Skip to content

Create linkedlist-1.java#1798

Open
Praniksha123 wants to merge 1 commit into
super30admin:masterfrom
Praniksha123:master
Open

Create linkedlist-1.java#1798
Praniksha123 wants to merge 1 commit into
super30admin:masterfrom
Praniksha123:master

Conversation

@Praniksha123

Copy link
Copy Markdown

No description provided.

@super30admin

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner

Reverse Linked List (linkedlist-1.java)

Strengths:

  • Clean, well-commented code with clear explanation of the approach
  • Correct implementation of the iterative reversal algorithm
  • Proper use of temporary variable to avoid losing reference to next node
  • Optimal time and space complexity matching the reference solution

Areas for Improvement:

  • The null check if(head==null) return head; is unnecessary since the while loop naturally handles this case and returns null anyway
  • Consider adding a recursive solution as well since the problem mentions "Could you implement both?" in the follow-up
  • For better code style, consider consistent spacing around operators (e.g., curr != null instead of curr!=null)

Overall Assessment:
The solution for the Reverse Linked List problem is correct, efficient, and well-written. It matches the reference solution in both time and space complexity.

VERDICT: PASS


Remove Nth Node From End of List

Strengths:

  1. Problem 2 shows excellent understanding of the two-pointer technique - this is actually superior to the reference solution as it achieves one-pass solution as required by the follow-up.
  2. Code is well-commented with clear explanations of the approach.
  3. Proper handling of edge cases (null checks, dummy node usage).
  4. Good variable naming and code structure throughout.

Areas for Improvement:

  1. Problem 3 could be optimized to O(1) space using Floyd's cycle detection algorithm (slow/fast pointers) instead of HashSet.
  2. In Problem 2, the temp variable and subsequent null assignment is unnecessary in Java as the garbage collector will handle it - this is just a minor style observation.

Overall, the student demonstrates strong understanding of linked list operations and algorithmic thinking.

VERDICT: PASS


Linked List Cycle II

Strengths:

  1. Clear and well-documented code with step-by-step comments
  2. Correct logic for cycle detection using HashSet
  3. Proper handling of edge cases (null head)
  4. Good variable naming conventions

Areas for Improvement:

  1. Space Complexity: The problem explicitly asks for O(1) space solution in the follow-up. Consider implementing Floyd's cycle detection algorithm (slow and fast pointers) which achieves O(1) space.
  2. Minor Bug: Line if(head==null) return head; should return null instead of head for correctness, though functionally they are equivalent here.
  3. The student provided solutions for multiple problems but only problem 3 is relevant to the actual task.

Suggested Improvement:
To achieve O(1) space, implement the two-pointer approach:

  • Phase 1: Use slow and fast pointers to detect if a cycle exists
  • Phase 2: If cycle exists, reset slow to head and move both pointers one step at a time until they meet at the cycle start

VERDICT: NEEDS_IMPROVEMENT

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

2 participants