Skip to content

Add "Cargo Cult Religion" to B floor of ORI#12

Open
DefenderOfBasic wants to merge 1 commit intomainfrom
cargo-cult-religion
Open

Add "Cargo Cult Religion" to B floor of ORI#12
DefenderOfBasic wants to merge 1 commit intomainfrom
cargo-cult-religion

Conversation

@DefenderOfBasic
Copy link
Contributor

I think everyone who has reached "ORI level" has independently deduced this in one way or another (although may not agree 100% with my phrasing here?)

Everyone in ORI has discovered one way or another the truth that ancient religions were trying to express from first principles. If religion was being created from scratch in modern times, we would call it "the science of alignment", of which AI alignment is a small subset.

It is hard to talk to people who don't yet understand this. I consider them "below the B floor", and one of my TODOs is writing a series of essays that brings people up to this level, because I think (1) it is true, and therefore (2) everyone can be brought up to this level, or will get there on their own eventually. This is part of why I think spending time doing science communication for Sam's God Conjecture is good for all of ORI


The phrase "cargo cult religion" is meant to package this entire concept in one succinct phrase. It's like a scissor statement because it triggers two distinct reactions:

  • wait, isn't ALL religion cargo cult?? what else is there other than blindly following rituals on faith?
  • Ah! Clever! You are using Feynman's "cargo cult science" to show that religion ALSO has "cargo cult" institutions, and to differentiate it form the REAL truth seeking religion

@strikingcrayon
Copy link

that TODO regarding bringing people up to the level is a Work onto itself separate from the work of ORI

God seemingly decides who can see and who cannot.

https://youtube.com/shorts/RWvJ_xC_C7U?si=5ZjITK31S5UURVlu

as we skill up, we earn new capacities to exist, based on our alignments and alignable potentials

A system which brings people Onboard is no different from a catechism or and education.

sourcing without an equalizing education if fallacious

we are learning to think like Christ
^ even those who owe it to those they serve to not say it so plainly

as plain as anything can be said when approaching truth
That which is aware of the inability of our selves.
that which ate of the fruit of Good and Evil

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

2 participants