Skip to content

docs(vedic): scope P2 validation evidence by field - #23

Draft
Jowitt13 wants to merge 2 commits into
mainfrom
vedic/p2-validation-evidence-boundary
Draft

docs(vedic): scope P2 validation evidence by field#23
Jowitt13 wants to merge 2 commits into
mainfrom
vedic/p2-validation-evidence-boundary

Conversation

@Jowitt13

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner

Summary

Updates ADR 0013 and the Vedic source matrix after auditing NDAstro 0.28.1 as a potential second reference.

  • Keeps Swiss swetest -sid1 -utc -emos fixtures as the ≤1′ hard acceptance gate for grahas, both Rahu modes, and Lagna.
  • Makes MIT cross-check evidence field-scoped rather than treating a partial candidate as a full oracle.
  • Records the NDAstro results: Sun–Saturn (0.710′) and mean Rahu (0.046′) pre-screen pass; true Rahu (7.633′) and Lagna (10.286′) fail. Those fields remain Swiss-only external numeric references.
  • Raises the P2 synthetic-case minimum from 50 to 100 and documents capture-manifest and transformation safeguards.
  • Adds a doc gate. No calculation, contract, lockfile, SBOM, bundle, or golden fixture changes.

Validation

  • pnpm run verify:cloud — passed (705 tests / 38 files).

Scope

Documentation and doc-gate only. No tag, release, published asset, or manifest promotion.

Jowitt13 added 2 commits July 30, 2026 18:04
Keep Swiss -sid1 external goldens as the ≤1′ hard gate while recording MIT cross-checks only for fields they demonstrably cover. Record the NDAstro 0.28.1 audit: Sun..Saturn and mean Rahu pre-screen pass; true Rahu and Lagna fail and remain Swiss-only external numeric references. Raise P2's synthetic-case minimum to 100 and pin disclosure/invariant safeguards with a doc gate. No calculation, contract, lockfile, SBOM, bundle or golden changes.
Record the two owner decisions of 2026-07-31 in ADR 0013 and its companions: the Vimshottari year model is fixed to dashaYear 'julian-365.25' (365.25 x 86400 SI seconds; savana-360/sidereal only as future new rulesets) and the Vaara sunrise rule is fixed to upper-limb + standard 34-arcmin refraction (upper-limb-standard-refraction). Both remain delivery-gated by verification evidence only: Vimshottari by the same-model dual-implementation cross-check, Vaara by the sunrise backend-mapping goldens (the -50-arcmin center mapping stays a P2/P3 implementation blocker). ADR Status stays Proposed because the Rahu node default is still awaiting owner confirmation. Open questions 2 and 3 are marked Resolved 2026-07-31; Consequences now separates frozen owner defaults from outstanding verification gates. vedic-docs.test.ts locks the new semantics without relaxing any capability-claim or precision gate. Docs only; no contracts, lockfile, SBOM, bundle, golden, Skill, manifest or release changes (verified zero diff).
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant