adding VEP for response-function products and analysis products

[loumir]

here is a proposal from HEIG interest group for a response-products vocabulary.
this one is already published but I did not find the VEP record here for this one .

I have also submitted a new proposal for analysis data products.

[loumir]

Ignore VEP numbers , they were just suggestions for our preparing workspace.
Sorry for that.

[msdemlei]

On Wed, Jun 24, 2026 at 09:11:21AM -0700, Mireille LOUYS wrote: here is a proposal from HEIG interest group for a response-products vocabulary. this one is already published but I did not find the VEP record here for this one .

There are not VEPs for draft vocabularies; they are simply created as part of a standard and directly updated via PRs against the Vocabulary repo. The rationale here is that draft vocabularies ought to be able to evolve quickly and there are no considerations for stability -- this is why they are drafts. If any change to the response-function vocabulary as published now is part of "VEP-25", would you turn this into a PR against Vocabularies or tell me what changes you would like to make? Thanks!

I have also submitted a new proposal for analysis data products.

Oh, that's a new vocabulary. I'm currently busy, but I can turn that into a vocabulary if there's sufficient consensus within the HEIG. I've looked at <https://ivoa.net/documents/Notes/VOHE/20241112/> but couldn't see where this vocabulary fits in, and from skimming "VEP-26" I couldn't figure that out either. So... where do you think the analysis-product-type vocabulary would be used?

[loumir]

Analysis products are supposed to be used in the note
'Proposal for ObsCore Extension for high energy astrophysics'
section 5.1.4 for definitions and section A 2.1 for use cases for instance for draws.
but the term 'analysis products' is currently hardly discussed agains "advanced products" that seems very fuzzy .
These files help to guide the data interpretation, and relate to statistical, behavioral analysis on various parameters measured in the data : photometry, contamination, etc. .
I suppose we need more thoughts about this.