Skip to content

MP-ADMIN-ADMINISTRATIVE-0813-CLOSURE-PREFLIGHT-001: make exact closure recovery unstarvable - #562

Merged
fyremael merged 12 commits into
mainfrom
control/mp-admin-0813-closure-preflight-001
Aug 18, 2026
Merged

MP-ADMIN-ADMINISTRATIVE-0813-CLOSURE-PREFLIGHT-001: make exact closure recovery unstarvable#562
fyremael merged 12 commits into
mainfrom
control/mp-admin-0813-closure-preflight-001

Conversation

@fyremael

@fyremael fyremael commented Aug 18, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

Successor execution repair under open control issue #554.

Protected observation after #559:

This PR makes only the already-authorized exact Aug13 closure path structurally first inside the existing single Referee/executor step. Candidate preparation and runtime-contract validation remain in their ordinary positions. The Referee/executor step then runs an exact-target-only preflight before administrative_autonomy_runtime.py execute.

The preflight imports the protected runtime overlay chain, asks the existing pending_closures classifier for the exact #475/#476 tuple, and, only when that exact tuple is the sole target, delegates unchanged to existing finish_closure mechanics. If the exact target is absent, it is a no-op and the ordinary runtime executes as before. If recovery completes, the step exits before the ordinary runtime so the checkout that predates the protected receipt merge is not reused.

The existing single-use github.token Referee credential remains exactly once in the workflow; Candidate/Referee/administrator separation and permissions are unchanged.

Scope:

The regression suite proves exact-target identity rejection, no-target/no-authority behavior, unchanged finish_closure delegation, runtime-overlay import ordering, preflight-before-full-runtime ordering, single-use Referee token preservation, and mandatory reachability through the existing administrative validation module.

Control-plane admission requires fresh exact-head machine gates, independent non-author exact-head APPROVED review, explicit Human Steward exact-head disposition, expected-head protected merge, and protected-main readback.

Refs #554, #555, #559, #475, #476, #558.

@fyremael
fyremael requested review from a team as code owners August 18, 2026 08:07
@fyremael
fyremael deployed to release-trust August 18, 2026 08:07 — with GitHub Actions Active
@gcl-release-trust

gcl-release-trust Bot commented Aug 18, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

Advisory visual status report — PRVSR-LIVE-PR562-78a2a8d43a5b-20260818082711

  • operative state: UNKNOWN
  • freshness: CURRENT
  • exact PR head: 78a2a8d43a5b4c02b949be51516188de6ba2fe60
  • source snapshot SHA-256: 000648aceaec3b81aa6fdc9166591b38742178958ec6d330fb0cea98682c5ae3
  • durable archive: governance/pr_visual_status_archive/grandchallenge/MATH-PROGRAMME/pr-562/PRVSR-LIVE-PR562-78a2a8d43a5b-20260818082711/

This is a deterministic, derived, advisory presentation of governed source state. It does not create review, authorization, merge, certification, or propagation authority. The target PR head was not modified by archive or transport generation.

Phase 1 archive branch: prvsr-advisory-archive/pr-562
Archive path: governance/pr_visual_status_archive/grandchallenge/MATH-PROGRAMME/pr-562/PRVSR-LIVE-PR562-78a2a8d43a5b-20260818082711/
Report generation or archive failure remains advisory and non-blocking.

@fyremael
fyremael deployed to release-trust August 18, 2026 08:09 — with GitHub Actions Active
jimsteeg
jimsteeg previously approved these changes Aug 18, 2026
@jimsteeg
jimsteeg deployed to release-trust August 18, 2026 08:13 — with GitHub Actions Active
@fyremael
fyremael requested a review from jimsteeg August 18, 2026 08:19

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author

EXACT-HEAD REVIEW CHECKPOINT

PR #562 is review-ready at exact head 78a2a8d43a5b4c02b949be51516188de6ba2fe60 against protected base 8381fb2345b7d226064f0d9cce12e73be2c7a584.

All 16 pull-request workflow lanes are terminal SUCCESS on this exact head, including:

  • Administrative maintenance automation validation 32115287079;
  • Programme policy checks 32115287041 (administrative and repository-regression shards green);
  • GCL conformance 32115287682;
  • Administrative maintenance dispatcher 32115287116;
  • the full triggered CMDG pinned replay matrix.

Scope remains five files only. The patch leaves candidate preparation and credential separation unchanged, preserves exactly one ${{ github.token }} Referee binding, and inserts an exact-target-only Aug13 closure preflight inside the existing Referee/executor step before the BEHIND/full-runtime path. The preflight can recover only issue #475 / merged PR #476 / record MP-ADMIN-ADMINISTRATIVE-REVIEW-2026-08-13-001; if absent it is a no-op, and if protected completion succeeds the stale checkout is not reused by the ordinary executor.

No completion-ledger edit, record re-execution/re-merge, #558 mutation/merge, generalized closure recovery, cadence/deadline reset, structural-frontier mutation, bypass/direct protected push, or substantive claim authority.

There are no unresolved review threads. The prior jimsteeg review on superseded head e3f6ddd7... is dismissed and creates no authority. Fresh independent non-author APPROVED review must bind exactly 78a2a8d43a5b4c02b949be51516188de6ba2fe60 before any Human Steward disposition or protected merge.

@jimsteeg
jimsteeg deployed to release-trust August 18, 2026 08:27 — with GitHub Actions Active
@fyremael
fyremael merged commit 06e62e6 into main Aug 18, 2026
50 checks passed
@fyremael
fyremael deleted the control/mp-admin-0813-closure-preflight-001 branch August 18, 2026 09:33
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

2 participants