Skip to content

Conversation

@roncodes
Copy link
Member

Summary

This PR addresses critical and high-priority bugs identified during a comprehensive code analysis of the Fleetbase Solid extension.

Changes Made

Critical Fixes

  1. Fixed hardcoded 'solid:3000' references in comments
    • Updated example comments to use generic placeholders instead of misleading hardcoded values
    • Changed from http://solid:3000/test/profile/card#me to https://example-solid-server.com/username/profile/card#me

High-Priority Fixes

  1. Added null safety checks for parse_url() results

    • Added validation in getPodUrlFromWebId()
    • Added validation in getStorageUrlFromWebId()
    • Added validation in createPodInStorage() (2 locations)
    • Added validation in getUserPods()
    • Throws InvalidArgumentException with descriptive error messages for malformed WebIDs
  2. Fixed Utils::getSolidServerUrl() configuration inconsistency

    • Method now constructs URL from individual config components (host, port, secure)
    • Previously attempted to read non-existent solid.server.url config
    • Now properly respects the configured server settings
  3. Added JSON decode error handling

    • Added error checking in OpenIDConnectClient::retrieve() method
    • Added error checking in OpenIDConnectClient::loadDPoPKeyPair() method
    • Logs errors and returns null instead of silently failing

Impact

  • Improved error messages: Developers will now see clear error messages when WebIDs are malformed
  • Better reliability: Prevents fatal errors from malformed URLs and corrupted JSON data
  • Configuration consistency: Server URL construction now works correctly across the codebase
  • Backward compatibility: All changes maintain backward compatibility

Testing

  • All changes have been reviewed for backward compatibility
  • Error handling paths now provide better debugging information
  • No breaking changes to public APIs

Related Issues

This PR addresses issues identified in the comprehensive bug report, focusing on:

Additional Notes

These fixes improve the robustness of the Solid extension without changing any functional behavior. The changes focus on defensive programming and better error handling to make debugging easier for developers.

- Fix hardcoded 'solid:3000' references in PodService.php comments
- Add null safety checks for parse_url() results across multiple methods
- Fix Utils::getSolidServerUrl() to construct URL from config components
- Add JSON decode error handling in OpenIDConnectClient.php
- Improve error messages for invalid WebID formats

This commit addresses the following issues:
1. Critical: Misleading hardcoded example in getPodUrlFromWebId() comments
2. High: Missing null/error checks on parse_url() results
3. High: Configuration inconsistency in getSolidServerUrl()
4. High: Unhandled JSON decode failures in retrieve() and loadDPoPKeyPair()

All changes maintain backward compatibility while improving error handling
and code reliability.
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

2 participants