Feedback

feedbacklog.typ

@@ -22,3 +22,63 @@
   feedback: "The structure of the presentation is rather unique; it would be great if you could help the audience to follow it easier.",
   response: "To help the audience to follow the presentation easier, a progress-bar was added at the bottom of the slides to show the milestones of the presentation and highlight the one that indicates the current slide.",
 )
+
+#feedback(
+  feedback: "Is the resource pool, as the main contribution, independent of the programming exercise language?",
+  response: "Yes, the resource pool is completely independent of the exercises.",
+)
+
+#feedback(
+  feedback: "The pool does not load the JDK etc., since prebuilt IDE images are used instead. However, the pool still thinks of images differently, so isn't there a dependency after all?",
+  response: "There is a dependency in that sense, as raised by Prof. Krusche.",
+)
+
+#feedback(
+  feedback: "Was the benchmark done with only one specific blueprint?",
+  response: "Yes, the benchmark was only done with one version/language configuration.",
+)
+
+#feedback(
+  feedback: "Can you explain how the resource pooling works? What happens if there are many different configurations?",
+  response: "Prewarming happens separately, so there is a pool for each version. Different versions are unrelated to each other in that sense.",
+)
+
+#feedback(
+  feedback: "How many prewarmed resources were there for the benchmark?",
+  response: "For the benchmark with 50 concurrent users, there were 50 prewarmed resources. If demand exceeds that, the system falls back to lazy provisioning.",
+)
+
+#feedback(
+  feedback: "Do you think it is realistic to have 50 prewarmed sessions?",
+  response: "Yes, the system can definitely support over 100 without any issues, so this is realistic.",
+)
+
+#feedback(
+  feedback: "Are prewarmed resources created at the same time? Does prewarming happen automatically in the background?",
+  response: "Predictive scaling would ideally determine the size of the pool automatically, but currently this is done manually.",
+)
+
+#feedback(
+  feedback: "How many resources does one session contain?",
+  response: "0 CPU and a small amount of RAM.",
+)
+
+#feedback(
+  feedback: "So the prewarmed resources basically sleep until needed - is waking them up faster?",
+  response: "Yes, since it is just an HTTP service that isn't being used, waking it up is fast.",
+)
+
+#feedback(
+  feedback: "The presentation was good overall, with mostly dynamic behavior and a good visual representation. Matthias really liked the thesis and the work done.",
+  response: "",
+)
+
+#feedback(
+  feedback: "(This is about future ideas) How exactly do you determine how many resources you want to provision?",
+  response: "Deterministic data is used first, such as exam schedules, since there is no problem having too many resources. These simple signals are taken into account first.",
+)
+
+#feedback(
+  feedback: "(This is about future ideas) Is this deterministic data provided by the instructors?",
+  response: "No, the data is taken directly from Artemis, without any manual intervention from the instructors.",
+)