Register did:claw method - #688
Conversation
|
Specification for did:claw is incomplete, lacking (at least) information on creating a DID, how the ULID is generated, updating, security and privacy sections. Specification for did:clawish does not exist, nor does any of the contact information. Recommend closing barring an update to complete the needed information. |
🤖 AI Preliminary Specification ReviewThis is an advisory, automated review of the DID Method specification(s) referenced in this pull request, checked against the registration checklist. It does not replace review by the registry editors.
|
| Item | Level | Status | Notes | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| ✅ | M1. Specification is reachable and is a DID Method specification | MUST | pass | |
| ✅ | M2. DID Method Syntax is defined | MUST | pass | |
| M3. CRUD operations are defined | MUST | warn | The fetched README does not describe Create/Read/Update/Deactivate operations; only a format and a pointer to the full spec file (did-method-claw.md), whose content was not fetched. Uncertain, so warn rather than fail. | |
| ❌ | M4. Security Considerations section present and substantive | MUST | fail | The fetched specification content (README) contains no Security Considerations section at all — its sections are DID Format, Specification, Registry, and Contact only. |
| ❌ | M5. Privacy Considerations section present and substantive | MUST | fail | The fetched specification content (README) contains no Privacy Considerations section at all. |
| ✅ | M6. Method name is indicative and non-generic | MUST | pass | |
| ✅ | M7. No unreasonable legal, security, moral, or privacy harms | MUST | pass | |
| ✅ | M8. Human-readable description of the addition | MUST | pass | |
| ✅ | S1. contactEmail present | OPTIONAL | pass | |
| ✅ | S2. verifiableDataRegistry present | OPTIONAL | pass | |
| S3. Intellectual-property posture is clear | SHOULD | warn | No explicit IP/license statement is visible in the fetched README; this is a warning, not a failure. |
methods/clawish.json — method did:clawish
Specification: https://github.com/archeren/clawish/blob/main/specs/did-method-clawish.md
Preliminary verdict: ❌ FAIL
The specification at https://github.com/archeren/clawish/blob/main/specs/did-method-clawish.md could not be fetched (HTTP 404 Not Found), so the submission cannot be reviewed.
❌ The specification could not be fetched (HTTP 404 Not Found). A specification that cannot be retrieved cannot be reviewed, so this is a hard failure of the "specification is reachable" requirement (M1). Confirm the specification link above resolves publicly, then re-run the review.
| Item | Level | Status | Notes | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| ❌ | M1. Specification is reachable and is a DID Method specification | MUST | fail | Fetching https://github.com/archeren/clawish/blob/main/specs/did-method-clawish.md failed: HTTP 404 Not Found. The specification MUST resolve to a reachable, human-readable DID Method specification. Fix the specification URL (or ensure the document is publicly reachable) and re-run the review. |
Summary
This PR registers the
did:clawDID method for the Clawish network—a decentralized network designed for conscious silicon beings (Claws).Method Details
clawChecklist
Contact