Reorganize folders for clarity and maintainability#21
Conversation
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Pull request overview
This PR reorganizes the codebase folder structure to improve clarity and maintainability. The changes consolidate UI components into a three-tier hierarchy (elements/layout/sections), centralize SEO-related code, and eliminate dead code and unnecessary abstractions.
Key Changes:
- Reorganized UI components into
elements/,layout/, andsections/directories - Consolidated SEO code into a dedicated
seo/folder with JSON-LD generation and metadata constants - Moved
app/page.tsxtoapp/(home)/page.tsxusing Next.js route groups - Inlined single-use configuration constants from
ci/config.tsinto their respective files
Reviewed changes
Copilot reviewed 68 out of 93 changed files in this pull request and generated 2 comments.
Show a summary per file
| File | Description |
|---|---|
| ui/sections/* | New page-specific components (post-header, post-pagination, likes-row, etc.) |
| ui/layout/* | New site-wide layout components (header, footer, page-layout, header-nav) |
| seo/* | New centralized SEO folder with JSON-LD generators and metadata constants |
| app/(home)/page.tsx | Moved homepage from app/page.tsx using route groups |
| io//fetch.ts | Added caching support and updated imports |
| ci/metadata/validate.ts | Inlined configuration constants |
| utils/dates.ts | Deleted (functions moved to consuming files) |
Comments suppressed due to low confidence (1)
ui/sections/home-summary.tsx:1
- The updated sentence structure is awkward with the period mid-sentence. Consider: "I care about reliability, ergonomics and getting the details right. Since I'd rather not get paged, I spend time thinking about what could go wrong and how we can make sure it doesn't."
import { type ReactElement } from 'react'
💡 Add Copilot custom instructions for smarter, more guided reviews. Learn how to get started.
app/[slug]/page.tsx
Outdated
| // TODO: confirm if this is the right behaviour; what pages would this apply to? | ||
| return {} |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
This TODO comment indicates uncertainty about the behavior. Since getPost returns null when a slug isn't found, returning an empty metadata object here would mean pages with invalid slugs get no metadata at all. Consider either removing this early return (let the notFound() call below handle it), or document which specific scenario this handles.
| // TODO: confirm if this is the right behaviour; what pages would this apply to? | |
| return {} | |
| notFound() |
| const params = { | ||
| books: { medium: 'ebook' as iTunesMedium, entity: 'ebook' as iTunesEntity }, | ||
| albums: { medium: 'music' as iTunesMedium, entity: 'album' as iTunesEntity }, | ||
| podcasts: { medium: 'podcast' as iTunesMedium, entity: 'podcast' as iTunesEntity }, | ||
| }[category] |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
The params mapping uses inline type assertions that could be eliminated by properly typing the mapping object. Consider: const params: Record<MediaCategory, { medium: iTunesMedium; entity: iTunesEntity }> = { ... } to remove the need for type assertions.
| const params = { | |
| books: { medium: 'ebook' as iTunesMedium, entity: 'ebook' as iTunesEntity }, | |
| albums: { medium: 'music' as iTunesMedium, entity: 'album' as iTunesEntity }, | |
| podcasts: { medium: 'podcast' as iTunesMedium, entity: 'podcast' as iTunesEntity }, | |
| }[category] | |
| const params = ( | |
| { | |
| books: { medium: 'ebook', entity: 'ebook' }, | |
| albums: { medium: 'music', entity: 'album' }, | |
| podcasts: { medium: 'podcast', entity: 'podcast' }, | |
| } satisfies Record<MediaCategory, { medium: iTunesMedium; entity: iTunesEntity }> | |
| )[category] |
Pull Request ReviewThis is an excellent refactoring that significantly improves the codebase's organization and maintainability. The changes demonstrate thoughtful architectural decisions and follow best practices throughout. ✅ Strengths1. Excellent Code Organization
2. Strong Type Safety ✨The codebase demonstrates excellent TypeScript practices throughout:
3. Comprehensive Test Coverage
4. Clean Architecture Patterns
5. Performance & Caching Improvements
6. Accessibility Maintained
🔍 Minor Observations1. Potential TODO to Address// app/[slug]/page.tsx:39-42
if (!post) {
// TODO: confirm if this is the right behaviour; what pages would this apply to?
return {}
}This TODO should be resolved. If a post doesn't exist, 2. API Parameter Changes
3. Test Mocking PatternsThe test files extensively mock PageLayout: vi.mock('@/ui/layout/page-layout', () => ({
default: ({ children }: { children: React.ReactNode }) => (
<main id="main" className="flex-auto flex flex-col">
{children}
</main>
),
}))This is duplicated across multiple test files. Consider extracting to a shared test utility to reduce duplication. 4. Cache Adapter InjectionBoth 🎯 Best Practices Followed
🛡️ Security
📊 Impact Summary
🎉 VerdictStrongly Approve ✅ This PR represents exemplary refactoring work:
The only action item is resolving the TODO in Great work! This will make the codebase much easier to navigate and maintain going forward. 🚀 |
…ng to generate metadata
1 participant
✅ What
ui/into three tiers:elements/(primitives like Link, Image),layout/(site structure like Header, Footer), andsections/(page-specific blocks like PostHeader, LikesRow)seo/folder consolidating metadata constants and JSON-LD generation (was scattered acrossutils/andapp/)app/page.tsx→app/(home)/page.tsxusing Next.js route groups to reduce root clutterpublic/_redirects.test.ts→io/cloudflare/_redirects.test.ts(tests shouldn't be in published assets)io/retry→io/utils/retryfor better organizationio/tmdb/constants.ts(never used),io/notion/getPage.ts(unused helper)ci/config.tsand inlined all constants into their single-use files (onlyOUT_DIRwas used in 2 places, rest were single-use)🤔 Why
ui/structure makes it immediately clear where to add new components (reusable primitive? page-specific section? site-wide layout?)app/root clutter while maintaining Next.js routing conventions