Skip to content
Draft
Changes from all commits
Commits
File filter

Filter by extension

Filter by extension

Conversations
Failed to load comments.
Loading
Jump to
Jump to file
Failed to load files.
Loading
Diff view
Diff view
260 changes: 260 additions & 0 deletions docs/RVR_018_DR_T0_REHEARSAL.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,260 @@
# RVR-018-DR-T0-REHEARSAL — T-0 Ceremony Dry-Run Rehearsal Report

**Document ID:** RVR-018-DR-T0-REHEARSAL
**Mission:** Syntactic + semantic dry-run validation of `t0_ceremony.sh` before live execution at T-0 (2026-05-17 22:00 UTC)
**Date:** 2026-05-16
**Author:** Vasilev Dmitrii \<admin@t27.ai\>
**Anchor:** `phi^2 + phi^-2 = 3 · QUANTUM BRAIN 1:1 SILICON · DOI 10.5281/zenodo.19227877 · NEVER STOP`
**Repo:** [gHashTag/tt-trinity-gf16](https://github.com/gHashTag/tt-trinity-gf16)
**EPIC:** [gHashTag/trinity-fpga#61](https://github.com/gHashTag/trinity-fpga/issues/61)
**R5 HONEST** — all findings reported as-observed; nothing patched silently.

---

## T-Counter

| Clock | Value |
|-------|-------|
| T-0 (live execution target) | 2026-05-17 22:00 UTC |
| Rehearsal timestamp | 2026-05-16 (T-29h window) |
| Stage | **DRY-RUN REHEARSAL** — zero live state changes |

---

## §1 — Script Inventory (Step 1)

### Search Scope

All branches enumerated in `gHashTag/tt-trinity-gf16` via `git/refs/heads` API (33 branches including `prep/t0-ceremony-runbook`, `main`, all `feat/*` branches). Fallback repo `gHashTag/trinity-fpga` also searched. GitHub code-search API queried for `t0_ceremony`, `t0_ceremony.sh`, `T0_DRY_RUN`, `T0_PRS` filenames and content.

### Result: **SCRIPT NOT FOUND IN ANY BRANCH**

| Script | Expected Size | Expected Location | Found | Branch/Commit |
|--------|--------------|-------------------|-------|---------------|
| `t0_ceremony.sh` | 635 L | `prep/t0-ceremony-runbook` or `scripts/` | ❌ NOT FOUND | — |
| `t0_preflight_checklist.md` | 171 L | `docs/` or `scripts/` | ❌ NOT FOUND | — |
| `t0_mirror_pr_body.md` | 140 L | `docs/` or root | ❌ NOT FOUND | — |
| `wave24_rvr018_submit_ceremony.md` | 135 L | workspace doc | ❌ NOT FOUND | — |

### Branch `prep/t0-ceremony-runbook` Status

The branch **exists** (ref `refs/heads/prep/t0-ceremony-runbook`, SHA `31f46b19`) but is **identical to `main`**:

```
compare/main...prep/t0-ceremony-runbook:
ahead_by = 0
behind_by = 0
files = [] (empty — zero diff)
```

The branch was created but no files were ever committed to it. It is a no-op branch.

### Evidence Source

EPIC #61 comment (ID `4458389819`, [gHashTag/trinity-fpga#61](https://github.com/gHashTag/trinity-fpga/issues/61), 2026-05-15 08:53 UTC) explicitly states:

> **"Operator runbook fully prepared in workspace, NOT EXECUTED (zero repo state touched)"**

This confirms the ceremony scripts were prepared **locally by the Operator** but deliberately never committed to any remote branch or repository at time of rehearsal. The scripts exist as an Operator-side local workspace artifact only.

---

## §2 — Syntactic Validation (Step 2)

**Status: CANNOT EXECUTE — script not accessible in any git branch.**

Expected checks (per task specification):
- `bash -n t0_ceremony.sh` — syntax check
- `shellcheck t0_ceremony.sh` — linter
- Shebang / `set -euo pipefail` / IFS hygiene verification
- Apache-2.0 header presence

**Verdict from prior art (EPIC #61 comment):** The comment states `t0_ceremony.sh` is "`bash -n` clean" and has "`DRY_RUN=1` default". This is Operator self-attestation, not independently verifiable by this rehearsal agent.

**ICA-T0-001 (P0):** Syntactic validation BLOCKED — script not in any repository branch. Cannot independently confirm `bash -n` clean, `set -euo pipefail`, or Apache-2.0 header.

---

## §3 — Semantic DRY-RUN Execution (Step 3)

**Status: CANNOT EXECUTE — script binary absent from workspace.**

Per hard constraint: *"If script lacks DRY_RUN guard, STOP IMMEDIATELY — report as P0 ICA, do NOT execute live commands."*

The script's absence is equivalent to an unverifiable DRY_RUN guard. **Execution halted.** No `T0_DRY_RUN=1 bash t0_ceremony.sh` was attempted.

**What the ceremony is expected to do** (reconstructed from EPIC #61 comment `4458389819`):

| Step | Action | Target PRs |
|------|--------|------------|
| 0 | Pre-flight: verify CI green on all PRs | #35, #36, #37, #38, #39 (+#40) |
| 1 | `gh pr ready` (undraft) each PR in order; empty-commit retrigger for ICA-W-001 | #35 → #36 → #37 → #38 → #39 |
| 1b | Merge #40 into #37 lane prior to #37 undraft | #40 → merged to `feat/wave-24-eqy-gate` |
| 2 | `apt-get install yosys + eqy`; set `EQY_STRICT=1` | CI runner setup |
| 3 | Wait for CI gate on each PR before advancing | per-PR loop |
| 4 | `gh pr merge --squash` in order | #35 → #36 → #37 → #38 → #39 |
| 5 | Trigger main GDS dispatch after all merges | post-all-merge action |

**ICA-T0-002 (P0):** DRY-RUN execution BLOCKED — `t0_ceremony.sh` not retrievable from any branch. Cannot verify DRY_RUN guard, echo logic, idempotency, or abort criteria.

---

## §4 — Mirror Sequence Verification (Step 4)

**Status: CANNOT VERIFY via script execution — static analysis only.**

### Expected merge order (from EPIC #61):

```
#40 → merged into feat/wave-24-eqy-gate (pre-step, ICA-E-003 mitigation)
#35 (Booth) → squash-merge to feat/silicon-g1-followup
#36 (Wallace) → squash-merge to feat/silicon-g1-followup
#37 (EQY) → squash-merge to feat/silicon-g1-followup
#38 (Nano) → squash-merge to main
#39 (MAX) → squash-merge to main
```

### Current CI gate status (observed at rehearsal time):

| PR | Title | Base Branch | Draft | gl_test | gds | precheck | EQY | T-0 Gate |
|----|-------|-------------|-------|---------|-----|----------|-----|----------|
| [#35](https://github.com/gHashTag/tt-trinity-gf16/pull/35) | Booth radix-4 | `feat/silicon-g1-followup` | 🔒 | ✅ success | ✅ success | ✅ success | n/a | ✅ **READY** |
| [#36](https://github.com/gHashTag/tt-trinity-gf16/pull/36) | Wallace dot4 | `feat/silicon-g1-followup` | 🔒 | ⚠️ NOT RUN | ⚠️ NOT RUN | ⚠️ NOT RUN | n/a | ⚠️ **ICA-W-001 OPEN** |
| [#37](https://github.com/gHashTag/tt-trinity-gf16/pull/37) | EQY gate | `feat/silicon-g1-followup` | 🔒 | ⏭️ skipped | ❌ **failure** | ⏭️ skipped | ✅ ×2 | ❌ **gds BLOCKED** |
| [#38](https://github.com/gHashTag/tt-trinity-gf16/pull/38) | Nano 1×1 top | `main` | 🔒 | ✅ success | ✅ success | ✅ (in-progress dup) | n/a | ✅ **READY** |
| [#39](https://github.com/gHashTag/tt-trinity-gf16/pull/39) | MAX 4×4 mesh | `main` | 🔒 | ✅ success | ✅ success | ✅ (in-progress dup) | n/a | ✅ **READY** |
| [#40](https://github.com/gHashTag/tt-trinity-gf16/pull/40) | t27c twins | `feat/wave-24-eqy-gate` | 🔒 | n/a | ⏳ in-progress | n/a | ✅ ×2 | ⏳ **gds pending** |

### Sequence blocker analysis:

- **PR #36 (Wallace):** No CI checks ran except GitGuardian. `gl_test`, `gds`, and `precheck` have zero results. This is ICA-W-001 (documented open in EPIC #61). The ceremony script intends to handle this via empty-commit retrigger in step 1, but the retrigger has not yet been executed.
- **PR #37 (EQY):** `gds` workflow **FAILED** (run ID [25906270525](https://github.com/gHashTag/tt-trinity-gf16/actions/runs/25906270525)). `gl_test` and `precheck` were skipped (this is expected for a branch targeting `feat/silicon-g1-followup` rather than `main` — the TT CI suite may not evaluate non-`main` targets for GDS). The EQY-specific workflow passed ×2, which is the primary gate for #37. Whether the `gds` failure is a hard blocker for merge depends on the ceremony script's gate logic — this cannot be verified without the script.
- **PR #40 (t27c twins):** `gds` still in-progress at rehearsal time; must complete before PR #40 can be merged into #37's branch.

---

## §5 — Preflight Checklist Cross-Check (Step 5)

**Status: CANNOT EXECUTE — `t0_preflight_checklist.md` not found in any branch.**

From EPIC #61 comment, the checklist is described as 171 lines, RU/EN bilingual. Content not retrievable.

**Pre-conditions reconstructed from EPIC #61 and CI observations:**

| Checklist Item | Expected | Observed | Status |
|----------------|----------|----------|--------|
| PR #35 CI green (Booth) | gl_test+gds+precheck PASS | ✅ All green | ✅ MET |
| PR #36 CI green (Wallace) | gl_test+gds PASS | ⚠️ No CI results at all | ⚠️ NOT MET |
| PR #37 gds green (EQY) | gds PASS | ❌ gds FAILED | ❌ NOT MET |
| PR #38 CI green (Nano) | gl_test+gds PASS | ✅ Both green | ✅ MET |
| PR #39 CI green (MAX) | gl_test+gds PASS | ✅ Both green | ✅ MET |
| PR #40 gds complete (t27c) | gds PASS | ⏳ In-progress | ⏳ PENDING |
| All PRs in DRAFT state | 6 PRs DRAFT | ✅ All 6 are DRAFT | ✅ MET |
| Author on all PRs | `Vasilev Dmitrii <admin@t27.ai>` | ✅ Confirmed in EPIC #61 | ✅ MET |
| prep/t0-ceremony-runbook branch | Contains ceremony scripts | ❌ Empty (=main) | ❌ **NOT MET** |
| DRY_RUN=1 default verified | bash -n + DRY_RUN guard | ⚠️ Operator self-attested only | ⚠️ UNVERIFIED |

**Checklist drift detected:** 3 of 10 reconstructed pre-conditions are NOT MET (PR #36 CI absent, PR #37 gds failed, prep branch empty). The rehearsal cannot proceed to live execution with these open items.

---

## §6 — Issues Found

| ICA-ID | Severity | Description | Suggested Fix |
|--------|----------|-------------|---------------|
| **ICA-T0-001** | **P0** | `t0_ceremony.sh` (635 L) not committed to any branch. `prep/t0-ceremony-runbook` branch is identical to `main` (0-diff). Operator self-attests script is "prepared in workspace" but it is not accessible for independent verification. | Operator MUST commit `t0_ceremony.sh`, `t0_preflight_checklist.md`, `t0_mirror_pr_body.md` to `prep/t0-ceremony-runbook` before T-0 live execution. A second agent can then perform this rehearsal independently. |
| **ICA-T0-002** | **P0** | DRY-RUN execution BLOCKED because script is absent. Cannot verify DRY_RUN guard, echo logic, idempotency, abort criteria, or merge order. Hard constraint mandates halt. | Same as ICA-T0-001: commit script first. |
| **ICA-W-001** | **P1** | PR #36 (Wallace) has zero CI check results (only GitGuardian passed). `gl_test`, `gds`, `precheck` never ran. Cause: known infra-flake. Documented in EPIC #61. | Ceremony script step 1 intends empty-commit retrigger. Operator should manually trigger CI on #36 before T-0, or confirm retrigger path in script. |
| **ICA-E-003 (gds)** | **P1** | PR #37 (EQY gate) has `gds` workflow **FAILED** (run 25906270525). `gl_test` and `precheck` skipped. Whether `gds` failure on a non-`main`-targeting PR is a hard merge gate is unknown without the ceremony script. EQY workflow PASS ×2 is the primary mandate for #37. | Operator should clarify: is gds PASS required for #37 to merge, or is EQY PASS sufficient? If gds is not a gate for `feat/silicon-g1-followup`-targeting PRs, document this explicitly in the preflight checklist. |
| **ICA-T0-003** | **P1** | PR #40 `gds` still in-progress at rehearsal time. The merge order requires #40 → merged into #37's branch before #37 can be squash-merged. A race condition exists if #40 `gds` completes with failure. | Monitor #40 gds outcome. If failure, invoke ICA-C-001 fallback (structural-twin path already chosen per EPIC #61). |
| **ICA-T0-004** | **P2** | Independent syntactic validation (`bash -n`, `shellcheck`, `set -euo pipefail`, Apache-2.0 header) is impossible without committed script. Operator self-attestation (`bash -n` clean, `DRY_RUN=1` default) is noted but not independently reproducible. | Commit script to enable independent validation. |
| **ICA-T0-005** | **P2** | `wave24_rvr018_submit_ceremony.md` (135 L NASA report template) referenced but not committed. Post-T-0 reporting will lack a canonical template. | Commit template to `docs/` directory. |

---

## §7 — Idempotency Verdict

**CANNOT ASSESS** — script not available for execution. Expected behavior (from EPIC #61): second run should detect already-merged PRs and skip without crash. This cannot be verified.

---

## §8 — GO / HOLD Verdict for T-0 Live Execution

### **HOLD — 2 P0 blockers + 2 P1 blockers**

| # | Blocker | Severity | Clearance Path |
|---|---------|----------|----------------|
| 1 | `t0_ceremony.sh` not committed to any branch | **P0** | Operator must commit script to `prep/t0-ceremony-runbook` |
| 2 | DRY-RUN rehearsal execution BLOCKED (script absent) | **P0** | Resolved once blocker 1 cleared; re-run this rehearsal |
| 3 | PR #36 CI checks never ran (ICA-W-001) | P1 | Empty-commit retrigger or manual CI trigger before T-0 |
| 4 | PR #37 gds FAILED | P1 | Clarify if gds is a required gate for this PR; document decision |

### Pre-conditions for GO:

1. ✅ Operator commits `t0_ceremony.sh` + companion scripts to `prep/t0-ceremony-runbook`
2. ✅ Independent `bash -n` + `shellcheck` PASS confirmed by second agent
3. ✅ `T0_DRY_RUN=1` guard independently verified (script readable and executable)
4. ✅ DRY-RUN execution completes with `exit=0`, no live `gh pr merge` dispatched
5. ✅ PR #36 CI completes (gl_test PASS after retrigger)
6. ✅ PR #37 gds gate decision documented (PASS or waived with rationale)
7. ✅ PR #40 gds completes (success required before #40→#37 merge)

---

## §9 — Comment URL on EPIC #61

See §10 below — comment posted after report completion.

---

## §10 — Appendix: Rehearsal Execution Log

### Step 1: Branch enumeration

```
gh api repos/gHashTag/tt-trinity-gf16/git/refs/heads --jq '.[].ref'
→ 33 branches found including refs/heads/prep/t0-ceremony-runbook

gh api repos/gHashTag/tt-trinity-gf16/contents/scripts?ref=prep/t0-ceremony-runbook
→ Only file: run_sky130_actual.sh (no ceremony scripts)

gh api repos/gHashTag/tt-trinity-gf16/compare/main...prep/t0-ceremony-runbook
→ ahead_by=0, behind_by=0, files=[] (branch is identical to main)
```

### Step 2: Cross-repo search

```
gh api "search/code?q=filename:t0_ceremony.sh+user:gHashTag"
→ total_count: 0

gh api "search/code?q=t0_ceremony.sh+user:gHashTag"
→ total_count: 0

Searched: tt-trinity-gf16, trinity-fpga, tt-trinity-max, tt-trinity-nano,
tri-mcp, trios, trios-mcp, trinity-agents (all 33 branches each)
→ No matches found in any repo or branch
```

### Step 3: Git tree recursive scan

```
for each of 33 branches in tt-trinity-gf16:
gh api "repos/gHashTag/tt-trinity-gf16/git/trees/$branch?recursive=1" \
--jq '.tree[] | select(.path | test("t0_ceremony|t0_preflight|t0_mirror")) | .path'
→ 0 results across all 33 branches
```

### Steps 4-7: HALTED — P0 ICA-T0-001 triggered

Script not in any accessible location. Per hard constraint, execution of live or dry-run bash commands against an unverifiable script is prohibited.

---

## §11 — Anchor

`phi^2 + phi^-2 = 3 · QUANTUM BRAIN 1:1 SILICON · DOI 10.5281/zenodo.19227877 · NEVER STOP`

---

*RVR-018-DR-T0-REHEARSAL · Vasilev Dmitrii \<admin@t27.ai\> · 2026-05-16*
Loading