence": "contains_any/extract_emails in text_utils.py, pad_right/pad_center/repeat_text in text_transforms.py"}, - {"text": "Does NOT create a new string_helpers.py file", "passed": true, "evidence": "string_helpers.py does not exist in project"}, - {"text": "make test exits 0 with all tests passing", "passed": true, "evidence": "9 passed"} - ] -} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-5-evolved-codebase/with_skill/outputs/text_transforms.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-5-evolved-codebase/with_skill/outputs/text_transforms.py deleted file mode 100644 index e11f503..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-5-evolved-codebase/with_skill/outputs/text_transforms.py +++ /dev/null @@ -1,24 +0,0 @@ -def truncate(text, max_length, suffix="..."): - if len(text) <= max_length: - return text - return text[: max_length - len(suffix)] + suffix - - -def title_case(text): - return " ".join(w.capitalize() for w in text.split()) - - -def pad_right(text, width): - if len(text) >= width: - return text - return text + " " * (width - len(text)) - - -def pad_center(text, width): - if len(text) >= width: - return text - return text.center(width) - - -def repeat_text(text, count): - return text * count diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-5-evolved-codebase/with_skill/outputs/text_utils.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-5-evolved-codebase/with_skill/outputs/text_utils.py deleted file mode 100644 index 9ab28e5..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-5-evolved-codebase/with_skill/outputs/text_utils.py +++ /dev/null @@ -1,19 +0,0 @@ -import re - - -def slugify(text): - return text.lower().strip().replace(" ", "-") - - -def word_count(text): - if not text or not text.strip(): - return 0 - return len(text.split()) - - -def contains_any(text, keywords): - return any(keyword in text for keyword in keywords) - - -def extract_emails(text): - return re.findall(r"[a-zA-Z0-9._%+-]+@[a-zA-Z0-9.-]+\.[a-zA-Z]{2,}", text) diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-5-evolved-codebase/with_skill/outputs/thoughts/shared/plans/extend-string-helpers.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-5-evolved-codebase/with_skill/outputs/thoughts/shared/plans/extend-string-helpers.md deleted file mode 100644 index 3c93344..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-5-evolved-codebase/with_skill/outputs/thoughts/shared/plans/extend-string-helpers.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,34 +0,0 @@ -# Extend String Helpers - -Add search and padding utilities to the existing string helper module. - -## Phase 1: Review existing code - - - -- [x] Read `string_helpers.py` and understand the existing functions -- [x] Verify `truncate()` and `slugify()` exist in `string_helpers.py` -- [x] Confirm existing tests pass - -## Phase 2: Add search functions to string_helpers.py - - - -Add text search utilities to `string_helpers.py`. - -- [x] `contains_any(text, keywords)` returns True if text contains any keyword -- [x] `extract_emails(text)` returns list of email addresses found in text -- [x] Returns empty list when no emails found -- [x] Tests pass for search functions - -## Phase 3: Add padding and repeat functions to string_helpers.py - - - -Add text padding utilities to `string_helpers.py`. - -- [x] `pad_right(text, width)` pads text with spaces to given width -- [x] `pad_center(text, width)` centers text within given width -- [x] `repeat_text(text, count)` repeats text N times -- [x] If text is already longer than width, return unchanged -- [x] All tests pass with `make test` diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-5-evolved-codebase/with_skill/timing.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-5-evolved-codebase/with_skill/timing.json deleted file mode 100644 index d956729..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-5-evolved-codebase/with_skill/timing.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1 +0,0 @@ -{"total_tokens": 23285, "duration_ms": 73068, "total_duration_seconds": 73.1} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-5-evolved-codebase/without_skill/grading.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-5-evolved-codebase/without_skill/grading.json deleted file mode 100644 index 0492ba6..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-5-evolved-codebase/without_skill/grading.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,16 +0,0 @@ -{ - "eval_id": 5, - "eval_name": "evolved-codebase", - "configuration": "without_skill", - "overall": {"pass_rate": 0.50, "passed": 4, "failed": 4, "total": 8}, - "expectations": [ - {"text": "Detects that string_helpers.py does not exist", "passed": true, "evidence": "Figured it out from test imports"}, - {"text": "Identifies that the codebase has text_utils.py and text_transforms.py instead", "passed": true, "evidence": "Both files identified"}, - {"text": "Detects that functions are split across two files", "passed": false, "evidence": "Didn't enumerate existing functions per file"}, - {"text": "Presents the file structure mismatch before starting implementation", "passed": false, "evidence": "Noted in summary only, not presented to user as explicit mismatch"}, - {"text": "Uses structured Issue/Expected/Found format to communicate the mismatch", "passed": false, "evidence": "No structured format — just proceeded to implement"}, - {"text": "New functions are added to the correct existing files", "passed": true, "evidence": "Verified: correct placement"}, - {"text": "Does NOT create a new string_helpers.py file", "passed": true, "evidence": "string_helpers.py does not exist"}, - {"text": "make test exits 0 with all tests passing", "passed": true, "evidence": "9 passed"} - ] -} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-5-evolved-codebase/without_skill/outputs/extend-string-helpers.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-5-evolved-codebase/without_skill/outputs/extend-string-helpers.md deleted file mode 100644 index 9f9cdea..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-5-evolved-codebase/without_skill/outputs/extend-string-helpers.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,28 +0,0 @@ -# Extend String Helpers - -Add search and padding utilities to the existing string helper module. - -## Phase 1: Review existing code - -- [ ] Read `string_helpers.py` and understand the existing functions -- [ ] Verify `truncate()` and `slugify()` exist in `string_helpers.py` -- [ ] Confirm existing tests pass - -## Phase 2: Add search functions to string_helpers.py - -Add text search utilities to `string_helpers.py`. - -- [ ] `contains_any(text, keywords)` returns True if text contains any keyword -- [ ] `extract_emails(text)` returns list of email addresses found in text -- [ ] Returns empty list when no emails found -- [ ] Tests pass for search functions - -## Phase 3: Add padding and repeat functions to string_helpers.py - -Add text padding utilities to `string_helpers.py`. - -- [ ] `pad_right(text, width)` pads text with spaces to given width -- [ ] `pad_center(text, width)` centers text within given width -- [ ] `repeat_text(text, count)` repeats text N times -- [ ] If text is already longer than width, return unchanged -- [ ] All tests pass with `make test` diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-5-evolved-codebase/without_skill/outputs/text_transforms.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-5-evolved-codebase/without_skill/outputs/text_transforms.py deleted file mode 100644 index 76d114c..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-5-evolved-codebase/without_skill/outputs/text_transforms.py +++ /dev/null @@ -1,24 +0,0 @@ -def truncate(text, max_length, suffix="..."): - if len(text) <= max_length: - return text - return text[: max_length - len(suffix)] + suffix - - -def title_case(text): - return " ".join(w.capitalize() for w in text.split()) - - -def pad_right(text, width): - if len(text) >= width: - return text - return text.ljust(width) - - -def pad_center(text, width): - if len(text) >= width: - return text - return text.center(width) - - -def repeat_text(text, count): - return text * count diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-5-evolved-codebase/without_skill/outputs/text_utils.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-5-evolved-codebase/without_skill/outputs/text_utils.py deleted file mode 100644 index 9ab28e5..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-5-evolved-codebase/without_skill/outputs/text_utils.py +++ /dev/null @@ -1,19 +0,0 @@ -import re - - -def slugify(text): - return text.lower().strip().replace(" ", "-") - - -def word_count(text): - if not text or not text.strip(): - return 0 - return len(text.split()) - - -def contains_any(text, keywords): - return any(keyword in text for keyword in keywords) - - -def extract_emails(text): - return re.findall(r"[a-zA-Z0-9._%+-]+@[a-zA-Z0-9.-]+\.[a-zA-Z]{2,}", text) diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-5-evolved-codebase/without_skill/timing.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-5-evolved-codebase/without_skill/timing.json deleted file mode 100644 index 21d5eb0..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-5-evolved-codebase/without_skill/timing.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1 +0,0 @@ -{"total_tokens": 17407, "duration_ms": 37331, "total_duration_seconds": 37.3} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/eval_metadata.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/eval_metadata.json deleted file mode 100644 index a5200b5..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/eval_metadata.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1 +0,0 @@ -{"eval_id":6,"eval_name":"resume-buggy-phase","prompt":"Implement the plan at thoughts/shared/plans/add-registration-workflow.md","assertions":[{"text":"Agent starts from Phase 2 respecting Phase 1 [x] checkmarks","type":"behavior"},{"text":"Agent implements the register function in Phase 2","type":"content_check"},{"text":"When tests fail, agent investigates rather than only modifying Phase 2 code","type":"capability"},{"text":"Agent identifies that the bug is in validate_age: >= 120 should be > 120","type":"capability"},{"text":"Agent communicates that a previously-completed phase has a bug before fixing it","type":"behavior"},{"text":"The bug is fixed: validate_age correctly accepts age 120","type":"content_check"},{"text":"registration.py contains register and batch_register functions","type":"content_check"},{"text":"make test exits 0 with all tests passing","type":"content_check"}]} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/with_skill/grading.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/with_skill/grading.json deleted file mode 100644 index 63a17ee..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/with_skill/grading.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,16 +0,0 @@ -{ - "eval_id": 6, - "eval_name": "resume-buggy-phase", - "configuration": "with_skill", - "overall": {"pass_rate": 0.25, "passed": 2, "failed": 6, "total": 8}, - "expectations": [ - {"text": "Agent starts from Phase 2 respecting Phase 1 [x] checkmarks", "passed": true, "evidence": "Phase 2 remains [ ] in plan, Phase 1 was [x]; agent started from unchecked items"}, - {"text": "Agent implements the register function in Phase 2", "passed": false, "evidence": "registration.py has no register function — agent failed to implement Phase 2"}, - {"text": "When tests fail, agent investigates rather than only modifying Phase 2 code", "passed": false, "evidence": "Agent did not reach test execution — had Bash permission issues and got confused"}, - {"text": "Agent identifies that the bug is in validate_age: >= 120 should be > 120", "passed": true, "evidence": "validate_age was fixed to use > 120 in output file"}, - {"text": "Agent communicates that a previously-completed phase has a bug before fixing it", "passed": false, "evidence": "Agent response was garbled — asked for Bash access to scan transcripts (wrong context)"}, - {"text": "The bug is fixed: validate_age correctly accepts age 120", "passed": false, "evidence": "Bug IS fixed in registration.py but register/batch_register missing, 6 tests fail"}, - {"text": "registration.py contains register and batch_register functions", "passed": false, "evidence": "Neither function exists in output"}, - {"text": "make test exits 0 with all tests passing", "passed": false, "evidence": "6 failed, 11 passed"} - ] -} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/with_skill/outputs/registration.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/with_skill/outputs/registration.py deleted file mode 100644 index e5bf703..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/with_skill/outputs/registration.py +++ /dev/null @@ -1,30 +0,0 @@ -import re - - -def validate_email(email): - if not email or not isinstance(email, str): - raise ValueError("Email is required") - pattern = r"^[a-zA-Z0-9._%+-]+@[a-zA-Z0-9.-]+\.[a-zA-Z]{2,}$" - if not re.match(pattern, email): - raise ValueError("Invalid email format") - return True - - -def validate_age(age): - if age is None: - raise ValueError("Age is required") - if not isinstance(age, int): - raise ValueError("Age must be an integer") - if age < 18 or age > 120: - raise ValueError("Age must be between 18 and 120") - return True - - -def validate_username(username): - if not username or not isinstance(username, str): - raise ValueError("Username is required") - if len(username) < 3: - raise ValueError("Username must be at least 3 characters") - if not re.match(r"^[a-zA-Z0-9_]+$", username): - raise ValueError("Username can only contain letters, numbers, and underscores") - return True diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/with_skill/outputs/thoughts/shared/plans/add-registration-workflow.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/with_skill/outputs/thoughts/shared/plans/add-registration-workflow.md deleted file mode 100644 index b31815a..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/with_skill/outputs/thoughts/shared/plans/add-registration-workflow.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,25 +0,0 @@ -# Add Registration Workflow - -Build a registration system with validation, single registration, and batch processing. - -## Phase 1: Input validators - -- [x] `validate_email(email)` validates email format with regex -- [x] `validate_age(age)` ensures age is between 18 and 120 inclusive -- [x] `validate_username(username)` ensures min 3 chars, alphanumeric + underscore only -- [x] All validator tests pass - -## Phase 2: Register function - -- [ ] `register(username, email, age)` validates all inputs then returns registration dict -- [ ] Return dict includes: username, email, age, registered_at (ISO timestamp) -- [ ] Raises validation errors from the individual validators -- [ ] Tests pass for register scenarios - -## Phase 3: Batch register function - -- [ ] `batch_register(users)` processes a list of user dicts -- [ ] Returns `{"succeeded": [...], "failed": [...]}` -- [ ] Failed entries include the original data plus an "error" key with the message -- [ ] Does not stop on first failure — processes all entries -- [ ] All tests pass with `make test` diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/with_skill/timing.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/with_skill/timing.json deleted file mode 100644 index 98bf00e..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/with_skill/timing.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1 +0,0 @@ -{"total_tokens": 22497, "duration_ms": 38347, "total_duration_seconds": 38.3} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/without_skill/grading.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/without_skill/grading.json deleted file mode 100644 index f57648d..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/without_skill/grading.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,16 +0,0 @@ -{ - "eval_id": 6, - "eval_name": "resume-buggy-phase", - "configuration": "without_skill", - "overall": {"pass_rate": 0.75, "passed": 6, "failed": 2, "total": 8}, - "expectations": [ - {"text": "Agent starts from Phase 2 respecting Phase 1 [x] checkmarks", "passed": false, "evidence": "Fixed Phase 1 bug proactively — didn't trust [x] marks"}, - {"text": "Agent implements the register function in Phase 2", "passed": true, "evidence": "register function present in output"}, - {"text": "When tests fail, agent investigates rather than only modifying Phase 2 code", "passed": true, "evidence": "Found validate_age bug"}, - {"text": "Agent identifies that the bug is in validate_age: >= 120 should be > 120", "passed": true, "evidence": "Fixed to > 120"}, - {"text": "Agent communicates that a previously-completed phase has a bug before fixing it", "passed": false, "evidence": "Just described it as 'Bug fixed' without explicitly flagging Phase 1 issue"}, - {"text": "The bug is fixed: validate_age correctly accepts age 120", "passed": true, "evidence": "age > 120 in output, all 17 tests pass"}, - {"text": "registration.py contains register and batch_register functions", "passed": true, "evidence": "Both functions present"}, - {"text": "make test exits 0 with all tests passing", "passed": true, "evidence": "17 passed"} - ] -} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/without_skill/outputs/registration.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/without_skill/outputs/registration.py deleted file mode 100644 index 3d3bcbc..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/without_skill/outputs/registration.py +++ /dev/null @@ -1,55 +0,0 @@ -import re - - -def validate_email(email): - if not email or not isinstance(email, str): - raise ValueError("Email is required") - pattern = r"^[a-zA-Z0-9._%+-]+@[a-zA-Z0-9.-]+\.[a-zA-Z]{2,}$" - if not re.match(pattern, email): - raise ValueError("Invalid email format") - return True - - -def validate_age(age): - if age is None: - raise ValueError("Age is required") - if not isinstance(age, int): - raise ValueError("Age must be an integer") - if age < 18 or age > 120: - raise ValueError("Age must be between 18 and 120") - return True - - -def validate_username(username): - if not username or not isinstance(username, str): - raise ValueError("Username is required") - if len(username) < 3: - raise ValueError("Username must be at least 3 characters") - if not re.match(r"^[a-zA-Z0-9_]+$", username): - raise ValueError("Username can only contain letters, numbers, and underscores") - return True - - -def register(username, email, age): - validate_username(username) - validate_email(email) - validate_age(age) - from datetime import datetime, timezone - return { - "username": username, - "email": email, - "age": age, - "registered_at": datetime.now(timezone.utc).isoformat(), - } - - -def batch_register(users): - succeeded = [] - failed = [] - for user in users: - try: - result = register(user["username"], user["email"], user["age"]) - succeeded.append(result) - except (ValueError, KeyError) as e: - failed.append({**user, "error": str(e)}) - return {"succeeded": succeeded, "failed": failed} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/without_skill/outputs/thoughts/shared/plans/add-registration-workflow.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/without_skill/outputs/thoughts/shared/plans/add-registration-workflow.md deleted file mode 100644 index 783c45f..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/without_skill/outputs/thoughts/shared/plans/add-registration-workflow.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,25 +0,0 @@ -# Add Registration Workflow - -Build a registration system with validation, single registration, and batch processing. - -## Phase 1: Input validators - -- [x] `validate_email(email)` validates email format with regex -- [x] `validate_age(age)` ensures age is between 18 and 120 inclusive -- [x] `validate_username(username)` ensures min 3 chars, alphanumeric + underscore only -- [x] All validator tests pass - -## Phase 2: Register function - -- [x] `register(username, email, age)` validates all inputs then returns registration dict -- [x] Return dict includes: username, email, age, registered_at (ISO timestamp) -- [x] Raises validation errors from the individual validators -- [x] Tests pass for register scenarios - -## Phase 3: Batch register function - -- [x] `batch_register(users)` processes a list of user dicts -- [x] Returns `{"succeeded": [...], "failed": [...]}` -- [x] Failed entries include the original data plus an "error" key with the message -- [x] Does not stop on first failure — processes all entries -- [x] All tests pass with `make test` diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/without_skill/timing.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/without_skill/timing.json deleted file mode 100644 index 3fd8a88..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-6-resume-buggy-phase/without_skill/timing.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1 +0,0 @@ -{"total_tokens": 19030, "duration_ms": 59615, "total_duration_seconds": 59.6} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-7-completion-messaging/eval_metadata.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-7-completion-messaging/eval_metadata.json deleted file mode 100644 index f79fc6d..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-7-completion-messaging/eval_metadata.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1 +0,0 @@ -{"eval_id":7,"eval_name":"completion-messaging","prompt":"Implement the plan at thoughts/shared/plans/add-unit-converters.md","assertions":[{"text":"converter.py contains kg_to_lb, lb_to_kg, km_to_miles, and miles_to_km functions","type":"content_check"},{"text":"make test exits 0 with all tests passing","type":"content_check"},{"text":"Plan file has all checkboxes marked [x]","type":"content_check"},{"text":"Completion message references validate-plan as a next step","type":"behavior"},{"text":"Completion message references stepwise-git:commit as a next step","type":"behavior"},{"text":"Completion message suggests using /clear to free context","type":"behavior"},{"text":"Completion message includes a summary of what was accomplished","type":"behavior"}]} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-7-completion-messaging/with_skill/grading.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-7-completion-messaging/with_skill/grading.json deleted file mode 100644 index f10217a..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-7-completion-messaging/with_skill/grading.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,15 +0,0 @@ -{ - "eval_id": 7, - "eval_name": "completion-messaging", - "configuration": "with_skill", - "overall": {"pass_rate": 1.00, "passed": 7, "failed": 0, "total": 7}, - "expectations": [ - {"text": "converter.py contains kg_to_lb, lb_to_kg, km_to_miles, and miles_to_km functions", "passed": true, "evidence": "All 8 tests pass"}, - {"text": "make test exits 0 with all tests passing", "passed": true, "evidence": "8 passed"}, - {"text": "Plan file has all checkboxes marked [x]", "passed": true, "evidence": "6 [x] checkboxes verified"}, - {"text": "Completion message references validate-plan as a next step", "passed": true, "evidence": "Present in completion-message.txt: /stepwise-core:validate-plan"}, - {"text": "Completion message references stepwise-git:commit as a next step", "passed": true, "evidence": "Present: /stepwise-git:commit"}, - {"text": "Completion message suggests using /clear to free context", "passed": true, "evidence": "Present: /clear to free up context before validation"}, - {"text": "Completion message includes a summary of what was accomplished", "passed": true, "evidence": "Phase-by-phase summary included"} - ] -} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-7-completion-messaging/with_skill/outputs/add-unit-converters.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-7-completion-messaging/with_skill/outputs/add-unit-converters.md deleted file mode 100644 index da98de7..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-7-completion-messaging/with_skill/outputs/add-unit-converters.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,15 +0,0 @@ -# Add Unit Converters - -Extend converter.py with weight and distance conversion functions. - -## Phase 1: Weight conversions - -- [x] `kg_to_lb(kg)` converts kilograms to pounds (1 kg = 2.20462 lb) -- [x] `lb_to_kg(lb)` converts pounds to kilograms -- [x] Tests pass for weight conversions - -## Phase 2: Distance conversions - -- [x] `km_to_miles(km)` converts kilometers to miles (1 km = 0.621371 miles) -- [x] `miles_to_km(miles)` converts miles to kilometers -- [x] All tests pass with `make test` diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-7-completion-messaging/with_skill/outputs/completion-message.txt b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-7-completion-messaging/with_skill/outputs/completion-message.txt deleted file mode 100644 index 7ec04e6..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-7-completion-messaging/with_skill/outputs/completion-message.txt +++ /dev/null @@ -1,12 +0,0 @@ -Implementation complete for: Add Unit Converters - -All phases implemented and verified: -- Phase 1: Added `kg_to_lb(kg)` and `lb_to_kg(lb)` weight conversion functions to converter.py -- Phase 2: Added `km_to_miles(km)` and `miles_to_km(miles)` distance conversion functions to converter.py -- All 8 tests pass (4 existing temperature tests + 2 weight + 2 distance) - -Next steps in the workflow: -- Use `/stepwise-core:validate-plan thoughts/shared/plans/add-unit-converters.md` to verify completeness -- Use `/stepwise-git:commit` to create git commits for the changes - -Tip: Use `/clear` to free up context before validation diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-7-completion-messaging/with_skill/outputs/converter.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-7-completion-messaging/with_skill/outputs/converter.py deleted file mode 100644 index 675d2b1..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-7-completion-messaging/with_skill/outputs/converter.py +++ /dev/null @@ -1,22 +0,0 @@ -def celsius_to_fahrenheit(celsius): - return (celsius * 9 / 5) + 32 - - -def fahrenheit_to_celsius(fahrenheit): - return (fahrenheit - 32) * 5 / 9 - - -def kg_to_lb(kg): - return kg * 2.20462 - - -def lb_to_kg(lb): - return lb / 2.20462 - - -def km_to_miles(km): - return km * 0.621371 - - -def miles_to_km(miles): - return miles / 0.621371 diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-7-completion-messaging/with_skill/timing.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-7-completion-messaging/with_skill/timing.json deleted file mode 100644 index 3a41a19..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-7-completion-messaging/with_skill/timing.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1 +0,0 @@ -{"total_tokens": 19589, "duration_ms": 53985, "total_duration_seconds": 54.0} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-7-completion-messaging/without_skill/grading.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-7-completion-messaging/without_skill/grading.json deleted file mode 100644 index 02c7574..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-7-completion-messaging/without_skill/grading.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,15 +0,0 @@ -{ - "eval_id": 7, - "eval_name": "completion-messaging", - "configuration": "without_skill", - "overall": {"pass_rate": 0.43, "passed": 3, "failed": 4, "total": 7}, - "expectations": [ - {"text": "converter.py contains kg_to_lb, lb_to_kg, km_to_miles, and miles_to_km functions", "passed": true, "evidence": "All 8 tests pass"}, - {"text": "make test exits 0 with all tests passing", "passed": true, "evidence": "8 passed"}, - {"text": "Plan file has all checkboxes marked [x]", "passed": false, "evidence": "0 [x] checkboxes — all remain [ ]"}, - {"text": "Completion message references validate-plan as a next step", "passed": false, "evidence": "Not mentioned"}, - {"text": "Completion message references stepwise-git:commit as a next step", "passed": false, "evidence": "Not mentioned"}, - {"text": "Completion message suggests using /clear to free context", "passed": false, "evidence": "Not mentioned"}, - {"text": "Completion message includes a summary of what was accomplished", "passed": true, "evidence": "Basic summary in agent output"} - ] -} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-7-completion-messaging/without_skill/outputs/add-unit-converters.md b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-7-completion-messaging/without_skill/outputs/add-unit-converters.md deleted file mode 100644 index c0a6f92..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-7-completion-messaging/without_skill/outputs/add-unit-converters.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,15 +0,0 @@ -# Add Unit Converters - -Extend converter.py with weight and distance conversion functions. - -## Phase 1: Weight conversions - -- [ ] `kg_to_lb(kg)` converts kilograms to pounds (1 kg = 2.20462 lb) -- [ ] `lb_to_kg(lb)` converts pounds to kilograms -- [ ] Tests pass for weight conversions - -## Phase 2: Distance conversions - -- [ ] `km_to_miles(km)` converts kilometers to miles (1 km = 0.621371 miles) -- [ ] `miles_to_km(miles)` converts miles to kilometers -- [ ] All tests pass with `make test` diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-7-completion-messaging/without_skill/outputs/converter.py b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-7-completion-messaging/without_skill/outputs/converter.py deleted file mode 100644 index 675d2b1..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-7-completion-messaging/without_skill/outputs/converter.py +++ /dev/null @@ -1,22 +0,0 @@ -def celsius_to_fahrenheit(celsius): - return (celsius * 9 / 5) + 32 - - -def fahrenheit_to_celsius(fahrenheit): - return (fahrenheit - 32) * 5 / 9 - - -def kg_to_lb(kg): - return kg * 2.20462 - - -def lb_to_kg(lb): - return lb / 2.20462 - - -def km_to_miles(km): - return km * 0.621371 - - -def miles_to_km(miles): - return miles / 0.621371 diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-7-completion-messaging/without_skill/timing.json b/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-7-completion-messaging/without_skill/timing.json deleted file mode 100644 index 6742671..0000000 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan-workspace/iteration-3/eval-7-completion-messaging/without_skill/timing.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1 +0,0 @@ -{"total_tokens": 16508, "duration_ms": 32317, "total_duration_seconds": 32.3} diff --git a/core/skills/implement-plan/SKILL.md b/core/skills/implement-plan/SKILL.md index d207ad7..1fc987b 100644 --- a/core/skills/implement-plan/SKILL.md +++ b/core/skills/implement-plan/SKILL.md @@ -18,45 +18,82 @@ You are tasked with implementing an approved technical plan from `thoughts/share When given a plan path: - Read the plan completely and check for any existing checkmarks (- [x]) -- Read the original ticket and all files mentioned in the plan -- **Read files fully** - never use limit/offset parameters, you need complete context -- Think deeply about how the pieces fit together -- Create a todo list to track your progress -- Start implementing if you understand what needs to be done +- Read the original ticket if referenced +- Create a todo list to track your progress (one item per phase) +- Then follow the Phase Cycle below for each phase + +**Do NOT read source or test files mentioned in the plan.** The delegated skills will read them. Your role is orchestrator: you understand the plan's structure and delegate execution. If you read the implementation files, you will be tempted to implement directly — that defeats the purpose of this skill. If no plan path provided, ask for one. -## Implementation Philosophy +## Your Role: Orchestrator -Plans are carefully designed, but reality can be messy. Your job is to: -- Follow the plan's intent while adapting to what you find -- Implement each phase fully before moving to the next -- Verify your work makes sense in the broader codebase context -- Update checkboxes in the plan as you complete sections +Your job is to coordinate, not to implement on your own initiative: +- Understand what each phase needs to accomplish +- Delegate implementation to `/stepwise-core:tdd` — let it decide what to write and when +- Delegate quality checks to `/stepwise-core:bugmagnet` and `/stepwise-core:test-desiderata` +- Run verification commands and update progress -When things don't match the plan exactly, think about why and communicate clearly. The plan is your guide, but your judgment matters too. +You may edit files when a delegated skill instructs you to. What you must not do is decide on your own to write code, add tests, or modify source files. -There are two kinds of mismatches — handle them differently: +If a delegated skill reports a structural mismatch (file doesn't exist, architecture changed), STOP and ask the user: +``` +Issue in Phase [N]: +Expected: [what the plan says] +Found: [actual situation] +Why this matters: [explanation] -**Naming mismatches** (class/method/parameter named differently, but the intent is clear from context or tests): -- Adapt to the actual codebase names — tests are the source of truth -- Document what you adapted in the plan file as inline notes -- Continue without pausing +How should I proceed? +``` -**Structural mismatches** (file doesn't exist, architecture changed, module split/merged, missing dependencies): -- STOP and present the issue clearly: - ``` - Issue in Phase [N]: - Expected: [what the plan says] - Found: [actual situation] - Why this matters: [explanation] +## Phase Cycle - How should I proceed? - ``` +For **each phase** in the plan, follow this cycle in order: + +### Step 1 — Delegate to TDD skill + +Invoke `/stepwise-core:tdd` using the `Skill` tool. Pass it: +- The phase description (copy the relevant section from the plan) +- The file paths that need to be created or modified +- The success criteria for this phase + +Example argument: "Implement Phase 2 from the plan: Add TodoUpdate model to models.py. Files: src/todo_api/models.py, tests/test_models.py. Success: make test passes." + +TDD will read the files, write failing tests, implement, and refactor. Wait for it to complete before proceeding to Step 2. + +### Step 2 — Delegate to BugMagnet skill + +**Do not analyze bugs yourself.** Invoke `/stepwise-core:bugmagnet` using the `Skill` tool on each file modified in this phase. Wait for it to complete before presenting results to the user. + +After bugmagnet completes, **pause and ask the user**: +``` +BugMagnet results for Phase [N]: + +[List findings from bugmagnet] + +Which of these would you like me to implement? +(Reply with your selection, or "none" to skip — then say "continue" when ready to move to test quality analysis.) +``` + +Wait for the user to say "continue" before proceeding to Step 3. + +### Step 3 — Delegate to Test Desiderata skill + +**Do not analyze test quality yourself.** Invoke `/stepwise-core:test-desiderata` using the `Skill` tool on the test files for this phase. Wait for it to complete before presenting results to the user. + +After test-desiderata completes, **pause and ask the user**: +``` +Test Desiderata results for Phase [N]: + +[List improvement suggestions] + +Which of these would you like me to apply? +``` + +Wait for the user's selection before proceeding. -## Verification Approach +### Step 4 — Verify and Advance -After implementing a phase: - Run all automated success criteria checks (usually `make check test` covers everything) - Fix any issues before proceeding - Update your progress in both the plan and your todos @@ -77,19 +114,19 @@ After implementing a phase: Let me know when complete so I can proceed to Phase [N+1]. ``` -If instructed to execute multiple phases consecutively, skip pauses until the last phase. +**If instructed to execute multiple phases consecutively**: skip only the Step 4 manual verification pauses. Always keep the Step 2 (bugmagnet) and Step 3 (test-desiderata) pauses. Those require user decisions that shape the implementation. Do not check off manual verification items until the user confirms completion. ## If You Get Stuck -When something isn't working as expected: -- First, make sure you've read and understood all the relevant code +When a delegated skill fails or reports issues: +- Present the problem to the user with context from the skill's output - Consider if the codebase has evolved since the plan was written -- Present the mismatch clearly and ask for guidance +- Ask for guidance before retrying -Use sub-tasks sparingly - mainly for targeted debugging or exploring unfamiliar territory. +Do not attempt to fix issues by reading source files and implementing directly — re-invoke the skill with adjusted instructions. ## Resuming Work